Just War and Military Morale: A Brief Reflection on the Correlation Between the Legality of War and the Moral Repercussions for Members of US and UK Forces Arising from the Questionable Legality of the Campaign Iraqi Freedom of March 2003
- Sascha-Dominik Bachmann
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Does it matter to a member of the military whether the military campaign in which he is taking part is lawful or not? Despite the observation that the crime of aggression (post Kampala 2010) constitutes a ‘leadership crime par excellence,’ which limits any (future) criminal responsibility accordingly, the legality or illegality of any military action under international law can create moral implications for the common foot soldier and mid-level officer and also have a tangible impact on the national legal frameworks under which these forces operate. This short article uses the example of Operation Iraqi Freedom (2003) to discuss the repercussions of a—most likely—illegal military campaign for individual members of democratic armed forces before the background of the present discussion of NATO led action in Libya.
- Ambos, K (2010) The crime of aggression after Kampala. German Yearbook of International Law 53: pp. 463-509
- Bachmann, S, Kemp, G (2010) The international crime of aggression in the context of the global ‘war on terror’: Some legal and ethical perspectives. JSAL 2: pp. 309-330
- Brunnée, J, Toope, S (2004) Slouching towards new ‘just’ wars: international law and the use of force after September 11th’. Netherlands International Law Review 54: pp. 363-392 CrossRef
- Fisler-Damrosch, L., and Oxman, B., eds. 2003. Future implications of the iraq conflict. The American Society of International Law.
- Fournet, C. 2006. International crimes: theories, practice and evolution. CMP Publishing.
- Garraway, C. 1999. Superior orders and the international criminal court: Justice delivered or justice denied. International Review of the Red Cross 836: 785–794.
- Kemp, G. 2010. Individual criminal liability for the international crime of aggression, 207–237. Intersentia: Antwerp/Oxford.
- Gray, C (2004) International law and the use of force. Oxford University Press, New York
- Kelsen, H. 1947. Will the judgement in the nuremberg trial constitute a precedent in international law. International and Comparative Law Quarterly 161.
- Kritsiotis, D. 2002. On the Jus ad bellum and Jus in bello of operation enduring freedom. ASIL Proceedings pp 35–41.
- Linnan, D. ed. 2008. Enemy combatants, terrorism, and armed conflict law: a guide to the issues. Westport: Praeger Security.
- McGoldrick, D (2004) From ‘9–11’ to the Iraq War 2003. Hart Publishing, Oxford and Portland, Oregon
- Nolte and Krieger. 2002. Europäische Wehrrechtssysteme.
- Ratner, S, Bischoff, J, Abrams, J (2009) Accountability for human rights atrocities in international law-beyond the nuremberg legacy. Oxford University Press, Oxford
- Ratner, S. 2002. Jus ad bellum and Jus in Bello after September 11’ in 96 AJIL 905–921.
- Schmitt, M (2004) The legality of operation Iraqi freedom under international law. Journal of Military Ethics 3: pp. 82-104 CrossRef
- van Baarda, T. 2011. The ethical challenges of a complex security environment. In Ethics, law and military operations, ed. Whetham D. Palgrave Macmillan.
- van der Vyver, J. 2003. Ius contra bellum and American foreign policy 28 SAYIL 1–28: 4.
- Wedgwood, R (2003) The fall of Saddam Hussein: Security council mandates and preemptive self-defense. AJIL 97: pp. 577 CrossRef
- Just War and Military Morale: A Brief Reflection on the Correlation Between the Legality of War and the Moral Repercussions for Members of US and UK Forces Arising from the Questionable Legality of the Campaign Iraqi Freedom of March 2003
Liverpool Law Review
Volume 32, Issue 3 , pp 197-208
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Armed conflict
- Legality of the use of force
- Military morale
- Court martials
- Operation Iraqi freedom
- Crime of aggression
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. School of Law, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, UK