A Structural Analysis of the Phlogiston Case
- Maria Caamaño
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The incommensurability thesis, as introduced by T.S. Kuhn and P.K. Feyerabend, states that incommensurable theories are conceptually incompatible theories which share a common domain of application. Such claim has often been regarded as incoherent, since it has been understood that the determination of a common domain of application at least requires a certain degree of conceptual compatibility between the theories. The purpose of this work is to contribute to the defense of the notion of local or gradual incommensurability, as proposed by late Kuhn. The application of this notion would allow to render the incommensurability thesis coherent. To support this view, a typical example of incommensurability will be formally analyzed by applying the structuralist metatheory developed, among others by W. Balzer, C.U. Moulines and J.D. Sneed. The structural reconstruction of the relation between the phlogiston theory and the oxygen theory offered here will reveal that they are locally incommensurable, and will even make possible to determine the ontological reduction relation that they also exemplify.
- Balzer, W, Moulines, CU, Sneed, JD (1987) An architectonic for science. The structuralist program. Reidel, Dordrecht
- Brock, WH (1992) The Fontana history of chemistry. Fontana Press, London
- Cohen, IB (1985) Revolution in science. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge
- Conant, J. B. (1948). The overthrow of the Phlogiston theory. In Harvard case histories in experimental science (pp. 67–115). Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
- Díez, JA, Moulines, CU (1999) Fundamentos de Filosofía de la Ciencia. Ariel, Barcelona
- Feyerabend, P. K. (1962/1981). Explanation, reduction, and empiricism. Reprinted in Realism, rationalism and scientific method. Philosophical papers (Vol. I, pp. 44–96). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Feyerabend, PK (1977) Changing patterns of reconstruction. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 28: pp. 351-369 CrossRef
- Kamlah, A A logical investigation of the Phlogiston case. In: Balzer, W eds. (1984) Reduction in science. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, pp. 217-238
- Kuhn, TS (1962/1970) The structure of scientific revolutions (1962). The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- Kuhn, TS (1976) Theory change as structure-change: Comments on the Sneed formalism. Erkenntnis 10: pp. 179-199 CrossRef
- Kuhn, TS (1983) Commensurability, comparability, communicability. Philosophy of Science Association II: pp. 669-688
- Laudan, L (1977) Progress and its problems. University of California Press, Berkeley
- Mayr, D (1976) Investigations of the concept of reduction I. Erkenntnis 10: pp. 275-294 CrossRef
- Moulines, CU Ontological reduction in the natural sciences. In: Balzer, W eds. (1984) Reduction in science. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, pp. 51-70
- Moulines, C. U. (1991). Pluralidad y recursión. Estudios epistemológicos (p. 266). Madrid: Alianza.
- Moulines, C. U. (2000). Is there genuinely scientific progress? In A. Jonkisz & L. Koj (Eds.), On comparing and evaluating scientific theories, Poznan Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities, 72, pp. 173–197.
- Niiniluoto, I (1980) Scientific progress. Synthese 45: pp. 427-462 CrossRef
- Partington, JR (1962) A history of chemistry. Macmillan and Company Limited, London
- Spector, M (1978) Concepts of reduction in physical science. Temple University Press, Philadelphia
- Stegmüller, W (1976) The structure and dynamics of theories. Springer-Verlag, New York
- Thagard, P (1992) Conceptual revolutions. Princeton University Press, Princeton
- A Structural Analysis of the Phlogiston Case
Volume 70, Issue 3 , pp 331-364
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Maria Caamaño (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Departamento de Filosofía, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Plaza del Campus s/n, 47005, Valladolid, Spain