The role of ecotourism in conservation: panacea
or Pandora’s box? Article Received: 28 April 2003 Revised: 11 November 2003 Accepted: 11 November 2003 DOI:
Cite this article as: Krüger, O. Biodivers Conserv (2005) 14: 579. doi:10.1007/s10531-004-3917-4 Abstract
Does ecotourism contribute towards conservation of threatened species and habitats or is it just a marketing ploy of the tourism industry? Using 251 case studies on ecotourism from the literature, I looked at the distribution of case studies over continents, habitats and flagship species types and what factors influenced whether an ecotourism regime was perceived as ecologically sustainable by authors. Over 50% of ecotourism case studies were reported from Africa and Central America. The overall distribution of ecotourism case studies did not reflect vertebrate endemism, nor overall tourism distribution in terms of tourist numbers and receipts. There were significant differences between continents and habitats with regard to the proportion of sustainable case studies: ecotourism is perceived to be less sustainable in South America and Asia, and in island and mountain habitats. The type of flagship species also influenced whether ecotourism was classified as sustainable or not: ecotourism with no flagship species was rarely classified as sustainable while charismatic bird and mammal species were associated with a higher probability of sustainability. In a multivariate analysis, flagship species type and local community involvement were important predictors of sustainability in ecotourism. Detailed a priori planning, local involvement and control measures were perceived by authors of case studies to increase the success of ecotourism in conservation. They also perceived that ecotourism can only be an effective conservation tool under certain conditions. If these are met, the evidence indicates that ecotourism can make a contribution to conservation.
Keywords Ecotourism Flagship species Local community Nature-based tourism Sustainability References Aylward, B., Allen, K., Echeverria, J., Tosi, J. 1996 Sustainable ecotourism in Costa Rica: the Monteverde Cloud Forest Preserve Biodiversity and Conservation 5 315 343 CrossRef Google Scholar Beeton, S. 1998Ecotourism: A Practical Guide for Rural Communities Landlinks, Collingwood Australia Google Scholar Boo, E. 1990Ecotourism: The Potentials and Pitfalls. Vol. 1 & 2 WWF Washington, DC. Google Scholar Boo, E. 1991 Planning for ecotourism Parks 2 4 8 Google Scholar Boyle, S.A., Sampson, F.B. 1985 Effects of non-consumptive recreation on wildlife: a review Wildlife Society Bulletin 13 110 116 Google Scholar Brown, G.M., Henry, W. 1993 The economic value of elephants Edwards, G. eds. Economics and Ecology: New Frontiers and Sustainable Development. Chapman & Hall London Google Scholar Budowski, G. 1976 Tourism and conservation: conflictcoexistence or symbiosis? Environmental Conservation 3 27 31 Google Scholar Burnie, D. 1994 Ecotourists to paradise New Scientist 1942 23 27 Google Scholar Butynski, T.M., Kalina, J. 1998 Gorilla tourism: a critical look Milner-Gulland, E.J. Mace, R. eds. Conservation of Biological Resources Blackwell London 294 313 Google Scholar Cater, E. 1994a Introduction Cater, E. Lowman, G. eds. Ecotourism: A Sustainable Option? John Wiley & Sons ChichesterUK 3 17 Google Scholar Cater, E. 1994b Ecotourism in the third world – problems and prospects for sustainability Cater, E. Lowman, G. eds. Ecotourism: A Sustainable Option? John Wiley & Sons ChichesterUK 69 86 Google Scholar Cater, E., Lowman, G. 1994Ecotourism: A Sustainable Option? John Wiley & Sons ChichesterUK Google Scholar Ceballos-Lascurain, H. 1996TourismEcotourismand Protected Areas: The State of Nature-based Tourism Around the World and Guidelines for its Development IUCN CambridgeUK Google Scholar Chi, Y., Luzar, E.J. 1998 An economic analysis of non-consumptive wildlife recreation expenditures Louisiana Rural Economist 60 8 11 Google Scholar Child, B. 1996 The practice and principles of community-based wildlife management in Zimbabwe: the CAMPFIRE programme Biodiversity and Conservation 5 369 398 CrossRef Google Scholar Coburn, B.A. 1984 Sagarmatha: managing a Himalayan World Heritage site Parks 9 10 13 Google Scholar Davis, D., Tisdell, C.A. 1998 Tourist levies and willingness to pay for a whale shark experience Tourism Economics 5 161 174 Google Scholar De Groot, R.S. 1983 Tourism and conservation in the Galapagos Islands Biological Conservation 26 291 300 CrossRef Google Scholar Durbin, J.C., Ratrimoarisaona, S.N. 1996 Can tourism make a major contribution to the conservation of protected areas in Madagascar? Biodiversity and Conservation 5 345 353 CrossRef Google Scholar Fennell, D.A. 1999Ecotourism: An Introduction Routledge London Google Scholar Goodwin, H. 1996 In pursuit of ecotourism Biodiversity and Conservation 5 277 291 CrossRef Google Scholar Gossling, S. 1999 Ecotourism: a means to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem functions? Ecological Economics 29 303 320 CrossRef Google Scholar Groombridge, B. 1992Global Biodiversity Chapman & Hall London Google Scholar Gurung, C.P., De Coursey, M. 1994 The Annapurna Conservation Area Project: a pioneering example of sustainable tourism? Cater, E. Lowman, G. eds. Ecotourism: A Sustainable Option? John Wiley & Sons ChichesterUK 177 194 Google Scholar Heywood, V.H. 1995Global Biodiversity Assessment Cambridge University Press CambridgeUK Google Scholar Hoyt, E. 1996 Whale watching: a global overview of the industry’s rapid growth and some implications and suggestions for Australia Colgan, K. Prasser, S. Jeffery, A. eds. Encounters with Whales, 1995 Proceedings Australian Nature Conservation Agency CanberraAustralia 31 36 Google Scholar Hulme, D., Murphree, M. 2001African Wildlife and Livelihoods James Currey OxfordUK Google Scholar Isaacs, J.C. 2000 The limited potential of ecotourism to contribute to wildlife conservation Wildlife Society Bulletin 28 61 69 Google Scholar Kallen, C. 1990Tourism as a conservation tool Working paperWorld Resources Institute Washington, DC Google Scholar Kenchington, R.A. 1989 Tourism in the Galapagos Islands: the dilemma of conservation Environmental Conservation 16 227 236 Google Scholar King, D.A., Stewart, W.P. 1996 Ecotourism and commodification: protecting people and places Biodiversity and Conservation 5 293 305 CrossRef Google Scholar Kinnaird, M.F., O’Brien, T.G. 1996 Ecotourism in the Tangkoko DuaSudara Nature Reserve: opening Pandora’s box? Oryx 30 65 73 CrossRef Google Scholar Leader-Williams, N. 2002 Animal conservation, carbon and sustainability Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A 360 1787 1806 PubMed Google Scholar Liddle, M.J. 1997Recreation Ecology: The Ecological Impact of Outdoor Recreation and Ecotourism Chapman & Hall London Google Scholar Loon, R.M., Polakow, D. 2001 Ecotourism ventures: rags or riches? Annals of Tourism Research 28 892 907 CrossRef Google Scholar Margoluis, R., Salafsky, N. 1998Measures of Success: Designing, Managing, and Monitoring Conservation and Development Projects Islands Press Washington, DC Google Scholar McNeely, J.A. 1994 Protected areas for the 21st century: working to provide benefits to society Biodiversity and Conservation 3 390 405 CrossRef Google Scholar McNeely, J.A., Miller, K.R., Reid, W.V., Mittermeier, R.A., Werner, T.B. 1990Conserving the World’s Biological Diversity World Bank Washington, DC Google Scholar Moran, D. 1994 Contingent valuation and biodiversity: measuring the user surplus of Kenyan protected areas Biodiversity and Conservation 3 663 684 CrossRef Google Scholar Munn, C.A. 1992 Macaw biology and ecotourismor when a bird in the bush is worth two in the hand Beissinger, S.R. Snyder, N.F.R. eds. New World Parrots in Crisis: Solutions from Conservation Biology Smithsonian Institution Press Washington, DC 47 72 Google Scholar Myers, N. 1972 National Parks in savannah Africa Science 178 1255 1263 PubMed Google Scholar Myers, N., Mittermeier, R.A., Mittermeier, C.G., Da Fonseca, G.A.B., Kent, J. 2000 Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities Nature 403 853 858 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Nolan, M.L., Nolan, S. 1998 Limits to ecotourism growth and sustainability: the Galapagos example Oppermann, M. eds. Pacific Rim Tourism CAB International WallingfordUK 144 155 Google Scholar Perez, M.R., Byron, N. 1999 A methodology to analyze divergent case studies of non-timber forest products and their development potential Forest Science 45 1 14 Google Scholar Place, S.E. 1991 Nature tourism and rural development in Tortuguero Annals of Tourism Research 18 186 201 CrossRef Google Scholar Reid, D.G. 1999Ecotourism Development in Eastern and Southern Africa University of Guelph Press GuelphCanada Google Scholar Ruschmann, D.V.D.M. 1992 Ecological tourism in Brazil Tourism Management 13 125 128 CrossRef Google Scholar Salafsky, N., Margoluis, R. 1999 Threat reduction assessment: a practical and cost-effective approach to evaluating conservation and development projects Conservation Biology 13 830 841 CrossRef Google Scholar Salafsky, N., Cauley, H., Balachander, G., Cordes, B., Parks, J., Margoluis, C., et al. 2001 A systematic test of an enterprise strategy for community-based biodiversity conservation Conservation Biology 15 1585 1595 CrossRef Google Scholar Salewski, V., Göken, F., Korb, J., Schmidt, S. 2000 Has the white-necked rockfowl Picathartes gymnocephala still a chance in LamtoIvory Coast? Bird Conservation International 10 41 46 CrossRef Google Scholar Shackley, M. 1995 The future of gorilla tourism in Rwanda Journal of Sustainable Development 3 61 72 Google Scholar Shackley, M. 1996 Too much room at the inn? Annals of Tourism Research 23 449 462 CrossRef Google Scholar Steele, P. 1995 Ecotourism: an economic analysis Journal of Sustainable Tourism 3 29 44 CrossRef Google Scholar Stiles, G.F., Clark, D.A. 1989 Conservation of tropical rain forest birds: a case study from Costa Rica American Birds 43 420 428 Google Scholar Vickland, K. 1989 New tourists want new destinations Travel and Tourism Executive Report 9 1 4 Google Scholar Vivanco, L.A. 2001 Spectacular quetzals, ecotourismand environmental futures in Monte VerdeCosta Rica Ethnology 40 79 92 Google Scholar Wall, G. 1997 Is ecotourism sustainable? Environmental Management 21 483 491 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Walpole, M.J., Goodwin, H.J., Ward, K.G.R. 2001 Pricing policy for tourism in protected areas: lessons from Komodo National Park, Indonesia Conservation Biology 15 218 227 CrossRef Google Scholar Wearing, S., Neil, J. 1999Ecotourism: Impacts, Potentials and Possibilities Butterworth Heinemann OxfordUK Google Scholar Weaver, D.B. 1991 Alternatives to mass tourism in Dominica Annals of Tourism Research 18 414 432 CrossRef Google Scholar Weaver, D.B. 1998Ecotourism in the Less Developed World CAB International WallingfordUK Google Scholar Wells, M.P. 1992 Biodiversity conservation, affluence and poverty: mismatched costs and benefits and efforts to remedy them Ambio 21 237 243 Google Scholar Wells, M.P. 1993 Neglect of biological riches: the economics of nature tourism in Nepal Biodiversity and Conservation 2 445 464 CrossRef Google Scholar Wheeller, B. 1992 Is progressive tourism appropriate? Tourism Management 13 104 105 CrossRef Google Scholar Wight, P. 1996 North American ecotourists: market profile and trip characteristics Journal of Travel Research 34 2 10 CrossRef Google Scholar Wilson, C., Tisdell, C. 2001 Sea turtles as a non-consumptive tourism resource especially in Australia Tourism Management 22 279 288 CrossRef Google Scholar World Commission on Environment and Development, WCED 1987Our common future Oxford University Press Oxford, UK Google Scholar Zar, J.H. 1999Biostatistical Analysis Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River New Jersey Google Scholar