Taking the Self out of Self-Rule
- Michael Garnett
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Many philosophers believe that agents are self-ruled only when ruled by their (authentic) selves. Though this view is rarely argued for explicitly, one tempting line of thought suggests that self-rule is just obviously equivalent to rule by the self. However, the plausibility of this thought evaporates upon close examination of the logic of ‘self-rule’ and similar reflexives. Moreover, attempts to rescue the account by recasting it in negative terms are unpromising. In light of these problems, this paper instead proposes that agents are self-ruled only when not ruled by others. One reason for favouring this negative social view is its ability to yield plausible conclusions concerning various manipulation cases that are notoriously problematic for nonsocial accounts of self-rule. A second reason is that the account conforms with ordinary usage. It is concluded that self-rule may be best thought of as an essentially social concept.
- Blackford LB, (2010) Panel Approves Compromise Bill to Make College Transfers Easier, Lexington Herald-Leader, March 19.
- Boud D (1981) ed. Developing Student Autonomy in Learning, Nichols Publishing Company
- Buss S (2005) Valuing Autonomy and Respecting Persons: Manipulation, seduction, and the basis of moral constraints. Ethics 115(2):195–235 CrossRef
- Chishi H (2010) NSCN-IM Rejects Autonomy. The Calcutta Telegraph, March, 19
- Christman J (1991) Autonomy and Personal History, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 21.
- Christman J (2007) Autonomy, History, and the Subject of Justice, Social Theory and Practice 33.
- Christman J (2009) The Politics of Persons: Individual autonomy and socio-historical selves, Cambridge University Press.
- Cohen GA (1996) Reason, Humanity, and the Moral Law. In C. Korsgaard, The Sources of Normativity, Cambridge University Press.
- Datta D, Grant J (1990) Relationships Between Type of Acquisition, the Autonomy Given to the Acquired Firm, and Acquisition Success: An empirical analysis, Journal of Management 16.
- Ekstrom LW (1993) A Coherence Theory of Autonomy. Philos Phenomenol Res 53:599–616 CrossRef
- Ekstrom L (2005) Autonomy and Personal Integration, in Personal Autonomy, ed. J. S. Taylor, Cambridge University Press.
- Frankfurt HG (1971) Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person. J Philos 68(1):5–20 CrossRef
- Frankfurt HG (1975) Three Concepts of Free Action. Proc Aristot Soc 49:113–25
- Frankfurt HG (1999) Autonomy, Necessity, and Love, in Necessity, Volition, and Love, Cambridge University Press.
- Frankfurt HG (2002) Reply to Jonathan Lear, in Contours of Agency: Essays on themes from Harry Frankfurt, ed. S. Buss and L. Overton, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
- Friedman M (2003) Autonomy, Gender, Politics, Oxford University Press.
- Haselager WFG (2005) Robotics, Philosophy and the Problems of Autonomy. Pragmat Cogn 13:518 CrossRef
- Hobbes T (1996) Leviathan, ed. R. Tuck, Cambridge University Press.
- Hoover K (2010) Consumer Bureau at Federal Reserve would have Autonomy, Phoenix Business Journal, March 19
- Korsgaard CM (2010) Self-Constitution: Agency, identity, and integrity, Oxford University Press.
- McKenna, 2005. The Relationship between Autonomous and Morally Responsible Agency, in Personal Autonomy, ed. J. S. Taylor, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Mele AR (1995) Autonomous Agents: From self-control to autonomy, Oxford University Press.
- Mele AR (2006) Free Will and Luck, Oxford University Press.
- Mele AR (2008) Manipulation, Compatibilism, and Moral Responsibility. The Journal of Ethics 12(3–4):263–86 CrossRef
- Meyers DT (1989) Self, Society, and Personal Choice, Columbia University Press
- Meyers DT (2000) Intersectional Identity and the Authentic Self? Opposites Attract!, in Relational Autonomy: Feminist Perspectives on Autonomy, Agency, and the Social Self, ed. C. Mackenzie and N. Stoljar, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Moran R (2002) Frankfurt on Identification: Ambiguities of activity in mental life, in Contours of Agency: Essays on themes from Harry Frankfurt, ed. S. Buss and L. Overton, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
- Noggle R (1995) Autonomy, Value, and Conditioned Desire. Am Philos Q 32(1):57–69
- Plato (1987) Republic, trans. D. Lee, Penguin Books.
- Scanlon TM (2002) Reasons and Passions, in Contours of Agency: Essays on themes from Harry Frankfurt, ed. S. Buss and L. Overton, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
- Spector, P. E. 1986. Perceived Control by Employees: A meta-analysis of studies concerning autonomy and participation at work, Human Relations 39.
- Velleman JD (1992) What Happens When Someone Acts? Mind 101:461–481 CrossRef
- Velleman JD (2002) Identification and Identity, in Contours of Agency: Essays on themes from Harry Frankfurt, ed. S. Buss and L. Overton, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
- Watson G (1975) Free Agency. J Philos 72:205–20 CrossRef
- Williams R (2010) State Schools Accused of Turning Pupils into ‘Well-Drilled Automatons’, The Guardian, March 19.
- Wolf S (1990) Freedom Within Reason, Oxford University Press.
- Taking the Self out of Self-Rule
Ethical Theory and Moral Practice
Volume 16, Issue 1 , pp 21-33
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Michael Garnett (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Philosophy, Birkbeck College, University of London, Malet Street, London, WC1E 7HX, UK