Does telecommuting reduce vehicle-miles traveled? An aggregate time series analysis for the U.S.
Cite this article as: Choo, S., Mokhtarian, P.L. & Salomon, I. Transportation (2005) 32: 37. doi:10.1007/s11116-004-3046-7 Abstract
. This study examines the impact of telecommuting on passenger vehicle-miles traveled (VMT) through a multivariate time series analysis of aggregate nationwide data spanning 1966–1999 for all variables except telecommuting, and 1988–1998 for telecommuting. The analysis was conducted in two stages. In the first stage, VMT (1966–1999) was modeled as a function of conventional variables representing economic activity, transportation price, transportation supply and socio-demographics. In the second stage, the residuals of the first stage (1988–1998) were modeled as a function of the number of telecommuters. We also assessed the change in annual VMT per telecommuter as well as VMT per telecommuting occasion, for 1998. The models suggest that telecommuting reduces VMT, with 94% confidence. Together with independent external evidence, the results suggest a reduction in annual VMT on the order of 0.8% or less. Even with impacts that small, when informally compared to similar reductions in VMT due to public transit ridership, telecommuting appears to be far more cost-effective in terms of public sector expenditures.
Keywords aggregate analysis telecommuting teleworking time series analysis vehicle-miles traveled modeling/forecasting References Box, GEP, Jenkins, GM 1976Time Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control Holden-Day San Francisco Google Scholar
Choo S, Mokhtarian, PL & Salomon I (2001)
Impacts of Telecommuting on Vehicle-Miles Traveled: A Nationwide Time Series Analysis. Publication No. P600-01-020, the California Energy Commission, Sacramento, CA. Available at www.its.ucdavis.edu/publications/2002/RR-02-05.pdf. Conlisk, J 1971 When collinearity is desirable Western Economic Journal 9 393 407 Google Scholar DeCorla-Souza, P 2000 Induced highway travel: Transportation policy implications for congested metropolitan areas Transportation Quarterly 54 13 30 Google Scholar Gately, D 1990 The U.S demand for highway travel and motor fuel The Energy Journal 11 59 73 Google Scholar Greene, DL 1992 Vehicle use and fuel economy: How big is the ‘rebound’ effect The Energy Journal 13 117 143 Google Scholar Greene, WH 1997Econometric Analysis3 Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ Google Scholar Hamer, R, Kroes, E, van Ooststroom, H 1991 Teleworking in The Netherlands: An evaluation of changes in travel behaviour Transportation 18 365 382 Google Scholar Henderson, DK, Koenig, BE, Mokhtarian, PL 1996 Using travel diary data to estimate the emissions impacts of transportation strategies: The Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration Project Journal of the Air and Waste Management Association 46 47 57 Google Scholar
Holtzclaw J (undated) Does a mile in a car equal a mile on a train? Exploring public transit’s effectiveness in reducing driving. Available at www.sierraclub.org/sprawl/articles/reducedriving.asp, accessed July 10, 2004. Also available as Table 5 at http://www.vtpi.org/tdm/tdm62.htm (accessed July 10, 2004), with further discussion.
Hu, PS, Young, JR 1999Summary of Travel Trends: 1995 Nationwide Personal Transportation Survey. Publication No. FHWA-PL-00-006 US Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration Washington, DC Google Scholar Illegems, V, Verbeke, A, S’Jegers, R 2001 The organizational context of teleworking implementation Technological Forecasting and Social Change 68 275 291 Google Scholar Kennedy, P 1998A Guide to Econometrics4 MIT Press Cambridge, MA Google Scholar Kitamura, R, Nilles, J, Fleming, D, Conroy, P 1990 Telecommuting as a transportation planning measure: Initial results of State of California pilot project Transportation Research Record 1285 98 104 Google Scholar Kumapley, RK, Fricker, JD 1996 Review of methods for estimating vehicle miles traveled Transportation Research Record 1551 59 66 Google Scholar Mankiw, NG 2003Macroeconomics5 Worth Publishers New York, NY Google Scholar Mokhtarian, PL 1998 A synthetic approach to estimating the impacts of telecommuting on travel Urban Studies 35 215 241 Google Scholar Mokhtarian, PL, Varma, KV 1998 The tradeoff between trips and distance traveled in analyzing the emissions impacts of center-based telecommuting Transportation Research D 3 419 428 Google Scholar Mokhtarian, PL, Handy, SL, Salomon, I 1995 Methodological issues in the estimation of travel, energy, and air quality impacts of telecommuting Transportation Research A 29 283 302 Google Scholar
Mokhtarian PL, Salomon I Choo S (forthcoming) Measuring the measurable: Why can’t we agree on the number of telecommuters in the US? Quality and Quatity.
Nilles, JM 1988 Traffic reduction by telecommuting: A status review and selected bibliography Transportation Research A 22 301 317 Google Scholar Nilles, JM, Carlson, FR, Jr., Gray, P, Hanneman, GJ 1976The Telecommunications-Transportation Tradeoff: Options for Tomorrow John Wiley and Sons New York Google Scholar Noland, RB 2001 Relationships between highway capacity and induced vehicle travel Transportation Research A 35 47 72 Google Scholar Pendyala, R, Goulias, KG, Kitamura, R 1991 Impact of telecommuting on spatial and temporal patterns of household travel Transportation 18 383 409 Google Scholar
Quantitative Micro Software (2000)
EViews 4.0 User’s Guide. Irvine, CA: Quantitative Micro Software. Savin, NE, White, KJ 1977 The Durbin–Watson test for serial correlation with extreme sample sizes or many regressors Econometrica 45 1989 1996 Google Scholar Schimek, P 1996 Gasoline and travel demand models using time series and cross-section data from United States Transportation Research Record 1558 83 89 Google Scholar Springer, RK, Resek, RW 1981 An econometric model of gasoline consumption, vehicle miles traveled, and new car purchases Energy Systems and Policy 5 73 87 Google Scholar Ulberg, C, Gordon, A, Spain, D, Fortenbery, E, Whitaker, B, Fireman, S 1993Evaluation of the Puget Sound Telecommuting Demonstration: Survey Results and Qualitative Research Washington State Energy Office Olympia, Washington Google Scholar
United States Department of Energy (1994)
Energy, Emissions, and Social Consequences of Telecommuting. Washington, DC: US DOE Office of Policy, Planning, and Program Evaluation, Report No. DOE/PO–0026. Varma, KV, Ho, C-I, Stanek, DM, Mokhtarian, PL 1998 Duration and frequency of telecenter use: Once a telecommuter, always a telecommuter Transportation Research C 6 47 68 Google Scholar
Ziliak ST & McCloskey DN (2003) Size matters: The standard error of regressions in the
American Economic Review. Available at www.econ.mq.edu/seminars/McCloskey.pdf, accessed February 17, 2004.