The pain of rejection, the sweetness of revenge
- Crispin Wright
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
I focus on Richard’s repudiation of Frege’s doctrine of the primacy of assertion and his proposal that a sui generis speech act/attitude of denial, or rejection,
The main chapters of When Truth Gives Out speak interchangeably of ‘denial’ and ‘rejection’, but the latter also features as a term for a third sui generis form of speech act in Appendix 1. I’ll frame the discussion to follow in terms of ‘rejection’ reserving ‘denial’—I’ll usually say: “proper denial”—for a form of illocution of P appropriate when P is false in the same way and to just the extent that the assertion of P is appropriate when P is true.is needed to address both the phenomenon of borderline-case vagueness and the semantic paradoxes.
Richard’s driving thought about vagueness is encapsulated in the following passage:
If Jo is a borderline case of baldness, he is not bald. If so, it is a fact that Jo is not bald, and one can state that fact by seriously uttering
(0) Jo is not bald
And if Jo is a borderline case of baldn ...
- Beall, Jc. (2009). Spandrels of truth. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Field, H. (2008). Saving truth from paradox. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Priest, G. (2006). In contradiction. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Restall, G. (2006). In progress, assertion, denial, accepting, rejecting, symmetry, paradox and all that. http://consequently.org/papers/assertiondenialparadox.pdf
- Rumfitt, I. (2000). “Yes” and “no”. Mind, 109(436), 781–823. CrossRef
- Wright, C. (2001). On being in a quandary: Relativism, vagueness, logical revisionism. Mind, CX, 45–98; reprinted in The Philosopher’s Annual, volume 24 (2001).
- Wright, C. (2003). Vagueness: A fifth column approach. In J. C. Beall & M. Glanzberg (Eds.), Liars & heaps: New essays on paradox. Oxford: Oxford University press.
- Wright, C. (2007). Wang’s paradox. In R. Auxier & L. Hahn (Eds.), The philosophy of Michael Dummett: the library of living philosophers (Vol. XXXI). Open Court: Chicago and La Salle.
- Wright, C. (2010). The illusion of higher-order vagueness. In R. Dietz & S. Morruzzi (Eds.), Cuts and clouds. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Wright, C. (forthcoming). On the characterisation of borderline cases. In G. Ostertag (Ed.), Meanings and other things: essays on Stephen Schiffer. Cambridge: MIT press.
- The pain of rejection, the sweetness of revenge
Volume 160, Issue 3 , pp 465-476
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Crispin Wright (1) (2)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Philosophy, New York University, 5 Washington Place, New York, NY, USA
- 2. The Northern Institute of Philosophy, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, AB24 3UB, Scotland