Paleoclimate changes inferred from stable isotopes and magnetic properties of organic-rich lake sediments in Arctic Norway
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Janbu, A.D., Paasche, Ø. & Talbot, M.R. J Paleolimnol (2011) 46: 29. doi:10.1007/s10933-011-9512-2
- 982 Downloads
Stable isotope measures in organic matter are frequently used as indicators of past climate change. Although such analyses can provide valuable information, there is considerable uncertainty associated with studies of organic-rich sediments, especially those from Arctic lakes and bogs. We studied stable isotopes of carbon and nitrogen, and magnetic properties in a sediment core from a small alkaline lake with a high sedimentation rate, Lake Nattmålsvatn, Norway. There is good correspondence among the different sediment variables during the late glacial, and they seemingly reflect major climate variations such as the Allerød Interstade and the Younger Dryas, as well as the transition into the current interglacial. During the early Holocene, however, these relationships are more complex and δ13C and δ15N values do not stabilize until ~7,500 cal year BP. A significant excursion in all variables occurs between 6,850 and 6,500 cal year BP and is interpreted to represent climate deterioration. Holocene δ13C values vary little and indicate that isotopically-depleted dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) in the lake, possibly influenced by methanotrophy and high pCO2, dominated the lake’s carbon cycle. Holocene δ15N is similarly muted, likely due to the availability of abundant dissolved nitrogen. Bulk organic matter is probably dominated by phytoplankton remains produced beneath the ice cover in late spring and during ice breakup when isotopically-depleted DIC, pCO2 and ammonium availability were maximal. Thus, use of δ13C and δ15N as indicators of Holocene paleoclimate and paleoproductivity variation can be challenging in a lake such as Nattmålsvatn, where ice cover isolates the basin for large parts of the year, allowing dissolved respiratory gases to accumulate in the water column. In contrast, magnetic variables appear to better track climate variations. In particular, runoff-driven influx of minerogenic sediments shows high variability that can be attributed to regional changes in Holocene winter precipitation. The most striking shifts occur between 4,000 and 2,300 cal year BP.
KeywordsStable isotopesHoloceneClimateEnvironmental magnetismNorwayArctic
Small lakes respond quickly to environmental changes, adjusting immediately to seasonal temperature shifts, catchment runoff, and spring snow melt. Responses may include algal blooms, precipitation of authigenic calcite, and changes in the composition of the chironomid community. These combined seasonal influences, in addition to external factors, determine the variations in sediment organic matter over time.
In organic-rich lake sediments, organic matter (OM) content can be assessed by weight loss on ignition (LOI) or by measure of total organic carbon (TOC), the latter a measure of the carbon in OM (Dean 1974). Because bulk organic matter has multiple potential sources within and outside the lake, other analyses are required to interpret shifts in OM content. The residual (inorganic) component of the sediment, whether detrital, biogenic silica (diatoms), authigenic carbonate, or a combination thereof, should also be determined.
When organisms die, their remains are subject to microbial decomposition. Net loss of organic matter can be great, and there may be alteration of the primary material. Despite these transformations, the carbon/nitrogen ratio (C/N) and δ13C and δ15N values of bulk organic matter can be used to track the origin of the OM, providing information about the relative contributions of autochthonous versus allochthonous OM to the deposits (Meyers and Lallier-Vergés 1999; Talbot and Johannessen 1992; Filippi and Talbot 2004). Furthermore, the magnetic properties of minerogenic matter that reaches the lake can be used to constrain the external influx of OM identified from isotope measures. Inferring the minerogenic input by means of rock magnetism can also be used to track flood history and other important past environmental events in the catchment (Thompson and Oldfield 1986; Evans and Heller 2003).
The ability of lakes to respond rapidly to environmental changes and to record those changes in their sediment makes lacustrine deposits attractive archives for study of high-frequency paleoclimate oscillations (Bradley 1999). Coastal lakes in Scandinavia are especially suitable for such purposes, as they generally display high sedimentation rates. Many of these lakes were beyond the ice sheet margin during the Younger Dryas (12,900–11,700 cal year BP), suggesting that their sediment records may extend beyond the last glacial-interglacial transition. Several studies have shown that these waterbodies are sensitive to climate fluctuations and that their sediments record regional climate changes (Vorren et al. 1988; Birks et al. 2005; Bjune et al. 2005; Paasche et al. 2007a, b). To our knowledge, no previous study in northern Norway has used carbon and nitrogen isotopes in combination with rock magnetic properties to infer past climate changes on a sub-centennial time scale.
This study addresses the prospects and problems associated with using carbon and nitrogen isotopes as indicators of past climate change in high-latitude lakes with organic-rich sediments. We conducted analyses on a well-dated lacustrine record that spans the entire Holocene and late glacial, at multi-decadal resolution. In addition to recording the withdrawal of the inland ice sheet and/or a local ice cap, the sediment record documents several distinct climatic phases during the Holocene, including a prominent climatic excursion ~6,700 cal year BP. The challenges associated with using δ13C and δ15N in organic-rich lake deposits are highlighted and we emphasize how methanogenesis and seasonal ice cover may dampen the climate sensitivity of the lake.
The nearest meteorological station lies 11 km to the northeast, at Finnsnes. For the period 1961–1990, it recorded a mean annual temperature of 3.2°C, a July mean of 12.5°C and a January mean of −4.3°C. Lakes in the region are commonly ice covered from October/November until late May. Mean annual precipitation is approximately 1,000 mm, of which ~35% falls from May to September, while ~65% falls from 1 October through April (Klimaavdelingen 1993a, b). Chemical and meteorological data are presented in Table S1.
Lake Nattmålsvatn is currently considered an alkaline Chara lake, with charophytes and marl precipitation during summer (Langangen 1995, 2004). Marl is common in the shallow waters and along the shore. During earlier centuries, local farmers collected the marl for their fields, leaving holes along the banks. Marl lake sediments are excellent archives of environmental change (Kelts and Hsü 1978; Hollander and McKenzie 1991; Bradbury and Dean 1993; Noe-Nygaard 1995; Hammarlund et al. 2003; Teranes et al. 1999; Leng and Marshall 2004; Diefendorf et al. 2008) and one of our original objectives in this study was to compare the isotopic records from the carbonate and OM fractions in the Lake Nattmålsvatn sediment. Two cores retrieved from the deepest part of the lake, however, yielded almost 6 m of blackish, organic-rich sediments with no apparent carbonate. The cores also smelled of H2S. Despite the fact that Lake Nattmålsvatn is today an alkaline Chara lake according to pH measurements, there is no evidence in the sediment record for its present state. Our isotope analyses were thus carried out only on the sediment OM fraction.
Materials and methods
Core collection and LOI and carbon analyses
Two cores, designated Core I and Core II, were taken ~100 m apart in March 2002. The cores were collected from the deepest part of the lake using an 11-cm-diameter piston corer (Nesje 1992) operated from surface ice. Both cores were sampled for LOI550 at 0.5-cm intervals by extracting 1 cm3 of wet material. Samples were weighed, dried overnight at 105°C, and re-weighed to assess percent dry weight. Next, samples were subjected to rising temperatures for half an hour and then combusted at 550°C for 1 h in a Nabertherm controller C6 muffle furnace. After ignition, samples were cooled in a desiccator and re-weighed to estimate OM content (Dean 1974). Twenty samples were analysed for TOC using a LECO furnace.
A full set of smear slides was prepared from Core I to examine the organic material in the sediment. Smear slides were prepared from samples taken every 2–10 cm, except across identifiable sedimentological boundaries, where closer-interval samples were taken. Small samples of moist sediment were prepared for visual examination under a petrographic microscope. Smears were mounted beneath a cover slip using standard epoxy adhesive. Plane- and cross-polarised light and incident UV radiation were used to examine the slides. Analysis showed that sediments are composed of a variety of minerogenic and organic components, including authigenic minerals, notably pyrite and feldspar at some depths in the core.
Isotope and elemental analysis
Core I was subsampled every 4 cm for organic carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope analysis of bulk organic matter (OM), total organic carbon (TOC) and total nitrogen (TN) content. Sample aliquots were reacted with 1 M HCl at 50°C to remove possible traces of carbonate. After 24 h, samples were rinsed in distilled water five times and dried in an oven at 40°C. Dried samples were then crushed in an agate mortar to homogenize them and reduce grain size. There has been concern about whether components of the nitrogen isotopic composition are lost when samples are reacted in HCl and oven-dried (Meyers and Teranes 2001). We thus ran 20 freeze-dried and homogenised bulk samples from the same levels that were prepared using HCl and by oven-drying, to test if there were differences between results derived from the two preparation methods (Table S2). Because we found no large discrepancy between the methods, the HCl treatment was applied to the nitrogen isotope samples throughout the core. All isotope samples were analysed according to standard methods at Iso-Analytical Inc., England, with an elemental analyser connected to a continuous flow isotope-ratio mass spectrometer. Analytical precision was ±0.3‰ for δ15N and ±0.1‰ for δ13C. The elemental analyser provides measurements of total organic carbon (TOC) and nitrogen content (TN). There was no evidence for presence of inorganic nitrogen (Talbot 2001), and TN thus reflects total organic nitrogen. In this study, C/N ratios are expressed as weight percent. Carbon isotope values are reported in standard δ notation (‰) relative to VPDB (PeeDee Belemnite) (Coplen 1982), and nitrogen values are reported with respect to atmospheric nitrogen (AIR).
Magnetic susceptibility (χbulk), anhysteretic remnant magnetization (ARM), and saturation isothermal remnant magnetization (SIRM), were measured to characterize the minerogenic material deposited in the lake. Such measurements permit discrimination between, for instance, glacial and non-glacial sediments, as reflected in changes in the strength of the signal or shifts in the S-ratio (IRM100mT/sIRM2T). Such data can be used to identify the end of deglaciation and to characterize the input of detrital material throughout the Holocene.
Core I was sampled for magnetic analyses with plastic boxes every 1 cm throughout the core (n = 489). Initial magnetic susceptibility (χbulk) was determined on both wet and dry samples using a KLY-2 induction bridge with a sensitivity of 4 × 10−8 SI. ARM was imposed with a 0.1mT DC field and a 100mT AC-field in a 2G af-demagnetizer on contiguous samples collected from the basal 89 cm of the core (489–400 cm depth; n = 89). SIRM was obtained for the same interval (489–400 cm depth; n = 89) using an ASC IM10-30 Impulse Magnetizer for which saturation levels (SIRM) were assumed by applying a 2T field. Because there was little difference between measurements performed with 1T and 2T fields (n = 20), we assume that “saturation” was obtained with a 2T field. Backfield measurements were performed after exposing the samples to a 100mT field (IRM-100mT). Subsequently, the S-ratio was used to indicate the dominant magnetic mineralogy (Stober and Thompson 1979). Low values represent the presence of canted-ferromagnetic minerals such as α–Fe2O3 (haematite) and high values represent the presence of ferromagnetic minerals such as Fe3O4 (magnetite). Magnetic susceptibility was measured on splits from Cores I and II using a Bartington instrument equipped with a MS2E surface sensor. Measurements were performed in the Paleomagnetic Laboratory at the University of Bergen, Norway or at the Magnetic Laboratory at ETH, in Zürich, Switzerland.
The late glacial record
No macrofossils were located in the lowest part of the core. Ages before 10,370 cal year BP were obtained by extrapolation and therefore have large associated uncertainties. Mean late glacial sampling resolution is ~30 years/cm and somewhat better for the Holocene. Relatively large clasts embedded in silty clays in the lowermost part of the core are thought to reflect deglaciation.
Organic matter is absent below 455 cm, so isotopic analysis of OM was only possible on samples from that depth and above (Fig. 4). The earliest part of the record shows a negative δ13C excursion during the Allerød Interstade. Thereafter, following a return to higher δ13C values, δ13C decreases steadily upward through this section of the core, a trend that is also apparent in the early-late Holocene δ13COM records from other marl lakes (Diefendorf et al. 2008). δ15N also decreases upward, but in a more irregular fashion than the carbon isotopes (Fig. 5).
LOI550 values tend to be correlated inversely with magnetic susceptibility during the late glacial (Fig. 6). A rapid increase in LOI550, from 1–2 to 10–11%, occurs at the onset of the Allerød, ~13,500 cal year BP. There is an equally swift return to lower values (5%) at the onset of the Younger Dryas, ~12,700 cal year BP. At 11,500 cal year BP, values rise again, but a temporary return to lower values is associated with the previously described anomaly in magnetic properties. Based on the results presented above, three sedimentary phases (P4–P6), representing late glacial changes, were recognized in Core I (Fig. 7).
The Holocene record
From 10,300 to 6,800 cal year BP, LOI values gradually increase, from less than 10 to more than 70% (Figs. 5, 6). During the first 1,000 years of this period, the LOI increased stepwise, but during the latter 2,500 years of this period, the increase was smoother. At 6,800 cal year BP, LOI declined by ~15% (Fig. 6) for about 500 years. During the rest of the Holocene LOI values are extremely high, reaching a maximum of ~81% at 3,500 cal year BP, after which they declined for 1,300 years, to 60%.
Holocene variations in χbulk indicate that the influx of minerogenic matter after 9,500 cal year BP was low, although values averaged 10−7 × 1.48 m3 kg−1. There were marked strengthenings of magnetic susceptibility twice during the late Holocene (Fig. 6). The first increase began around 4,000 cal year BP, at which time higher values were attained rapidly. After 2,300 cal year BP, values began to increase further, a trend that continues towards the top of the core with χbulk values of 10−7 × 2.15 m3 kg−1.
Smear slides illustrate the organic-rich nature of the Holocene sediments and contain little siliclastic material (mainly quartz), suggesting minimal input of minerogenic grains from the surrounding landscape. The organic fraction contains unstructured (amorphous) material of probable algal origin, as well as from higher plants, in particular well preserved remains of the moss Drepanocladus sp., and from a variety of aquatic invertebrates (Fig. 8). Diatoms are few, small and poorly preserved from the beginning of the Holocene until ca. 5,500 cal year BP, but thereafter become abundant, with a pronounced increase in large species. Early Holocene sediments contain euhedral, in some cases elongate, crystals of feldspar, showing typical albite twinning (Fig. 8). Their perfect crystal form strongly suggests they are authigenic feldspar. The crystals become rare and eventually disappear around 5,000 cal year BP, at the same time diatoms become abundant.
The δ13C record from the earliest Holocene continues the trend seen in the late glacial. From the Younger Dryas, there is a transition to lower δ13C values in the Holocene. The δ13Corg curve stabilizes ~8,000 cal year BP and values remain low (<−38.3‰) for the rest of the Holocene, except for a short period of isotope enrichment at 6,700–6,400 years BP, the Atlantic period, corresponding to the lower LOI values described above (Fig. 5).
Nitrogen isotope values (δ15Norg) also display a trend to progressively lower values into the Holocene, but not as smooth a trend as for δ13Corg (Fig. 5). The Younger Dryas and perhaps the Preboreal Oscillation (PBO) have the highest values, around +2.2 to +4‰, probably because immature soils provided the dominant source of nitrogen during this period (Wolfe et al. 1999; Talbot 2001). δ15N values stabilise at relatively low values, −4 to −2‰, at around 7,500 cal year BP, and remain low for the rest of the Holocene, except for a period of isotope enrichment in the Atlantic period, as seen for carbon isotope ratios (Fig. 5). There are, however, slight temporal differences between the trends in carbon and nitrogen isotope signals during this period (Fig. 5). After about 3,200 cal year BP the nitrogen isotope ratios increase slightly, but display relatively low variability.
Sources of organic matter in sediments
Organic matter is frequently a minor constituent of lake sediments. In Lake Nattmålsvatn, organic matter dominates the sediment mass, with maximum LOI values near 82% (Fig. 2). We assume that the residual material from the loss-on-ignition procedure consists largely of diatoms, given the low MS signal and the smear slide observations.
Both δ13C and δ15N display large ranges, ~20 and ~9‰, respectively, suggesting major changes in carbon and nitrogen cycling throughout the post-glacial history of Lake Nattmålsvatn. In the late glacial, there were δ13C values greater than −25‰. Sediments of that phase consist of silt with low TOC content, alternating with silty gyttja. This reflects a pioneer phase with little catchment vegetation. Dissolution of detrital carbonate and exposed marble bedrock would have been the principal source of DIC at that time, contributing isotopically enriched runoff to the lake, which in turn would generate OM with relatively high δ13C values. A similar scenario is apparent in Lough Inchiquin (Eire), where the limestone bedrock dominated the isotopic composition of lake OM during the immediate post-glacial period (Diefendorf et al. 2008).
Evidence for weathering of labile glacial detritus is also provided by abundant pyrite framboids in parts of this section, which were formed by microbial sulphate reduction. The dissolved sulphate required for pyrite formation probably came from the oxidation of detrital pyrite in tills derived from mica schist. Pyrite is absent from younger deposits, despite the anoxic conditions that must have prevailed in such organic-rich sediments. Once all detrital pyrite had been removed from the glacial deposits, there presumably was no other source of sulphate, and bacterial sulphate reduction was no longer an important process in Holocene lake sediments.
The isotope and elemental data display some interesting relationships (Fig. 9). During the initial postglacial period, there is a positive correlation between δ13C and δ15N (Fig. 9), but this breaks down around 8,000–7,000 cal year BP when δ13C stabilises at −38.1 ± 0.3‰, while δ15N varies over a range ~5‰ (Fig. 9). At the same time there is a shift in the δ15N vs. TN relationship (Fig. 9), as the OM displays a much higher TN content. This change supports our inference that the transition from oligotrophic conditions that prevailed during the late glacial, to eutrophic conditions, occurred at ca. 8,000 cal year BP (Fig. 5).
The δ15N and δ13C in the early part of the record show an inverse correlation with TN and TOC, respectively. This is opposite to what is expected if variations in isotopic composition are driven by primary productivity (Hollander and McKenzie 1991; Bade et al. 2004). The inverse relationships suggest, instead, that the DIC and DIN pools available for primary production were not limited. Development of ice cover for 5–7 months each year may have contributed to this DIC and DIN availability. Respiration of sediment OM during winter months can lead to accumulation of dissolved and free gases beneath the ice, notably carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia and nitrous oxide (Wetzel 2001), with concentrations well in excess of those resulting from equilibrium with the atmosphere (Kortelainen et al. 2000; Striegl et al. 2001; Huttunen et al. 2003a, b). Primary production may also continue beneath the ice (Wetzel 2001). Although it is likely that production in Lake Nattmålsvatn was low during the dark winter months, high insolation at these northern latitudes during April and May could have stimulated high rates of primary production beneath the ice at a time when dissolved nutrients would have been at their highest concentrations. Very low Holocene δ13C values may reflect assimilation of this DIC pool under the ice and during the ensuing period of ice-out, when primary production reaches a peak (Boström and Pettersson 1977). Carbon isotope values lower than about −32‰ suggest that methane oxidation has contributed CO2 to the DIC pool (Rau 1978; Whiticar and Faber 1986). Another reason for the low values may be elevated pCO2, as fractionation increases with increased CO2 concentration (Degens et al. 1968). The remarkably constant δ13C record for the Holocene suggests that Lake Nattmålsvatn was, and still is, a well-buffered system. We do not, however, have a good explanation for why the δ13C value for Holocene OM stabilized at −38.1 ± 0.3‰.
Abundance of dissolved nitrogen species may also explain the low δ15N values (<0‰). Like C isotopes in organic matter, N-isotope fractionation increases with rising N availability (Talbot 2001). Unlike the δ13C record, however, δ15N did not stabilise at a fixed value, but varied over a range of ~2‰, probably due to variations in N availability, likely in the form of ammonia (Billaud 1968), and drawdown of the DIN reservoir as the spring bloom proceeded.
Low δ13C and δ15N values in Holocene OM were interrupted only by higher values from 6,850 to 6,500 cal year BP (Fig. 5). Nitrogen isotopes, in particular, suggest a return at that time to near-late-glacial conditions. Concomitant reductions in TOC, TN and LOI, accompanied by the rise in δ15N and a small rise in C/N (Figs. 4, 5), are consistent with a reduction in lake productivity and an increased supply of plant and soil OM to the lake. As mentioned, we interpret this excursion to be the result of a previously unrecognised brief period of cooling in Arctic Norway.
Feldspar authigenesis also provides insight into the state of the lake. The paucity of diatoms in the feldspar-bearing section suggests that the silica necessary for feldspar precipitation may have been provided by diatom dissolution. The solubility of opaline silica increases dramatically at pH ≥ 8. Diatom dissolution probably occurred when the lake was at least seasonally alkaline, with a pH greater than the current 8. Such conditions could have been achieved in a climate warmer and drier than today’s, when high rates of primary production and greater summer evaporation led to elevated surface water pH. Increased diatom abundance and the accompanying disappearance of feldspar after ca. 5,500 cal year BP suggest a change to less alkaline conditions, probably due to a transition to a cooler, wetter climate that characterised the later Holocene in the Senja region.
Correlation of TOC and LOI
We speculate that 3 and 4 above, i.e. extremely high LOI values (>60%) in combination with a change in OM composition, are responsible for the poor relationship between LOI and TOC. Below 60% LOI there is a very strong correlation between the two variables (r = 0.99, P < 0.001) (Fig. 10). As noted above, there is a gradual decrease in C/N ratio after the middle Holocene, indicating an increasing proportion of nitrogen-rich OM in sediments, originating from lake primary production. This is also evident in the %TN curve, which shows the highest nitrogen concentrations in the latest part of the Holocene (Fig. 5). Alternatives (1) and (2) were rejected for several reasons. Sample size was small (1 ml wet material), so incomplete ignition is unlikely to have been a problem. Furthermore, the strong stratigraphic correlation between LOI values in Cores I and II also suggests complete ignition was not a problem. Furthermore, measurement errors with the elemental analyzer are highly unlikely. The instrument is routinely tested using carbon-rich materials such as wheat flour, with TOC values >40%, and should therefore be capable of handling organic-rich lacustrine sediments. In addition, TOC values are not consistently low or high relative to what might be expected from LOI. Instead, there is simply wide scatter.
TOC and LOI values from the Lake Nattmålsvatn cores display corresponding trends over the long time frame (Fig. S1), but the signals diverge in some sections, particularly when OM exceeds 60%. The TN and C/N records enable us to conclude that poor correlation occurs in lake sediments consisting of more nitrogen-rich OM, in the middle and late Holocene.
Calcite was observed in shallow waters and along the lake shore during fieldwork in July 2002. Greyish-white coatings on submersed rocks and twigs and marl on the lake bottom confirmed that Nattmålsvatn is a Chara (marl) lake. Langangen (1995) supports this observation, but nonetheless, there is no evidence of carbonate in the core. Several samples were checked for carbonate by XRD analysis and all yielded negative results.
Calcite dissolution in hard-water lakes has been described from other sites, e.g. the Swiss Alps (Ohlendorf and Sturm 2001). Biogenic calcite precipitation in Lake Hagelseewli occurs in late summer as a result of photosynthetic uptake of CO2. The following winter, the precipitated calcite is completely dissolved. The long period of ice cover leads to bottom waters strongly undersaturated with respect to calcite. During ice cover, bottom waters become anoxic and pH declines.
In the northern part of Norway examined in this study, ice cover on lakes of small to medium size and depth averages 5–7 months (Økland and Økland 1998), but can be longer. Such conditions are similar to those in the Swiss Alps, and winter processes are probably similar in the lakes of both regions. Neither Hagelseewli nor Nattmålsvatn is a “typical” oligotrophic, alkaline water body. For instance, there is considerable decomposition of OM in both lakes. In this study, such decomposition was evident from the strong H2S odor, as well as methanogenesis in the sediments. The organic matter is subject to microbial decomposition, with consequent consumption of O2. Even in an oligotrophic hard-water lake such as Nattmålsvatn, oxygen depletion at the sediment–water interface may occur, but does not necessarily lead to oxygen depletion of the entire hypolimnion. Similar scenarios are described by Økland and Økland (1998).
In Lake Nattmålsvatn, surface sediments are dominated by particles from high autochthonous organic production during spring and summer, along with precipitated calcite. There are only minor amounts of detrital material. Decomposition of the OM produces slightly acidic conditions at the sediment–water interface with a sufficiently low pH to dissolve the precipitated calcite. A higher influx of detrital material could possibly ‘protect’ the calcite from dissolution.
Minerogenic influx and environmental implications
The lowermost part of the core is characterized by greyish silt containing larger clasts, most likely related to the local retreat of the inland ice sheet and/or a local ice cap at Senja (Fig. 1). The sequence reveals high values for ARM, SIRM and χbulk that appear to drop relatively rapidly (Fig. 7). Such high values are only surpassed by the brief period centred at 10,250 cal year BP, which might represent the Saksunarvatnet Ash layer (Mangerud et al. 1986, Rasmussen et al. 2007). Although exact dating of the deglaciation may not be possible, its timing can be constrained. The lake was positioned between two ice-sheet margins, the youngest and best defined being the Younger Dryas, referred to locally as the Tromsø-Lyngen stage (Andersen 1968). The older one is commonly referred to as the D-event (Vorren and Plassen 2002) (Fig. 1). According to Vorren and Plassen (2002), this event occurred between 13.8 and 13.2 14C years BP. Recalibrating the raw 14C dates ±150 year with CALIB 5.0.2, the event dates to between 15,890 ± 270 and 15,120 ± 250 cal year BP. Consequently, deglaciation of Lake Nattmålsvatn took place after 15,120 ± 250 and before 12,900 cal year BP. Our age-depth model suggests that deglaciation occurred earlier, around 15,400 ± 250 cal year BP, but this age is tentative. A more likely scenario for deglaciation is the Bølling warming, which started around 14,700 cal year BP, when cirque glaciers in the region started receding (Paasche et al. 2007a).
Holocene minerogenic influx to the lake can be broadly divided into four phases (Fig. 5). The early Holocene transition (P4) included what might be the Saksunarvatnet Ash (10,347 before 2000 AD) (Fig. 7). This interval was followed by a long and stable phase from 9,500 to 4,000 cal year BP, during which there were eight brief (<50 years) episodes with greater minerogenic material. In addition to these short periods, there were two prominent events that lasted much longer. The first one spanned the period between 6,850 and 6,500 cal year BP, and the second lasted from about 6,000–5,750 cal year BP (Fig. 5). These episodes of higher minerogenic matter influx probably reflect an increase in runoff from a sustained increase in winter precipitation (Bakke et al. 2010).
At 4,000 cal year BP, a shift occurred in <100 years, marking the onset of inferred increased runoff that prevailed for 1,700 years. At 2,300 cal year BP, minerogenic matter increased again and the positive trend continued to the end of the record at ca. 1,100 cal year BP. We also interpret these two shifts to indicate wetter winter conditions which might have been related to large-scale atmospheric circulation anomalies. This interpretation is in good accordance with results from northern Fennoscandia (Vorren et al. 2007; Bakke et al. 2005; Paasche et al. 2004, 2007a, b).
Timing of events in the sediment record
In the late glacial period, variations in isotope values (δ13C and δ15N), MS, LOI and C/N in the Lake Nattmålsvatn cores occurred synchronously (Figs. 4, 6). Vegetation was poorly developed at the time and there was a large influx of detrital particles from the lake catchment. There was a strong correlation between δ13C and δ15N, and an inverse correlation between the isotope signatures and their respective elemental concentrations (TOC and TN), from the late glacial up to the levels where methane oxidation had a profound influence on the isotope results (Figs. 4, 9). These results are explained by the profound effect of prolonged ice cover on carbon and nitrogen cycling in Lake Nattmålsvatn. The termination of the Younger Dryas and the beginning of the Holocene are not reflected synchronously in variables LOI, TOC and C/N. This is because the relative increase in OM did not result from increased soil erosion and input of terrestrial plant material, which implies that the gradual depletion of both δ13C and δ15N values was not a result of changes in OM source, but rather, changes in DIC and DIN. The decrease in χbulk in the early Holocene contrasts with the gradual increase in LOI, indicating less transport of detrital material to the lake (Fig. 6). The increasing LOI values signal a smaller relative amount of detrital material in the sediment. The MS values record a diminishing magnetic signal in sediment that already displayed a weak signal.
In the Holocene, C/N ratios were stable. TOC and TN values increased, whereas δ13C and δ15N values declined. The δ13C reached “steady” values earlier than other variables, indicating that methanogenesis and oxidation of methane began early in the Holocene. Variables other than δ13C, however, indicate that variations did occur in the Holocene.
The 6,850–6,500 cal year BP event, evident in the isotope and the LOI550 stratigraphies, is the most striking excursion in the Holocene (Fig. 5). The C/N signal, however, showed little change. This may indicate sustained lake production in combination with reduced influx of terrestrial OM. Although the event is recorded in both the δ13C and δ15N datasets, it is more pronounced in the latter. This probably does not reflect differences in response time between these variables, but may instead indicate that the DIC changed little in the system and that a threshold must be surpassed before a shift in δ13C occurs. If winter ice cover helped maintain low δ15N and δ13C values, then ice out probably lead to ventilation of depleted DIN and DIC, perhaps changing the δ13C values.
In recent years, winters in northern Norway have been mild, and persistent low temperatures have not set in until January and February, resulting in a very short period of ice cover on lakes. Comparable conditions may have existed during the 6,850–6,500 cal year BP event, with mild, wet winters and poorly developed ice cover. Plant growth and algal blooms in summer may have remained unchanged, despite milder winters. Under such a scenario, the composition of OM would not change. For example, the C/N ratio would not be affected. Altered winter conditions, however, would change DIN and DIC, and also cause a stronger MS signal, given that greater winter precipitation leads to higher runoff from the catchment, bringing more minerogenic matter into the lake.
From 6,300 to 4,000 cal year BP there was a decline in C/N ratio. This decline was probably associated with a relative decrease in the amount of terrestrial OM accumulating in the lake sediments or a gradual increase in aquatic primary production.
Different climate proxies in lake sediments have different thresholds and sensitivities to climate changes that affect a lake and its catchment. Some proxy variables may be highly sensitive, whereas others only respond to major climate and environmental changes. Additionally, there may be temporal differences in response among the climate proxies in a paleoclimatic study. The core chronologies and inter-site correlation within a lake may further compromise interpretations. In the Lake Nattmålsvatn records, only the deglaciation events produced synchronous changes among most of the proxies. The deglacial was a period with increased detrital influx and moderate to low amounts of OM in the sediments. Holocene deposits are extremely organic-rich, which seems to have lowered the sensitivity of the climate proxies used in this study, yielding relatively constant values. The exception to this generalization was the 6,850–6,500 cal year BP event, which is recorded by all proxies except C/N ratio. As suggested, most of the proxy variables were probably affected by shifts in winter conditions, whereas the C/N ratio stayed rather constant because it reflects organic matter production during summer.
Stable isotopes of organic matter (δ13C and δ15N) in sediments do not serve as strong paleoclimate proxies in lakes such as Lake Nattmålsvatn. The large amount of organic matter production and deposition, in combination with methanogenesis and prolonged seasonal ice cover, makes the lake less sensitive to changing environmental conditions. Magnetic variables are better suited to track climate and environmental variations, predominantly fluctuations in winter precipitation that affect catchment runoff.
A period of microbially-mediated pyrite formation during the late glacial probably reflects weathering of newly exposed, pyrite-bearing glacial detritus. Once removal of the detrital pyrite was complete, sulphate concentrations in the lake were insufficient to permit formation of early diagenetic pyrite.
Isotopic and elemental data suggest that Lake Nattmålsvatn changed from an oligotrophic to a eutrophic waterbody about 8,000 cal year BP.
Authigenic feldspar formation during the early Holocene was the result of alkaline conditions in the lake. This was probably due to a warmer and drier climate, which promoted diatom dissolution, thus providing the silica required for feldspar precipitation.
Climatic deterioration from 6,850 to 6,500 cal year BP has not been described previously in Scandinavia. This anomaly most likely represents a period of increased winter precipitation and reduced ice cover. A two-step increase in winter precipitation, at 4,000 and 2,300 cal year BP, is indicated by magnetic susceptibility, and corresponds to the ‘Holocene Turnover’ evident in other paleoclimate studies.
Loss-on-ignition (LOI) and elemental analysis revealed a previously undescribed relationship between TOC and LOI550 in organic-rich sediments. At LOI550 values >60%, there is no longer a linear relationship between LOI550 and TOC. This may reflect variations in the C/N ratio of the organic matter. This decoupling of LOI550 and TOC makes it difficult to interpret changes in both proxies or link their variations to to specific climatic conditions. Overall, however, long-term major trends in LOI550 and TOC were in agreement.
We thank Jostein Bakke, Bjørn Christian Kvisvik and Åsmund Bakke for help with coring of Lake Nattmålsvatn, Nils Erik Janbu for field assistance in 2002, and Karl Fredrik Alnes for proofreading. We also extend our thanks to Prof. Reidar Løvlie and Prof. Ann Hirt for use of the Paleomagnetic Laboratory in Bergen (UIB) and the Laboratory for Natural Magnetism in Zürich (ETH), respectively. The Norwegian Geological Survey (NGU) performed the LECO and XRD analyses. This work was financed by a Norwegian Research Council grant through NORPEC, a Strategic University Program (SUP) at the University of Bergen, led by Prof. H.J.B. Birks. Finally, we offer our sincere thanks to two anonymous reviewers and especially Editor-in-Chief Mark Brenner for valuable feedback. This is publication nr. A321 from the Bjerknes Centre of Climate Research.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.