Ostracoda as an aid in identifying 2004 tsunami sediments: a report from SE coast of India
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Hussain, S.M., Mohan, S.P. & Jonathan, M.P. Nat Hazards (2010) 55: 513. doi:10.1007/s11069-010-9543-4
- 189 Views
Four short core samples were collected from the creek, estuarine regions of southeast (SE) coast of India affected by the 2004 Asian Tsunami. The study is aimed to signify the importance of ostracoda species in identifying major natural events (e.g. Tsunamis) in the coastal regions. The presence of many marine ostracoda species in the beach areas and the comparative studies with earlier reports from SE coast indicate that these species were brought by the high-energy tsunami waves. The depositional feature of ostracoda species in the beach and estuarine region also infers on the nature and force of tsunami waves in a particular region. The results clearly support that microfossils can be used to identify the major natural events close to coastal regions.
KeywordsOstracoda2004 TsunamiCore sampleDepositionSE coast of India
The recent 2004 Asian Tsunami has undermined the importance to identify the deposits through various methods to develop a clear image on the nature of this event. The tsunamis often cause extensive damage to the coastal region due to the sudden rush of sea waves which cause erosion and deposition of sediments in many places. These deposits signify the high energy during the major event and sometimes, it also has similar characters to that of storm surge or cyclonic events. However, the recent mircopaleontological studies have made significant inroads in identifying the tsunami deposits in many places and also in past natural events (Chagué-Goff et al. 2002; Nagendra et al. 2005; Kortekaas and Dawson 2007; Clague et al. 1999; Williams and Hutchinson 2000).
Studies related to the recent 2004 Asian Tsunami have been made by several authors along southeast coast of India on various geological aspects (Srinivasalu et al. 2005, 2007, 2008, 2009a, b; Yeh et al. 2006). The transport of foraminiferal species from deeper regions to the coastal regions in other areas has been reported by Dominey-Howes et al. (1999) (Western Australia); Hindson et al. (1999) (Algrave, Portugal); Fujiwara et al. (2000) (Southern Kanto region, Pacific coast of Central Japan); Luque et al. (2002) (Bay of Cadiz, Spain); Ruiz et al. (2004) (Doñana National Park, SW Spain); Nagendra et al. (2005) (SE coast of India); Hussain et al. (2006), Malik et al. (2006) (Andaman Islands, Indian Ocean); Nigam and Chaturvedi (2006) (NE Arabian sea); Hawkes et al. (2007), Jankaew et al. (2008) (Malaysia–Thailand Peninsula) and Smedile et al. (2007) (Eastern Sicily, Italy).
The aim of the present article is to report on the presence of ostracoda species from core samples in the tsunami sediments from southeast coast of India. This study further enhances the knowledge on the use of ostracoda as a useful aid in identifying the recent 2004 tsunami deposit in various other regions that has been affected by the natural event.
2 Study area
The coastal region of southeast coast of India was affected in a devastating manner during the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami where three large waves hit the Indian coast 3 h after the major earthquake. In many places, the sea waves caused extensive damage to engineering structures and erosion/deposition of sediments. As part of a larger research development program by Department of Geology, University of Madras, the backwater and coastal regions along the southeast coast of India have been extensively studied for various aspects related to distribution of microfauna in the coastal regions by Hussain (1998), Sridhar et al. (1998), Mohan et al. (2001), Ayyamperumal et al. (2006), Hussain et al. (2007), Janaki-Raman et al. (2007) and Stephen-Pichaimani et al. (2008) during the last 10 years. These studies clearly reflect the distribution of microfossils and the nature of substratum in the southeast coast of India. The above studies serve as a database for interpretation on various aspects related to geological side for major interpretations after the tsunami event in 2004.
3 Materials and methods
The sample collection for the present study was done during the month of April 2005. Several sites were selected for core samples, and it was based on previous survey immediately after the disaster in December 2004, after careful examination of the substratum in the coastal areas. The core samples were collected using a PVC tube of 2.5′′ diameter and 2.5 m in length. The PVC tube was pre-cleaned with dilute HCl before the sampling, and it was slowly pushed into the estuarine/river bed until about ~30 cm of the tube remained above the ground. The tube was sealed using a Plumber’s dummy, and it was retrieved from the river bed. Subsequently, the top and bottom of the core samples were sealed, transferred to the laboratory and stored in −20°C. On the basis of stratigraphical and depositional sequence, four core samples were selected i.e. C1 (Ennore Creek, North of Chennai City), C2 (Cooum River estuary), C3 (Muttukadu backwaters) and C4 (Sunnambu River, Pondicherry) (Fig. 1). The core samples were sub-sampled at 5-cm interval, and the retrival rate for C1 was 90 cm (18 samples), C2: 80 cm (16 samples), C3: 100 cm (20 samples) and C4: 75 cm (15 samples), respectively.
The ostracodal species were separated, identified and were photographed using a scanning electron microscope (JEOL-JFC 6360) in Department of Geology, University of Madras, India, and all the specimens are indexed and stored in the repository.
4 Results and discussion
The core sample (C1) collected from Ennore creek in northern Chennai yields Neomonoceratina iniqua, Basslerites liebaui and Hemicytheridea reticulata. The second core sample (C2 from Cooum River) is dominated by Calliistocythere flavidofusca intricatoides, Mutilus pentoekensis, Keijella reticulate, Neomonoceratina iniqua, Basslerites liebaui, Hemicytheridea reticulate, Stigmatocythere indica, Caudites javana and Loxoconcha sp., respectively.
The presence of Callistocythere falvidofusca intricatoides in the C2 indicates that it has been deposited in the low energy region of the Cooum estuary due to the arrival/retrieval of three different tsunami waves. The presence of this species indicates that they are brought in from the continental shelf area as they dwell in the coastal region less than 100-m water depth (e.g. Yassini 1979; Bergin et al. 2006). The ostracodal species recorded in both the core samples (C1, C2) suggest considerable agglutinated forms in the top 70 cm which is due to the fact that they have stayed in the water column for a considerable period of time before deposition indicting a low energy levels (in sea water) in the northern part of the Tamil Nadu state compared to the inundation in the southern regions of the state (e.g. Cuddalore and Nagapattinam). Moreover, in C2 a change in the species color is observed from 70-cm depth, indicating that the tsunami deposits are nearly 0–70 cm thickness which is also very well supported by the change in sediment distribution from sandy-fine sand to clay organic-rich layers in the contaminated river beds of Chennai city (e.g. Covelli et al. 2006; Zúñiga et al. 2007). Eyewitness and scientific articles that reported the 2004 tsunami event have documented three large waves, and in many places the backwash took place only after the third tsunami wave. Hence, the possibility of the small agglutinated forms to stay afloat in the water column is more than expected (e.g. Paris et al. 2007). The above inference is also in accordance with earlier report in the same area by Srinivasalu et al. (2009a), indicating that the tsunami layers are seen above the organic layers in many places.
In the cores C3 and C4 collected from Muthupet backwaters and Sunnambu River (Pondicherry), the following species were recorded: Xestoleberis variegata, Caudites javana, Tanella gracilis and Loxoconcha sp respectively. The presence of reworked species especially Tanella gracilis and Loxoconcha sp. at lower depth (below 40–70 cm) in both the core samples suggests that they are reworked in the sandy sediments due to the churning tsunami waves of very high energy (e.g. Ruiz et al. 2004). In addition, the absence of these two species in the northern part (especially in C1, C2) suggests that the southern part of the study area has borne the brunt of the devastation caused by the tsunami waves as reported by many authors (on erosion, deposition and inundation) (Le Roux and Vargas 2005; Shanmugam 2006; Srinivasalu et al. 2009a, b; Yeh et al. 2006). In both the core samples (C3 and C4), the depositional sequence indicates several inter-bedded fine sand and sand layers in the top 5–70-cm depth which correlates well with the earlier article by Srinivasalu et al. (2007), who had reported similar deposits in various transects in this region.
4.1 Identifying the origin of ostracoda species using comparative studies
Comparison of ostracoda species in pre-tsunami locations in Gulf of Mannar, off Karikkattukuppam south of Chennai (from water depth 0–50 m) and post-tsunami sediments (present study) from southeast coast of India
Name of the species
Bairdoppilata (B.) alcyonicola# (Maddocks)
Basslerites liebaui* (Jain)
Bythoceratina mandviensis (Jain)
Callistocythere falvidofusca intricatoides (Ruggieri)
Caudites javana* (Kingma)
Chrysocythere keiji* (Jain)
Cyprideis sp. cf. mandviensis* (Jain)
Cytherelloidea leroyi* (Keij)
H. reticulata* (Kingma)
Hemicytherura subulata# (Ahmed et al.)
Hemikrithe peterseni (Jain)
Henryhowella (Neoheryhowella) hartmani (Jain)
Keijia demissa* (Brady)
Keijella reticulata# (Whatley and Quanhong)
K. whatleyi (Jain)
Loxoconcha megapora indica* (Benson and Maddocks)
Loxocorniculum lilljeborgii# (Brady)
Macrocyprina decora# (Brady)
Mutilus pentoekensis# (Kingma)
Neocytheromorpha sp. cf. N. indoarabica (Khosla)
N. reticulata* (Mohan et al.)
Neomonoceratina iniqua* (Brady)
N. jaini* (Varma et al.)
N. porocostata# (Howe and McKenzie)
Paijenborchellina prona# (Lubimova and Guha)
P. keij (Varma et al.)
Paracytheroma ventrosinuosa# (Zhao and Whatley)
Paradoxostoma bhatiai (Shyam Sunder et al.)
Phlyctenophora orientalis (Brady)
Propontocypris (P.) crocata# (Maddocks)
P. (S.) bengalensis (Maddocks)
Spinoceratina spinosa* (Annapurna and Rama Sarma)
Stigmatocythere indica (Jain)
S. kingmai (Whatley and Quanhong)
Tanella gracilis* (Kingma)
Xestoleberis variegata# (Brady)
The following species are characteristic of shallow marine habitat Basslerites liebaui, Calliistocythere flavidofusca intricatoides, Caudites javana, Hemicytheridea reticulata, Keijella reticulata,Loxoconcha sp., Mutilus pentoekensis, Neomonoceratina iniqua, Stigmatocythere indica, Tanella gracilis and Xestoleberis variegate. These species are reported periodically in the core samples collected from the various landforms along the study area after the tsunami event. The occurrence in the land region and all along the marginal marine environment indicates that they were transported by the tsunami waves. The presence of marine ostracodal species in all the core samples clearly suggests that they have been transported from inner shelf environment due to the strong tsunami waves that hit the coast. Similar observation on the depositional feature of the ostracoda species has already been reported by Nagendra et al. (2005) (Nagapattinam, SE coast of India), Hussain et al. (2006) (Andaman Islands) and Ruiz et al. (2004) (Doñana park, SW Spain).
4.2 Identification of depositional sequence
The use of carapace–valve ratio has been widely used in recent years to identify the depositional environment in the aquatic regions. The main reason for the use of carapace in the present study is to know the speed or the depositional environment in the area as the carapace often sinks to the bottom very quickly during rapid deposition without any destruction to muscles and ligaments. However, when the sedimentation is slow, the carapace opens up and gets separated due to intense bacterial activity.
Distribution of carapaces and open valves in actual numbers in the present study
The present study on the presence of ostracodal species has made significant impact on the use of microfossils to identify recent tsunami deposits.
The presence of marine ostracodal species in the core samples clearly suggests that the tsunami waves have transported these species along with the sediments.
The comparative study of pre-tsunami and post-tsunami species from southeast coast of India also indicates the presence of marine ostracodal species in the core sediments indicating the transportation and depositional feature of this major event.
The depositional sequence of ostracoda species also suggests that the wave energy in the northern part of the study area is marginally lower compared to the southern region.
The results clearly signify the identification and the study of microfossils (especially ostracoda) can be used in identification of major events in the coastal zone regions.
This work is funded by DST, New Delhi, India through project no. SR/S4/ES135-4.3/2005. SMH wishes to express his thanks to Dr. M. Prithiviraj, DST, New Delhi, India for his help in various aspects and Dr. Brian Atwater for the financial support to this present paper in AOGS 2007 at Bangkok. Special thanks to Dr. P. Ganesan and Mr. S. Arikesan for their help in the field and sample processing. MPJ wishes to express his thanks to EDI, COFAA-IPN and SNI, CONACyT, Mexico.