Fractal dimension of metallic fracture surface Original Article Received: 15 November 2004 Accepted: 03 May 2006 DOI:
Cite this article as: Kotowski, P. Int J Fract (2006) 141: 269. doi:10.1007/s10704-006-8264-x Abstract
In this study, a complete method of determination of the fractal dimension for fracture surfaces of ferrous alloys has been proposed. This dimension is determined for the vertical profile obtained by the profile technique cross-section. The image of the profile, seen through the microscope coupled with a camera, is recorded in a computer, where numerical processing is performed. For calculation of the same fractal dimension, the fd3 program has been used, which is available through the Internet. The essential element of the method is optimisation concerning microscopic magnification (scale of a length), resolution of the recorded image and selection of the grey level threshold at binarization. The tests for the stability of discretization, which enable minimization of the error of the measurement, have also been carried out. These tests consist in checking the difference in fractal dimensions for the same profile obtained in two different methods of contouring as well as the difference between capacitive, informative and correlative dimensions. In both cases, too big difference suggests that the determined dimension is not reliable. This method allows determination of the fractal dimension with an absolute accuracy of 0.05 in non-dimensional units. The method has been employed in many studies. In this paper the following tests have been presented: a “fractal map” of the fracture surface was made, an influence of the mechanical notch radius in a compact specimen on the fractal dimension of the fracture surface, an influence of the distortion rate on the fractal dimension, an effect of fatigue crack propagation rate on the fractal dimension and influence of the stress-intensity factor on the fractal dimension of the fracture surface. The following materials were examined: Armco iron, P355N steel and 41Cr4 steel in different states after the heat treatment. The measurements have been made for the specimens of the compact type. There was considered an influence of location of the place of measurement on the fractal dimension being determined. The dimension was determined on the profiles lying longwise and crosswise the crack propagation direction. It has been found that the fractal dimension of the fracture surface does not depend on a place of measurement. This suggests, among other things, that a distinction between the places, which were created under conditions of the plane stress, and the places, which were created under conditions of the plane strain state, cannot be made with the help of the fractal dimension. When testing an influence of the radius of the mechanical tip notch on the fractal dimension of a fracture surface, this dimension was determined in the places located at different distances from the tip of the mechanical notch. With respect to the radii up to 1.0 mm, no significant differences in fractal dimensions have been found. The fractal dimensions of the fracture surface for all examined materials were practically the same and they ranged from 2.02 to 2.10. However in some ranges of d
a/d N rate the dimension was changing inversely proportional to d a/d N. Obtained results confirm that fractal dimension do not depend on the investigated material. Keywords Method Fractal dimension Fracture surface Metal References Babadagli, T, Develi, K 2003 Fractal characteristics of rocks fractured under tension Theoret Appl Fract Mech 39 73 88 CrossRef Google Scholar Balankin, AS, Yanevich, GN 1991 Ergodynamics of impact cratering and principles of simulation of an impact Soviet Tech Phys Lett 17 236 238 Google Scholar Balankin, AS 1992 Fractal mechanics of deformed media and the topology of fracture in solids Doklady Akademii Nauk 322 869 874 MathSciNet Google Scholar Balankin, AS, Susarrey, O 1996 Statistical topography of the set of admissible crack paths in a brittle solid Int J Fract 81 R27 R32 CrossRef Google Scholar Balankin, AS 1997 Physics of fracture and mechanics of self-affine cracks Eng Fract Mech 57 135 203 CrossRef Google Scholar Balankin, AS, Morales, D, Gomez-Mancilla, , Susarrey, O, Campos, I 2000 Fractal properties of fracture surfaces in steel 1045 Int J Fract 106 L21 L26 CrossRef Google Scholar Balankin, AS, Susarrey, O, Urriolagoitia, G, Hernandez, LH 2002 Self-affine nature of the stress-strain behavior of an elastic fractal network Phys. Lett. A 297 376 386 MATH CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Balankin, AS, Morales, D 2005 Anomalous roughness of turbulent interfaces with system size dependent local roughness exponent Phys Lett A 339 23 32 CrossRef ADS MATH Google Scholar
Bažant ZP (1995a) Scaling theories for quasibrittle fracture: recent advances and new directions. 2nd International Conference on Fracture Mechanics of Concrete and Concrete Surfaces, at ETH, Zürich, 515–534
Bažant, ZP 1995b Scaling of quasi-brittle fracture and fractal question J Eng Mater Technol 117 316 367 Google Scholar Bažant, ZP 1997a Fracturing truss model: size effect in shear failure of reinforced concrete J Eng Mech ASCE 123 1276 1288 Google Scholar Bažant, ZP 1997b Scaling of quasi-brittle fracture: Hypotheses of invasive and lacunar fractality, their critique and Wiebull connection Int J Fract 83 41 65 CrossRef Google Scholar Bažant, ZP, Yavari, A 2005 Is the cause of size effect on structural strength fractal or energeticá1statistical Eng Fract Mech 72 1 31 CrossRef Google Scholar Borodich, FM 1992 Fracture energy in a fractal cracks propagating in concrete or rock Doklady Rossiyskoy Akademii Nauk 325 1138 1141 Google Scholar Borodich, FM 1994 Fracture energy of brittle and fractal cracks Fractals Nat Appl Sci 41 61 68 Google Scholar Borodich, FM 1997 Some fractal models of fracture J Mech Phys Solid 45 239 259 MATH CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Borodich, FM 1999 Fractals and fractal scaling in fracture mechanics Int J Fract 95 239 259 CrossRef Google Scholar Borodich, FM, Onishchenko, DA 1999 Similarity and fractality in the modelling of roughness by a multilevel profile with hierarchical structure Int J Solid Struct 36 2585 2612 MATH MathSciNet CrossRef Google Scholar Borodich, FM 2001 Self-similar models and size effect of multiple fracture Fractals 9 17 30 CrossRef Google Scholar Bouchaud, E, Lapasset, G, Planes, J 1990 Fractal dimension of fractured surfaces: a Universal Value? Europhys Lett 13 73 79 ADS Google Scholar Bouchaud, E 1994 Complex microstructures analysis: fracture surfaces as an example Solid State Phenomena 35–36 353 368 Google Scholar Bouchaud, E 1997 Scaling properties of cracks J Phys: Condens Matter 9 4319 4344 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Bouchaud, E, Bouchaud, JP, Fisher, DS, Ramanathan, S, Rice, JR 2002 Can crack front waves explain the roughness of cracks? J Mech Phys Solid 50 1703 1725 MATH CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Brown, SR, Scholz, CH 1985 Broad bandwidth study of the topography of natural rock surfaces J Geophys Res 90B 12575 12582 ADS CrossRef Google Scholar Carpinteri, A 1994 Scaling laws and renormalization groups for strength and toughness of disordered materials Int J Solid Struct 31 291 302 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar
Carpinteri A, Chiaia B, Maradei F (1995) Experimental determination of the fractal dimension of disordered fracture surfaces In Advanced technology for design and fabrication of composite materials and structures, Kluwer, New York, pp 269–292
Carpinteri, A, Chiaia, B, Cornetti, P 2002 A scale-invariant cohesive crack model for quasibrittle materials Eng Fract Mech 69 207 217 CrossRef Google Scholar Celli, A, Tucci, A, Esposito, L, Palmonari, C 2003 Fractal analysis of cracks in aluminazirconia composites J Euro Ceram Soc 23 469 479 CrossRef Google Scholar Chapparda, D, Degasnea, I, Hurec, G, Legrandb, E, Audranb, M, Baslea, MF 2003 Image analysis measurements of roughness by texture and fractal analysis correlate with contact profilometry Biomaterials 24 1399 1407 CrossRef Google Scholar Cherepanov, GP, Balankin, AS, Ivanova, VS 1995 Fractal fracture mechanics—a review Eng Fract Mech 51 997 1033 CrossRef Google Scholar Cox, BL, Wang, JS 1993 Fractal surfaces: measurement and applications in the earth sciences Fractals 1 87 115 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar Dauskardt, RH, Haubensak, F, Ritchie, RO 1990 On the interpretation of the fractal character of fractured surfaces Acta Metall Mater 38 143 159 CrossRef Google Scholar Dossou, F, Gauvin, R 1994 The correlation between the fractal dimension of fractured surfaces and mechanical properties of 6061/Al 2O − 3/10–20% p Fractals 2 249 252 CrossRef Google Scholar Dubuc, B, Quiniou, JF, Roques-Carmes, C 1989 Evaluating the fractal dimension of profiles Phys Rev A 39 1500 1512 MathSciNet CrossRef ADS Google Scholar
Falconer K (1990) Fractal geometry—mathematical foundations and applications. University of Bristol
Falconer, K 1997Techniques in fractal geometry John & Sons Chichester MATH Google Scholar Feder, J 1988Fractals Plenum Press New York MATH Google Scholar Gao, H 1993 Surface roughening and branching instabilities in dynamic fracture J Mecha Phys Solids 41 457 486 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Gol‘dshteĭn, RV, Mosolov, AB 1991 Cracks with a fractal surface Doklady Akademii Nauk 36 603 605 MathSciNet Google Scholar Gol‘dshteĭn, RV, Mosolov, AB 1992 Fractal cracks J Appl Mat Mech 56 563 571 CrossRef Google Scholar Gol‘dshteĭn, RV, Mosolov, AB 1993 Multifractal failure geometry and the scale effect Doklady Akademii Nauk 329 429 431 Google Scholar Griffith, AA 1920 The phenomenon of rupture and flow in solids Phil Trans Roy Soc London A221 163 198 ADS Google Scholar Hansen, A, Engoy, T, Måly, KJ 1994 Measuring Hurst exponents with the first return method Fractals 2 527 533 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar Hansen, A, Plauraboue, F, Roux, S 1995 Shadows in a self-affine landscape Fractals 3 91 98 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar Hao, Y, Wang, Z, Kang, Y 1994 Fractal analysis on the fatigue fracture surface along the crack propagation direction Steel Res 65 305 308 Google Scholar Hisatsune, K, Takuma, Y, Tanaka, Y, Udoh, K, Kawasaki, K 1998 Fractal dimension of grain boundary in CuAu alloys refined by platinum addition J Mater Sci 33 4783 4785 CrossRef Google Scholar Imre, A, Pajkossy, T, Nyikos, L 1992 Electrochemical determination of the fractal dimension of fractured surfaces Acta Metallica Material 40 1819 1826 CrossRef Google Scholar Ivanova, VS, Balankin, AS, Ermishkin, V, Kovnerisryi, Y, Tamayo, P 1993 The fractal geometry of amorphous structures and the synergetics of vitrifivation of metallic alloys Soviet Phys Doklady 37 222 224 ADS Google Scholar
Ivanova VS, Balankin AS, Bunin IJ, Oksogoev AA (1994) Synergetics and fractals in materials science. Nauka, Moscow.
Kappraff, J 1991Connections: the geometric bridge between art and science McGraw-Hill New York MATH Google Scholar Kedzia, A, Rybaczuk, M, Dymecki, J 1997 Fractal estimation of the senile brain atrophy Folia Neuropath 35 235 238 Google Scholar
Kedzia A, Rybaczuk M (1998) The Fractal analysis of the human cortex vessels. Folia Morphologica 57.
Krupa K, Stoppel P (1993) Programs for filtration of bitmap files and for fractal dimensions estimation. Raport IMMT nr PRE–14/93 (in polish), Wrocław University of Technology, Wrocław.
Kotowski P (1996) Fractal dimension of fracture surface. Preparation of the fracture surface XVI Sympozjum nt. Zmeczenie i Mechanika Pekania (in polish), Bydgoszcz.
Kotowski P, Rybaczuk M, Stoppel P (1996) Fracture toughness and fractal dimension. Method of fractal dimension estimation. XVII Sympozjum Mechaniki Eksperymentalnej Ciała Stałego (in polish), Warszawa.
Kotowski P (2003) Fractal characteristics of the fracture surface of chosen iron alloys. Doctor thesis (in polish), Wrocaw University of Technology, Wrocław.
Kuznetsov PV, Panin VE, Levin KV, Lipnitskii AG, VI, Schreiber J (2001) Fractal dimension and effects of correlation of the mesostructure of the surface of plastically deformed iron silicide polycrystals and austenitic corrosion-resistant steel. Mater Sci Heat Treatment 43:89–94
Kyriacos, S, Buczkowski, S, Nekka, F, Cartilier, L 1994 A modified box-counting method Fractals 2 321 324 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar Lopez, J, Hansali, G, Zahouani, , Le Bosse, JC, Mathia, T 1995 3-D fractal based characterization for engineered surface topography Int J Mech Tool Manufacture 35 211 217 CrossRef Google Scholar Lung, CW, Wang, SG, Long, QY 2000 Elastic fracture in driven media Physica B 279 139 141 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Majumdar, A, Tien, CL 1990 Fractal characterization and simulation of rough surfaces Wear 136 313 327 CrossRef Google Scholar Måloy, KJ, Hansen, A, Hinrichsen, EL, Eoux, S 1992 Experimental measurements of the roughness of brittle cracks Phys Rev Lett 68 213 215 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar
Mandelbrot BB (1982) The fractal geometry of nature. W. H. Freeman, San Francisco.
Mandelbrot, BB, Passoja, DE, Paullay, AJ 1984 Fractal character of fractured surfaces of metals Nature 308 721 722 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Meakin, P 1991 Models for materials failure and deformation Science 252 226 234 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Meakin, P 1993 The growth of rough surfaces and interfaces Phys Report 235 189 289 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Moreira, JG, Silva, JK, Kamphorst, SO 1994 On the fractal dimension of self-affine profiles J Phys A: Mathematics General 27 8079 8089 MATH CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Morel, S, Schmittbuhl, J, Bouchaud, E, Valentin, G 2000a Scaling of crack surfaces and implications for fracture mechanics Phys Rev Lett 85 1678 1681 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar
Morel S, Bouchaud E, Valentin G (2000b) Size effect in fracture: roughening of crack surfaces and asymptotic analysis. Phys Rev B 65.
Morel, S, Bouchaud, E, Schmittbuhl, J, Valentin, G 2000 R-curve behavior and roughness development of fracture surfaces Int J Fract 114 307 325 CrossRef Google Scholar Morgenstern, O, Sokolov, IM, Blumen, A 1993 Statistical model for surface fracture Europhys Lett 22 487 492 ADS Google Scholar Mosolov, AB 1991a Cracks with fractal surfaces Dokl Akad Nauk SSSR 319 840 844 Google Scholar Mosolov, AB 1991b Fractal J-integral in fracture Sov Tech Phys Lett 17 698 700 Google Scholar Mosolov, AB, Borodich, FM 1992 Fractal fracture of brittlebodies during compression Dokl Akad Nauk SSSR 37 263 265 MathSciNet Google Scholar Mosolov, AB 1993 Mechanics of fractal cracks in brittle solids Europhys Lett 24 673 678 ADS Google Scholar Neimark, AA 1992 A new approach to the determination of the surface fractal dimension of porous solids Physica A 191 258 262 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Panagiotopoulos, PD 1992 Fractal geometry in solids and structures Int J Solid Struct 29 2159 2175 MATH MathSciNet CrossRef Google Scholar Panagiotopoulos, PD, Panagouli, OK, Mistakidis, ES 1993 Fractal geometry and fractal material behavior in solids and structures Arch Appl Mech 63 1 24 MATH CrossRef Google Scholar Pande, C, Smith, S, Richards, LE 1987 Fractal characteristics of fractured surfaces J Mater Sci Lett 6 295 297 CrossRef Google Scholar Power, WL, Tullis, TE, Brown, SR, Boitnott, GN, Scholz, CH 1987 Roughness of Natural Fault Surfaces Geophys Res Lett 14 29132 Google Scholar Power, WL, Tullis, TE 1991 Euclidean and fractal models for description of rock surface roughness J Geophys Res 96 415 424 ADS Google Scholar Rough, S, Schmittbuhl, J, Vilotte, JP, Hansen, A 1993 Some physical properties of self-affine rough surfaces Europhys Lett 23 277 282 ADS Google Scholar
Russ JC (1994) Fractal surfaces. NY Plenum Press.
Schmittbuhl, J, Gentier, S, Roux, S 1993 Field measurements of the roughness of fault surfaces Geophys Res Lett 20 639 641 ADS Google Scholar Schmittbuhl, J, Roux, S, Berthaud, Y 1994 Development of roughness in crack propagation Europhys Lett 28 585 590 ADS Google Scholar Schmittbuhl, J, Schmitt, F, Scholz, C 1995 Scaling invariance of crack surfaces J Geophys Res 100 5953 5973 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Schmittbuhl, J, Vilotte, JP 1995 Reliability of self-affine measurements Phys Rev E 51 131 147 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Schmittbuhl, J, Delaplace, A, Måly, KJ, Perfettini, H, Vilotte, JP 2003 Slow crack propagation and slip correlations Pure Appl Geophys 160 961 976 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar
Simonsen I, Hansen A (1998) Determination of the Hurst Exponent by use of Wavelet Transforms. Phys Rev E 58(3)
Sumiyoshi, H, Matsuoka, S, Ishikawa, K, Nihei, M 1992 Fractal characteristic of scanning tunneling microscopic images of brittle fracture surfaces on molybdenum JSME Int J 35 449 445 Google Scholar Tanaka, M 1997 The creep-rupture properties and the initiation and growth of the grain-boundary cracks in the cobalt-base HS-21 alloy J Mat Sci 32 1781 1788 CrossRef Google Scholar Tanaka, M, Kayama, A, Kato, R, Ito, Y 1999 Estimation of the fractal dimension of fracture surface patterns by box-counting method Fractals 7 335 340 CrossRef Google Scholar Tanaka, M, Kayama, A 2001 Automated image processing for fractal analysis of fracture surface profiles in high-temperature materials J Mater Sci Lett 20 907 909 CrossRef Google Scholar Tanaka, M, Kato, R, Kayama, A 2002 Size distribution of surface cracks and crack pattern in austenitic SUS316 steel plates fatigued by cyclic bending J Mater Sci 37 3945 3951 CrossRef Google Scholar Theocaris, PS, Panagiotopoulos, PD 1993 The fractal assumption in cracks: bilateral calculation methods Int J Numer Methods Eng 36 1597 1604 MATH MathSciNet CrossRef Google Scholar Underwood, EE, Banerji, K 1983 Statistical analysis of facets in a computer simulated surface Acta Stereol 2 75 80 Google Scholar Underwood, EE, Banerji, K 1986 Fractals in fractography Mater Sci Eng 80 1 14 CrossRef Google Scholar
Underwood EE, Banerji K (1992) Fractal analysis of fracture surface. Metals Handbook, vol. 12. Fractography, ASM, New York, 211–215
Vandembroucq, D, Roux, S 1997 Conformal mapping on rough boundaries. 1. Applications to harmonic problems Phys Rev E 55 6171 6185 MathSciNet CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Wang, SG 2003 The dependence of the fractal dimension of crack on material for brittle fracture in two dimensions Phys Lett A 308 455 460 MATH CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Weiss, J 2001 Self-affinity of fracture surfaces and implications on a possible size effect on fracture energy Int J Fract 109 365 381 CrossRef Google Scholar Wong, P, Howard, J, Lin, JS 1986 Surface roughening and the fractal nature of rocks Phys Rev Lett 57 637 640 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Xie, H 1989 The fractal effect of irregularity on crack branching on the fracture toughness of brittle materials Int J Fract 41 267 274 CrossRef Google Scholar Xie, H, Sanderson, DJ 1995a Fractal effect of crack propagation on dynamic stress intensity fractors and crack velocities Int J Fract 74 29 42 CrossRef Google Scholar Xie, H, Sanderson, DJ 1995b Fractal kinematics of crack propagation in geomaterials Eng Fract Mech 50 529 536 CrossRef Google Scholar Yavari, A, Hockett, KG, Sarkani, S 2000 The fourth mode of fracture in fractal fracture mechanics Int J Fract 101 365 384 CrossRef Google Scholar Yavari, A, Sarkani, S, Moyer, ET 2002 The mechanics of self-similar and self-affine fractal cracks Int J Fract 114 1 27 CrossRef Google Scholar Zhang, X, Knackstedt, MA, Chan, DYC, Peterson, L 1996 On the universality of fracture surface roughness Europhys Lett 34 121 126 CrossRef ADS Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2006