Methods to Evaluate Health information Systems in Healthcare Settings: A Literature Review
Purchase on Springer.com
$39.95 / €34.95 / £29.95*
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.
Although information technology (IT)-based applications in healthcare have existed for more than three decades, methods to evaluate outputs and outcomes of the use of IT-based systems in medical informatics is still a challenge for decision makers, as well as to those who want to measure the effects of ICT in healthcare settings. The aim of this paper is to review published articles in the area evaluations of IT-based systems in order to gain knowledge about methodologies used and findings obtained from the evaluation of IT-based systems applied in healthcare settings. The literature review includes studies of IT-based systems between 2003 and 2005. The findings show that economic and organizational aspects dominate evaluation studies in this area. However, the results focus mostly on positive outputs such as user satisfaction, financial benefits and improved organizational work. This review shows that there is no standard framework for evaluation effects and outputs of implementation and use of IT in the healthcare setting and that until today no studies explore the impact of IT on the healthcare system’ productivity and effectiveness.
Supplementary Material (0)
- Kaplan, B., Evaluating informatics applications—some alternative approaches: theory, social interactionism, and call for methodological pluralism. Int. J. Med. Inform. 64:39–56, 2001. CrossRef
- Ammenwerth, E., Brender, J., Nykanen, P., Prokosch, H. U., Rigby, M., and Talmon, J., Visions and strategies to improve evaluation of health information systems. Reflections and lessons based on the HIS-EVAL workshop in Innsbruck. Int. J. Med. Inform. 73:479–491, 2004. CrossRef
- Ammenwerth, E., Iller, C., and Mansmann, U., Can evaluation studies benefit from triangulation? A case study. Int. J. Med. Inform. 70:237–248, 2003. CrossRef
- Andersen, J. G., Aydin, C. E., and Jay, S. J., Evaluating Healthcare Information Systems: Methods and Applications. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage publication, 1994.
- Friedman, C. P., and Wyatt, J. C., Evaluation Methods in Medical Informatics. New York: Springer, 1996.
- Kaplan, B., and Shaw, N. T., Future directions in evaluation research: People, organizational, and social issues. Methods Inf. Med. 43:215–231, 2004.
- Phil, W., An assessment of strategies for information system evaluation: Lessons for education. Int. J. Educ. Res. 25:361–371, 1996. CrossRef
- Delpierre, C., Cuzin, L., Fillaux, J., Alvarez, M., Massip, P., and Lang, T., A systematic review of computer-based patient record systems and quality of care: More randomized clinical trials or a broader approach. Int. J. Qual. Health Care. 16:407–416, 2004. CrossRef
- Wang, S. J., Middleton, B., Bardon, C. G., Spurr, C. D., Carchidi, P. J., Kittler, A. f., Goldszar, R. C., Fairchild, D. G., Sussman, A. J., Kuperman, G. J., and Bates, D. W., A cost-benefit analysis of electronic medical records in primary care. Am. J. Med. 114:397–403, 2003. CrossRef
- Laerum, H., Karlsen, T. H., and Faxvaag, A., Effects of scanning and eliminating paper-based medical records on hospital physicians’ clinical work practice. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 10:160–588, 2003. CrossRef
- Ruland, C. M., and Ravn, I. H., Usefulness and effects on costs and staff management of a nursing resource management information system. J. Nurs. Manag. 11:208–215, 2003.
- Houston, T. K., Ray, M. N., Crawford, M. A., Giddens, T., and Berner, E. S., Patient perceptions of physician use of handheld computers. AMIA Annu. Symp. Proc. 299–303, 2003.
- Ammenwerth, E., Mansmann, U., Iller, C., and Eichstädter, R., Factors affecting and affected by user acceptance of computer-based nursing documentation: Results of a two-year study. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 10:69–84, 2003. CrossRef
- Zhang, W. P., Yamauchi, K., Mizuno, S., Zhang, R., and Huang, D. M., Analysis of cost and assessment of computerized patient record systems in Japan based on questionnaire survey. Med. Inform. Internet Med. 29:229–238, 2004. CrossRef
- Laerum, H., Karlsen, T. H., and Faxvaag, A., Use of and attitudes to a hospital information system by medical secretaries, nurses and physicians deprived of the paper-based medical record: A case report BMC Med. Inform. Decis. Mak. 4:18, 2004. CrossRef
- Hier, D. B., Rothschild, A., LeMaistre, A., and Keeler, J., Differing faculty and housestaff acceptance of an electronic health record one year after implementation. Medinfo. 11:1300–1303, 2004.
- Rotich, J. K., Hannan, T. J., Smith, F. E., Bii, J., Odero, W. W., Vu, N., Mamlin, B. W., Mamlin, J. J., Einterz, R. M., and Tierney, W. M., Installing and implementing a computer-based patient record system in sub-Saharan Africa: The Mosoriot Medical Record System. Med. Inform. Internet Med. 10:295–303, 2003.
- Stengel, D., Bauwens, K., Walter, M., Kopfer, T., and Ekkernkamp, A., Comparison of handheld computer-assisted and conventional paper chart documentation of medical records. A randomized, controlled trial. J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 86:553–560, 2004.
- Likourezos, A., Chalfin, D. B., Murphy, D. G., Sommer, B., Darcy, K., and Davidson, S. J., Physician and nurse satisfaction with an Electronic Medical Record System. J. Emerg. Med. 27:419–424, 2004. CrossRef
- Pagliari, C., Gilmour, M., and Sullivan, F., Evaluating national electronic clinical communications implementation in Scotland. Medinfo. 11:1794, 2004.
- Baum, A., Figar, S., Serverino, J., Assale, D., Schachner, B., Otero, P., Luna, D., and de Quiros, F. G., Assessing the impact of change in the organization of a technical support system for a health information systems (HIS). Medinfo. 11:1367–1370, 2004.
- Hobson, J. C., Khemani, S., and Singh, A., Prospective audit of the quality of ENT emergency clinic notes before and after introduction of a computerized template. J. Laryngol. Otol. 119:264–266, 2005. CrossRef
- Kaushal, R., Blumenthal, D., Poon, E. G., Jha, A. K., Franz, C., Middleton, B., Glaser, J., Kuperman, G., Christino, M., Fernandopulle, R., Newhouse, J. P., and Bates, D. W., The costs of a national health information network. Ann. Intern. Med. 143:165–173, 2005.
- Raja, E. E., Mahal, R., and Masih, V. B., An exploratory study to assess the computer knowledge, attitude and skill among nurses in healthcare setting of a selected hospital in Ludhiana, Punjab, India. Medinfo. 11:1304–1307, 2004.
- Clayton, P. D., Naus, S. P., Bowes, W. A., Madsen, T. S., Wilcox, A. B., Orsmond, G., Rocha, B., Thornton, S. N., Jones, S., Jacobsen, C. A., Udall, M. R., Rhodes, M. L., Wallace, B. E., Cannon, W., Gardner, J., Huff, S. M., and Leckman, L., Physician use of electronic medical records: issues and successes with direct data entry and physician productivity. AMIA Annu. Symp. Proc. 141–145, 2005.
- White, M., Computerised versus handwritten records. Paediatr. Nurs. 17:15–18, 2005.
- Wilcox, A. B., Jones, S. S., Dorr, D. A., Cannon, W., Burns, L., Radican, K., Christensen, K., Brunker, C., Larsen, A., Narus, S. P., Thornton, S. N., and Clayton, P. D., Use and impact of a computer-generated patient summary worksheet for primary care. AMIA Annu. Symp. Proc. 824–828, 2005.
- Makela, K., Virjo, I., Aho, J., Kalliola, P., Koivukoski, A. M., Kurunmaki, H., Kahara, M., Uusitalo, L., Valli, M., Vuotari, V., and Ylinen, S., Electronic patient record systems and the general practitioner: an evaluation study. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:S2:66–68, 2005. CrossRef
- Zurita, L., and Nohr, C., Patient opinion–EHR assessment from the users perspective. Medinfo. 11:1333–1336, 2004.
- Breslow, M. J., Rosenfeld, B. A., Doerfler, M., Burke, G., Yates, G., Stone, D. J., Tomaszewicz, P., Hochman, R., and Plocher, D. W., Effect of a multiple-site intensive care unit telemedicine program on clinical and economic outcomes: an alternative paradigm for intensivist staffing. Crit. Care Med. 32:31–38, 2004. CrossRef
- Scalvini, S., Capomolla, S., Zanelli, E., Benigno, M., Domenighini, D., Paletta, L., Glisenti, F., and Giordano, A., Effect of home-based telecardiology on chronic heart failure: Costs and outcomes. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:S1:16–18, 2005. CrossRef
- Noble, S. M., Coast, J., and Benger, J. R., A cost-consequences analysis of minor injuries telemedicine. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:15–19, 2005. CrossRef
- Persaud, D. D., Jreige, S., Skedgel, C., Finley, J., Sargeant, J., and Hanlon, N., An incremental cost analysis of telehealth in Nova Scotia from a societal perspective. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:77–84, 2005. CrossRef
- Dillon, E., Loermans, J., Davis, D., and Xu, C., Evaluation of the westerrn Australian Department of Health telehealth project. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:S2:19–S2:121, 2005. CrossRef
- Larcher, B., Arisi, E., Berloffa, F., Demichelis, F., Eccher, C., Galligioni, E., Galvagni, M., Martini, G., Sboner, A., Tomio, L., Zumiani, G., Graiff, A., and Forti, S., Analysis of user-satisfaction with the use of a teleconsultation system in oncology. Med. Inform. Internet. Med. 28:73–84, 2003. CrossRef
- Bratan, T., Clarke, M., Jones, R., Larkworthy, A., and Paul, R., Evaluation of the practical feasibility and acceptability of home monitoring in residential homes. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11(Suppl 1):29–31, 2005. CrossRef
- Mair, F. S., Goldstein, P., May, C., Angus, R., Shiels, C., Hibbert, D., O’Connor, J., Boland, A., Roberts, C., Haycox, A., and Capewell, S., Patient and provider perspectives on home telecare: preliminary results from a randomized controlled trial. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11(Suppl 1):95–97, 2005. CrossRef
- Linassi, A. G., and Li Pi Shan, R., User satisfaction with a telemedicine amputee clinic in Saskatchewan. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:414–418, 2005. CrossRef
- Young, T. L., and Ireson, C., Effectiveness of school-based telehealth care in urban and rural elementary schools. Pediatrics. 112:1088–1094, 2003. CrossRef
- Baldwin, L., Clarke, M., Hands, L., Knott, M., and Jones, R., The effect of telemedicine on consultation time. J. Telemed. Telecare. 9:S1:71–73, 2003. CrossRef
- Finkelstein, J., Khare, R., and Ansell, J., Feasibility and patients’ acceptance of home automated telemanagement of oral anticoagulation therapy. Proc. AMIA Symp. 230–234, 2003.
- Vontetsianos, T., Giovas, P., Katsaras, T., Rigopoulou, A., Mpirmpa, G., Giaboudakis, P., Koyrelea, S., Kontopyrgias, G., and Tsoulkas, B., Telemedicine-assisted home support for patients with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: preliminary results after nine-month follow-up. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:S1:86–S1:88, 2005. CrossRef
- Grady, B. J., and Melcer, T., A retrospective evaluation of TeleMental Healthcare services for remote military populations. Telemed J E Health. 11:551–558, 2005. CrossRef
- Wong, Y. K., Hui, E., and Woo, J., A community-based exercise programme for older persons with knee pain using telemedicine. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:310–315, 2005. CrossRef
- Beuscart-Zephir, M. C., Pelayo, S., Degoulet, P., Anceaux, F., Guerlinger, S., and Meaux, J. J., A usability study of CPOE’s medication administration functions: impact on physician-nurse cooperation. Medinfo. 11:1018–1022, 2004.
- Galanter, W. L., Polikaitis, A., and DiDomenico, R. J., A trial of automated safety alerts for inpatient digoxin use with computerized physician order entry. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 11:270–277, 2004. CrossRef
- Shulman, R., Singer, M., Goldstone, J., and Bellingan, G., Medication errors: a prospective cohort study of hand-written and computerised physician order entry in the intensive care unit. Crit. Care. 9:R516–R521, 2005. CrossRef
- Galanter, W. L., Didomenico, R. J., and Polikaitis, A., A trial of automated decision support alerts for contraindicated medications using computerized physician order entry. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 12:269–274, 2005. CrossRef
- Sintchenko, V., Iredell, J. R., Gilbert, G. L., and Coiera, E., Handheld computer-based decision support reduces patient length of stay and antibiotic prescribing in critical care. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 12:398–402, 2005. CrossRef
- Short, D., Frischer, M., and Bashford, J., The development and evaluation of a computerised decision support system for primary care based upon ‘patient profile decision analysis’. Inform. Prim. Care. 11:195–202, 2003.
- Ruland, C. M., White, T., Stevens, M., Fanciullo, G., and Khilani, S. M., Effects of a computerized system to support shared decision making in symptom management of cancer patients: Preliminary results. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 10:573–579, 2003. CrossRef
- Park, R. W., Shin, S. S., Choi, Y. I., Ahn, J. O., and Hwang, S. C., Computerized physician order entry and electronic medical record systems in Korean teaching and general hospitals: Results of a 2004 survey. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 12:642–647, 2005. CrossRef
- Gandhi, T. K., Weingart, S. N., Seger, A. C., Borus, J., Burdick, E., Poon, E. G., Leape, L. L., and Bates, D. W., Outpatient prescribing errors and the impact of computerized prescribing. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 20:837–841, 2005. CrossRef
- Ohsfeldt, R. L., Ward, M. M., Schneider, J. E., Jaana, M., Miller, T. R., Lei, Y., and Wakefield, S., Implementation of hospital computerized physician order entry systems in a rural state: Feasibility and financial impact. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 12:20–27, 2005, Jan. CrossRef
- Bogucki, B., Jacobs, B. R., and Hingle, J., Computerized reminders reduce the use of medications during shortages. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 11:278–280, 2004. CrossRef
- Van den Brink, J. L., Moorman, P. W., de Boer, M. F., Pruyn, J. F., Verwoerd, C. D., and van emmel, J. H., Involving the patient: a prospective study on use, appreciation and effectiveness of an information system in head and neck cancer care. Int. J. Med. Inform. 74:839–849, 2005. CrossRef
- Choi, S. S., Jazayeri, D. G., Mitnick, C. D., Chalco, K., Bayona, J., and Fraser, H. S., Implementation and initial evaluation of a Web-based nurse order entry system for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis patients in Peru. Medinfo. 11:202–206, 2004.
- Odhiambo-Otieno, G. W., Evaluation of existing district health management information systems a case study of the district health systems in Kenya. Int. J. Med Inform. 74:733–744, 2005. CrossRef
- Scott, J. T., Rundall, T. G., Vogt, T. M., and Hsu, J., Kaiser Permanente’s experience of implementing an electronic medical record: A qualitative study. BMJ. 331:1313–1316, 2005. CrossRef
- Aarts, J., and Berg, M., A tale of two hospitals: a sociotechnical appraisal of the introduction of computerized physician order entry in two Dutch hospitals. Medinfo. 11:999–1002, 2004.
- Koppel, R., Metlay, J. P., Cohen, A., Abaluck, B., Localio, A. R., Kimmel, S. E., and Strom, B. L., Role of computerized physician order entry systems in facilitating medication errors. JAMA. 293:1197–1203, 2005. CrossRef
- Vimarlund, V., and Olve, N. G., Economic analyses for ICT in elderly healthcare: Questions and challenges. Health Informatics J. 11:309–321, 2005. CrossRef
- Olve, N. G., Vimarlund, V., and Agerbo, M. Evaluation as multi-actor trade-off—A challenge in introducing ICT innovations in the health sector. Invited paper, 4th WSEAS International Conference on E-Activities. Miami, Florida, USA, November 17–19, 2005.
- Adams, W. G., Mann, A. M., and Bauchner, H., Use of an electronic medical record improves the quality of urban pediatric primary care. Pediatrics. 111:626–632, 2003. CrossRef
- Pizziferri, L., Kittler, A. F., Volk, L. A., Honour, M. M., Gupta, S., Wang, S., Wang, T., Lippincott, M., Li, Q., and Bates, D. W., Primary care physician time utilization before and after implementation of an electronic health record: A time-motion study. J. Biomed. Inform. 38:176–188, 2005. CrossRef
- Bryson, M., Tidy, N., Smith, M., and Levy, S., An online survey of nurses’ perceptions, knowledge and expectations of the National Health Service modernization programme. J. Telemed. Telecare. 11:S1:64–66, 2005. CrossRef
- Hebert, M. A., and Korabek, B., Stakeholder readiness for telehomecare: implications for implementation. Telemed J E Health. 10:85–92, 2004. CrossRef
- Kaufman, D. R., Starren, J., Patel, V. L., Morin, P. C., Hilliman, C., Pevzner, J., Weinstock, R. S., Goland, R., and Shea, S. A cognitive framework for understanding barriers to the productive use of a diabetes home telemedicine system. AMIA Annu. Symp. Proc. 356–360, 2003.
- Ash, J. S., Sittig, D. F., Seshadri, V., Dykstra, R. H., Carpenter, J. D., and Stavri, P. Z., Adding insight: a qualitative cross-site study of physician order entry. Medinfo. 11:1013–1017, 2004.
- Ash, J. S., Gorman, P. N., Seshadri, V., and Hersh, W. R., Computerized physician order entry in U.S. hospitals: results of a 2002 survey. J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 11:95–99, 2004. CrossRef
- Ammenwerth, E., and de Keizer, N., An inventory of evaluation studies of information technology in healthcare trends in evaluation research 1982–2002. Methods Inf. Med. 44:44–56, 2005.
- Kaplan, B., Evaluating informatics applications—Clinical decision support systems literature review. Int. J. Med. Inform. 64:39–56, 2001. CrossRef
About this Article
- Methods to Evaluate Health information Systems in Healthcare Settings: A Literature Review
Journal of Medical Systems
Volume 31, Issue 5 , pp 397-432
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer US
- Additional Links
- Evaluation studies
- Medical informatics
- Literature review
- Industry Sectors