Reproductive and Life History Parameters of Wild Female Macaca assamensis
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Fürtbauer, I., Schülke, O., Heistermann, M. et al. Int J Primatol (2010) 31: 501. doi:10.1007/s10764-010-9409-3
- 826 Views
Information on basic reproductive parameters and life-history traits is crucial for the understanding of primate evolution, ecology, social behavior, and reproductive strategies. Here, we report 4 yr of data on reproductive and life-history traits for wild female Assamese macaques (Macaca assamensis) at Phu Khieo Wildlife Sanctuary, northeastern Thailand. During 2 consecutive reproductive seasons, we investigated reproductive behavior and sexual swelling size in 16 females and collected 1832 fecal samples. Using enzyme immunoassays, we measured fecal estrogen and progesterone metabolites to assess ovarian activity and timing of ovulation and to ascertain conceptions and pregnancies. Timing of reproduction was strictly seasonal (births: April–July, 86% in April–June, 4 yr, n = 29; conceptions: October–February, 65% in December–January, 2 yr, n = 17). Females showed no cyclic ovarian activity outside the mating season and conceived in their first or second cycle (mean: 1.2 cycles to conception, n = 13). Gestation length was on average 164.2 d (range: 158–170, n = 10), and females had their first infant at an age of 5 yr (n = 4). Interbirth intervals were bimodally distributed, with females giving birth on average every 13.9 or 23.2 mo. Shorter interbirth intervals were linked to early parturition within the birth season. Most females displayed subcaudal sexual swellings which, however, did not reliably indicate female reproductive status or fertility. Overall, our results fall within the range of findings reported for other macaque species. These results thus add to the growing body of information available for wild macaques, facilitating comparative studies for a better understanding of interspecific differences in social and reproductive patterns.
KeywordsAssamese macaquesfecal hormone analysisgestation lengthinterbirth intervalseasonalitysexual swellings
The diversity and plasticity of primate life-history traits, e.g., age at first birth, gestation length, weaning age, interbirth interval, and underlying reproductive parameters, e.g., number of ovarian cycles to conception, timing of cyclic ovarian activity and reproduction, ovarian cycle characteristics, allow researchers to address questions relating to evolution, ecology, and social behavior (Dixon 1983; Hrdy and Whitten 1987; Kappeler and Pereira 2003; Lee and Kappeler 2003). In particular, sexual strategies are assumed to be moulded by life-history (Kappeler et al. 2003). Thus, investigation of female basic reproductive parameters and life-history traits is a crucial first step when studying reproductive strategies used by males and females, and when exploring how they are associated with each other.
Macaques provide ideal conditions for comparative studies concerning the linkage between life histories and reproductive strategies. All macaque species share basic patterns of social organization: They all live in multimale, multifemale groups and they mate promiscuously, males disperse, whereas females are philopatric (Thierry 2007). On the other hand, they vary in social and reproductive traits, e.g., the degree of seasonality, with births occurring year-round or being restricted to a few months; social structure, dominance relationships; mating patterns; and the development of sexual signals, e.g., sexual swellings, sex skin coloration, copulation calls, all of which may influence the reproductive strategies of both sexes (Dixon 1998; van Noordwijk and van Schaik 2004).
Although the number of studies on macaques steadily increases, some species remain virtually unexplored. Moreover, owing to the difficulties of collecting data from naturally reproducing wild populations, some species are exclusively investigated under captive or free-ranging conditions. However, studies on reproductive and life-history parameters of wild individuals are crucial because it is well known that provisioning can influence reproductive physiology leading, for instance, to an acceleration of puberty and thus earlier age at first reproduction, e.g., Macaca fuscata: Takahata et al. (1998); Papio hamadryas: Zinner et al. (1994) or to a shortening of interbirth intervals (Takahata et al. 1998) compared to the situation found in naturally reproducing populations in the wild. Further, non-natural conditions may blur the degree of reproductive seasonality, e.g., females may cycle and breed throughout the year in captivity, whereas in the wild reproduction of the same species may be restricted to a defined period (Brockman and van Schaik 2005).
We investigated female reproductive parameters and life-history traits in a little known species, the Assamese macaque (Macaca assamensis) applying noninvasive hormone analyses. Assamese macaques are sexually dimorphic, breed seasonally (Bernstein and Cooper 1999; Ostner et al. 2008) and, like other macaques, live in multimale-multifemale groups with female philopatry and male dispersal. They are most closely related genetically to Tibetan macaques (Hoelzer and Melnick 1996) and have been classified as a species with a rather relaxed dominance style (Bernstein and Cooper 1999; Cooper and Bernstein 2002; Thierry et al. 2000). However, to our knowledge, apart from 1 study on female menstrual cycle patterns in captive Assamese macaques (Wehrenberg et al. 1980), no data are currently available on female reproductive parameters and life-history traits in this species. Here, we report for the first time data on breeding seasonality, i.e., timing of conceptions and distribution of births, female age at first birth, number of cycles to conception, gestation length, interbirth interval, and sexual swelling patterns obtained from a naturally reproducing wild Assamese macaque population living in northeastern Thailand.
Study Site and Subjects
We conducted the study between 2006 and 2009, including collection of detailed behavioral data and fecal samples during 2 complete mating seasons (MS, October to early February) and one nonmating season (NMS, mid-February to September), at the Phu Khieo Wildlife Sanctuary (PKWS, 157,300 ha, 16°5′–35′N, 101°20′–55–E, 300–1300 masl), northeastern Thailand, which consists of dry evergreen forest with patches of dry dipterocarp forest and bamboo stands (Borries et al. 2002). We collected data from a fully habituated group of Assamese macaques consisting of 53 individuals (12 adult females) during the MS 2007/2008 and 55 individuals (14 adult females) during the MS 2008/2009. In total, we collected fecal samples and data on sexual swellings from 16 females (11 multiparous, 4 primiparous, and 1 nulliparous females), 8 individuals being followed in each season. We selected females which, based on their reproductive history, were considered most likely to conceive in the respective MS. One female disappeared around the estimated date of parturition in June 2008, and 1 pregnant female died in March 2009. Demographic data, i.e., births and deaths for all individuals, were available from May 2006 through August 2009.
Fecal Sample Collection and Hormone Analyses
We collected and analyzed a total of 1832 fecal samples from 16 focal females. To characterize ovarian cycle patterns and assess timing of conception, we collected on average 4.6 ± 0.5 samples/wk from each focal individual during the 2 MSs. During the NMS we collected 4·7 samples/mo from all focal females, and, after females gave birth in 2008, we continued collection of feces from lactating females (n = 6; 1 sample/wk) until the end of the MS 2008/2009. We collected samples directly after defecation, and placed a 5–15 g well homogenized portion in a tube labeled with subject ID and date, kept them cold using ice packs during the day, and froze them immediately at −20°C after return to the field station. Samples were stored frozen until being shipped to the endocrine laboratory. We collected samples opportunistically throughout the day; however, we collected the majority of samples (83%) between 08:00 and 13:00 h.
For hormone analysis, we lyophilized and pulverized fecal samples and extracted an aliquot of 0.05–0.08 g with 3 ml of 80% methanol in water by vortex-mixing for 10 min (Heistermann et al. 1995). After centrifugation (3000 rpm, 10 min) of the fecal suspension, we decanted the supernatant into a glass tube and stored it at −20°C until assay. We analyzed fecal extracts for concentrations of immunoreactive estrone conjugates (E1C) and 20α-dihydroprogesterone (20α-OHP) using microtiter plate enzyme immunoassays (EIA), previously shown to reflect accurately female ovarian function in macaques and other primate species (Dubuc et al. 2009; Heistermann et al. 1995, 2001; Shideler et al. 1993). Details of the EIA procedures have been described previously by Heistermann and Hodges (1995, E1C) and Heistermann et al. (1995, 20α-OHP). Sensitivities of the assays at 90% binding were 1.0 pg for E1C and 1.5 pg for 20α-OHP. Intra- and interassay coefficients of variation, calculated from replicate determinations of high- and low-value quality controls, were 5.7% and 6.5% (high) and 8.8% and 14.5% (low) for E1C measurements and 7.5% and 13.1% (high) and 9.2% and 16.7% (low) for 20α-OHP determinations. All fecal hormone data are expressed as mass per gram of dry feces.
Timing of Ovulation and Conception and Number of Cycles to Conception
Because fecal estrogen profiles did generally not show a consistent preovulatory peak (see Results) for unknown reasons, we solely used the fecal progestogen profiles to determine the number of cycles to conception and the presumed day of ovulation and conception. The postovulatory progestogen rise is a reliable indicator that ovulation has indeed occurred, and this is the most widely used approach for determining timing of ovulation in primates (Barelli et al. 2007; Engelhardt et al. 2004; O’Neill et al. 2004; Strier and Ziegler 1997). As described in many other studies (Carosi et al. 1999; Engelhardt et al. 2004; Heistermann et al. 2008), we used the defined rise in fecal progestogen levels above a threshold of the mean ± 2 SD of 5 preceding baseline values to indicate the onset of the postovulatory (luteal) phase of an ovarian cycle or the onset of gestation (indicated by maintenance of elevated luteal phase progestogen levels for >4 wk). Levels below this threshold indicated the follicular phase of the cycle. On the basis of a time lag of about 2 d in the excretion of progesterone metabolites in the feces of macaques (Shideler et al. 1993), we considered d –3 relative to the day of the defined progestogen increase (d 0) as the most likely day of ovulation. Because of the possible variability in the temporal relationship between ovulation and the postovulatory fecal progestogen increase (Shideler et al. 1993), and because daily samples during the periovulatory period were not always available, data on the timing of ovulation/conception can be expected to include an error of 1–2 d.
Age at First Birth
We estimated age at first birth for primiparous females retrospectively based on body size comparisons with different age cohorts, which can be clearly distinguished owing to the strong reproductive seasonality.
We calculated gestation length in individual females as the interval between the hormonally determined day of conception and the observed day of parturition.
Interbirth Interval (IBI) and Postpartum Amenorrhea (PPA)
We calculated interbirth intervals in days and then converted them to months (1 mo = 30.4 d) on the basis of observed parturitions. In cases where the exact day of parturition was unknown (9 of 24 births), we used the midpoint of the first and the last possible day of parturition (unknown period of max. 12 d). We included only IBIs following a surviving offspring (>12 mo). We calculated the duration of PPA for females with 1-yr IBIs by counting the days between parturition and next conception. We applied binary logistic regression with SPSS 17.0 to analyze the relationship between the occurrences of 1-yr IBIs and the timing of parturitions within the birth seasons. We used the occurrence of 1-yr IBIs as the dependent, and the number of days between the first day of the first month in which births occur (April 1) and the date of parturition as the independent variable. The 1-sided significance level was set at p < 0.05.
Reproductive and life history parameters of wild female Assamese macaques
∼ 1 yr
∼ 2 yr
Cycles to conception
Timing of conceptions
67% in December/January
Age at first birth
Timing of births
69% in May/June
Female Reproductive Physiology
Seven of 8 focal females conceived in the MS 2007/2008, whereas in the MS 2008/2009 all 8 focal females became pregnant. In addition, in 2009 2 nonfocal females that had also conceived an infant in 2007/2008 gave birth.
Gestation Length and Age at First Birth
For ten females for which the day of conception and the day of parturition were known, length of gestation averaged 164.2 ± 4.0 d (median = 164.5, n = 10, range: 158–170).
Age at first birth was 5 yr for all 4 primiparous females.
Interbirth Interval (IBI) and Infant Mortality
We here describe for the first time female reproductive parameters and life-history traits in wild female Assamese macaques. We present data on reproductive seasonality, basic female reproductive physiology, gestation length, age at first birth, interbirth interval, and sexual swellings, derived from a naturally reproducing wild population. For most parameters, the values found for Assamese macaques fall into the range reported for other macaque species. The distribution of interbirth intervals and the large interindividual variability in swelling patterns, however, appear to deserve further attention.
Seasonal timing of reproduction among macaques covers the entire range from year-round breeding, e.g., in pigtail macaques (Macaca nemestrina), to extreme seasonal reproduction in the Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata; range across macaques: 46–365 d; Nunn 1999a). Seasonal breeding implies physiological and behavioral transition from a nonreproductive to a reproductive state, i.e., females may show a change in reproductive cyclicity (Walker et al. 1983), likely caused by environmental factors (photoperiod, temperature, rainfall, food abundance; Brockman and van Schaik 2005).
In our study, 65% of conceptions were confined to December and January and 86% of births occurred within the 3-mo period of April–June, indicating a strict reproductive seasonality (sensu van Schaik et al. 1999) in Assamese macaques. Similar to Japanese (Hill 1997) and Barbary macaques (Ménard and Vallet 1996), Assamese macaques at Phu Khieo Wildlife Sanctuary live in a markedly seasonal habitat with seasonal changes in rainfall (Grassman et al. 2005) and food availability (Koenig et al. 2004, Schülke et al. unpublished). However, a fine-grained analysis of potential triggers for the timing of reproduction is pending.
Female Reproductive Physiology
As in previous studies on various primate taxa (Barelli et al. 2007; Carosi et al. 1999; Dubuc et al. 2009; Engelhardt et al. 2004; Heistermann et al. 2008; Higham et al. 2009 Ziegler et al. 2000), measurement of fecal progestogen excretion proved to be a reliable tool for the assessment of female reproductive status, including the timing of ovulation and conception in Assamese macaques. By contrast, the measurement of fecal estrogens in Assamese macaques appears to be less useful in assessing female ovarian function because estrogen profiles often lacked a clear preovulatory peak and showed no marked elevation in levels during gestation. The reason why our results for Assamese macaques differ in this respect from those reported for other macaque species (Brauch et al. 2007; Dubuc et al. 2009; Engelhardt et al. 2004; Fujita et al. 2001) is not clear. Given that it is unlikely that Assamese macaques differ in their mechanisms of hormonal regulation of the ovarian cycle and pregnancy from other macaques, our finding of less informative fecal estrogen profiles is likely related to species differences in estrogen metabolism and pattern of excretion or assay methodology. In this respect there are 4 nonmutually exclusive potential explanations. First, in Assamese macaques estrogens may be predominantly excreted into the urine rather than into the feces, rendering fecal measurements less informative. Second, measurement of other estrogen metabolites than the one measured here might be more adequate for monitoring estrogen excretion in this species. However, analysis of estradiol and total estrogens in a subset of cycles did not show better profiles (data not shown). Third, the E1C antibody used here might have potentially cross-reacted with fecal compounds unrelated to estrogen secretory dynamics, thereby confounding an existing pattern. Last but not least, given the short-term nature of the preovulatory estrogen peak, it cannot be excluded that in some females the estrogen peak was just missed because daily samples were often not available during the periovulatory period. A study on estrogen metabolism and excretion, including HPLC analysis to help clarify 1) the identity of the major fecal estrogen metabolites excreted in female Assamese macaques and 2) the potential for co-measurement of nonestrogenic compounds by any given estrogen assay used would be a useful step toward resolving this issue in the future.
Consistent with the strong reproductive seasonality, females showed a typical hormonal pattern, with absence of cyclic ovarian activity during the nonmating season (“flat liner”) and resumption of ovarian cycles during the mating season, a phenomenon also seen in other primate species with a highly seasonal reproduction, e.g., Macaca sylvanus: Moehle et al. (2005); Semnopithecus entellus: Ziegler et al. (2000). The lack of ovulatory cycles during the nonmating season was seen irrespective of whether or not females were nursing an infant. This further underscores the impact of the observed seasonality on female reproductive physiology in this species.
Like other seasonally breeding macaque species, e.g., Macaca sylvanus: Küster and Paul (1984); Moehle et al. (2005); Macaca mulatta: Lindburg (1971); Macaca fuscata: Takahata (1980), Assamese macaque females conceived mostly during the first cycle of the mating season. Hence, ovarian cycle characteristics, i.e., the length of the ovarian cycle, and its component phases, could be determined only for the few females that conceived in their second cycle, and was 24, 30, and 38 d (with 11-, 15-, and 13-d luteal phases). These data fall well into the range of observed cycle lengths in macaques (26.4–38.0 d; Thierry 2007) and compare well with cycle length data of 32 ± 2 d (divided into a 16 ± 1 d follicular phase and a 16 ± 1 d luteal phase) reported by Wehrenberg et al. (1980) for captive individuals based on blood hormone analysis.
Gestation among macaques is relatively constant and ranges from 160 to 182 d (Kappeler and Pereira 2003), and female age at first birth in macaques, based on captive and wild data, ranges from 3.5 to 6.5 yr (Melnick and Pearl 1987). An average gestation length of 164 d and an age of first reproduction of 5 yr, as found for Assamese macaques here, fits well into the reported ranges.
Interbirth Interval (IBI)
The IBIs in Assamese macaques are bimodally distributed, with females giving birth on average 14 mo or 23 mo after the previous birth, i.e., the next year or after 2 yr (range across macaques: 12–24 mo; Kappeler and Pereira 2003). The IBI is made up of 3 components: gestation length (GL), postpartum amenorrhea (PPA), and the duration of ovarian cycling to conception (DC). Because GL in any primate species is relatively invariable (Dixon 1998), differences in IBI within a species as reported here for Assamese macaques can be caused only by differences in the duration of PPA and/or DC (provided that under natural conditions a female would inevitably conceive). Most Assamese macaque females conceived in their first cycle, i.e., DC is minimized. PPA for 4 females with a 1-yr IBI ranged from 265 to 290 d (birth until next conception), and thus was relatively constant. This indicates that the time that a female needs to resume cycling after giving birth is restricted owing to inhibitory effects of lactation (McNeilly 2001) and maternal body condition. Concerning the latter, studies on several primate taxa have shown that females need to attain a critical body weight before they can resume ovarian cycling, e.g., Papio anubis: Bercovitch (1987); Propithecus verrauxi verrauxi: Lewis and Kappeler (2005); Macaca nemestrina: Maninger et al. (2000); Semnopithecus entellus: Ziegler et al. (2000); Homo sapiens: Frisch and McArthur (1974). In line with this, nutritional conditions appear to affect the length of the IBI (Borries et al. 2001; Takahata et al. 1998). Similarly, it has been shown that infants need to reach a minimum body mass threshold for weaning (Lee 1996, 1999; Lee et al. 1991). Accordingly, the timing of parturition within the birth season may play an important role, simply because females that give birth early in the birth season have more time to reach the conditions required to resume cyclic ovarian activity in the following mating season. Females should therefore be more likely to have an infant in the consecutive year, and thus a short IBI, when they give birth early in the birth season. Our results support this hypothesis because the occurrence of 1-yr IBIs was significantly linked to early parturition within the birth season.
In addition, owing to lactational constraints on ovarian activity, the loss of an infant may shorten the length of the IBI, e.g., Papio cynocephalus: Altmann et al. (1977); Trachypithecus leucocephalus: Jin et al. (2009); Macaca maurus: Okamoto (2000); Mandrillus sphinx: Setchell et al. (2002); Macaca fuscata: Tanaka et al. (1970); Macaca thibetana: Zhao and Deng (1988); Papio hamadryas: Zinner et al. (1994). This effect may be stronger in nonseasonal species than in strictly seasonal species, in which the timing of infant loss may be crucial: if the infant dies late in the mating season or even after the end of the mating season, a female may not be able to resume cycling. This may lead to infanticide being a favorable strategy for males only during a specific time window. In this study, infant mortality was low (6.9%), and only 1 of 6 1-yr IBIs was preceded by the loss of a 4-mo-old infant at the beginning of the mating season for an unknown reason. Another infant died at an age of 10 mo during the nonmating season, and this did not result in a shorter IBI.
Although the loss of an infant may shorten the length of the IBI, depending on the timing of the loss, it does not appear to be the ultimate cause for the occurrence of 1-yr IBIs in female Assamese macaques. This and the linkage between 1-yr IBIs and the timing of parturition within the birth season, in turn, suggest that the IBIs are, to some extent, influenced by physiological constraints that may be partly linked to the strong reproductive seasonality. However, long-term data are needed to investigate the potential impact of age, rank, and ecological factors on the distribution of 1- and 2-yr IBIs in this species (Borries et al. 2001; Robbins et al. 2007; Setchell et al. 2002).
Coloration and swelling of sex skin during the menstrual cycle are found in many Old World primate species, most of them living in multimale–multifemale groups (Clutton-Brock and Harvey 1976; Nunn et al. 2001). Changes in size and coloration of female sex skin swellings may reflect changes in estrogen and progesterone secretion, i.e., the E/P ratio, with ovulation usually occurring during the period of maximum swelling size (Brauch et al. 2007; Deschner et al. 2003; Higham et al. 2008). Sex skin swellings have evolved at least 3 times independently in Old World primates (Dixon 1983; Hrdy and Whitten 1987), and several species display an exaggeration of this trait (Nunn 1999b). Macaque species exhibit pronounced variation in size and coloration of sex skin swellings. Large and pinkish swellings involving skin in the subcaudal, circumanal, paracallosal, vulval, and clitoral areas occur in species of the silenus-sylvanus group, whereas members of the fascicularis, and the sinica-arctoides groups show reduced swellings (Dixon 1983, 1998). Interestingly, in some macaque species adolescent females exhibit larger swellings than do adult females (Anderson and Bielert 1994; Dixon 1983), and swellings or sex skin color changes during early pregnancy (post-conception swellings) are common, e.g., Macaca fascicularis: Engelhardt et al. (2007); Macaca sylvanus: Moehle et al. (2005); reviewed in Hrdy and Whitten (1987). Not only the appearance of sexual swellings but also their functional significance varies among macaque species, i.e., swellings may convey reliable information on female reproductive state, e.g., Macaca sylvanus: Brauch et al. (2007), or, in contrast, may have limited, e.g., Macaca fascicularis: Engelhardt et al. (2005) or no apparent signaling content, e.g., Macaca thibetana: Li et al. (2005).
As predicted for a seasonal species (Dixon 1998; cf. van Schaik et al. 1999), Assamese macaque females did not exhibit prominent sexual swellings. We found remarkable interindividual differences in swelling patterns that mostly concur with van Noordwijk’s (1985) findings in female long-tail macaques. The maximum swelling size attained varied among females, and some females did not show swellings at all, despite the fact that they were conceiving and thus reproductively normal. Young females showed swellings of larger maximum size, and may have a swelling a year before their first conception (Fürtbauer, pers. obs.). As we found neither apparent cyclic size changes nor a link between swelling patterns and hormonal profiles/timing of conceptions, the observed swelling characteristics suggest that, in contrast to macaque species with a pronounced swelling, the subcaudal swellings in female Assamese macaques do not reliably indicate female reproductive status and fertility, and may simply be a relic of an ancestral trait. It may be possible, however, that the method used in this study—visual judgment instead of video imaging—did not pick up on very subtle changes in sexual swelling patterns.
Conclusions and Implications for Female Reproductive Strategies
In summary, the reproductive parameters and life-history traits reported in the present study for female Assamese macaques mostly resemble findings for other macaque species. Although this is not surprising, the information generated here is useful in helping to complete the data base on reproductive and life-history traits in wild macaques and thus facilitating species comparisons. More importantly, however, knowledge in this area will also be crucial for future studies investigating the reproductive biology of Assamese macaques. In this respect, the finding of a strong reproductive seasonality with a high degree of clustering in timing of conceptions, and thus suggesting female reproductive synchrony, is likely to influence strongly male and female reproductive strategies and their significance on reproductive success. Because asynchrony within estrus synchrony may occur (Pereira 1991), however, a thorough analysis of the temporal distribution of fertile phases together with male and female sexual activity is needed to investigate female reproductive strategies.
We thank the National Research Council of Thailand (NRCT) and the Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation (DNP) for permission (no. 0004.3/3618) to conduct this study. We thank J. Prabnasuk, K. Nitaya, and K. Kreetiyutanont (Phu Khieo Wildlife Sanctuary) for their cooperation and permission to conduct this study. We thank A. Koenig and C. Borries (Stony Brook University), who developed the field site at Huai Mai Sot Yai, for their support. We thank Andrea Heistermann and Jutta Hagedorn for technical assistance in hormone analysis, and M. Swagemakers, D. Bootros, T. Kilawit, A. Chunchaen, P. Saisawatdikul, S. Jomhlotwong, S. Rogahn, and W. Nuagchiyos for their help in the field. We thank J. Setchell and 2 anonymous referees for their valuable comments on the manuscript. We also thank N. Bhumpakphan, W. Eiadthong (Kasetsart University), and W. Brockelman (Mahidol University) for their support and cooperation. The project was supported with funds from the National Geographic Society, Max-Planck Society and the German Initiative of Excellence.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.