Comparing Short Form 6D, Standard Gamble, and Health Utilities Index Mark 2 and Mark 3 utility scores: Results from total hip arthroplasty patients Article Accepted: 20 December 2004 DOI:
Cite this article as: Feeny, D., Wu, L. & Eng, K. Qual Life Res (2004) 13: 1659. doi:10.1007/s11136-004-6189-2 Abstract Objective: The objectives are to compare SF-6D, standard gamble (SG), and Health Utilities Index (HUI) utility scores, compare change scores, and compare responsiveness.
Methods: A cohort of osteoarthritis patients referred for total hip arthroplasty (THA) were evaluated at the time of referral and followed until 3 months after THA. Patients were assessed using the SF-36, HUI2, HUI3, and the SG. Agreement is assessed using the intra-class correlation (ICC). Responsiveness is assessed using effect size, standardized response mean, and paired t-test. Results: Data was available for 86 patients at baseline and for 63 at both pre- and post-surgery. At baseline mean SF-6D (0.61), SG (0.62), and HUI2 (0.62) scores were similar; the mean HUI3 score (0.52) was lower. Standard deviations were 0.10, 0.32, 0.19, and 0.22. At baseline, agreement between SF-6D and SG scores was 0.13, agreement between SF-6D and HUI2 was 0.47, and agreement between SF-6D and HUI3 was 0.28. Agreement at pre- and post-surgery was similar. The change in scores between post- and pre-surgery was 0.10 for SF-6D, 0.16 for SG, 0.22 for HUI2, and 0.23 for HUI3. Effect sizes were 1.10 for HUI2, 1.08 for HUI3, 1.06 for SF-6D, and 0.48 for the SG. Conclusions: Agreement between SG scores and SF-6D and HUI scores was low. The estimate of change in utility associated with THA was lowest for SF-6D. Additional longitudinal studies to compare utility measures appear to be warranted.
Keywords HUI Responsiveness SF-6D Standard Gamble Utility Scores References Ware, J.E., Sherbourne, C.D. 1992 The MOS 36-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36). Med Care 30 473 483 PubMed Google Scholar Ware, J.E., Snow, K.K., Kosinski, M., Gandek, B. 1993SF-36 Health Survey Manual and Interpretation Guide. New England Medical Center, The Health Institute Boston Google Scholar Ware, J.E., Jr. 1996 The SF-36 Health Survey Spilker, B. eds. Quality of Life and Pharmacoeconomics in. Clinical Trials Lippincott-Raven Philadelphia, PA 337 345 Google Scholar Brazier, J., Roberts, J., Deverill, M. 2002 The estimation of a preference-based measure of health status from the SF-36. J Health Econom 21 271 292 CrossRef Google Scholar Mahon, J.L., Bourne, R., Rorabeck, C., Feeny, D., Stitt, L., Webster-Bogaert, S. 2002 The effect of waiting for elective total hip arthroplasty on health-related quality of life. Can med Assoc J 167 1115 1121 Google Scholar Blanchard, C., Feeny, D., Mahon, J.L., et al. 2004 Is the Health Utilities Index valid in total hip arthroplasty patients? Qual Life Res 13 339 348 CrossRef Google Scholar Blanchard, C., Feeny, D., Mahon, J.L., et al. 2003 Is the Health Utilities Index responsive in total hip arthroplasty patients? J Clini Epidemiol 56 1046 1054 CrossRef Google Scholar Feeny, D., Blanchard, C., Mahon, J.L., et al. 2003 Comparing community-preference based and direct standard gamble utility scores: Evidence from elective total hip arthroplasty. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 19 362 372 CrossRef Google Scholar Feeny, D., Blanchard, C.M., Mahon, J.L., et al. 2004 The stability of utility scores: Test–retest reliability and the interpretation of utility scores in elective total hip arthroplasty. Qual Life Res 13 15 22 CrossRef Google Scholar Feeny, D., Torrance, G.W., Furlong, W. 1996 Health Utilities Index Spilker, B eds. Quality of Life and Pharmacoeconomics in Clinical Trials Lippincott-Raven Philadelphia, PA 239 251 Google Scholar Feeny, D., Furlong, W., Torrance, G.W., et al. 2002 Multi-attribute and single-attribute utility functions for the Health Utilities Index Mark 3 system. Med Care 40 113 128 CrossRef Google Scholar Furlong, W.J., Feeny, D.H., Torrance, G.W., Barr, R.D. 2001 The Health Utilities Index (HUI) system for assessing health-related quality of life in clinical studies. Ann Med 33 375 384 PubMed Google Scholar Feeny, D., Furlong, W., Barr, R.D., Torrance, G.W., Rosenbaum, P., Weitzman, S. 1992 A comprehensive multiattribute system for classifying the health status of survivors of childhood cancer. J Clin Oncol 10 923 928 Google Scholar Torrance, G.W., Feeny, D.H., Furlong, W.J., Barr, R.D., Zhang, Y., Wang, Q. 1996 Multi-attribute preference functions for a␣comprehensive health status classification system: Health␣Utilities Index Mark 2. Med Care 34 702 722 CrossRef Google Scholar Laupacis, A., Bourne, R., Rorabeck, C., et al. 1993 Effect of elective total hip replacement upon health-related quality of life. J Bone Joint Surg 75-A 1619 1626 Google Scholar
Furlong W, Feeny D, Torrance GW, Barr R, Horsman J. Guide to design and development of health-state utility instrumentation. McMaster University Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis Working Paper No. 90-9, June 1990
Gibbons, J.D., Chakraborti, S. 1992Non-Parametric Statistical Inference3 Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York Google Scholar Hollander, M., Wolfe, D.A. 1973Non-Parametric Statistical Methods John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York Google Scholar Kleinbaum, D.G., Kupper, L.L., Muller, K.E. 1988Applied Regression Analysis Other Multivariable Methods2 PWS-Kent Boston, MA Google Scholar Deyo, R.A., Diehr, P., Patrick, D.L. 1991 Reproducibility and responsiveness of health status measures: Statistics and strategies for evaluation Controlled Clin Trials 12 142S 158S Google Scholar Shrout, P.E., Fleiss, J.L. 1979 Intraclass correlations: Uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychol Bull 86 420 428 CrossRef Google Scholar Nunnally, J.C. 1978Psychometric Theory2 McGraw-Hill New York Google Scholar Wright, J.G., Young, N.L. 1997 A comparison of different indices of responsiveness. J Clin Epidemiol 50 239 246 CrossRef Google Scholar McDowell, I., Newell, C. 1996Measuring Health: A Guide to Rating Scales and Questionnaires2 Oxford University Press New York Google Scholar Juniper, E.F., Guyatt, G.H., Jaeschke, R. 1996 How to develop and validate a new health-related quality of life instrument Spilker, B. eds. Quality of Life and Pharmacoeconomics in Clinical Trials2 Lippincott-Raven Publishers Philadelphia 49 56 Google Scholar Hollingworth, W., Deyo, R.A., Sullivan, S.D., Emerson, S.S., Gray, D.T., Jarvik, J.G. 2002 The practicality and validity of directly elicited and SF-36 derived Health State Preferences in patients with low back pain. Health Econom 11 71 85 CrossRef Google Scholar Kopec, J.A., Willison, K.D. 2003 A comparative review of four preference-weighted measures of health-related quality of life. J Clin Epidemiol 56 317 325 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Feeny, D., Furlong, W., Saigal, S., Sun, J. 2004 Comparing directly measured standard gamble scores to HUI2 and HUI3 utility scores: Group and individual-level comparisons. Soc Sci Med 58 799 809 CrossRef Google Scholar Gold, M.R., Patrick, D.L., Torrance, G.W., et al. 1996 Identifying and valuing outcomes Gold, M.R. Siegel, J.E. Russell, L.B. Weinstein, M.C. eds. Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine Oxford University Press New York 82 134 Google Scholar Grootendorst, P., Feeny, D., Furlong, W. 2000 Health Utilities Index Mark 3: Evidence of construct validity for stroke and arthritis in a population health survey. Med Care 38 290 299 CrossRef Google Scholar Drummond, M. 2001 Introducing economic and quality of life measurements into clinical studies. Ann Med 33 344 349 Google Scholar Bosch, J.L., Halpern, E.F., Scott Gazelle, G. 2002 Comparison of preference-based utilities of the Short-Form 36 Health Survey and Health Utilities Index before and after treatment of patients with intermittent claudication. Med. Decis Making 22 403 409 CrossRef Google Scholar Lee, T.A., Hollingworth, W., Sullivan, S.D. 2003 Comparison of directly elicited preferences derived from the SF-36 in adults with asthma. Med Decis Making 23 323 334 CrossRef Google Scholar Longworth, L., Bryan, S. 2003 An empirical comparison of EQ-5D and SF-6D in liver transplant patients Health Econom 12 1061 1067 CrossRef Google Scholar Rabin, R., de Charro, F. 2001 EQ-5D: A measure of health status␣from the EuroQol Group. Ann Med 33 337 343 Google Scholar Dolan, P. 1997 Modeling valuations for EuroQol health states. Med Care 35 1095 1108 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Conner-Spady, B., Suarez-Almazor, M.E. 2003 Variation in the estimation of quality-adjusted life-years by different preference-based instruments. Med Care 41 791 801 CrossRef Google Scholar O’Brien, B.J., Spath, M., Blackhouse, G, Severens, J.L., Dorian, P., Brazier, J. 2003 A view from the bridge: Agreement between the SF-6D utility algorithm and the Health Utilities Index Health Econom 12 975 981 CrossRef Google Scholar Copyright information
© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004