Ethical Considerations in Rural Health Care: A Pilot Study of Clinicians in Alaska and New Mexico
Cite this article as: Warner, T.D., Monaghan-Geernaert, P., Battaglia, J. et al. Community Ment Health J (2005) 41: 21. doi:10.1007/s10597-005-2597-1 Abstract
To investigate differences in the experiences of rural versus non-rural clinicians, we surveyed caregivers in New Mexico and Alaska regarding ethical aspects of care provision. Consistent with past literature, rural compared to non-rural clinicians perceived patients as having less access to health care resources. They reported more interaction with patients and less awkwardness in relationships with their patients outside of work. Rural clinicians also reported their patients expressed more concern about knowing them in both personal and professional roles, had more concerns over confidentiality, and experienced more embarrassment concerning stigmatizing illnesses. Ethical issues and implications of these results for providing care in rural areas are discussed.
Keywords rural ethics health care confidentiality stigma References Bushy, A., Rauh, J. R. 1991 Implementing an ethics committee in rural institutions Journal of Nursing Administration 21 18 25 PubMed Google Scholar Conger, R., Elder, G. 1994Families in Troubled Times: Adapting to Change in Rural America Aldine de Gruyter New York Google Scholar Leon, P. H., Wakefield, M., Schultz, A. J., Williams, J., Bos, G. R. 1989 Rural America Unique opportunities for health care delivery and health services research American Psychology 44 1298 1306 CrossRef Google Scholar Flax, J. W., Ivens, R. E., Wagenfeld, M. O., Weiss, R. J. 1978 Mental health and rural America: An overview Community Mental Health Review 3 3 15 Google Scholar Geyman, J. P., Hart, L. G., Norris, T. E., Coombs, J. B., Lishner, D. M. 2000 Educating generalist physicians for rural practice: How are we doing Journal of Rural Health 16 56 80 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Glusker, P 1989 Ethical decisions in small hospitals Annals Internal Medicine 110 413 Google Scholar Kane, C. F., Ennis, J. M. 1996 Health care reform and rural mental health: severe mental illness Community Mental Health Journal 32 445 462 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Mulder, P. L., Kenkel, M. B., Shellenberger, S., Constantine, M. G., Streiegel, S., Sears, F. S., Jumper-Thurman, P., Kalodner, M., Danda, C. E., Hagar, A. 2000The behavioral health care needs of rural women American Psychological Association Washington, DC Google Scholar Mutel, C., Donham, K. 1983Medical Practice in Rural Communities Springer-Verlag New York, NY Google Scholar Niemira, D. A. 1988 Grassroots grappling: Ethics committees at rural hospitals Annals of Internal Medicine 15 981 983 Google Scholar
Purtilo, R., & Sorrell, J. (1986). The ethical dilemmas of a rural physician. Hasting Center Report, 27–28.
Ricketts, T. C. 1999Rural Health in the United States Oxford University Press New York Google Scholar Ricketts, T. C. 2000 The changing nature of rural health care Annual Review of Public Health 21 639 657 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Roberts, L., Battaglia, J., Epstein, R S. 1999 Frontier ethics: mental health care needs and ethical dilemmas in rural communities Psychiatric Services 50 497 503 PubMed Google Scholar Roberts, L., Battaglia, J., Smithpeter, M., Epstein, R. S. 1999 An oce on Main Street Health care dilemmas in small communities Hastings Center Report 29 28 37 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Roberts, LW, Warner, TD, Brody, J, Monaghan, P, Smrcka, J, Nguyen, K, et al. 2001 Stigma, ethics and the frontier Challenges in caring for people with serious illnesses in Alaska and New Mexico Arctic Research of the United States 15 2 13 Google Scholar Robertson, E. Sloboda, Z. Boyd, G. Beatty, L. Kozel, N. eds. 1997NIDA Research Monograph 168. Rural Substance Abuse: State of Knowledge and Issues Department of Health and Human Services Bethesda, MD Google Scholar Rost, K. 1998 Rural-urban dierences in depression treatment and suicidality Medical Care 36 1098 1107 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
Rural Information Center Health Service. (2003).
Rural Health Statistics: Rural Information Center Health Service.
Rural Policy Research Institute. (2003). Rural by the Numbers. Rural Policy Research Institute.
Shelton, D., Frank, R. 1995 Rural mental health coverage under health care reform Community Mental Health Journal 31 539 551 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Thurston-Hicks, A., Paine, S., Hollifield, M. 1998 Functional impairment associated with psychological distress and medical severity in rural primary care patients Psychiatric Services 49 951 955 PubMed Google Scholar Ullom-Minnich, P. D., Kallail, K. J. 1993 Physicians’ strategies for safeguarding confidentiality: the influence of community and practice characteristics Journal of Family Practice 37 445 448 PubMed Google Scholar Wagenfeld, M.O., Murray, J.D., Mohatt, D.F., Bruyn, J.C. 1993 Mental health service delivery in rural areas: Organizational and clinical issues NIDA Res Monograph 168 418 437 Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005