Date: 13 Jun 2013
The Culture of Mediocrity
- Joseph C. Hermanowicz
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Select groups and organizations embrace practices that perpetuate their inferiority. The result is the phenomenon we call “mediocrity.” This article examines the conditions under which mediocrity is selected and maintained by groups over time. Mediocrity is maintained by a key social process: the marginalization of the adept, which is a response to the group problem of what to do with the highly able. The problem arises when a majority of a group is comprised of average members who must decide what to do with high performers in the group. To solve this problem, reward systems are subverted to benefit the less able and the adept are cast as deviant. Marginalization is a resolution of two tensions: marginalization of the adept for their behavior, and protection from the adept for the mediocre. The American research university is used as an example to describe the phenomenon and to formulate a theoretic argument. The forms and consequences of marginalization are discussed. Marginalizing the adept illustrates an anti-meritocratic behavioral pattern which serves to sustain social systems on which all people, however able, depend.
Different versions of this paper were presented at meetings of the American Sociological Association, Boston, Massachusetts and the International Sociological Association, Gothenburg, Sweden. The author acknowledges the many helpful comments and suggestions provided by James W. Balkwell, Mark Cooney, James J. Dowd, Monica Gaughan, Erika T. Hermanowicz, David Karen, Daniel McFarland, Cecilia Ridgeway, and Mitchell Stevens. Particular thanks are given to Christena E. Nippert-Eng, Margaret V. Sachs, and Barry Schwartz for multiple readings and discussions of this work.
Abbott, Andrew. 1988. The system of professions: An essay on the division of expert labor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. (ed.). 1987. The micro-macro link. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ainsworth-Darnell, James W., and Douglas B. Downey. 1998. Assessing the oppositional culture explanation for racial/ethnic differences in school performance. American Sociological Review 63: 536–553.CrossRef
Becker, Howard S., Blanche Geer, and Everett C. Hughes. 1968. Making the grade: The academic side of college life. New York: Wiley.
Berger, Joseph, Cecilia Ridgeway, M. Hamit Fisek, and Robert Z. Norman. 1998. The legitimation and delegitimation of power and prestige orders. American Sociological Review 63: 379–405.
Blau, Peter M. 1973. The organization of academic work. New York: Wiley.
Bosk, Charles. 1979. Forgive and remember: Managing medical failure. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1983. The field of cultural production, or the economic world reversed. Poetics 12: 311–356.CrossRef
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984a. Homo academicus. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984b. Distinction: A social critique of the judgment of taste. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Burawoy, Michael. 1979. Manufacturing consent: Changes in the labor process under monopoly capitalism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Burris, Val. 2004. The academic caste system: Prestige hierarchies in PhD exchange networks. American Sociological Review 69: 239–264.CrossRef
Castilla, Emilio J., and Stephen Benard. 2010. The paradox of meritocracy in organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly 55: 543–576.CrossRef
Cole, Jonathan R., and Stephen Cole. 1973. Social stratification in science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Collins, Randall. 1971. Functional and conflict theories of educational stratification. American Sociological Review 36: 1002–1019.CrossRef
Collins, Randall. 1975. Conflict sociology: Toward an explanatory science. New York: Academic Press.
Collins, Randall. 1988. The micro contribution to macro sociology. Sociological Theory 6: 242–253.CrossRef
Collins, Randall. 1992. Conflict theory. In Encyclopedia of sociology, vol. 1, eds. Edgar F. Borgatta, and Marie L. Borgatta, 288–290. New York: Macmillan.
Cook, Karen S., and Karen A. Hegtvedt. 1983. Distributive justice, equity, and equality. Annual Review of Sociology 9: 217–241.CrossRef
Davis, Kingsley, and Wilbert E. Moore. 1945. Some principles of stratification. American Sociological Review 10: 242–249.CrossRef
De Waal, Frans. 2007. Chimpanzee politics. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Durkheim, Emile.  1982. The rules of sociological method. Edited with an introduction by Steven Lukes (transl: Halls, W.D.). New York: Free Press.
Farkas, George, Christy Lleras, and Steve Maczuga. 2002. Does oppositional culture exist in minority and poverty peer groups. American Sociological Review 67: 148–155.CrossRef
Feather, N.T. 1989. Attitudes towards the high achiever: The fall of the tall poppy. Australian Journal of Psychology 41: 239–267.CrossRef
Fine, Gary Alan. 2012. Tiny publics: A theory of group action and culture. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Fordham, Signithia, and John U. Ogbu. 1986. Black students’ school success: Coping with the burden of ‘acting white’. Urban Review 18: 176–206.CrossRef
Fordham, Signithia. 1996. Blacked out: Dilemmas of race, identity, and success at capital high. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Freidson, Eliot. 1970. Professional dominance. Chicago: Aldine.
Gamson, William A. 1961. A theory of coalition formation. American Sociological Review 26(3): 373–382.CrossRef
Gaston, Jerry. 1978. The reward system in British and American science. New York: Wiley.
Goode, William J. 1967. The protection of the inept. American Sociological Review 32: 5–19.CrossRef
Goode, William J. 1978. The celebration of heroes: Prestige as a control system. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Hegtvedt, Karen A., and Barry Markovsky. 1995. Justice and injustice. In Sociological perspectives on social psychology, eds. Karen S. Cook, Gary Alan Fine, and James S. House, 257–280. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
Hegtvedt, Karen A. 2007. Theories of social justice. In Encyclopedia of sociology, ed. George Ritzer, 4432–4436. Oxford: Blackwell.
Hodson, Randy. 2001. Dignity at work. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRef
Hodson, Randy, Vincent J. Roscigno, and Steven H. Lopez. 2006. Chaos and the abuse of power: Workplace bullying in organizational and interactional context. Work and Occupations 33: 382–416.CrossRef
Irwin, John, and Donald R. Cressey. 1962. Thieves, convicts and the inmate culture. Social Problems 10: 142–155.CrossRef
Jackall, Robert. 1997. Wild cowboys: Urban marauders and the forces of order. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Jasso, Guillermina. 1980. A new theory of distributive justice. American Sociological Review 45(1): 3–32.CrossRef
Jermier, J. 1988. Sabotage at work: A rational view. Research in the Sociology of Organizations 6: 101–134.
Katchadourian, Herant, and John Boli. 1994. Cream of the crop: The impact of elite education in the decade after college. New York: Basic Books.
Kempner, Joanna, Jon F. Merz, and Charles L. Bosk. 2011. Forbidden knowledge: Public controversy and the production of nonknowledge. Sociological Forum 26: 475–500.CrossRef
Kluegel, J.R., and E.R. Smith. 1986. Beliefs about inequality: Americans’ views of what is and what ought to be. New York: de Gruyter.
Kohn, Melvin L. 1977. Class and conformity: A study in values. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ladd, E.C. 1994. The American ideology. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Ladd, E.C., and K.H. Bowman. 1998. Attitudes toward economic inequality. Washington, DC: El Press.
Long, J. Scott, and Mary Frank Fox. 1995. Scientific careers: Universalism and particularism. Annual Review of Sociology 21: 45–71.CrossRef
Merton, Robert K. 1973a. The normative structure of science. In The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations, ed. Norman W. Storer, 267–278. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Article originally published in 1942.
Merton, Robert K. 1973b. The Matthew effect in science. In The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations, ed. Norman W. Storer, 439–459. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Article originally published in 1969.
Merton, Robert K., and Harriet Zuckerman. 1973. Age, aging, and age structure in science. In The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations, ed. Norman W. Storer, 497–559. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Article originally published in 1972.
Merton, Robert K.  1968a. Social theory and social structure. New York: Free Press.
Merton, Robert K.  1968b. The self-fulfilling prophecy. In Social theory and social structure, 475–490. New York: Free Press.
Metzger, Walter P. 1973. Academic tenure in America: A historical essay. In Faculty tenure, eds. William R. Keast, and John W. Macy Jr., 93–159. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Morrill, Calvin, Mayer N. Zald, and Hayagreeva Rao. 2003. Covert political conflict in organizations: Challenges from below. Annual Review of Sociology 29: 391–415.CrossRef
Parsons, Talcott. 1951. The social system. New York: Free Press.
Phillips, Damon J., and Ezra W. Zuckerman. 2001. Middle-status conformity: Theoretical restatement and empirical demonstration in two markets. American Journal of Sociology 107: 379–429.CrossRef
Reskin, Barbara. 1977. Scientific productivity and the reward system of science. American Sociological Review 42: 491–504.CrossRef
Ridgeway, Cecilia. 2006a. Status construction theory. In Contemporary social psychological theories, ed. Peter J. Burke, 301–323. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Ridgeway, Cecilia. 2006b. Inequality, status, and the construction of status beliefs. In Handbook of sociological theory, ed. Jonathan H. Turner, 323–340. New York: Springer.
Ridgeway, Cecilia. 2012. What binds low status members to the group? Paper presented at the International Sociological Association Forum, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Rivera, Lauren. 2012. Hiring as cultural matching: The case of elite professional service firms. American Sociological Review 77(6): 999–1022.
Roy, Donald. 1958. ‘Banana time’: Job satisfaction and informal interaction. Human Organization 18: 158–168.
Roy, Donald. 1952. Quota restriction and goldbricking in a machine shop. American Journal of Sociology 57: 427–442.CrossRef
Roy, Donald. 1954. Efficiency and ‘the fix’: Informal intergroup relations in a piecework machine shop. American Journal of Sociology 60: 255–266.CrossRef
Salin, Denise. 2003. Ways of explaining workplace bullying: A review of enabling, motivating and precipitating structures and processes in the work environment. Human Relations 56: 1213–1232.CrossRef
Shils, Edward. 1972. The constitution of society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Shils, Edward. 1984. The academic ethic. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Simmel, Georg. 1906. The sociology of secrecy and of the secret societies. American Journal of Sociology 11: 441–498.CrossRef
Smigel, Erwin. 1964. The Wall Street lawyer: Professional organization man? Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
Tumin, Melvin M. 1953. Principles of stratification: A critical analysis. American Sociological Review 18: 387–394.CrossRef
Twale, Darla J., and Barbara M. De Luca. 2008. Faculty incivility. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Twenge, Jean M., Kathleen R. Cantanese, and Roy F. Baumeister. 2002. Social exclusion causes self-defeating behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83: 606–615.CrossRef
Ward, David A., and Gene G. Kassebaum. 1965. Women’s prison: Sex and social structure. Chicago: Aldine.
Welsh, Sandy. 1999. Gender and sexual harassment. Annual Review of Sociology 25: 169–190.CrossRef
Western, Bruce. 2006. Punishment and inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Willis, Paul. 1977. Learning to labor: How working class kids get working class jobs. New York: Columbia University Press.
Zuckerman, Harriet, and Robert K. Merton. 1971. Patterns of evaluation in science: Institutionalization, structure and functions of the referee system. Minerva 9: 66–100.CrossRef
Zuckerman, Harriet. 1977. Scientific elite: Nobel laureates in the United States. New York: Free Press.
Zuckerman, Harriet. 1988. The sociology of science. In Handbook of sociology, ed. Neil J. Smelser, 511–574. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
- The Culture of Mediocrity
Volume 51, Issue 3 , pp 363-387
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Higher education
- Reward systems
- Academic careers
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Sociology, The University of Georgia, Athens, GA, 30602-1611, USA