Case Studies of Ethics Scandals: Effects on Ethical Perceptions of Finance Students
Cite this article as: Cagle, J.A.B. & Baucus, M.S. J Bus Ethics (2006) 64: 213. doi:10.1007/s10551-005-8503-5 Abstract
Ethics instructors often use cases to help students understand ethics within a corporate context, but we need to know more about the impact a case-based pedagogy has on students’ ability to make ethical decisions. We used a pre- and post-test methodology to assess the effect of using cases to teach ethics in a finance course. We also wanted to determine whether recent corporate ethics scandals might have impacted students’ perceptions of the importance and prevalence of ethics in business, so we used in-depth case studies of several of the major scandals (e.g., Enron, Tyco, Adelphia). Our results are somewhat surprising since studying ethics scandals positively impacts students’ ethical decision making and their perceptions of the ethics of businesspeople.
Keywords Case pedagogy case studies corporate misconduct ethics ethics across the curriculum ethics scandals ethics training teaching ethics References Ahmed, M. M., Chung, K., Eichenseher, J. W. 2003 ‘Business Students’ Perception of Ethics and Moral Judgment: A Cross-Cultural Study’ Journal of Business Ethics 43 89 102 CrossRef Google Scholar Ang, James 1993 ‘On Financial Ethics’ Financial Management 22 32 60 Google Scholar
Baucus, S. Melissa and L. Paula Rechner: 1995, ‘Framing and Reframing: A Process Model of Ethical Decision Making’,
International Association of Business and Society Proceedings, 2–7. Baumhart, R. C. 1961 ‘How Ethical Are Businessmen?’ Harvard Business Review 39 6 25 Google Scholar Borkowski, S. C., Ugras, Y. J. 1992 ‘The Ethical Attitudes of Students as a Function of Age, Sex, and Experience’ Journal of Business Ethics 11 63 69 CrossRef Google Scholar
Brenner, S. N. and E. A. Molander: 1977, ‘Is the Ethics of Business Changing?’,
Harvard Business Review, January/February, 57–71. Byerly, R. T., Dave, D., Medlin, B. D. 2002 ‘Ethics in Business Program Curricula: An Empirical Investigation of the Attitudes and Perceptions of United States Students’ International Journal of Management 19 357 365 Google Scholar Cole, B. C., Smith, D. L. 1996 ‘Perceptions of Business Ethics: Students vs. Business People’ Journal of Business Ethics 15, 889 896 CrossRef Google Scholar Cole, B. C., Smith, D. L. 1995 ‘Effects of Ethics Instruction on the Ethical Perceptions of College Business Students’ Journal of Education for Business 70 351 357 Google Scholar DesJardins, J. R., Diedrich, E. 2003 ‘Learning What It Really Costs: Teaching Business Ethics With Life-Cycle Case Studies’ Journal of Business Ethics 48 33 42 CrossRef Google Scholar
Feldman, H. D. and R. C. Thompson: 1990, ‘Teaching Business Ethics: A Challenge for Business Educations in the 1990s’,
Journal of Marketing Education , Summer, 10–22. Ford, R., Richardson, W. 1994 ‘Ethical Decision Making: A Review of the Empirical Literature’ Journal of Business Ethics 13 205 221 CrossRef Google Scholar Froelich, K. S., Kottke, J. L. 1991 ‘Measuring Individual Beliefs About Organizational Ethics’ Educational and Psychological Measurement 51 377 383 Google Scholar Gandz, J., Hayes, N. 1988 ‘Teaching Business Ethics’ Journal of Business Ethics 7 657 669 CrossRef Google Scholar George, R. J. 1987 ‘Teaching Business Ethics: Is There a Gap Between Rhetoric and Reality?’ Journal of Business Ethics 6 513 518 Google Scholar Gilligan, C. 1982In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA Google Scholar Green, S., Weber, J. 1997 ‘Influencing Ethical Development: Exposing Students to the AICPA Code of Conduct’ Journal of Business Ethics 16 777 790 CrossRef Google Scholar
Hess, D. W. and C. S. Norman: 2004, ‘Teaching Ethics in Investment Classes: A Series of Vignettes’, Journal of Financial Education, (Spring), 41–60.
Jones, E. E., Nisbett, R. E. 1971The Actor and the Observer: Divergent Perceptions of the Causes of Behavior General Learning Press Morristown, NJ Google Scholar Kohlberg, L. 1981Essays in Moral Development, Volume I: The Philosophy of Moral Development Harper and Row New York Google Scholar Kohlberg, L. 1984Essays in Moral Development, Volume II: The Philosophy of Moral Development Harper and Row New York Google Scholar Kumar, K., Borycki, C., Nonis, S. A., Yauger, C. 1991 ‘The Strategic Decision Framework: Effect on Students’ Business Ethics’ Journal of Education for Business 67 74 79 Google Scholar Langenderfer, H. Q., Rockness, J. W. 1989 ‘Integrating Ethics into the Accounting Curriculum: Issues, Problems, and Solutions’ Issues in Accounting Education 4 58 69 Google Scholar Luthar, H. K., DiBattista, R. A., Gautschi, T. 1997 ‘Perception of What the Ethical Climate Is and What It Should Be: The Role of Gender, Academic Status, and Ethical Education’ Journal of Business Ethics 16 205 217 CrossRef Google Scholar
Manley, G. G., C. J. Russell and M. R. Buckley: 2001, ‘Self-Enhancing in Perceptions of Behaving Unethically ’, Journal of Education for Business, (September/October), 21–27.
Mathison, D. L. 1988 ‘Business Ethics Cases and Decision Models: A Call for Relevancy in the Classroom’ Journal of Business Ethics 7 777 782 CrossRef Google Scholar McCabe, D. L., Dukerich, J. M., Dutton, J. E. 1991 ‘Context, Values and Moral Dilemmas: Comparing the Choices of Business and Law School Students’ Journal of Business Ethics 10 951 960 CrossRef Google Scholar McCabe, D. L., Dukerich, J. M., Dutton, J. E. 1994 ‘The Effects of Professional Education on Values and the Resolution of Ethical Dilemmas: Business School vs. Law School Students’ Journal of Business Ethics 13 693 700 CrossRef Google Scholar Parsa, F., Lankford, W. M. 1999 ‘Students’ View of Business Ethics: An Analysis’ Journal of Applied Social Psychology 29 1045 1057 Google Scholar Rest, J. 1986Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory Praeger New York Google Scholar Roderick, J. C., Jelley, H. M., Cook, J. R., Forcht, K. A. 1991 ‘The Issue of White Collar Crime for Collegiate Schools of Business’ Journal of Education for Business 66 287 290 Google Scholar Schlaefli, A., Rest, J. R., Thoma, S. J. 1985 ‘Does Moral Education Improve Moral Judgment? A Meta-Analysis of Intervention Studies Using the Defining Issues Test’ Review of Educational Research 55 319 352 Google Scholar Shannon, J. R., Berl, R. L. 1997 ‘Are We Teaching Ethics in Marketing?: A Survey of Students’ Attitudes and Perceptions’ Journal of Business Ethics 16 1059 1075 CrossRef Google Scholar Strong, V. K., Hoffman, A. N. 1990 ‘There is Relevance in the Classroom: Analysis of Present Methods of Teaching Business Ethics’ Journal of Business Ethics 9 603 607 CrossRef Google Scholar
Thoma, S. J.: 1985, ‘On Improving the Relationship Between Moral Judgment and External Criteria: The Utilizer/Non-untilizer Dimension’, unpublished dissertation, University of Minnesota.
Waerneryd, K. E., Westlund, K. 1993 ‘Ethics and Economic Affairs in the World of Finance’ Journal of Economic Psychology 14 523 539 Google Scholar Welton, R. E., Lagrone, R. M., Davis, J. R. 1994 ‘Promoting the Moral Development of Accounting Graduate Students: An Instructional Design and Assessment’ Accounting Education 3 35 50 Google Scholar