Emerging from the causal drain
- Richard Corry
- … show all 1 hide
Purchase on Springer.com
$39.95 / €34.95 / £29.95*
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.
For over 20 years, Jaegwon Kim’s Causal Exclusion Argument has stood as the major hurdle for non-reductive physicalism. If successful, Kim’s argument would show that the high-level properties posited by non-reductive physicalists must either be identical with lower-level physical properties, or else must be causally inert. The most prominent objection to the Causal Exclusion Argument—the so-called Overdetermination Objection—points out that there are some notions of causation that are left untouched by the argument. If causation is simply counterfactual dependence, for example, then the Causal Exclusion Argument fails. Thus, much of the existing debate turns on the issue of which account of causation is appropriate. In this paper, however, I take a bolder approach and argue that Kim’s preferred version of the Causal Exclusion Argument fails no matter what account one gives of causation. Any notion of causation that is strong enough to support the premises of the argument is too strong to play the role required in the logic of the argument. I also consider a second version of the Causal Exclusion Argument, and suggest that although it may avoid the problems of the first version, it begs the question against a particular form of non-reductive physicalism, namely emergentism.
- Anscombe, G. E. M. (1971). Causality and determination: An inaugural lecture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Armstrong, D. (1997). A world of states of affairs. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef
- Burge, T. (1993). Mind-body causation and explanatory practice. In J. Heil & A. Mele (Eds.), Mental causation (pp. 97–120). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
- Cartwright, N. (1983). How the laws of physics lie. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Corry, R. (2006). Causal realism and the laws of nature. Philosophy of Science, 73(3), 261–276. CrossRef
- Corry, R. (2009). How is scientific analysis possible? In T. Handfield (Ed.), Dispositions and causes (pp. 158–188). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Crane, T., & Mellor, D. H. (1990). There is no question of physicalism. Mind, 99(394), 185–206. CrossRef
- Creary, L. (1981). Causal explanation and the reality of natural component forces. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly, 62(2), 148–157.
- Crisp, T. M., & Warfield, T. A. (2001). Kim’s master argument. Noûs, 35(2), 304–316. CrossRef
- Hitchcock, C. (2007). What Russell got right. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 45–65). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Horgan, T. E. (1997). Kim on mental causation and causal exclusion. Philosophical Perspectives, 11, 165–184.
- Kim, J. (1989). Mechanism, purpose, and explanatory exclusion. Philosophical Perspectives, 3, 77–108. CrossRef
- Kim, J. (1990). Explanatory exclusion and the problem of mental causation. In E. Villanueva (Ed.), Information, semantics, and epistemology (pp. 36–56). Cambridge, MA: Basil Blackwell.
- Kim, J. (1992). “Downward causation” in emergentism and non-reductive physicalism. In A. Beckermann, H. Flohr, & J. Kim (Eds.), Emergence or reduction?. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
- Kim, J. (1993a). The non-reductivist’s troubles with mental causation. In J. Heil & A. Mele (Eds.), Mental causation (pp. 189–210). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
- Kim, J. (1993b). Supervenience and mind. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef
- Kim, J. (1998). Mind in a physical world: An essay on the mind-body problem and mental causation. Cambridge, MA: Bradford Books.
- Kim, J. (2003). Blocking causal drain and other maintenance chores with mental causation. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 67(1), 151–176. CrossRef
- Kim, J. (2005). Physicalism, or something near enough. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Kim, J. (2006a). Being realistic about emergence. In P. Clayton & P. Davies (Eds.), The re-emergence of emergence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Kim, J. (2006b). Philosophy of mind. Cambridge, MA: Westview Press.
- Kim, J. (2006c). Emergence: Core ideas and issues. Synthese, 151(3), 547–559. CrossRef
- List, C., & Menzies, P. (2009). Nonreductive physicalism and the limits of the exclusion principle. Journal of Philosophy, CVI(9), 475–502.
- Loewer, B. (2001). Review of J. Kim, mind in a physical world. Journal of Philosophy, 98(6), 315–324. CrossRef
- Loewer, B. (2007). Counterfactuals and the second law. In H. Price & R. Corry (Eds.), Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality: Russell’s republic revisited (pp. 293–326). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- McLaughlin, B. P. (1992). The rise and fall of British emergentism. In A. Beckermann, H. Flohr, & J. Kim (Eds.), Emergence or reduction?: Prospects for nonreductive physicalism. Berlin: De Gruyter.
- Nagel, E. (1949). The meaning of reduction in the natural sciences. In R. Stauffer (Ed.), Science and civilization (pp. 99–135). Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
- O’Connor, T., & Wong, H. Y. (2005). The metaphysics of emergence. Noûs, 39(4), 658–678. CrossRef
- Sarkar, S. (1992). Models of reduction and categories of reductionism. Synthese, 91(3), 167–194. CrossRef
- Wimsatt, W. C. (1979). Reductionism and reduction. In P. D. Asquith & H. E. Kyburg (Eds.), Current research in philosophy of science (pp. 352–377). East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association.
- Wong, H. Y. (2010). The secret lives of emergents. In A. Corradini & T. O’Connor (Eds.), Emergence in science and philosophy (pp. 7–24). New York: Routledge.
- Woodward, J. (2003). Making things happen: A theory of causal explanation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Emerging from the causal drain
Volume 165, Issue 1 , pp 29-47
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Jaegwon Kim
- Non-reductive physicalism
- Causal Exclusion
- Richard Corry (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. School of Philosophy, University of Tasmania, Private Bag 41, Hobart, TAS, 7001, Australia