Sustainable Consumption Governance: A History of Promises and Failures Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Fuchs, D.A. & Lorek, S. J Consum Policy (2005) 28: 261. doi:10.1007/s10603-005-8490-z Abstract
What are the implications of the current international political, and economic settings for consumer policy, and, in particular, those regarding sustainable consumption? In terms of improvements in the efficiency of consumption, the settings have induced efforts to this effect and show potential for further progress. In terms of necessary changes in consumption levels and patterns, however, little progress has been made since the Rio Summit nor is there likely to be any in the near future. These two dimensions of sustainable consumption need to be differentiated, as there is a substantial amount of controversy regarding our ability to achieve sustainable consumption on the basis of improvements in efficiency alone. The paper traces these differences with respect to the work of the major international governmental organizations (IGOs) engaged in developing sustainable consumption governance. It argues that the lack of commitment to strong sustainable consumption among IGOs can be explained by their “weakness” as actors in global governance and the existence of strong opposing interests among consumers and business actors.
References Bentley, M. 2000Global consumer class report: In search of common ground for common good United Nations Environmental Programme Paris Google Scholar
Bentley, M., & de Leeuw, B. (2000).
Sustainable consumption indicators. Report for UNEP DTIE. Paris: United Nations Environmental Programme Bruijn, T. Tukker, A. eds. 2002 Partnership and leadership: Building alliances for a sustainable future Kluwer Dordrecht Google Scholar Charkiewicz, E., Bennekom, S., Young, A. 2001Transitions to sustainable consumption and production: Concepts, policies, and actions Shaker Maastricht Google Scholar Charter, M., Polonsky, M. J. 1999Greener marketing Greenleaf Sheffield Google Scholar Clapp, J. 1998 The privatization of global environmental governance Global Governance 4 295 316 Google Scholar Daly, H. 1998 Consumption: The economics of value added and the ethics of value distributed Westra, L. Werhane, P. eds. The business of consumption Rowman & Littlefield Lanham, MD 461 467 Google Scholar Diehl, P. eds. 1997 The politics of global governance. International organizations in an interdependent world Lynne Rienner Boulder, CO Google Scholar Dowty, A., Loescher, G. 1999 Changing norms in international responses to domestic disorder Väyrynen, R. eds. Globalization and global governance Rowman & Littlefield Lanham, MD 199 221 Google Scholar European Association of Communications Agencies & World Federation of Advertisers 2002Industry as a partner for sustainable development. Advertising EACA & WFA Brussels Google Scholar Finnemore, M., Sikkink, K. 1998 International norm dynamics and political change International Organization 52 887 917 CrossRef Google Scholar Friends of the Earth International 1997Sustainable consumption – A global perspective Friends of the Earth Amsterdam Google Scholar Fuchs, D. 2005Understanding business power in global governance Nomos Baden-Baden Google Scholar
Fuchs, D., & Lorek, S. (2001).
An inquiry into the impact of globalization on the potential for “sustainable consumption” in households. Oslo: Programme for Research and Documentation for a Sustainable Society (ProSus), University of Oslo. Report No. 2/01 Fuchs, D., Lorek, S. 2002 Sustainable consumption governance in a globalizing world Global Environmental Politics 2 19 45 CrossRef Google Scholar
Fuchs, D., & Lorek, S. (2004).
Sustainable consumption: Political debate and actual impact. Vienna: Sustainable Europe Research Institute. SERI Working Paper 4 Fuchs, D., Mazmanian, D. 1998 The greening of industry: Needs of the field Business Strategy and the Environment 7 193 203 CrossRef Google Scholar Gatersleben, B., Vlek, C. 1998 Household consumption, quality of life, and environmental impacts: A psychological perspective and empirical study Noorman, K. Schoot Uiterkamp, T. eds. Green households? Domestic consumers, environment, and sustainability Earthscan London 141 183 Google Scholar Georg, S. 1999 The social shaping of household consumption Ecological Economics 28 455 466 CrossRef Google Scholar Gibson, R. eds. 1999 Voluntary initiatives Broadview Press Peterborough Google Scholar Grande, E. 2001 Die neue Unregierbarkeit: Globalisierung und die Grenzen des Regierens jenseits des Nationalstaats Technische Universität, Lehrstuhl für Politische Wissenschaft München Google Scholar Greening, L. A., Green, D. L., Difiglio, C. 2000 Energy efficiency and consumption – The rebound effect – A survey Energy Policy 28 389 401 CrossRef Google Scholar Holliday, C., Schmidheiny, S., Watts, P. 2002Walking the talk. The business case for sustainable development Greenleaf Sheffield Google Scholar ICSPAC 2002Waiting for delivery Integrative Strategies Forum Rockville, MD Google Scholar IIED 1997Unlocking trade opportunities: Changing consumption and production patterns International Institute for Environment and Development London Google Scholar IIED 1998 Consumption in a sustainable world (Kabelvag Report) International Institute for Environment and Development Oslo Google Scholar Langhorne, R. 2001The coming of globalization. Its evolution and contemporary consequences Palgrave Houndmills, UK Google Scholar Lorek, S., Spangenberg, J. H. 2001 Indicators for environmentally sustainable household consumption International Journal of Sustainable Development 4 101 120 CrossRef Google Scholar Messner, D., Nuscheler, F. 1996 Global governance. Challenges to German politics on the threshold of the twenty-first century Development and Peace Foundation Bonn Google Scholar Messner, D., Nuscheler, F. 2003 Das Konzept Global Governance. Stand und Perspektiven Institut für Entwicklung und Frieden Duisburg Google Scholar
Ministry of Environment Norway (1994).
Report of the Sustainable Consumption Symposium. Oslo: Ministry of the Environment Norway
Ministry of Environment Norway (1995).
Report of the Oslo Ministerial Roundtable. Oslo: Ministry of the Environment Norway OECD 1997Sustainable consumption and production: Clarifying the concepts Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Paris Google Scholar OECD 1998Towards sustainable development – Environmental indicators Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Devclopment Paris Google Scholar OECD 1999Towards more sustainable household consumption patterns – Indicators to measure progress Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Paris Google Scholar OECD 2002aTowards sustainable household consumption? Trends and policies in OECD countries Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Paris Google Scholar OECD 2002bInformation and consumer decision-making for sustainable consumption Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Paris Google Scholar Princen, T. 1999 Consumption and environment: Some conceptual issues Ecological Economics 31 347 363 CrossRef Google Scholar Princen, T. 2003 Principles for sustainability: From cooperation and efficiency to sufficiency Global Environmental Politics 3 33 50 CrossRef Google Scholar Qureshi, A. 1996The World Trade Organization: Implementing international trade norms Manchester University Press Manchester Google Scholar Reisch, L., Scherhorn, G. 1999 Sustainable consumption Dahiya, S. B. eds. The current state of economic science Spellbound Rhotak 657 690 Google Scholar Røpke, I. 1999 The dynamics of willingness to consume Ecological Economics 28 399 420 CrossRef Google Scholar Røpke, I. 2001 New technology in everyday life – Social processes and environmental impact Ecological Economics 38 403 322 CrossRef Google Scholar Rosenau, J. Czempiel, E. O. eds. 1992Governance without government: Order and change in world politics Cambridge University Press Cambridge Google Scholar Scholte, J. A. 2000Globalization. A critical introduction Macmillan Basingstoke Google Scholar Schor, J. 1998The overspent American. Upscaling, downshifting, and the new consumer Basic Books New York Google Scholar Schrader, U. 1999 Consumer acceptance of eco-efficient services. A German perspective Greener Management International 25 105 121 Google Scholar Smart, B. 1992Beyond compliance: A new industry view of the environment World Resources Institute Washington Google Scholar Spangenberg, J. H. eds. 1995 Towards sustainable Europe Friends of the Earth Publications Luton/Bedfordshire Google Scholar Spangenberg, J. H., Lorek, S. 2002 Environmentally sustainable household consumption: From aggregate environmental pressures to priority fields of action Ecological Economics 43 127 140 CrossRef Google Scholar Thomas, C. 2000Global governance, development and human security Pluto Press London Google Scholar UN 1993Earth Summit: Agenda 21 – The United Nations programme of action from Rio United Nations New York Google Scholar
Changing consumption patterns – Report of the Secretary-General. New York: United Nations
Comprehensive review of changing consumption and production patterns – Report of the Secretary-General. New York: United Nations
Changing consumption patterns – Report of the Secretary-General. New York: United Nations UNCHS 1997Changing consumption patterns in human settlements United Nation Commission on Human Settlement Nairobi Google Scholar UNDESA 1995International work programme on changing consumption and production patterns United Nations New York Google Scholar UNDESA 1998Measuring changes in consumption and production patterns. A set of indicators United Nations New York Google Scholar UNDESA 1999Trends in consumption and production: Household energy consumption United Nations New York Google Scholar UNDESA 2003Survey of international activities on consumption and production patterns United Nations New York Google Scholar
Human Development Report 1998. New York: United Nations Development Programme UNECE 1998Recommendations to ECE governments on encouraging local initiatives towards sustainable consumption patterns United Nations Economic and Social Council Aarhus Google Scholar UNEP 2001Consumption opportunities. Strategies for change. A report for decision-makers United Nations Environmental Programme Paris Google Scholar
A global status report. Paris: United Nations Environmental Programme
Sustainable consumption and production: Creating opportunities in a changing world. Report of the 4th International Business Forum. Berlin: Carl Duisberg Gesellschaft UNEP/CI 2002Tracking progress: Implementing sustainable consumption policies United Nations Environmental Programme Nairobi Google Scholar UN/WSSD 2002Plan of implementation United Nations New York Google Scholar WBSCD 1996Sustainable development and production: A business perspective World Business Council for Sustainable Development Geneva Google Scholar WBSCD 1999Sustainability through the market World Business Council for Sustainable Development Geneva Google Scholar WBCSD 2002The business case for sustainable development World Business Council for Sustainable Development Geneva Google Scholar Worldwatch 2004State of the world 2004 Worldwatch Institute Washington, DC Google Scholar