Journal for General Philosophy of Science

, Volume 42, Issue 1, pp 17-31

First online:

Semantic Challenges to Scientific Realism

  • Holger AndreasAffiliated withSeminar für Philosophie, Logik und Wissenschaftstheorie, LMU München Email author 

Rent the article at a discount

Rent now

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access


This paper is concerned with connections between scientific and metaphysical realism. It is not difficult to show that scientific realism, as expounded by Psillos (1999) clearly qualifies as a kind of metaphysical realism in the sense of Putnam (1980). The statement of scientific realism therefore must not only deal with underdetermination and the dynamics of scientific theories but also answer the semantic challenges to metaphysical realism. As will be argued, the common core of these challenges is the proposition that a (metaphysical) realist semantics leads to semantic agnosticism in the sense that we are unable to grasp the proper meanings and referents of our linguistic expressions. Having established this, I will focus more specifically on the question of whether scientific realism—in its state-of-the-art account—has the resources to make reference to scientific concepts intelligible such that the semantic challenges can be answered.


Causal-descriptive theory of reference Internal realism Metaphysical realism Scientific and structural realism Ramsey account of scientific theories Theoretical concepts