Soil seed banks of two montane riparian areas: implications for restoration Article Received: 20 March 2003 Accepted: 12 January 2004 DOI:
Cite this article as: Richter, R. & Stromberg, J.C. Biodivers Conserv (2005) 14: 993. doi:10.1007/s10531-004-7844-1 Abstract
Understanding the role of seed banks can be important for designing restoration projects. Using the seedling emergence method, we investigated the soil seed banks of two montane, deciduous riparian forest ecosystems of southeastern Arizona. We contrasted the seed banks and extant vegetation of Ramsey Canyon, which is the site of riparian restoration activities, with that of Garden Canyon, which has been less affected by human land uses. Fewer plant species were found at Ramsey Canyon than Garden Canyon, for both the seed bank and extant vegetation, and the vegetation at Ramsey Canyon (seed bank and extant) had consistently drier wetland indicator scores. As well, vegetation patterns within sampling zones (channel margins and adjacent riparian forests) differed between canyons. At Garden Canyon channel margins, the seed bank and extant vegetation had relatively high similarity, with herbaceous wetland perennial species dominating. Extant vegetation in the floodplain riparian forest zone at Garden Canyon had a drier wetland indicator score than the seed bank, suggesting that the floodplains are storing seeds dispersed from wetter fluvial surfaces. Vegetation patterns for Ramsey Canyon channel margins were similar to those for Garden Canyon floodplains. Vegetation patterns in the Ramsey Canyon riparian forest zone were indicative of non-flooded conditions with an abundance of upland species in the soil seed bank and extant vegetation. Channel geomorphology measurements indicated that much of the riparian forest zone at Ramsey Canyon is functionally a terrace, a condition that may be a legacy of channel erosion from historic land uses. Steep, erodible channel slopes may contribute to the low seed bank germinant density at Ramsey Canyon channel margins, and narrower flood-prone area may explain the greater terrestrialization of the vegetation in both sampling zones. We recommend testing the use of donor soils from more diverse stream reaches to restore biodiversity levels at Ramsey Canyon, following restoration activities such as channel-widening. Seed banks from Garden Canyon, for example, although predominantly consisting of herbaceous perennials, would supply species with a range of moisture tolerances, life spans, and growth forms. We also recommend that restorationists take care not to harm seed banks exposed during removal of introduced species; at Ramsey Canyon, soil seed banks were equally diverse in areas with high and low cover of the introduced
Vinca major (a legacy of Ramsey Canyon land use). Keywords Channel morphology Diversity Fluvial surface Headwater stream Land use Propagule Restoration Riparian Soil seed banks Vinca major References Abernethy, V.J., Willby, N.J. 1999 Changes along a disturbance gradient in the density and composition of propagule banks in floodplain aquatic habitats Plant Ecology 140 177 190 Google Scholar Archibold, O.W., Brooks, D., Delanoy, L. 1997 An investigation of the invasive shrub European buckthorn, Rhamnus cathartica L., near Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. Canadian Field Naturalist 111 617 621 Google Scholar Barbour, M.G., Burk, J.H., Pitts, W.D. 1999Terrestrial Plant Ecology Benjamin/Cummings Menlo Park, California Google Scholar Baskin, C.C., Baskin, J.M. 1998Seeds: Ecology, Biogeography, and Evolution of Dormancy and Germination Academic Press New York Google Scholar
Boudell J. and Stromberg J.C. Role of seed banks in maintaining biodiversity in a riparian ecosystem:
Hassayampa River, Arizona (in preparation).
Bowers, J.E., McLaughlin, S.P. 1996 Flora of the Huachuca Mountains, a botanically rich and historically significant sky island in Cochise County, Arizona Flora of the Huachuca Mountains, Cochise County, Arizona-Nevada Academy of Sciences 29 66 107 Google Scholar Briggs, M.K. 1996Riparian Ecosystem Recovery in Arid Lands The University of Arizona Press Tucson, Arizona Google Scholar Brown, D.E. eds. 1994Biotic Communities: Southwestern United States and Northwestern Mexico University of Utah Press Salt Lake City, Utah Google Scholar Brown, S.C., Bedford, B.L. 1997 Restoration of wetland vegetation with transplanted wetland soil: an experimental study Wetlands 17 424 437 Google Scholar Burke, D.J. 1997 Donor wetland soil promotes revegetation in wetland trials Restoration and Management Notes 15 168 172 Google Scholar Combroux, I.C.S., Bornette, G., Amoros, C. 2002 Plant regenerative strategies after a major disturbance: The case of a riverine wetland restoration Wetlands 22 234 246 Google Scholar Curtis, J.T., McIntosh, R.P. 1951 An upland forest continuum in the prairie-forest border region of Wisconsin Ecology 32 476 496 Google Scholar Deiller, A.F.J., Walter, M.N., Tremolieres, M. 2001 Effects of flood interruption on species richness, diversity and floristic composition of woody regeneration in the upper Rhine alluvial hardwood forest Regulated Rivers–Research and Management 17 393 405 Google Scholar
Desert Research Institute, Western Regional Climate Center 2001. Historic climate information [online].
Reno, Nevada, USA.Available at http://www.wrcc.dri.edu (verified 29 July 2002).
Finlayson, C.M., Cowie, I.K., Bailey, B.J. 1990 Sediment seedbanks in grassland on the Magela Creek floodplain, northern Australia Aquatic Botany 38 163 176 Google Scholar Goodson, J.M., Gurnell, A.M., Angold, P.G., Morrissey, I.P. 2001 Riparian seed banks: structure process and implications for riparian management Progress in Physical Geography 25 301 325 Google Scholar Goodson, J.M., Gurnell, A.M., Angold, P.G., Morrissey, I.P. 2002 Riparian seed banks along the lower River Dove UK: their structure and ecological implications Geomorphology 47 45 60 Google Scholar Green, R.H. 1979Sampling Design and Statistical Methods for Environmental Biologists John Wiley & Sons New York Google Scholar Grime, J.P. 1974 Vegetation classification by reference to strategies Nature 250 26 31 Google Scholar Hanlon, T.J., Williams, C.E., Moriarity, W.J. 1998 Species composition of soil seed banks of Allegheny Plateau riparian forests Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 125 199 215 Google Scholar Harmon, J.M., Franklin, J.F. 1995 Seed rain and seed bank of third- and fifth-order streams on the western slope of the Cascade RangeResearch Paper PNW-RP-480. Department of Agriculture Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station Portland, Oregon Google Scholar Herbert, R.F., Jackson, W.T., Wee, S.R. 1990 Fort Huachuca, Arizona: A century of development and changing missionsPrepared for U.S. Army Garrison, Fort Huachuca, Arizona, USA Jackson Research Projects Davis, California Google Scholar Holzel, N., Otte, A. 2001 The impact of flooding regime on the soil seed bank of flood-meadows Journal of Vegetation Science 12 209 218 Google Scholar Karwan, D.L., Allan, J.D., Bergen, K.M. 2001 Changing near-stream land use and river channel morphology in the Venezuelan Andes Journal of the American Water Resources Association 37 1579 1587 Google Scholar Kearney, T.H., Peebles, R.H. 1951Arizona Flora University of California Press Berkeley, California Google Scholar Leck, M.A., Parker, V.T., Simpson, R.L. 1989Ecology of Soil Seed Banks Academic Press San Diego, California Google Scholar Leopold, L.B. 1994A View of the River Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts Google Scholar Naiman, R.J. Bilby, R.E. eds. 1998River Ecology and Management Lessons from the Pacific Coastal Ecoregion Springer New York Google Scholar Naiman, R.J., Décamps, H., Pollock, M. 1993 The role of riparian corridors in maintaining regional biodiversity Ecological Applications 3 209 212 Google Scholar Patten, D.T. 1998 Riparian ecosystems of semi-arid North America: diversity and human impacts Wetlands 18 498 512 CrossRef Google Scholar Perger, B. 1996Ramsey Canyon history, 3rd edn. Unpublished report on file at The Nature Conservancy’s Ramsey Canyon Preserve Hereford, Arizona Google Scholar Pettit, N.E., Froend, R.H. 2001 Availability of seed for recruitment of riparian vegetation: a comparison of a tropical and a temperate river ecosystem in Australia Australian Journal of Botany 49 515 528 Google Scholar
Reed Jr. P.B. 1988. National list of plant species that occur in wetlands: southwest (region 7). U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service Biological Report 88(26.7).
Richards, C., Johnson, L.B., Host, G.E. 1996 Landscape-scale influences on stream habitats and biota Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53 295 311 Google Scholar Roberts, H.A. 1981 Seed banks in soils: reserves of viable seeds present in the soil and on its surface Advances in Applied Biology 6 1 55 Google Scholar Rosgen, D., Silvey, L. 1998Field Guide for Stream Classification Wildland Hydrology, Pagosa Springs Colorado Google Scholar Rossell, I.M., Wells, C.L. 1999 The seed banks of a southern Appalachian fen and an adjacent degraded wetland Wetlands 19 365 371 Google Scholar Shaw, H.G. 1999 Garden Canyon watershed–a vision and a missionPrepared for the Department of the Army at Fort Huachuca, Arizona The Juniper Institute Chino Valley, Arizona Google Scholar Stromberg, J.C. 2002 Flood flows and population dynamics of Arizona sycamore ( Platanus wrightii) Western North American Naturalist 62 170 187 Google Scholar Thompson, K. 2000 The functional ecology of soil seed banks Fenner, M. eds. Seeds: The Ecology of Regeneration in Plant Communities, 2nd edn. CAB International New York 215 235 Google Scholar Toledo, Z.O., Kauffman, J.B. 2001 Root biomass in relation to channel morphology of headwater streams Journal of the American Water Resources Association 37 1653 1663 Google Scholar
USDA, NRCS 1999. The PLANTS database, Version 3.1 [online]. National Plant Data Center, Baton
Rouge, Louisiana.Available at http://plants.usda.gov/plants
USGS 2002. Surface-water data for USA [online]. Fort Collins, Colorado. Available at http://waterdata.usgs.gov (verified 29 July 2002).
van der Valk, A.G., Pederson, R.L., Davis, C.B. 1992 Restoration and creation of freshwater wetlands using seed banks Wetlands Ecology and Management 1 191 197 Google Scholar Wentworth, R.W., Johnson, G.P., Kologiski, R.L. 1988 Designation of wetlands by weighted averages of vegetation data: a preliminary evaluation Water Resources Bulletin 24 389 396 Google Scholar Whipple, S.A. 1978 The relationship of buried germinating seeds to vegetation in an old- growth Colorado subalpine forest Canadian Journal of Botany 56 1505 1509 CrossRef Google Scholar
Wilson E.D., Moore R.T. and Cooper J.R. 1969. Geologic map of Arizona. Arizona Bureau of Mines and
the United States Geological Survey.
Wohl, E.E. 2000Mountain Rivers American Geophysical Union Washington, DC Google Scholar Xiong, S.J., Nilsson, C., Johansson, M.E., Jansson, R. 2001 Responses of riparian plants to accumulation of silt and plant litter: the importance of plant traits Journal of Vegetation Science 12 481 490 Google Scholar