To Fall by Ambition—Grímur Thorkelín
and his Beowulf Edition Open Access
First Online: 11 September 2007 Received: 20 February 2007 Accepted: 31 March 2007 DOI:
Cite this article as: Fjalldal, M. Neophilologus (2008) 92: 321. doi:10.1007/s11061-007-9065-9 Abstract
Grímur Jónsson Thorkelín (1752–1829), the Icelandic first editor of the
Beowulf manuscript, had an unusual career that explains much about his edition. Thorkelín’s rise in the world of Danish scholarship was fast and culminated in a successful journey to Britain to look for documents relevant to Danish history. He returned with two transcripts of the hitherto neglected Beowulf manuscript, and upon his return, the position of Keeper of the Royal Privy Archives awaited him. But all was not as it seemed. Thorkelín was essentially a fraud as a scholar, a fact not lost on many of his contemporaries, and much of his advancement had been through ingratiation rather than scholarly achievement. Thorkelín was well aware that he might not have the ability to produce an edition from his transcripts, and for nearly 30 years he vacillated between caution and ambition. In the end, however, it became commonly known that he had invaluable historical materials in his possession, and then his hand was forced. The edition, when at long last it appeared in 1815, was a predictable disaster which exposed the editor for what he was and brought him misery rather than scholarly fame. Download to read the full article text References
Anon (1787). Review of Thorkelín’s edition of
Eyrbyggja saga. Nyeste Kjøbenhavnske Efterretninger om lærde Sager for 1787. 48, 753–764.
Birrell, T. A. (1966). The society of antiquaries and the taste for old English 1705–1840.
CrossRef Google Scholar
Bjork, R. (1996). Grímur Jónsson Thorkelin’s preface to the first edition of
Scandinavian Studies, 68
Christoffersen, J. (1946). Hvorledes Beowulf kom til Danmark.
Bogvennen, 2, 19–33.
Cooley, F. (1940). Early Danish criticism of
English Literary History, 7
Glahn, A. (1925). Mæcen og Klient—av en brevveksling mellem to bogvenner, 1785–1790.
Aarbog for bogvenner, 9
Hall, J. R. (1994). The first two editions of
: Thorkelin’s (1815) and Kemble’s (1833). In: D. G. Scragg & P. E. Szarmach (Eds.),
The editing of old English—papers from the 1990 Manchester Conference
(pp. 239–250). Woodbridge: D. S. Brewer.
Helgason, Á. (1808a). Review of Thorkelín’s new testament translation from 1807.
Kjøbenhavnske lærde Efterretninger, 31
Helgason, Á. (1808b). Recensentens Svar paa Antikritiken i
Tillægget til lærde Efterretninger
, 170, 32.
Kjøbenhavnske lærde Efterretningar, 33
Jørgensen, A. D. (1884).
Udsigt over de danske Rigsarkivers historie
. Copenhagen: De under Kirke- og Undervisningsministeriet samlede arkiver.
Kiernan, K. S. (1995). The legacy of Wiglaf. In: P. S. Baker (Ed.),
(pp. 195–218). New York: Garland Publishing.
Kristjánsson, A. (1999).
Nú heilsar þér á Hafnarslóð
. Reykjavík: Nýja bókafélagið.
Malone, K. (1951).
The Thorkelin transcripts of Beowulf in facsimile
. Copenhagen: Rosenkilde and Bagger.
Ólason, P. E. (1949).
íslenzkar æviskrár frá landnámstímum til ársloka 1940
, Vol. II. Reykjavík: Hið íslenzka bÓkmenntafélag.
Petersen, N. M. (1861).
Bidrag til den danske literaturs historie i oplysningens tidsalder, 1750–1800
. Copenhagen: Berlinske bogtrykkeri.
Shippey, T. A., & Haarder, A. (Eds.) (1998).
Beowulf—the critical heritage. London: Routledge.
Thorkelín, G. (1788).
Fragments of English and Irish history in the ninth and the tenth century, in two parts, translated from the original Icelandic, and illustrated with some notes
. London: Printed by and for John Nichols.
Thorkelín G. (1791).
Sketch of the character of his Royal Highness the Prince of Denmark to which is added a short review of the present state of literature and the polite arts in that country; interspersed with anecdotes/in four letters by a gentleman long resident in Copenhagen to a friend in London
. London: J. Ridgway.
Thorkelín, G. (1808). Svar paa hr. pastor Helgesens recension af det nye Testamente paa Island.
Tillæg til Kjøbenhavnske lærde Efterretninger, 32
Werlauff, E. C. (1910).
Erindringer af mit liv
. Copenhagen: Gyldendalske boghandel.
Wood, E. H. H. (1972). Letters to an antiquary—the literary correspondence of G. J. Thorkelin (1752–1829). Unpublished PhD thesis. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University.
© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2007