Two Problems of Direct Inference
- Paul D. Thorn
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The article begins by describing two longstanding problems associated with direct inference. One problem concerns the role of uninformative frequency statements in inferring probabilities by direct inference. A second problem concerns the role of frequency statements with gerrymandered reference classes. I show that past approaches to the problem associated with uninformative frequency statements yield the wrong conclusions in some cases. I propose a modification of Kyburg’s approach to the problem that yields the right conclusions. Past theories of direct inference have postponed treatment of the problem associated with gerrymandered reference classes by appealing to an unexplicated notion of projectability. I address the lacuna in past theories by introducing criteria for being a relevant statistic. The prescription that only relevant statistics play a role in direct inference corresponds to the sort of projectability constraints envisioned by past theories.
- Bacchus, F. (1990). Representing and reasoning with probabilistic knowledge. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
- Bacchus, F., Grove, A., Halpern, J., & Koller, D. (1996). From statistical knowledge bases to degrees of belief. Artificial Intelligence, 87(1–2), 75–143. CrossRef
- Colyvan, M., & Regan, H. (2001). Is it a crime to belong to a reference class? Journal of Political Philosophy, 9(2), 168–181. CrossRef
- Colyvan, M., Regan, H., & Ferson, S. (2007). Legal decisions and the reference class problem. International Journal of Evidence and Proof, 11(4), 274–286. CrossRef
- Fetzer, J. (1977). Reichenbach, reference classes, and single case ‘probabilities’. Synthese, 34, 185–217. CrossRef
- Fitelson, B., Hájek, A., & Hall, N. (2005). Probability. In S. Sarkar & J. Pfeifer (Eds.), Philosophy of science: An encyclopedia. Oxford: Routledge.
- Geffner, H., & Pearl, J. (1992). Conditional entailment: bridging two approaches to default reasoning. Artificial Intelligence, 53(2–3), 209–244. CrossRef
- Goodman, N. (1955). Fact, fiction, and forecast. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
- Hájek, A. (2007). The reference class problem is your problem too. Synthese, 156(3), 563–585. CrossRef
- Halpern, J. (2003). Reasoning about uncertainty. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
- Hempel, C. (1968). Lawlikeness and maximal specificity in probabilistic explanation. Philosophy of Science, 35(2), 116–133. CrossRef
- Horty, J., Thomason, R., & Touretzky, D. (1990). A sceptical theory of inheritance in nonmonotonic semantic networks. Artificial Intelligence, 42(2–3), 311–348. CrossRef
- Kraus, S., Lehmann, D., & Magidor, M. (1990). Nonmonotonic reasoning, preferential models and cumulative logics. Artificial Intelligence, 44(1–2), 167–207. CrossRef
- Kyburg, H. (1961). Probability and the logic of rational belief. Middleton, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press.
- Kyburg, H. (1974). The logical foundations of statistical inference. Dordrecht-Holland: Reidel Publishing Company. CrossRef
- Kyburg, H., & Teng, C. (2001). Uncertain inference. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossRef
- Levi, I. (1982). Direct inference. Journal of Philosophy, 74, 5–29. CrossRef
- Pollock, J. (1990). Nomic probability and the foundations of induction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Pollock, J. (2007). The Y-function. In G. Wheeler & B. Harper (Eds.), Probability and evidence: Essays in honour of Henry E. Kyburg Jr. London: College Publications.
- Pollock, J. (unpublished). Probable probabilities. PhilSci Archive, at: http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/3340/.
- Pust, J. (2011). Sleeping beauty and direct inference. Analysis.
- Reichenbach, H. (1949). A theory of probability. Berkeley: Berkeley University Press.
- Rhee, R. (2007). Probability, policy and the problem of the reference class. International Journal of Evidence and Proof, 11(4), 286–292. CrossRef
- Salmon, W. (1971). Statistical explanation. In W. Salmon (Ed.), Statistical explanation and statistical relevance. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
- Salmon, W. (1977). Objectively homogeneous reference classes. Synthese, 36, 399–414. CrossRef
- Salmon, W. (1984). Scientific explanation and the causal structure of the world. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Stone, M. (1987). Kyburg, Levi, and Petersen. Philosophy of Science, 54(2), 244–255. CrossRef
- Thorn, P. (2007). Three problems of direct inference. Dissertation, University of Arizona.
- Thorn, P. (forthcoming). Undercutting defeat via reference properties of differing arity: a reply to Pust. Analysis. http://analysis.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2011/09/02/analys.anr099.abstract.
- Venn, J. (1866). The logic of chance. New York: Chelsea Publishing Company.
- Two Problems of Direct Inference
Volume 76, Issue 3 , pp 299-318
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Paul D. Thorn (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Philosophisches Institut, University of Düsseldorf, Universitätsstr. 1, Düsseldorf, 40225, Germany