, Volume 22, Issue 1-2, pp 35-102
Date: 26 Mar 2011

The Plea of Alibi in International Criminal Law as Viewed Through the Prism of the Common Law

Rent the article at a discount

Rent now

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access

Abstract

The plea of alibi has acquired a prominent place in the short history of modern international criminal law, just as it does in common law criminal trials. At the ICTR, for instance, it is pleaded in virtually every case. It is expected that alibi will continue to vex the processes of international criminal courts and tribunals, especially given the exclusive focus of international criminal law on individual criminal responsibility, much of which has to do with the presence of accused persons at scenes of planning, conspiracy, instigation, aiding and abetting and execution of crimes. The plea of alibi in international criminal law is still a concept under construction. Jurisprudence is rife with uncertain propositions, tentative analyses and incomplete ideas. In the circumstances, there is a need to pay close attention to this area of the law. A constant review is required, with the aim of improving the law of alibi for its future application in international criminal proceedings. An attempt at such a review is made in the present article. The author reviews, among other things, the meaning of the term ‘alibi’; whether it is a ‘defence’; the feature of notice of alibi; burdens of proof in alibi cases, the prosecutorial duty to disprove the alibi, the need for clarity in the application of the principle of prosecutorial duty to disprove the alibi, and whether there should be a prosecutorial duty to investigate the alibi when timely notice is given; as well as alibi and the right to silence. The author approaches the discussions from the perspective of the common law, primarily due to the prominence of the plea of alibi in common law criminal trials in contrast to inquisitorial criminal trials.

Of the Bars of Ontario and Nigeria; also called to the Bar of British Columbia. Head of Chambers, International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda; formerly senior prosecution appeals counsel, Special Court for Sierra Leone; formerly senior prosecution trial counsel, International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda; and formerly senior legal officer in the Chambers of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. I would like to thank Roger S Clerk for his valuable comments on the paper.