Holism about value: some help for invariabilists
- Daniel Halliday
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
G.E. Moore’s principle of organic unity holds that the intrinsic value of a whole may differ from the sum of the intrinsic values of its parts. Moore combined this principle with invariabilism about intrinsic value: An item’s intrinsic value depends solely on its bearer’s intrinsic properties, not on which wholes it has membership of. It is often said that invariabilism ought to be rejected in favour of what might be called ‘conditionalism’ about intrinsic value. This paper is an attempt to show how invariabilism might be filled out in ways that allow its proponents to answer their conditionalist opponents. The main point consists in identifying how some amount of extrinsic part-value may contribute to whole-value that is nevertheless intrinsic. This enables an invariabilist to explain how the intrinsic value of a whole may differ from the sum of its intrinsic part-values, without abandoning the Moorean doctrine that intrinsic value supervenes on intrinsic properties (the proposal is nevertheless consistent with the view that invariabilist and conditionalist accounts might exist side by side). I finish with a brief explanation of how the main proposal could help construct invariabilist accounts of particular organic unities, looking beyond the more general argument they have with conditionalists.
- Bradley, B. (1998). Extrinsic value. Philosophical Studies, 91, 109–126. CrossRef
- Bradley, B. (2002). Is intrinsic value conditional? Philosophical Studies, 107, 23–44. CrossRef
- Bradley, B. (2006). Two concepts of intrinsic value. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 9, 111–130. CrossRef
- Broome, J. (1991). Weighing goods. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Brown, C. (2007). Two kinds of holism about values. The Philosophical Quarterly, 57(228), 456–463. CrossRef
- Chisholm, R. (1986). Brentano and intrinsic value. New York: Cambridge University Press.
- Dancy, J. (2003). Are there organic unities? Ethics, 113(3), 629–650. CrossRef
- Dancy, J. (2004). Ethics without principles. New York: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Dorsey, D. (2012). Intrinsic value and the supervenience principle. Philosophical Studies, 157, 267–285. CrossRef
- Fletcher, G. (2008). The consistency of qualitative hedonism and the value of (at least some) malicious pleasures. Utilitas, 20, 462–471. CrossRef
- Fletcher, G. (2010). Brown and Moore’s value invariabilism vs Dancy’s variabilism. The Philosophical Quarterly, 60(238), 162–168. CrossRef
- Hurka, T. (1998). Two kinds of organic unity. The Journal of Ethics, 2, 299–320. CrossRef
- Kagan, S. (1998). Rethinking intrinsic value. The Journal of Ethics, 2, 277–297. CrossRef
- Korsgaard, C. (1983). Two distinctions in goodness. (Reprinted in Creating the kingdom of ends, New York: Cambridge University Press.)
- Langton, R. (2007). Objective and unconditioned value. The Philosophical Review, 116, 157–185. CrossRef
- Lemos, N. (1994). Intrinsic value: Concept and warrant. New York: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef
- Lemos, N. (2006). Indeterminate value, basic value, and summation. In K. McDaniel, J. Raibley, R. Feldman, & M. Zimmerman (Eds.), The good, the right, life and death: Essays in honor of Fred Feldman. Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing.
- Lewis, D. (1983). Extrinsic properties. Philosophical Studies, 44(2), 197–200. CrossRef
- Moore, G.E. (1903). Principia Ethica. New York: Cambridge University Press.
- Rabinowicz, W., & Ronnow-Rasmussen, T. (1999). A distinction in value: Intrinsic and for its own sake. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 33–51.
- Zimmerman, M. (1999). Virtual intrinsic value and the principle of organic unities. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 59, 653–666. CrossRef
- Zimmerman, M. (2001). The nature of intrinsic value. New York: Rowman & Littlefield.
- Holism about value: some help for invariabilists
Volume 165, Issue 3 , pp 1033-1046
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Intrinsic value
- Extrinsic value
- Organic unity
- Daniel Halliday (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, University of Melbourne, Parkville, VIC, 3010, Australia