A Multi-Centre Investigation Towards Reaching a Consensus on the Immunohistochemical Detection of ERβ in Archival Formalin-ﬁxed Paraffin Embedded Human Breast Tissue
Cite this article as: Carder, P.J., Murphy, C.E., Dervan, P. et al. Breast Cancer Res Treat (2005) 92: 287. doi:10.1007/s10549-004-4262-8 Summary
Estrogen receptor (ER) α is a well-established independent prognostic factor in breast cancer whose presence determines the clinical implications of adjuvant endocrine therapy. A second receptor, ERb has been described, and a number of studies have examined its expression in breast tissue. However elucidation of the role played by ERb has been hampered by published immunohistochemical studies employing a variety of protocols and scoring systems such that inter-laboratory comparisons are difficult. Here we present a multi-centre study designed to critically evaluate inter-laboratory differences in methodology. Six UK and Irish centres participated in this study. A small series of breast cancers were stained using centre-speciﬁc laboratory protocols and scored using both centrespeciﬁc and standard scoring protocols. There was generally poor agreement as to what constituted a positive or negative case when centre-speciﬁc scoring systems were used with less than half of all cases in agreement. Concordance was improved when a standard scoring system was used but varied according to threshold for positivity employed and primary antibody. Our results emphasise the need for further studies addressing the role of ERb to be based on a wider consensus on criteria for positivity. Ideally this should be based on calibration against clinical outcome.
Keywords breast cancer estrogen receptor β immunohistochemistry References Kuiper, GGJM, Enmark, E, Pelto-Huikko, M, Nilsson, S, Gustafsson, J-A 1996 Cloning of a novel estrogen receptor expressed in rat prostate and ovary Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 93 5925 5930 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Mosselman, S, Polman, J, Dijkema, R 1996 ER-β: identification and characterisation of a novel human estrogen receptor FEBS Lett 392 49 53 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Tremblay, GB, Tremblay, A, Copeland, NG, Gilbert, DJ, Jenkins, NA, Labrie, F, Giguere, V 1997 Cloning, chromosomal localization, and functional analysis of the murine estrogen receptor β Mol Endocrinol 11 353 365 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Saunders, PT, Millar, MR, Williams, K, Macpherson, S, Harkiss, D, Anderson, RA, Orr, B, Groome, NP, Scobie, G, Fraser, HM 2000 Differential expression of estrogen receptor -α and -β and androgen receptor in the ovaries of marmosets and humans Biol Rep 63 1098 1105 Google Scholar Speirs, V, Adams, IP, Walton, DS, Atkin, SL 2000 Identification of wild type and exon 5 deletion variants of estrogen receptor β in normal human mammary gland J Clin Endo Metab 85 1601 1605 CrossRef Google Scholar Pelletier, G, El-Alfy, M 2000 Immunocytochemical localization of estrogen receptors alpha and beta in the human reproductive organs J Clin Endocrinol Metab 85 4835 4840 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Braidman, IP, Hainey, L, Batra, G, Selby, PL, Saunders, PT, Hoyland, JA 2001 Localisation of estrogen receptor beta protein expression in adult human bone J Bone Miner Res 16 214 220 PubMed Google Scholar Leav, I, Lau, KM, Adams, JY, McNeal, JE, Taplin, ME, Wang, J, Singh, H, Ho, SM 2001 Comparative studies of the estrogen receptors β and α and the androgen receptor in normal prostate glands, dysplasia and in primary and metastatic carcinoma Am J Pathol 159 79 92 PubMed Google Scholar Akgun, H, Lechago, J, Younes, M 2002 Estrogen receptor-β is expressed in Barrett’s metaplasia and associated adenocarcinoma of the esophagus Anticancer Res 22 1459 1461 PubMed Google Scholar Critchley, HO, Henderson, TA, Kelly, RW, Scobie, GS, Evans, LR, Groome, NP, Saunders, PT 2002 Wild-type estrogen receptor (ERβ1) and the splice variant (ERβcx/β2) are both expressed within the human endometrium throughout the normal menstrual cycle J Clin Endocrinol Metab 87 5265 5273 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Palmieri, C, Cheng, GJ, Saji, S, Zelada-Hedman, M, Warri, A, Weihua, Z, Van Noorden, S, Wahlstrom, T, Coombes, RC, Warner, M, Gustafsson, JA 2002 Estrogen receptor beta in breast cancer Endocr Relat Cancer 9 1 13 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Saunders, PT, Millar, MR, Macpherson, S, Irvine, DS, Groome, NP, Evans, LR, Sharpe, RM, Scobie, GA 2002 ERβ1 and ERβ2 splice variant (ERβcx/β2) are expressed in distinct cell populations in the adult human testis J Clin Endocrinol Metab 87 2706 2715 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Stabile, LP, Davis, AL, Gubish, CT, Hopkins, TM, Luketich, JD, Christie, N, Finkelstein, S, Siegfried, JM 2002 Human non-small cell lung tumors and cells derived from normal lung express both estrogen receptor alpha and beta and show biological responses to estrogen Cancer Res 62 2141 2150 PubMed Google Scholar Pais, V, Leav, I, Lau, KM, Jiang, Z, Ho, SM 2003 Estrogen receptor-beta expression in human testicular germ cell tumors Clin Cancer Res 9 4475 4482 PubMed Google Scholar Konstantinopoulos, PA, Kominea, A, Vandoros, G, Sykiotis, GP, Andricopoulos, P, Varakis, I, Sotiropoulou-Bonikou, G, Papavassiliou, AG 2003 Oestrogen receptor beta (ERβ) is abundantly expressed in normal colonic mucosa, but declines in colon adenocarcinoma paralleling the tumour’s dedifferentiation Eur J Cancer 39 1251 1258 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Harvey, JM, Clark, GM, Osborne, CK, Allred, DC 1999 Estrogen receptor status by immunohistochemistry is superior to the ligand-binding assay for predicting response to adjuvant endocrine therapy in breast cancer J Clin Oncol 17 1474 1481 PubMed Google Scholar Jensen, EV, Cheng, G, Palmieri, C, Saji, S, Makela, S, Noorden, S, Wahlstrom, T, Warner, M, Coombes, RC, Gustafsson, JA 2001 Estrogen receptors and proliferation markers in primary and recurrent breast cancer Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98 15197 15202 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Roger, P, Sahla, ME, Makela, S, Gustafsson, JA, Baldet, P, Rochefort, H 2001 Decreased expression of estrogen receptor β protein in proliferative preinvasive mammary tumours Cancer Res 61 2537 2541 PubMed Google Scholar Skliris, GP, Carder, PJ, Lansdown, MR, Speirs, V 2001 Immunohistochemical detection of ERβ in breast cancer: towards more detailed receptor profiling Br J Cancer 84 1095 1098 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Speirs, V, Skliris, GP, Burdall, SE, Carder, PJ 2002 Distinct expression patterns of ERα and ERβ in normal human mammary gland J Clin Path 55 371 374 PubMed Google Scholar Saunders, PT, Millar, MR, Williams, K, Macpherson, S, Bayne, C, O’Sullivan, C, Anderson, TJ, Groome, NP, Miller, WR 2002 Expression of oestrogen receptor β (ERβ1) protein in human breast cancer biopsies Br J Cancer 86 250 256 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Shaw, JA, Udokang, K, Mosquera, JM, Chauhan, H, Jones, JL, Walker, RA 2002 Oestrogen receptors α and β differ in normal human breast and breast carcinomas J Pathol 198 450 457 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Fuqua, SA, Schiff, R, Parra, I, Moore, JT, Mohsin, SK, Osborne, CK, Clark, GM, Allred, DC 2003 Estrogen receptor β protein in human breast cancer: correlation with clinical tumour parameters Cancer Res 63 2343 2439 Google Scholar Shaaban , AM, O’Neill, PA, Davies, MPA, Sibson, R, West, CR, Smith, PH, Foster, CS 2003 Declining estrogen receptor-β expression defines malignant progression of human breast neoplasia Am J Sug Pathol 27 1502 1512 CrossRef Google Scholar Speirs, V 2002 Oestrogen receptor β in breast cancer: good, bad or still too early to tell J Pathol 197 143 147 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Skliris, GP, Parkes, AT, Limer, JL, Burdall, SE, Carder, PJ, Speirs, V 2002 Evaluation of seven oestrogen receptor β antibodies for immunohistochemistry, Western blotting and flow cytometry in human breast tissue J Pathol 197 155 162 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Speirs, V, Carder, PJ, Lansdown, MRJ 2002 Oestrogen receptor β: how should we measure this? Br J Cancer 87 687 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Saunders, PTK, Miller, WR 2002 Author’s reply Reply Br J Cancer 87 688 689 CrossRef Google Scholar Skliris, GP, Munot, K, Bell, SM, Carder, PJ, Lane, S, Horgan, K, Lansdown, MRJ, Parkes, AT, Hanby, AM, Markham, AF, Speirs, V 2003 Reduced expression of oestrogen receptor β in invasive breast cancer and its re-expression using DNA methyltransferase inhibitors in a cell line model J Pathol 201 213 220 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Allred, DC, Harvey, JM, Berado, M, Clark, GM 1998 Prognostic and predictive factors in breast cancer by immunohistochemical analysis Mod Pathol 11 155 168 PubMed Google Scholar Balfe, P, McCann, A, McGoldrick, A, McAllister, K, Kennedy, M, Dervan, P, Kerin, MJ 2004 Estrogen receptor α and β profiling in human breast cancer Eur J Surg Oncol 30 469 474 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Nakopolou, L, Lazaris, AC, Panayotopoulou, , Giannopoulou, Givalos, Markaki, N, Keramopoulos, A 2004 The favourable prognostic expression of oestrogen receptor β immunohistochemical expression in breast cancer J Clin Pathol 57 523 528 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Barnes, DM, Millis, RR, Beex, LVAM, Thorpe, SM, Leake, RE 1998 Increased use of immunohistochemistry of oestrogen receptor measurement in mammary carcinoma: the need for quality assurance Eur J Cancer 34 1677 1682 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Ogawa, S, Inoue, S, Watanabe, T, Orimo, A, Hosoi, T, Ouchi, Y, Muramatsu, M 1998 Molecular cloning and characterization of human estrogen receptor βcx: a potential inhibitor of estrogen action in human Nucleic Acids Res 26 3505 3512 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Moore, JT, McKee, DD, Slentz-Kesler, K, Moore, LB, Jones, SA, Horne, EL, Su, JL, Kliewer, SA, Lehmann, JM, Willson, TM 1998 Cloning and characterization of human estrogen receptor β isoforms Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 247 75 78 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Poola, I 2003 Molecular assays to profile 10 estrogen receptor beta isoform mRNA numbers in ovary, breast, uterus and bone tissues Endocrine 22 101 111 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Miyoshi, Y, Taguchi, T, Gustafsson, JA, Noguchi, S 2001 Clinicopathological characteristics of estrogen receptor-beta-positive breast cancers Jpn J Cancer Res 92 1057 1061 PubMed Google Scholar Poola, I, Clarke, R, DeWitty, R, Lefall, LD 2002 Functionally active estrogen receptor isoform profiles in the breast tumors of African American women are different from the profiles in breast tumors of Caucasian women Cancer 94 615 623 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Leake, R, Barnes, D, Pinder, S, Ellis, I, Anderson, L, Anderson, T, Adamson, R, Rhodes, T, Miller, K, Walker, R 2000 Immunohistochemical detection of steroid receptors in breast cancer: a working protocol J Clin Pathol 53 634 635 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar
Speirs V, Carder PJ, Lane S, Dodwell D, Lansdown MRJ, Hanby AM: Oestrogen receptor β: what it means for patients with breast cancer. Lancet Oncol 5: 174–181, 2004 (Erratum in: Lancet Oncol 5: 208, 2004).