Environmental Harm: Political not Biological
- Mark Sagoff
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
In their fine paper, Evans et al. (2009) discuss the proposition that invasive non-native species (INS) are harmful. The question to ask is, “Harmful to whom?” Pathogens that make people sick and pests that damage their property—crops, for example—cause harms of kinds long understood in common law and recognized by public agencies. The concept of “harm to the environment,” in contrast, has no standing in common law or legislation, no meaning for any empirical science, and no basis in a political consensus other than might be drawn from the Endangered Species Act. As a generalization, the proposition that INS cause “environmental harm”—since this concept is empty of legal, scientific, and political meaning—must rest on definition, diktat, or diatribe. As Evans et al. suggest, however, the idea of “harm to the environment” is not always and certainly need not be arbitrary; it might gather significance in the context of a particular place through a political process that weighs economic concerns with cultural, religious, aesthetic, and other relevant beliefs, practices, and commitments that people who care about that place present. It is not clear, however, that adaptive management, which Evens et al. propose, will provide that democratic political process.
- Allendorf, F, Lunquist, L (2003) Introduction: Population biology, evolution, and control of invasive species. Conservation Biology 17: pp. 24-30 CrossRef
- Carlton, JT (2001) Introduced species in U.S. coastal waters: Environmental impacts and management priorities. Pew Oceans Commission, Arlington, Virginia
- Clavero, M, García-Berthou, E (2005) Invasive species are a leading cause of animal extinctions. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 20: pp. 110 CrossRef
- Clinton, WJ (1999) Executive order 13112 of February 3, 1999. Federal Register 64: pp. 6183-6186
- Evans, J. M., Wilkie, A. C., & Burkhardt, J. (2009). Adaptive management of nonnative species: moving beyond the “either-or” through experimental pluralism. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 22(1).
- Glassner-Shwayder, K. (2000). Briefing paper: Great Lakes nonindigenous invasive species. A product of the Great Lakes nonindigenous invasive species workshop, October 20–21, 1999.
- Isom, BG (1986) ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) special technical publication, 894. Rationale for sampling and interpretation of ecological data in the assessment of freshwater ecosystems. American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, PA CrossRef
- Kraft, C. (1996). Zebra mussel update #28, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Wisconsin Sea Grant Institute. http://www.sgnis.org/publicat/newsltr/zmupd28.htm.
- Lau, JA (2006) Evolutionary responses of native plants to novel community members. Evolution 60: pp. 56-63
- Lodge, DM, Shrader-Frechette, K (2003) Nonindigenous species: Ecological explanation, environmental ethics, and public policy. Conservation Biology 17: pp. 1-8 CrossRef
- National Invasive Species Council (NISC). (2006). Invasive species definition clarification and guidance white paper submitted by the definitions subcommittee of the Invasive Species Advisory Committee (ISAC). Approved by ISAC. Available at: http://www.invasivespeciesinfo.gov/docs/council/isacdef.pdf. Accessed 27 April 2006.
- Neumann, TW (1985) Human-wildlife competition and the passenger pigeon: Population growth from system destabilization. Human Ecology 13: pp. 389-410 CrossRef
- New York Sea Grant. (1997). Press release, January 15. U. S. newswire. Available at: http://www.seagrant.sunysb.edu/MediaArticles/USN-ZMs011597_files/application_files/CAK9MKK2_files/CAYXC9WB.htm.
- Harmful non-indigenous species in the United States. US Government Printing Office, OTA-F-656, Washington, DC
- Parker, IM, Simberloff, D, Lonsdale, WM, Goodell, K, Wonham, M, Kareiva, PM, Williamson, MH, Holle, B, Moyle, PB, Byers, JE, Goldwasser, L (1999) Impact: Toward a framework for understanding the ecological effects of invaders. Biological Invasions 1: pp. 3-19 CrossRef
- Pimentel, D, Lach, L, Zuniga, R, Morrison, D (2000) Environmental and economic costs of nonindigenous species in the United States. BioScience 50: pp. 53-65 CrossRef
- Pimentel, D, Zuniga, R, Morrison, D (2005) Update on the environmental and economic costs associated with alien-invasive species in the United States. Ecological Economics 52: pp. 273-288
- Reeve, S (2001) Going down in history. Geographical 73: pp. 60-66
- Reutter, J. M., Hushak L. J., Brainard Hilgendorf, M., Taylor, R. M., & Hayter, C. (1996). Sea grant zebra mussel update: A 1995 report of research, Part 1 of 2, Ohio Sea Grant College Program.
- Rosenzweig, ML (2001) The four questions: What does the introduction of exotic species do to biodiversity?. Evolutionary Ecology Research 3: pp. 361-367
- Sax, DF, Gaines, SD (2008) Species invasions and extinction: The future of native biodiversity on islands. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105: pp. 11490-11497 CrossRef
- Sax, DF, Gaines, SD, Brown, JH (2002) Species invasions exceed extinctions on islands worldwide: A comparative study of plants and birds. American Naturalist 160: pp. 766-783 CrossRef
- Sax, DF, Stachowicz, JJ, Brown, JH, Bruno, JF, Dawson, MN, Gaines, SD, Grosberg, RK, Hastings, A, Holt, RD, Mayfield, MM, O’Connor, MI, Rice, WR (2007) Ecological and evolutionary insights from species invasions. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 22: pp. 465-471 CrossRef
- Simberloff, D (2005) Non-native species do threaten the natural environment!. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 18: pp. 595-607 CrossRef
- Simberloff, D, Strong, DR (2000) Exotic species seriously threaten our environment. Chronicle of Higher Education 47: pp. B20
- Vellend, M, Harmon, LJ, Lockwood, JL, Mayfield, MM, Randall Hughes, A, Wares, JP, Sax, DF (2007) Effects of exotic species on evolutionary diversification. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 22: pp. 481-488 CrossRef
- Zimmer, Carl (2008). Friendly invaders. New York Times, Science Section. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/09/science/09inva.html?_r=1&8dpc&oref=slogin. Accessed 8 Sept 2008.
- Environmental Harm: Political not Biological
Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
Volume 22, Issue 1 , pp 81-88
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Invasive species
- Adaptive management
- Environmental harm
- Mark Sagoff (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Institute for Philosophy and Public Policy, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA