Breast cancer screening barriers and mammography completion in older minority women
Cite this article as: Young, R.F. & Severson, R.K. Breast Cancer Res Treat (2005) 89: 111. doi:10.1007/s10549-004-1476-8 Abstract Objectives. The study tested a behavioral and structural barriers model of breast cancer screening, while seeking to determine age effects of behavioral barriers, in order to identify the factors that inhibit screening among older, minority women. Methods. 405 older African-American women eligible for a federally funded cancer screening program were enrolled in the study. Participants were administered an intake questionnaire and followed for 3 months to determine mammography use. Results. Three months after enrollment in the program, 79% had not received breast cancer screening. The oldest cohort had significantly lower rates of mammography (just 16% of screened women were ≥60, p<0.05). Behavioral barriers (knowledge/information deficits, cancer risk perception, cancer fears) inhibited mammography in the oldest group; their breast cancer information deficits included less knowledge of breast cancer risk, treatment, and survivability (all p<0.001). Conclusions. Older women, with greater breast cancer risk than younger cohorts, should be targeted as a high need population for cancer screening. Even when financial and insurance barriers are removed mammography rates are 1/3 those of women <50. Since failure to be screened is related to knowledge and information barriers, health care providers have the potential to educate their older patients and subsequently increase the likelihood they will have regular cancer screening. Keywords age barriers breast cancer screening race References
Rimer BK: Audiences and messages for breast and cervical cancer screenings. In: Rimer BK (ed) Wellness Perspect 11(2): 13–39, 1995
The NCI Breast Cancer Screening Consortium: Screening mammography: a missed clinical opportunity? Results of the NCI Breast Cancer Screening Consortium and National Health Interview Survey Studies. JAMA 264: 54–58, 1990
Janz, NK, Schottenfeld, D, Doerr, K, et al. 1997 A two-step intervention to increase mammography among women aged 65 and older Am J Public Health 87 1683 1686 PubMed Google Scholar Stoddard, AM, Rimer, BK, Lane, D, et al. 1998 Underusers of mammogram screening: stage of adoption in 5 US Subpopulations. NCI Breast Cancer Screening Consort Prev Med 27 478 PubMed Google Scholar Burack, RC, George, J, Gurney, J 2000 Mammography use among women as a function of age and patient involvement in decision-making J Am Geriatr Soc 48 817 821 PubMed Google Scholar Mandelblatt, JS, Yabroff, KR 2000 Breast and cervical Cancer Screening for Older Women: Recommendations and Challenges for the 21st Century J Am Med Women’s Assoc 55 21 215 Google Scholar O’Malley, MS, Earp, JAL, Harris, RP 1997 Race and mammo-graphy use in two North Carolina Countries Am J Pub Health 87 782 786 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Urban, N, Anderson, G, Peacock, S 1994 Mammography screening: how important is cost as a barrier to use Am J. Pub Health 84 50 55 PubMed Google Scholar Black, BL, Ades, TB 1994 American cancer society urban demonstration projects: models for successful intervention Sem Oncol Nurs 10 96 103 Google Scholar Hughes, C, Lerman, C, Lustbader, E 1996 Ethnic differences in risk perception among women at increased risk for breast cancer Breast Cancer Res Treatment: 40 25 35 Google Scholar Brown, D 1996Cancer Awareness and Behavior Study. Report. Center for Urban Studies, Wayne State University Detroit, MI Google Scholar Suarez, L, Nichols, D, Roche, RA, Simpson, DM 1997 Knowledge, behavior, and fears concerning breast and cervical cancer among older low-income Mexican-American women Am J. Prev Med 13 137 142 PubMed Google Scholar Bradley, CJ, Given, CW, Roberts, C 2002 Race, socioeconomic status, and breast cancer treatment and survival J Nat Cancer Inst 94 490 496 PubMed Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Http://www.hhs.gov/news/press/2002pres/20020221.html.
Smith-Bindman, R, Kerlikowske, K, Gebretsadik, T, Newman, J 2000 Is screening mammography effective in elderly women Am J Med 108 112 119 PubMed Google Scholar Gulitz, E, Bustillo-Hernandez, M, Kent, E 1998 Missed cancer screening opportunities among older women: a review Cancer Practice 6 289 295 PubMed Google Scholar Rimer, BK, Schildkraut, JM, Lerman, C, Lin, TH, Audrain, J 1996 Participation in a women’s breast cancer risk counseling trial Cancer 77 2348 2355 PubMed Google Scholar Glanz, K, Resch, N, Lerman, C, et al. 1992 Factors associated with adherence to breast cancer screening among working women JOM 34 1071 1078 PubMed Google Scholar Lerman, C, Daly, M, Sands, C, et al. 1993 Psychological distress interferes with mammography adherence among women at risk for breast cancer J Nat Cancer Inst 85 1074 1080 PubMed Google Scholar Walter, LC, Covinsky, KE 2001 Cancer screening in elderly patients: a framework for individualized decision making JAMA 285 2750 2756 PubMed Google Scholar
Young RF, Hoey J, Stengle W: Delay/avoidance of mammography after breast cancer education. Meeting: Challenges of Comprehensive Cancer Control Sept. 7, 1999.
Phillips, JM, Cohen, MZ, Moses, G 1999 Breast cancer screening and African-American women: fear, fatalism, & silence. Oncology Nurs Forum 26 561 571 Google Scholar McCaul, KD, Reid, PA, Rathge, RW, Martinson, B 1996 Does concern about breast cancer inhibit or promote breast cancer screening Basic Appl Soc Psych 4 183 194 Google Scholar Gail, MH, Brinton, LA, Byar, DP 1989 Projecting individualized probabilities of developing breast cancer for white females examined annually J Natl Cancer Inst 81 1879 1886 PubMed Google Scholar Jacobellis, J, Cutter, G 2002 Mammography screening and differences in stage of disease by race/ethnicity Am J Public Health 92 1144 1150 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar