The role of self selection, usage uncertainty and learning in the demand for local telephone service
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Telephone services are often characterized by the presence of ‘fixed’ plans, involving only a fixed monthly fee, as well as ‘measured’ plans, with both fixed fees and per-unit charges for usage. Consumers are faced with the decisions of which plan to choose and how much to use the phone and these decisions are not, in general, independent. Due to the presence of a time lag between plan choice and usage decisions, consumers are uncertain about usage at the plan-choice stage. We develop a structural discrete/continuous model of plan choice and usage decisions of consumers that accounts for such uncertainty. Prior research has also found that consumers switch less often from fixed plans to measured plans to gain from potential savings than vice versa. Consumer uncertainty regarding their mean usage levels and different rates of learning by consumers in the two plans is a potential explanation for this phenomenon. We extend our discrete/continuous model to account for consumer learning about their mean usage and estimate different rates of learning for the two types of plans.
We estimate our model using data from the 1986 Kentucky local telephone tariff experiment. Even in the absence of any price variation over time, we are able to measure the price elasticities both of usage and of choice of plan. Using our parameter estimates, we simulate the effects of the introduction of a metered plan in a market with only a fixed plan and vice versa, on both firm revenues and consumer surplus. We also find that consumers learn very rapidly if they are on the measured plan but learn very slowly when they are on the fixed plan. We investigate an alternative assumption on the nature of the learning process in which only consumers in the measured plan have an opportunity to learn. We find that our empirical results are robust to this change of specification. We conduct counterfactual simulations to simulate enhanced calling plans from the firm and consumer points of view. Additional simulations to measure the value of information in this category are also carried out. We compute the value of both complete information, where the entire uncertainty about future usage is resolved, as well as that of limited information, where the consumer's uncertainty about mean usage is resolved, but the uncertainty about specific month-to-month usage remains. We find that the value of information is modest. We also find that a large proportion of the value of information is that about the mean usage, with the value of the information about a specific month's usage being relatively small.
- Chernew, M., Gowrisankaran, G., & Scanlon, D. P. (2006). Learning and the value of information: the evidence from health plan report cards. Working Paper, Washington University, St. Louis.
- Chiang, J. (1991). A simultaneous approach to whether, what and how much to buy questions. Marketing Science, 10, 297–315.
- Chintagunta, P. K. (1993). Investigating purchase incidence, brand choice and purchase quantity decisions of households. Marketing Science, 12, 184–208.
- Dubin, J. A., & McFadden, D. M. (1983). An econometric analysis of residential electric appliance holding and consumption. Econometrica, 52, 345–362. CrossRef
- Economides, N., Seim, K., & Viard, V. B. (2004). Quantifying the benefits of entry into local telephone service. Working Paper, Stanford University.
- Erdem, T., & Keane, M. P. (1996). Decision-making under uncertainty: capturing dynamic brand choice processes in turbulent consumer goods markets. Marketing Science, 15, 1–20. CrossRef
- Goettler, R. L., & Clay, K. (2006). Price discrimination with experience goods: sorting-induced biases and illusive surplus. Working Paper, Carnegie Mellon University.
- Hanneman, M. (1984). The discrete continuous model of consumer demand. Econometrica, 52, 541–561. CrossRef
- Hobson, M., & Spady, R. H. (1988). The demand for local telephone service under optional local measured service. Bellcore Economics Discussion Paper No. 50.
- Huang, C.-I. (2006). Estimating demand for cellular phone service under nonlinear pricing. Working Paper, Northwestern University.
- Iyengar, R. (2004). A structural demand analysis for wireless services under nonlinear pricing schemes. Working Paper, Columbia University.
- Iyengar, R., Ansari, A., & Gupta, S. (2006). A model of consumer learning for service usage and quality. Working Paper, University of Pennsylvania.
- Jin, G. Z., & Sorensen, A. T. (2005). Information and consumer choice: the value of publicized health plan ratings. Working Paper, University of Maryland, College Park.
- Lambrecht, A., Seim, K., & Skiera, B. (2005). Does uncertainty matter? Consumer behavior under three-part tariffs. Working Paper, University of California at Los Angeles.
- MacKie-Mason, J. K., & Lawson, D. (1993). Local telephone calling demand when customers face optimal and nonlinear price schedules. Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of Michigan.
- Manski, C. F., & Lerman, S. R. (1977). The estimation of choice probabilities from choice based samples. Econometrica, 45, 1977–1988. CrossRef
- Miravete, E. (2002). Choosing the wrong calling plan? Ignorance and learning. American Economic Review, 93, 297–310. CrossRef
- Moshkin, N. V., & Shachar, R. (2002). The asymmetric information model of state dependence. Marketing Science, 21, 435–454. CrossRef
- Nair, H. S., Dube, J.-P., & Chintagunta, P. K. (2005). Accounting for primary and secondary demand effects with aggregate data. Marketing Science, 24, 444–460. CrossRef
- Park, R. E., Wetzel, B. M., & Mitchell, B. M. (1983). Charging for local telephone calls: how household characteristics affect the distribution of calls in the GTE illinois experiment. Journal of Econometrics, 22, 339–364. CrossRef
- Small, K. A., & Rosen, H. S. (1981). Applied welfare economics with discrete choice models. Econometrica, 49, 105–130. CrossRef
- Song, I., & Chintagunta, P. K. (2006). A discrete/continuous model for multi-category purchase behavior of households. Journal of Marketing Research, forthcoming.
- Train, K. E., McFadden, D. L., & Ben-Akiva, M. (1987). The demand for local telephone service: a fully discrete model of residential calling patterns and service choices. Rand Journal of Economics, 18, 109–123. CrossRef
- The role of self selection, usage uncertainty and learning in the demand for local telephone service
Quantitative Marketing and Economics
Volume 5, Issue 1 , pp 1-34
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers-Plenum Publishers
- Additional Links
- Value of information
- Discrete/continuous models
- Learning models
- Optional calling plans
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, 518 Memorial Way, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA
- 2. Graduate School of Business, University of Chicago, Chicago, USA
- 3. Department of Economics, University of Texas at Austin, BRB 1.116, 1 University Station C3100, Austin, Texas, 78712-0301, USA
- 4. CEPR, London, UK