Transfer of 137Cs from water to fish is not linear in two northern lakes
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Tuovinen, T.S., Saengkul, C., Ylipieti, J. et al. Hydrobiologia (2013) 700: 131. doi:10.1007/s10750-012-1224-8
- 739 Views
Empirical data on the behavior of radionuclides in the biosphere are needed for validating radioecological models. In this study, data collected from two lakes in Northern Finland were used to investigate the transfer of 137Cs from lake water into fish during a 20-year period after the Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident. The results indicated that transfer of 137Cs in the food chains investigated is nonlinear: the water-to-fish concentration ratios (CRs) decreased with increasing 137Cs concentration in water. Major deviation from linearity (constant CR) commonly assumed in radioecological modeling was observed only at low 137Cs concentrations in water. Other findings of potential importance for radioecological models were that 137Cs concentrations were threefold higher in piscivores than in non-piscivores and that no differences in 137Cs uptake were found between the two piscivorous species (pike and perch) studied or between three non-piscivorous species (vendace, white fish, and roach) representing different feeding habits (planktivore, benthivore, and mixed diet).
KeywordsRadioecologyTransfer factorLinearity assumptionTrophic transfer137CsAquatic
Radioecological modeling is commonly used for predicting transfer of radionuclides in ecosystems, estimating doses, and assessing possible adverse effects on human health and wildlife. The ability of radioecological models to accurately predict concentrations and doses depends critically on empirical data on the behavior of specific radionuclides in the biosphere and on the correctness of basic assumptions used in the models.
Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident in 1986 is a major source of empirical data associated with radioecological modeling. The long-term fall-out from the Chernobyl accident consisted largely of the radionuclides of Cs, notably 137Cs, which was discharged into terrestrial, freshwater, and marine environments and is taken up by organisms into the food chain. In Finland, the most contaminated sites were in the middle of Southern Finland, whereas Northern Finland was the least contaminated because of distance from Chernobyl, speed and direction of wind, and intermittent rain (Arvela et al., 1990).
In radioecological modeling, transfer of radionuclides is commonly described by concentration ratios (CRs). For example, the CR for the relationship between fish and water radionuclide levels is defined as the activity concentration in fish (Bq kg−1 wet wt) divided by the activity concentration in water (Bq l−1) (IAEA, 2010). The use of CRs is based on the assumption that the transfer of elements is linear, i.e., that the CR for an element is, under comparable condition, constant regardless of the element concentration in the substrate such as soil or water. However, data on uptake from soil to plants are not consistent with the linearity assumption, indicating more effective uptake at low than high concentrations (Timperley et al., 1970; Sheppard & Sheppard, 1985; Simon & Ibrahim, 1987; Palm, 1994; Marschner, 1995; Krauss et al., 2002; Han et al., 2006; Tuovinen et al., 2011), and there is also some evidence indicating that transfer from water to fish may not be linear (Pyle & Clulow, 1997).
Although the size of fish and trophic level can be expected to influence the level of 137Cs in different species of fish (Sundbom et al., 2003), empirical data are scarce, and radioecological models typically assume that the CR values for different fish species are the same. For example, the ERICA Tool, which is a software program developed within the EC EURATOM-funded ERICA project to assess radiological risks to biota, assumes that CR values of fresh water fish depend only on habitat, with higher CR value for benthic fish than pelagic fish (Brown et al., 2008; Hosseini et al., 2008).
In the present study, data from two lakes in Finnish Lapland were used to investigate the relationship between 137Cs concentrations in water and fish. The data were available, because the Finnish Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority had carried out long-term monitoring after the Chernobyl accident in these lakes. The two lakes differ by size and level of nutrients, which offered a possibility to address possible lake-specific differences in the transfer of 137Cs. The dataset included activity concentrations for several fish species with different niches and trophic levels (planktivores, benthivores, and piscivores) in the lake ecosystem, which allowed us to investigate interspecies differences in transfer of 137Cs. As the data were collected from an area in Northern Finland where the 137Cs fallout level was low, they are suitable for investigating the possible nonlinearity, which most likely affects uptake into the food chain at low substrate concentrations.
Materials and methods
The activity concentrations of 137Cs in water and fish samples were measured by gamma spectrometry in the laboratory of the Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority (STUK). The activity concentration was determined using the Gamma-99 software developed at STUK.
Yearly geometric means were calculated for the water samples. Activity concentrations of 137Cs in fish were expressed per fresh weight (fw). The relationship between CRs and concentrations in lake water was studied by nonlinear regression analysis using GraphPad Prism version 4.03 for Windows (GraphPad Software Inc.).
137Cs concentration in lake water
137Cs concentration in fish during 1982–2006
In Lake Inari, the highest 137Cs concentration in perch was observed in 1986, but no data on 1986 concentrations are available for the other species (Fig. 3). In 1987, the concentration in pike, perch, vendace, and whitefish were 210, 237, 62, and 62 Bq kg−1 fw, respectively, with decreasing trends until about 2000. Consistent with the findings in Lake Apukka, the 137Cs concentrations of pike and perch were higher compared with other fish species.
Transfer from water to fish: concentration ratio
Transfer of 137Cs from fish to fish
This study produced three findings that may be important for radioecology in freshwater ecosystem. Transfer of 137Cs from lake water to fish was nonlinear. Transfer of 137Cs from water to piscivores was approximately three times higher than from water to non-piscivores. There was no difference between transfers of 137Cs from water to planktivores and benthivores.
Nonlinearity of transfer
In this study, the effect of water concentration on CR was studied only by comparing CRs measured at different times in the same lake. This approach could produce misleading results, if Cs persisted in fish tissues for years, as the concentrations in fish observed during the later years would reflect Cs accumulation from the peak exposure at the time of the Chernobyl accident. However, a significant effect of this type is not plausible for several reasons. The transfer pathway of Cs into fish can be described by an uptake–loss model consisting of uptake from water by producers and further transfer by consumption to first-order and second-order consumers (Pinder et al., 2009, 2011). At all trophic levels, loss of Cs from biota occurs because of excretion, mortality, migration, and other causes. The biological half-life for loss due to excretion, determined in fish contaminated by 137Cs and then kept in uncontaminated water, is of the order of tens to hundreds of days (Ugedal et al., 1992; Peters & Newman, 1999; Malek et al., 2004). This implies that the long ecological half-lives (up to tens of years) observed in fish growing in natural conditions (Sundbom et al., 2003) result from continuous uptake of 137Cs from the food chain, and that the Cs taken up at the time of peak concentrations did not persist in fish tissues during the 20-year follow-up of the present study. This conclusion is supported by the fast decrease of concentration in fish during the first years after the Chernobyl accident (Fig. 3). Moreover, vendace is a short-lived species, and the individuals of the other species were typically relatively young (judged by size), so all fish samples represent recent transfer of Cs from the food chain.
Measurements performed simultaneously in other lakes with different 137Cs concentrations would comprise an independent check for the nonlinear model used in the present study. Such data are available in the study by Saxen et al. (2010) who reported CRs for pike and perch from 1987 to 2006 in four southern Finland lakes, in which the 137Cs activity concentrations were much higher than in the present study (1.4–4.1 Bq l−1 in 1987; 0.21–0.44 Bq l−1 in 2006). They reported CR values from 1,700 to 21,000 (slightly higher values for pike than perch) with an overall mean of 6,000. These values are consistent with the observations of the present study: the curves for pike and perch shown in Fig. 4 suggested an asymptotic CR value around 10,000 or below at high 137Cs concentrations in water. There was some evidence that CR changes with time (with decreasing concentration in water) also in Saxen et al.’s data, but the changes were small compared to those observed in the present study and possibly influenced by low number of measurements at late points in time. Also, the direction of change was not consistent between two types of lakes, with decreasing CR in drainage lakes and increasing CR in seepage lakes. As both Lake Apukka and Lake Inari are drainage lakes, our data showing marked increase of CR values with time was not consistent with the decrease suggested by Saxen et al. (2010). Together, ours and Saxen et al.’s data suggested a relatively constant CR at high water concentrations and enhanced transfer into fish at low concentrations in water.
The present findings confirm previous observations (Pyle & Clulow, 1997) suggesting that transfer of 137Cs from water to fish is not linear: the CRs (which should be constant under the linearity assumption) were found to increase with decreasing 137Cs concentration in water. These findings (including the shape of the CR curves shown in Fig. 4) are similar to our findings in terrestrial ecosystem, where soil-to-plant CRs for several elements showed a similar dependency on soil concentration. (Tuovinen et al., 2011). It is tempting to assume that uptake by phytoplankton or aquatic plants of elements dissolved in water would be similar to uptake by terrestrial plants of elements dissolved in soil water. This first step in radionuclide uptake might be the only nonlinear step in the food chain. Our data on the transfer from fish to fish support this hypothesis: the CR for transfer from non-piscivorous to piscivorous fish was found to be constant, indicating linear transfer. Data on 137Cs concentrations at the first trophic levels of the aquatic ecosystem were not available in this study, but the nonlinear nature of uptake from water to algae has been well characterized in studies on biosorption, removal of metals or radionuclides from aqueous solution by biological materials (biosorbents). Several studies have shown that the biosorption of metals into live or dead algae is nonlinear and approximately follows Langmuir- or Freundlich-type equations (Volesky & Schiever, 1999; Klimmek et al., 2001; Davis et al., 2000; Havari and Mulligan, 2006; Doshi et al., 2007; Katircioglu et al., 2008; Shashirekha et al., 2008; Doshi et al., 2009).
Differences between species
The fish species studied included both piscivorous and three different non-piscivorous species. Pike is a typical piscivorous fish feeding on other fish species such as vendace and roach. As a fast growing species, it feeds on zooplankton and larvae for only a short period during its early life. Perch is a smaller species that feeds on fish, zooplankton, and benthic animals. Roach is one of the most common fish species in Finnish lakes, mostly because of diversity of its diet, including zooplankton, all kinds of benthos, and even aquatic plants, i.e., almost anything suitable for non-piscivorous fish. Vendace is a small fish species feeding on zooplankton. There are different forms of whitefish, including both planktivores and benthivores. Because the benthivorous form of whitefish has been restocked into Lake Inari since 1975, the whitefish investigated in the present study can be considered a benthivore. The fish species studied have lifetimes of more than 20 years in favorable conditions, excluding vendace, which has a life span of 4–6 years. Of the fish species studied, pike is the largest (up to 20–30 kg at the age of 20 years), followed by whitefish, perch, roach, and vendace.
Although radioecological models do not necessarily include different CR values for fish species representing different trophic levels, it is well known that accumulation of Cs is higher in organisms that are at higher levels in the food chain. Our finding of higher 137Cs levels and CR values in piscivorous species (pike and perch) than in the other species is consistent with numerous other studies showing that 137Cs activity concentrations increase with increasing trophic level in aquatic ecosystems (Rowan and Rasmussen, 1994; Rowan et al., 1998; Smith et al., 2000; Burger et al., 2001; Yoshutome et al., 2003; Brittain and Gjerseth, 2010; Fesenko et al., 2011) and strengthens the need to use different transfer functions for piscivores and non-piscivores. It is of interest that all three non-piscivorous species, in spite of their different feeding habits (a planktivore, a benthivore, and a species with mixed diet), showed very similar uptake of 137Cs. This result does not support using different transfer functions for pelagic and benthic fish species in radioecological models describing northern freshwater ecosystems, and suggests that 137Cs present in sediment does not essentially increase transfer of Cs into the benthivorous fish species studied. Only three non-piscivorous species were included, and so the results might not be valid for all such freshwater species. However, all these three species are common in northern lakes, important links in the food chain and relevant to human consumption of fish (of these species, roach is the only one that is not commonly used as human food, but it is an important feed to pike).
Comparison of the lakes
There are findings suggesting that uptake of 137Cs into fish might be higher in oligotrophic than in eutrophic lakes (Sarkka et al., 1996; Saxen & Koskelainen, 2005; Saxen & Ilus, 2008). The results of the present study did not provide evidence for such differences, as the CR curves were similar in a eutrophic (Lake Apukka) and an oligotrophic (Lake Inari) lake. Also, the transfer functions found in this study seem to be consistent with the data collected by Saxen et al. (2010) in four different lakes in southern Finland. However, the processes that determine the accumulation of 137Cs in fish are complex, and several environmental factors, such as water temperature, pH, water salinity, nutrients in water, organic matter content, potassium content, sedimentation rate, and type of sediment (Rowan & Rasmussen, 1994; Sarkka et al., 1996; Smith et al., 2000, 2002; Topcuoglu, 2001; Ilus & Saxen, 2005; Saxen & Koskelainen, 2005; Saxen & Ilus, 2008; Brittain & Gjerseth, 2010; Saxen et al., 2010; Strand & Dowdall, 2010; Fesenko et al., 2011), may affect Cs uptake. Data on such factors were not available in this study. Additional studies in different lakes would be useful to confirm whether the transfer functions determined is this study can be used to quantitatively estimate 137Cs uptake in different types of lakes.
Based on the results of this study, a nonlinear transfer function describes transfer of 137Cs into fish. The data were limited to five fish species in two different types of lakes, but they suggest that the level of transfer might differ only between piscivores and non-piscivores. The transfer function appeared to be similar in the three non-piscivorous species independent of feeding habits (planktivore, benthivore, or mixed diet). Also, no difference was observed between the two piscivorous species. The nonlinear transfer function resulted in major differences from linear models (constant CR) only at low water concentrations. For transfers between species at different trophic levels, the findings were consistent with linear transfer, and modeling could be based on a constant CR value of about 3 between piscivores and non-piscivores.
Tiina S. Tuovinen was supported by a grant from the State Nuclear Waste Management fund. Chutarat Saengul and her visit to the University of Eastern Finland was supported by the Bridging the Gap EMECW L 12 Project.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.