State-level Welfare Policies and Nonmarital Subsequent Childbearing Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Ryan, S., Manlove, J. & Hofferth, S.L. Popul Res Policy Rev (2006) 25: 103. doi:10.1007/s11113-006-0004-4 Abstract
Using discrete time event history analyses of data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID), we examine the association between state-level welfare waiver policies implemented before the 1996 welfare reform legislation and the risk of a nonmarital subsequent birth. Our study makes a unique contribution to the existing literature by using a national-level sample of unmarried mothers who ever received welfare. This high-risk sample represents the women of most interest to policymakers, as it is the exact group to whom welfare reform is targeted—welfare mothers at risk of having nonmarital additional births. The state policies we study include: family cap, earnings disregard, work exemptions, work requirements, and sanctions. We conclude that, although reducing the number of nonmarital births is a key goal of welfare reform, state-established welfare waiver policies do not have any influence on women’s childbearing behaviors in this sample, net of women’s individual characteristics and state economic environments. Even the family cap policy, which was designed for the sole purpose of reducing additional births, has no significant association with nonmarital subsequent childbearing. Instead, personal characteristics, not public policies, are stronger determinants of women’s childbearing decisions. Age, race/ethnicity, marital status, number of previous children, education level, and welfare receipt are significantly associated with nonmarital subsequent births. Overall, this paper contributes to an expanding body of research that shows minimal effects of welfare waivers on fertility. Our work suggests that more targeted policies are necessary to be able to influence individual family formation behaviors.
Keywords Family cap Fertility Nonmarital childbearing Welfare References
ACF Press Office. (2003). Re: HHS release – TANF program [press release]. Message posted to the Health and Human Services (HHS) press mailing list, archived at www.HHS.gov/news
Administration for Children and Families. (2003, 6/6/02). Fact sheets [Website]. Retrieved 10/19/03 from the World Wide Web: www.acf.dhhs.gov/news/facts/tanf.html
Allison, P. D. 1995Survival analysis using the SAS system: A practical guide SAS Institute Cary NC Google Scholar Becketti, S., Gould, W., Lillard, L., Welch, F. 1988 The PSID after fourteen years: An evaluation Journal of Labor Economics 6 472 492 CrossRef Google Scholar Beecroft, E., Cahill, K., Goodson, B. D. 2002The impacts of welfare reform on children: The Indiana welfare reform evaluation Abt Associates Inc Bethesda MD Google Scholar Blank, R. M. 2002 Evaluating welfare reform in the United States Journal of Economic Literature XL 1105 1166 CrossRef Google Scholar Bloom, D., Kemple, J., Morris, P., Scrivener, S., Verma, N., Hendra, R. 2000The family transition program: Final report on Florida’s initial time-limited welfare program Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation (MDRC) New York Google Scholar Bloom, D., Scrivener, S., Michalopoulos, C., Morris, P., Hendra, R., Adams-Ciardullo, D., Walter, J., Vargas, W. 2002Jobs first: Final report on Connecticut’s welfare reform initiative Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation (MDRC) New York Google Scholar Brown, S. L. 2000 Union transitions among cohabitors: The significance of relationship assessments and expectations Journal of Marriage and the Family 62 833 846 CrossRef Google Scholar Bumpass, L., Lu, H. 2000 Trends in cohabitation and implications for children’s family contexts in the United States Population Studies 54 29 41 Google Scholar Butler, A. C. 2002 Welfare, premarital childbearing, and the role of normative climate, 1968–1994 Journal of Marriage and the Family 64 295 313 CrossRef Google Scholar Camasso, M. J., Harvey, C., Jagannathan, R., Killingsworth, M. 1998aA final report on the impact of New Jersey’s family development program Rutgers University New Brunswick NJ Google Scholar Camasso, M. J., Harvey, C., Jagannathan, R., Killingsworth, M. 1998bA final report on the impact of New Jersey’s family development program. Results from a pre-post analysis of AFDC case heads from 1990 to 1996 Rutgers University New Brunswick NJ Google Scholar Caudill, S. B., Mixon, F. G. J. 2000 AFDC payments and illegitimacy ratios: A reappraisal of endogeneity using panel data American Journal of Economics and Sociology 59 451 462 CrossRef Google Scholar Council of Economic Advisors 1999The effects of welfare policy and the economic expansion on welfare caseloads: An update Council of Economic Advisors Washington, DC Google Scholar David, P. A., Sanderson, W. C. 1987 The emergence of a two-child norm among American birth controllers Population and Development Review 13 1 41 Google Scholar Fein, D. 1999Will welfare reform influence marriage and fertility? Early evidence from the ABC demonstration Abt Associates Inc Bethesda, MD Google Scholar Fein, D., Lindberg, L., London, R. A., Mauldon, J. 2002Welfare reform and family formation: Assessing the effects (Research Brief 1) Welfare Reform and Family Formation Project Bethesda, MD Google Scholar
Figlio, D. N., & Ziliak, J. P. (1998).
Welfare reform, the business cycle, and the decline in AFDC caseloads. Paper presented at the Conference on Welfare Reform and the Macroeconomy. Washington DC. Fitzgerald, J., Gottschalk, P., Moffitt, R. A. 1998a An analysis of sample attrition in panel data: The Michigan Panel Study of Income Dynamics Journal of Human Resources 33 251 299 CrossRef Google Scholar Fitzgerald, J., Gottschalk, P., Moffitt, R. A. 1998b The impact of attrition in the Panel Study of Income Dynamics on intergenerational analysis Journal of Human Resources 33 300 344 CrossRef Google Scholar
Fitzgerald, J., & Ribar, D. (2001).
The impact of welfare waivers on female headship decisions. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Washington DC. Foster, E. M., Hoffman, S. D. 2001 The young and the not quite so young: Age variation in the impact of AFDC benefits on nonmarital childbearing Wu Wolfe, L. L. B. eds. Out of wedlock: Causes and consequences of nonmarital fertility Russell Sage Foundation New York 173 201 Google Scholar Fraker, T. M., Ross, C. M., Stapulonis, R. A., Olse, R. B., Kovac, M. D., Dion, M. R., Rangarajan, A. 2002The evaluation of welfare reform in Iowa: Final impact report Mathematica Policy Research, Inc Washington DC Google Scholar
Gennetian, L., & Knox, V. (2003).
Staying single: The effects of welfare and employment programs on marriage and cohabitation. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Policy Analysis and Management, Washington DC.
Gibson, C., Edin, K., & McLanahan, S. (2003).
High hopes but even higher expectations: The retreat from marriage among low-income couples. Working paper 03-06-FF. Princeton NJ: Center for Research on Child Wellbeing Graefe, D. R., Lichter, D. T. 2002 Marriage among unwed mothers: Whites, blacks and Hispanics compared Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health 34 286 174 CrossRef Google Scholar Grogger, J., Karoly, L. A., Klerman, J. A. 2002Consequences of welfare reform: A research synthesis (DRU-2676-DHHS) RAND Santa Monica CA Google Scholar Harris, K. M., Raley, R. K., Rindfuss, R. R. 2002 Family configurations and child-care patterns: Families with two or more preschool-aged children Social Science Quarterly 83 455 471 CrossRef Google Scholar Hofferth, S. 1996 Child care in the United States today The Future of Children 6 41 61 CrossRef Google Scholar Hofferth, S. L., Stanhope, S., Harris, K. M. 2002 Exiting welfare in the 1990s: Did public policy influence recipients’ behavior? Population Research and Policy Review 21 433 472 CrossRef Google Scholar Horvath-Rose, A., Peters, H. 2001 Welfare waivers and non-marital childbearing Duncan Chase-Lansdale, G. P. L. eds. For better and for worse: Welfare reform and the well-being of children and families Russell Sage New York 222 244 Google Scholar Jagannathan, R., Camasso, M. J. 2003 Family cap and nonmarital fertility: The racial conditioning of policy effects Journal of Marriage and the Family 65 52 71 CrossRef Google Scholar
Joyce, T., Kaestner, R., & Korenman, S. (2003). Welfare reform and non-marital fertility in the 1990s: Evidence from birth records.
Advances in Economic Analysis & Policy, 3
: Article 6.
http://www.bepress.com/bejeap/advances/vol3/iss1/art6 Kaestner, R., Korenman, S., O’Neill, J. 2003 Has welfare reform changed teenage behaviors? Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 22 225 248 CrossRef Google Scholar Kaushal, N., Kaestner, R. 2001 Welfare to work: Has welfare reform worked? Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 20 699 719 CrossRef Google Scholar
Kearney, M. S. (2002).
Is there an effect of incremental welfare benefits on fertility behavior? A look at the family cap. Working paper. Cambridge MA: National Bureau of Economic Research Knox, V. W., Miller, C., Gennetian, L. 2000Reforming welfare and rewarding work: A summary of the final report on the Minnesota Family Investment Program MDRC New York Google Scholar
Levin-Epstein, J. (2003).
Lifting the lid off the family cap: States revisit problematic policy for welfare mothers. Childbearing and Reproductive Health Series Brief No. 1. Washington D.C.: Center for Law and Social Policy Lichter, D. T., Graefe, D. R. 2001 Finding a mate? The marital and cohabitation histories of unwed mothers Wu Wolfe, L. L. B. eds. Out of wedlock: Causes and consequences of nonmarital fertility Russell Sage Foundation New York 317 343 Google Scholar Lichter, D. T., Jayakody, R. 2002 Welfare reform: How do we measure success Annual Review of Sociology 28 117 141 CrossRef Google Scholar Loury, G. C. 2001 Preventing subsequent births to welfare recipients Besharov Germanis, D. J. P. eds. Preventing subsequent births to welfare mothers University of Maryland School of Public Affairs College Park MD Google Scholar Manlove, J., Mariner, C., Papillo, A. R. 2000 Subsequent fertility among teen mothers: Longitudinal analyses of recent national data Journal of Marriage & the Family 62 430 448 CrossRef Google Scholar Manning Smock, W. D. P. J. 1995 Why marry? Race and the transition to marriage among cohabitors Journal of Marriage and the Family 58 998 1010 CrossRef Google Scholar Martin, J. A., Hamilton, B. E., Sutton, P. D., Ventura, S. J., Menacker, F., Munson, M. L. 2003Births: Final data for 2002. National vital statistics reports (vol. 52, no. 10) National Center for Health Statistics Hyattsville, MD Google Scholar Martin, J., Park, M. M., Sutton, P. D. 2002Preliminary data for 2001. National vital statistics reports (vol. 50) National Center for Health Statistics Hyattsville, MD Google Scholar
Moffitt, R. A. (1999).
The effect of pre-PRWORA waivers on AFDC caseloads and female earnings, income, and labor force behavior. Paper presented at the ASSA Meetings. New York NY, January.
Moore, K. A. (1995).
Executive summary: Report to congress on out-of-wedlock childbearing
. (Full report available from DHHS Publication No. 95-1257-1). Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Also available on the Internet at:
http://www.cdc.gov/nchswww/nchshome.htm Musick, K 2002 Planned and unplanned childbearing among unmarried women Journal of Marriage and the Family 64 915 929 CrossRef Google Scholar Nechyba, T. J. 2001 Social approval, values, and AFDC: A reexamination of the illegitimate debate Journal of Political Economy 109 637 672 CrossRef Google Scholar Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning, Evaluation 1997Setting the baseline: A report on state welfare waivers U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Washington, DC Google Scholar Rindfuss, R. R., Parnell, A. M. 1989 The varying connection between marital status and childbearing in the united states Population and Development Review 15 447 470 Google Scholar Rosenzweig, M. 1999 Welfare, marital prospects, and nonmarital childbearing Journal of Political Economy 107 3 32 CrossRef Google Scholar Rossi, P. H. 2001 New Jersey’s family development program: An overview and critique of the Rutgers’ evaluation Besharov Germanis, D. J. P eds. Preventing subsequent births to welfare mothers University of Maryland School of Public Affairs College Park MD Google Scholar
Terry-Humen, E., Manlove, J., & Moore, K. A. (2001).
Births outside of marriage: Perceptions vs. Reality. Child Trends Research Brief. Washington, DC: Child Trends Turturro, C., Benda, B., Turney, H. 1997Arkansas welfare waiver demonstration project final report University of Arkansas at Little Rock, School of Social Work Little Rock, AK Google Scholar
U.S. Congress. (1996).
Public law 104–193: Personal responsibility and work opportunity reconciliation act of 1996: H.R. 3734, 1996 U.S. General Accounting Office 1997Implications of increased work participation for child care U.S. General Accounting Office Washington, DC Google Scholar Upchurch, D. M., Lillard, L. A., Panis, C. W. A. 2001 The impact of nonmarital childbearing on subsequent marital formation and dissolution Wu Wolfe, L. L. B. eds. Out of wedlock: Causes and consequences of nonmarital fertility Russell Sage Foundation New York 344 380 Google Scholar
Wallace, G., & Blank, R. (1999).
What goes up must come down? Explaining recent changes in public assistance caseloads. Paper presented at the Conference on Welfare Reform and the Macroeconomy, Washington DC Wilde, P. E., Hofferth, S., Stanhope, S., Noonan, M., Collins, N. 2000 Pre-1997 trends in welfare and food assistance in a national sample of families American Journal of Agricultural Economics 82 642 648 CrossRef Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2006