Minimalism on quotation? Critical review of Cappelen and Lepore’s language turned on itself
- Manuel García-Carpintero
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Research on quotation has mostly focussed in the past years on “mixed” or “open” quotation. In a recent book-length discussion of the topic, Cappelen and Lepore have abandon their previous Davidsonian allegiances, proposing a new view that they describe as minimalist, to a good extend on the basis of facts concerning mixed quotation. In this paper I critically review Cappelen and Lepore’s new minimalist proposals, briefly outlining my preferred Davidsonian view as a useful foil. I explore first their allegedly non-Davidsonian, anti-contextualist views about pure quotation, and then their new views on mixed quotation. I have complained in the first place that their proposals are not presented as perspicuously as they should be; and in the second place that, when we have a clearer picture of what appears to be the favoured account, the differences with their previous proposals and others already in the literature are not as great as they claim.
- Braun, D. (2005). Empty names, fictional names, mythical names. Noûs, 39, 596–631. CrossRef
- Cappelen, H., & Lepore, E. (1997). Varieties of quotation. Mind, 106, 429–450. CrossRef
- Cappelen, H., & Lepore, E. (1999). Using, mentioning and quoting: A reply to Saka. Mind, 108, 741–750. CrossRef
- Cappelen, H., & Lepore, E. (2007). Language turned on itself. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Cumming, S. (2005). Two accounts of indexicals in mixed quotation. Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 17, 77–88. CrossRef
- Davidson, D. (1979). Quotation. Theory and Decision, 11, 27–40. (Reprinted in Davidson, D. (1984). Inquiries into truth and interpretation. Oxford: Clarendon Press).
- García-Carpintero, M. (1994). Ostensive signs: Against the identity theory of quotation. Journal of Philosophy, xci, 253–264.
- García-Carpintero, M. (1998). Indexicals as token-reflexives. Mind, 107, 529–563.
- García-Carpintero, M. (2004). The deferred ostension theory of quotation. Noûs, xxxviii(4), 674–692.
- García-Carpintero, M. (2005). Double-duty quotation: The deferred ostension account. Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 17, 89–106.
- García-Carpintero, M. (2006). Recanati on the semantics/pragmatics distinction. Crítica, 38, 35–68.
- García-Carpintero, M. (2007). Bivalence and what is said. Dialectica, 61, 167–190.
- García-Carpintero, M. (Forthcoming). Double-duty quotation, conventional implicatures and what is said. In E. Brendel, J. Meibauer & M. Steinbach (Eds.), Understanding quotation. Berlin, New York: Mouton de Gruyter (Mouton Series in Pragmatics 7).
- Geurts, B., & Maier, E. (2005). Quotation in context. Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 17, 109–128. CrossRef
- Gómez Torrente, M. (2001). Quotation revisited. Philosophical Studies, 102, 123–153. CrossRef
- Gómez Torrente, M. (2005). Remarks on impure quotation. Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 17, 129–147. CrossRef
- Kaplan, D. (1989). Demonstratives. In J. Almog, J. Perry, & H. Wettstein (Eds.), Themes from Kaplan (pp. 481–563). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Nunberg, G. (1993). Indexicals and deixis. Linguistics and Philosophy, 16, 1–43. CrossRef
- Potts, C. (2005a). The logic of conventional implicatures. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Potts, C. (2005b). Lexicalized intonational meaning. University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers, 30, 129–146.
- Potts, C. (2007). The dimensions of quotation. In C. Barker & P. Jacobson (Eds.), Direct compositionality (pp. 405–431). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Predelli, S. (2003). Scare quotes and their relation to other semantic issues. Linguistics and Philosophy, 26, 1–28. CrossRef
- Predelli, S. (2008). The demonstrative theory of quotation. Linguistics and Philosophy, 31, 555–572. CrossRef
- Recanati, F. (2001). Open quotation. Mind, 110, 637–687. CrossRef
- Reimer, M. (2005). Too counter-intuitive to believe? Pragmatic accounts of mixed quotation. Belgian Journal of Linguistics, 17, 167–186. CrossRef
- Tsohatzidis, S. (1998). The hybrid theory of mixed quotation. Mind, 107, 661–664. CrossRef
- von Fintel, K. (2008). What is presupposition accommodation, again? Philosophical Perspectives, 22, 137–170. CrossRef
- Washington, C. (1992). The identity theory of quotation. Journal of Philosophy, LXXXIX, 582–605. CrossRef
- Minimalism on quotation? Critical review of Cappelen and Lepore’s language turned on itself
Volume 161, Issue 2 , pp 207-225
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Pure quotation
- Mixed quotation
- Direct discourse
- Conventional implicatures
- Author Affiliations
- 1. LOGOS-Departament de Lògica, Història i Filosofia de la Ciència, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain