Teaching for transfer of core/key skills in higher education: Cognitive skills
Cite this article as: Billing, D. High Educ (2007) 53: 483. doi:10.1007/s10734-005-5628-5 Abstract
This article is a result of a completed survey of the mainly cognitive science literature on the transferability of those skills which have been described variously as ‘core’, ‘key’, and ‘generic’. The literature reveals that those predominantly cognitive skills which have been studied thoroughly (mainly problem solving) are transferable under certain conditions. These conditions relate particularly to the methods and environment of the learning of these skills. Therefore, there are many implications for the teaching of key skills in higher education, which the article draws out, following a summary of the main findings of the research literature. Learning of principles and concepts facilitates transfer to dissimilar problems, as it creates more flexible mental representations, whereas rote learning of facts discourages transfer. Transfer is fostered when general principles of reasoning are taught together with self-monitoring practices and potential applications in varied contexts. Training in reasoning and critical thinking is only effective for transfer, when abstract principles and rules are coupled with examples. Transfer is promoted when learning takes place in a social context, which fosters generation of principles and explanations. Transfer improves when learning is through co-operative methods, and where there is feedback on performance with training examples. The specificity of the context in which principles are learned reduces their transfer. Transfer is promoted if learners are shown how problems resemble each other, if they are expected to learn to do this themselves, if they are aware of how to apply skills in different contexts, if attention is directed to the underlying goal structure of comparable problems, if examples are varied and are accompanied by rules or principles (especially if discovered by the learners), and if learners’ self-explanations are stimulated. Learning to use meta-cognitive strategies is especially important for transfer.
Keywords ability capability cognitive competency core generic key metacognitive skill teaching transfer References Adey, P., Shayer, M. 1994Really Raising Standards: Cognitive Intervention and Academic Achievement Routledge London Google Scholar Alexander, P.A., Murphy, P.K. 1999 ‘Nurturing the seeds of transfer: A domain-specific perspective’ International Journal of Educational Research 31 561 576 CrossRef Google Scholar Anderson, J.R., Lebiere, C. 1998The Atomic Components of Thought Erlbaum Hillsdale Google Scholar Anderson, J.R., Reder, L.M., Simon, H.A. 1996 ‘Situated learning and education’ Educational Researcher 25 5 11 CrossRef Google Scholar Atkinson, R.K., Derry, S.J., Renkl, A., Wortham, D. 2000 ‘Learning from examples: instructional principles from worked examples research’ Review of Educational Research 70 181 214 CrossRef Google Scholar
Barnett, R. (1994).
The Limits of Competence: Knowledge, Higher Education and Society. Buckingham: Society for Research into Higher Education and the Open University Press, pp. 44–45, 64–66, 79–80, 92–93, 166–168 Bassok, M., Holyoak, K.J 1993 ‘Pragmatic knowledge and conceptual structure: Determinants of transfer between quantitative domains’ Detterman, D.K. Sternberg, R.J. eds. Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition and Instruction Ablex Norwood, NJ 68 98 Google Scholar
Bennett N., Dunne E. and Carré C., (2000) Skills Development in Higher Education and Employment SRHE & Open University Press. Buckingham
Bereiter, C. 1995 ‘A dispositional view of transfer’ McKeough, A. Lupart, J. Marini, A. eds. Teaching for Transfer: Fostering generalization in Learning Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 21 34 Google Scholar Billing, D. 2003 ‘Generic Cognitive Abilities in Higher Education: An international analysis of skills sought by stakeholders’ Compare 33 335 350 CrossRef Google Scholar Bransford, J.D. Brown, A.L. Cocking, R.R. eds. 1999How People Learn: Brain, Mind, Experience and School National Academy Press Washington DC Google Scholar Bransford, J., Sherwood, R., Vye, N., Reiser, J. 1986 ‘Teaching thinking and problem solving: Research foundations’ American Psychologist 41 1078 1089 CrossRef Google Scholar Bridges, D. 1993 ‘Transferable skills: A philosophical perspective’ Studies in Higher Education 18 43 51 CrossRef Google Scholar Brown, J.S., Collins, A., Duguid, P. 1989 ‘Situated cognition and the culture of learning’ Educational Researcher 18 32 42 CrossRef Google Scholar Campione, J.C., Shapiro, A.M., Brown, A.L. 1995 ‘Forms of transfer in a community of learners: Flexible learning and understanding’ McKeough, A. Lupart, J. Marini, A. eds. Teaching for Transfer: Fostering Generalization in Learning Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 35 68 Google Scholar Carraher, D., Schliemann, A.D. 2002 ‘The transfer dilemma’ Journal of the Learning Sciences 11 1 24 CrossRef Google Scholar Case, J., Gunstone, R. 2002 ‘Metacognitive development as a shift in approach to learning: An in-depth study’ Studies in Higher Education 27 459 470 CrossRef Google Scholar Catrambone, R., Holyoak, K.J. 1989 ‘Overcoming contextual limitations on problem-solving transfer’ Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 15 1147 1156 CrossRef Google Scholar Covington, M.V. 1987 Instruction in problem-solving planning Friedman, S.L. Scholnick, E.K. Cocking, R.R. eds. Blueprints for Thinking: The Role of Planning in Cognitive Development Cambridge University Press New York 469 511 Google Scholar Cox, B.R. 1997 ‘The rediscovery of the active learner in adaptive contexts: A developmental-historical analysis of transfer’ Educational Psychologist 32 41 55 CrossRef Google Scholar DfES 2003Foundation Degrees: Meeting the Need for Higher Level Skills Department for Education and Skills London Google Scholar Detterman, D.K. 1993 ‘The case for the prosecution: Transfer as an epiphenomenon’ Detterman, D.K. Sternberg, R.J. eds. Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition and Instruction Ablex Norwood, NJ 1 24 Google Scholar Dufresne, R., Gerace, W.J., Hardiman, P.T., Mestre, J.P. 1992 ‘Constraining novices to perform expert-like problem analyses: Effects on schema acquisition’ Journal of the Learning Sciences 2 307 331 CrossRef Google Scholar Gentner, D., Markham, A.B. 1997 ‘Structure mapping in analogy and similarity’ American Psychologist 52 45 56 CrossRef Google Scholar Gick, M.L., Holyoak, K.J. 1987 ‘The cognitive basis of knowledge transfer’ Cormier, S.M. Hagman, J.D. eds. Transfer of Learning: Contemporary Research and Applications Academic Press Inc San Diego 9 46 Google Scholar Gray, W.D., Orasanu, J.M. 1987 ‘Transfer of cognitive skills’ Cormier, S.M. Hagman, J.D. eds. Transfer of Learning: Contemporary Research and Applications Academic Press Inc San Diego 183 215 Google Scholar
Greeno, J.G., Smith, D.R., Moore, J.L. and the Institute for Research on Learning (1993). ‘Transfer of situated learning’, in Detterman D.K. and Sternberg R.J. (eds.),
Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition and Instruction. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, pp. 99–167 Halpern, D.F. 1996Thought and Knowledge: An Introduction to Critical Thinking Erlbaum Mahaw, NJ Google Scholar Hatano, G., Greeno, J.G. 1999 ‘Commentary: Alternative perspectives on transfer and transfer studies’ International Journal of Educational Research 31 645 654 CrossRef Google Scholar Herrnstein, R.J., Nickerson, R.S., Sanchez, M., Swets, J.A. 1986 ‘Teaching thinking skills’ American Psychologist 41 1279 1289 CrossRef Google Scholar Kehr, H.M., Bles, P., Rosentiel, L. 1999 ‘Self-regulation, self-control and management training transfer’ International Journal of Educational Research 31 487 498 CrossRef Google Scholar Lim, E.L., Dixon, R.S., Moore, D.W. 1996 ‘Worked examples vs non-goal-specific problems: A test of schema development in geometry’ Educational Psychology 16 421 431 Google Scholar Lizzio, A., Wilson, K. 2004 ‘First-year students’ perceptions of capability’ Studies in Higher Education 29 109 128 CrossRef Google Scholar McCrindle, A.R., Christensen, C.A. 1995 ‘The impact of learning journals on metacognitive and cognitive processes and learning performance’ Learning and Instruction 5 167 185 CrossRef Google Scholar McDaniel, M.A., Schlager, M.S. 1990 ‘Discovery learning and transfer of problem-solving skills’ Cognition and Instruction 7 129 159 CrossRef Google Scholar McKeough, A. Lupart, J. Marini, A. eds. 1995Teaching for Transfer: Fostering Generalization in Learning Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 21 34 Google Scholar Marini, A., Genereux, R. 1995 ‘The challenge of teaching for transfer’ McKeough, A. Lupart, J. Marini, A. eds. Teaching for Transfer: Fostering Generalization in Learning Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 1 19 Google Scholar Mayer, R.C., Wittrock, M.C. 1996 ‘Problem-solving transfer’ Berliner, D.C. Calfee, R.C. eds. Handbook of Educational Psychology Macmillan New York 47 62 Google Scholar Mevarech, Z.R. 1999 ‘Effects of metacognitive training embedded in cooperative settings on mathematical problem solving’ Journal of Educational Research 92 195 205 Google Scholar Minnaert, A., Janssen, P.J. 1999 ‘The additive effect of regulatory activities on top of intelligence in relation to academic performance in higher education’ Learning and Instruction 9 77 91 CrossRef Google Scholar Newsome, G.L., III 2000 ‘A review of some promising approaches to understanding and improving thinking skills’ Journal of Research and Development in Education 33 199 222 Google Scholar Niedelman, M. 1991 ‘Problem solving and transfer’ Journal of Learning Disabilities 24 322 329 CrossRef Google Scholar Perez, R.S., Seidel, R.J. 1986 ‘Cognitive theory of technical training’ Sticht, T.G. Chang, F.R. Woods, S. eds. Advances in Reading/Language Research: Cognitive Science and Human Resources Management JAI Press Greenwich, CT Google Scholar Perkins, D.N., Salomon, G. 1987 ‘Transfer and teaching thinking’ Perkins, D.N. Lochhead, J. Bishop, J. eds. Thinking: The Second International Conference Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ Google Scholar Perkins, D.N., Salomon, G. 1989 ‘Are cognitive skills context-bound?’ Educational Researcher 18 16 25 CrossRef Google Scholar Perkins, D.N., Salomon, G. 1994 ‘Transfer of learning’ Husen, T. Postlethwaite, T. eds. The International Encyclopaedia of Education2 Elsevier/Pergamon Oxford 6452 6457 Google Scholar Phye, D. 1991 ‘Advice and feedback during cognitive training: Effects at acquisition and delayed transfer’ Contemporary Educational Psychology 16 87 94 CrossRef Google Scholar Pintrich, P.R. 1999 ‘The role of motivation in promoting and sustaining self-regulated learning’ International Journal of Educational Research 31 459 470 CrossRef Google Scholar Prabhakaran, V., Smith, J.A.L., Desmond, J.E, Glover, G.H., Gabrieli, J.D.E. 1997 ‘Neural substrates of fluid reasoning: An fMRI study of neocortical activation during performance of raven’s progressive matrices test’ Cognitive Psychology 33 43 63 CrossRef Google Scholar Reed, S.K. 1987 ‘A structure-mapping model for word problems’ Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 13 124 139 CrossRef Google Scholar Reed, S.K. 1993 ‘A schema-based theory of transfer vol 2’ Detterman, D.K. Sternberg, R.J. eds. Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition and Instruction Ablex Norwood, NJ 39 67 Google Scholar Resnick, L.B. 1987Education and Learning to Think National Academy Press Washington, DC Google Scholar Resnick, L., Collins, A. 1994 ‘Cognition and learning’ Husen, T. Postlethwaite, T. eds. The International Encyclopaedia of Education2 Elsevier/Pergamon Oxford 835 838 Google Scholar Rumelhart, D.E., Ortony, A. 1977 ‘The representation of knowledge in memory’ Anderson, R.C. Spiro, R.J. Montague, E. eds. Schooling and The Acquisition of Knowledge Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ Google Scholar Salvucci, D.D., Anderson, J.R. 2001 ‘Integrating analogical mapping and general problem solving: The path-mapping theory’ Cognitive Science 25 67 110 CrossRef Google Scholar Schoenfeld, A.H., Herrmann, D.J. 1982 ‘Problem perception and knowledge in expert and novice mathematical problem solvers’ Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition. 8 484 494 CrossRef Google Scholar Schraw, G., Nietfeld, J. 1998 ‘A further test of the general monitoring skill hypothesis’ Journal of Educational Psychology 90 236 248 CrossRef Google Scholar Simon, D.P., Simon, H.A. 1978 ‘Individual differences in solving physics problems’ Siegler, R.S. eds. Children’s Thinking: What Develops? Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Hillsdale, NJ Google Scholar Simons, P.R.J. 1994 ‘Metacognitive strategies, teaching and testing for’ Husen, T. Postlethwaite, T. eds. The International Encyclopaedia of Education2 Elsevier/Pergamon Oxford 3788 3792 Google Scholar Singley, M.K. Anderson, J.R. eds. 1989The Transfer of Cognitive Skill Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA Google Scholar Skin, N., Jonassen, D.H., McGee, S. 2003 ‘Predictors of well-structured and ill-structured problem-solving in an astronomical situation’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 40 6 33 CrossRef Google Scholar Sternberg, R.J., Frensch, P.A. 1993 ‘Mechanisms of transfer’ Detterman, D.K. Sternberg, R.J. eds. Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition and Instruction Ablex Norwood, NJ 25 38 Google Scholar Stokes, T.F., Baer, D.M. 1977 ‘An implicit technology of generalization’ Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 10 349 367 CrossRef Google Scholar Sweller, J. 1988 ‘Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning’ Cognitive Science 12 257 285 CrossRef Google Scholar Terenzini, P.T., Springer, L., Pascarella, E.T., Nora, A. 1995 ‘Influences affecting the development of students’ critical thinking skills’ Research in Higher Education 36 23 39 CrossRef Google Scholar Tuovinen, J.E., Sweller, J. 1999 ‘A comparison of cognitive load associated with discovery learning and worked examples’ Journal of Educational Psychology 91 334 341 CrossRef Google Scholar Merriënboer, J.J.G., Schuurman, J.G., Croock, M.B.M., Paas, F.G.W.C. 2002 ‘Redirecting learners’ attention during training: Effects on cognitive load, transfer test performance and training efficiency’ Learning and Instruction 12 11 37 CrossRef Google Scholar Veenan, M.C.J., Elshout, J.J., Meijer, J. 1997 ‘The generality vs domain-specificity of metacognitive skills in novice learning across domains’ Learning & Instruction 7 187 209 CrossRef Google Scholar Volcke, M. 2002 ‘Cognitive load: Updating the theory?’ Learning and Instruction 12 147 154 CrossRef Google Scholar Volet, S.E. 1991 ‘Modelling and coaching of relevant metacognitive strategies for enhancing university students’ learning’ Learning and Instruction 1 319 336 CrossRef Google Scholar Vollmeyer, R., Burns, B.D., Holyoak, K.J. 1996 ‘The impact of goal specificity on strategy use and the acquisition of problem structure’ Cognitive Science 20 75 100 CrossRef Google Scholar
Wade, S.E. and Reynolds, R.E. (1989) ‘Developing metacognitive awareness’.
Journal of Reading, October 1989, 33(1), 6–14. White, B.Y., Frederickson, J.R. 1998 ‘Inquiry, modeling and metacognition: Making science accessible to all students’ Cognition and Instruction 16 3 117 CrossRef Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2007