Life-history traits and potential invasiveness of introduced pumpkinseed Lepomis gibbosus populations in northwestern Europe
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Cucherousset, J., Copp, G.H., Fox, M.G. et al. Biol Invasions (2009) 11: 2171. doi:10.1007/s10530-009-9493-5
- 951 Downloads
To evaluate the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed Lepomis gibbosus introduced to northwestern European inland waters, growth and reproduction traits were examined in ten populations along a trajectory spanning northwestern Europe (Norway, England, Holland, Belgium and France) and evaluated in light of published dataset from Europe. In the 848 pumpkinseed captured, maximum age was 3–4 years, with a sex ratio near unity in all but one population. Significant variations with increasing latitude were observed in adult growth (age 2–3 increment in total length, TL) and mean age at maturity (AM), with non-significant variations observed in juvenile growth (TL at age 2), sex ratio and gonado-somatic index. As observed elsewhere in Europe, mean AM decreased significantly with increasing TL at age 2. Using this relationship, which has been proposed elsewhere as a potential predictive model of pumpkinseed invasiveness, eight of the ten populations could be provisionally categorized as ‘non-invasive’ (five populations), ‘transitional’ (one population) and ‘potentially invasive’ (two populations), with two populations not categorized due to insufficient data. Based on the available knowledge on each population, the relationship between juvenile growth and age at maturity appeared to predict reasonably the status of pumpkinseed in northwestern Europe and its applicability to other species should be tested.
KeywordsReproductionBody conditionLife-history strategyLatitudinal clinesNon-native speciesCentrarchidae
An invasive fish species has been defined as an “indigenous or nonindigenous species that spreads, with or without the aid of humans, in natural or semi-natural habitats, producing a significant change in composition, structure, or ecosystem processes, or cause severe economic losses to human activities” (Copp et al. 2005). Invasive fishes are of increasing concern to the biodiversity and ecosystem integrity of fresh waters (e.g. Vitousek et al. 1997; García-Berthou et al. 2005), and tools to predict species invasiveness are needed (Kolar and Lodge 2001). Life-history traits have been shown to be particularly good predictors of non-native fish establishment success in many cases (e.g. Fausch et al. 2001; Marchetti et al. 2004; Vila-Gispert et al. 2005; Olden et al. 2006), and life-history perspectives are useful for a mechanistic-based understanding of the patterns of fish invasions and species invasiveness (Olden et al. 2006; Ribeiro et al. 2008). Intra-specific variation in life-history traits at large spatial scales (i.e. latitudinal clines) have also been demonstrated, due to the relationship between latitude and temperature. For instance, the decrease in growth and the increase in age at maturity with latitude has been observed in many fish species (Blanck and Lamouroux 2007 and references therein). Because these traits influence species potential invasiveness, latitudinal changes in the invasiveness between populations of a non-native species can be expected across its introduction range. Consequently, more integrative approaches of life-history traits of non-native species along latitudinal clines are needed to assess their potential invasiveness (García-Berthou 2007). Indeed, studies on life-history traits of non-native species usually consider only a limited latitudinal gradient, without the most northerly or southerly populations (e.g. Copp and Fox 2007; Fox et al. 2007; Ribeiro et al. 2008).
Recent applications in the biology of invasive fishes are now addressing the adaptations in life-history traits of non-native fishes in their new environments, in particular the introduction of North American fish species (Fausch et al. 2001; Copp et al. 2004; Vila-Gispert et al. 2005; Copp and Fox 2007; Ribeiro et al. 2008). One of the most successful fish introductions to Europe has been that of the North American centrarchid, pumpkinseed Lepomis gibbosus (L.). Introduced to European inland waters during the late nineteenth century, the pumpkinseed is now established in at least 28 countries of Europe and western Asia Minor (Copp and Fox 2007). Apart from recent studies of pumpkinseed populations in England (Copp et al. 2002; Villeneuve et al. 2005), all previous studies of pumpkinseed growth and life-history under natural thermal conditions have been undertaken in southern and central Europe (Copp et al. 2004; Fox et al. 2007). However, the increased attention to northwestern populations has revealed pumpkinseed to be more widely distributed within countries of northwestern Europe than was previously believed (e.g. Verreycken et al. 2007; Van Kleef et al. 2008), despite the fact that the pumpkinseed is considered a warmwater species. The study of northwestern European populations is especially relevant for understanding how pumpkinseed life-history varies according to local climate across a latitudinal cline, resulting in a different invasive potential. Moreover, using the relationship between age at maturity and juvenile growth, the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed populations can be evaluated (Copp and Fox 2007).
The aim of the present study was to examine the variability of life-history traits of pumpkinseed populations across a latitudinal cline spanning northwestern Europe (southern Norway, northern and southern Netherlands, England, Belgium, northern France) in order to assess the potential invasiveness of the species in northwestern European and compare it with all available European populations (data compiled by Copp and Fox 2007). The specific objectives were to: (1) determine the general biological parameters and test for latitudinal clines in life-history traits of pumpkinseed within northwestern Europe, (2) test for the consistency of latitudinal clines in life history traits of pumpkinseed throughout Europe, and (3) examine the data in light of the model proposed by Copp and Fox (2007) to assess potential invasiveness of northwestern European pumpkinseed populations within a wider European context. Water temperature strongly influences the life-history traits of ectotherms in general (e.g. Atkinson 1994) and of pumpkinseed in particular (Fox and Crivelli 2001; Copp and Fox 2007), and is also negatively correlated with latitude. Consequently, we predicted that northwestern pumpkinseed populations would exhibit decreasing growth rates, increased age at maturity and reduced reproductive investment with increasing latitude and, thus, exhibit a lower invasiveness potential than southern Europe populations where potentially invasive populations have been reported (Fox et al. 2007).
Country, site code, site name, sampling dates, latitude and longitude of pumpkinseed Lepomis gibbosus populations sampling in northwestern Europe
1 July 2006
21 June 2006
22 June 2006
Cottesmore School Pond
8 June 2006
Batts Bridge Stream
8 June 2006
Isle of Wight
15 June 2005
23 June 2006
23 June 2006
14–17 May 2006
19 May 2006
Pumpkinseed were collected in 2005 and 2006 during their spawning period (mainly from mid-May to early July) by various means (electrofishing: EBS, EAP, BHP, BHS, FBM, FGL; netting (because electrofishing was not possible): HSP, HMP; funnel trapping: ECS; angling (due to low water conductivity and dense ligneous debris): NEP; see Table 1 for site codes). Sample size at some sites was restricted due to low pumpkinseed density or reduced sampling efficiency (i.e. NEP and HSP). Captured fish were immediately killed by an overdose of anaesthetic and placed in a slurry of ice water and chilled to freezing.
After defrosting, each specimen was processed according to Fox (1994), which involved measurement for total length (TL, nearest mm) and wet weight (nearest 0.1 g), removal of the gonads by dissection for determination of weight (nearest 0.01 g), sex and determination of maturity status. Female pumpkinseed with ovaries containing non-yolked or indistinguishable eggs were classed as immature, and those with ovaries containing yolked eggs were classed as mature. Scale samples were collected from between the lateral line and dorsal fin of each specimen. Importantly, when sample sizes for a given size-class were large, only a subset of the specimens were aged. Age was determined as per Steinmetz and Müller (1991) using scale impressions on acetate strips, read on a micro-projector (magnification: 47×), with age determination cross-checked using independent readings by a second reader on a sub-sample of specimens. Back-calculation of TL at age was undertaken using the linear relationship between scale radius and TL (Creaser 1926). Back-calculated TL at age estimated from this formula employed a fixed body-scale intercept value of 24 mm so as to reduce bias due to differences in the size distribution used to generate the intercept (Fox and Crivelli 2001). To provide an estimator of juvenile growth rate, we calculated the mean TL at age 2, the earliest age at which female pumpkinseed mature in cool-water populations (Fox 1994). As an estimator of adult growth rate, annual length increment was calculated as the difference in TL between ages 2 and 3, as TL at age 3 was the maximum age found in many of the sample sites.
As described by Ricker (1975, 1979), the linear relationship for TL versus weight was determined using all sampled individuals. Mean body condition factor was calculated according to Copp (2003) using the formula of Le Cren (1951), which requires populations to be sampled during the same period of the year: KLC = w/w’, where w is the observed weight of each individual and w’ is the expected weight using the length–weight relationship (log10W = −a + b log10L, where in this case a = −5.382 and b = 3.341; r2 = 0.9845, df = 847, P = 0.0001). KLC values > 1 or < 1 indicate that the individual is in better or worse condition, respectively, than the average individual of the same TL range. The slope parameter ‘b’ from the regression equation (log10W = b (log10 TL) ± a) was used as an estimator of ‘generalised’ condition (sensu Pitcher and Hart 1982).
Relationships between latitude and life-history traits (i.e., juvenile growth, adult growth, age at maturity, reproductive investment; proposed by Copp et al. 2002) and between age at maturity and juvenile growth were examined using linear regression, initially on the northwestern European data set and subsequently on the entire dataset available for Europe (as compiled by Copp and Fox 2007). The relationship between age at maturity and juvenile growth is used as a means of assessing the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed populations in Europe, whereby the transition phase between non-invasive and potentially invasive pumpkinseed populations is defined at its lower extent by the minimum age at maturity (age 1) and at its upper extent by the end of juvenile growth (which for many pumpkinseed populations is age 2, Fox 1994; Fox and Crivelli 2001; Copp et al. 2004). In this relationship, non-invasive populations of pumpkinseed, such as observed in England (Villeneuve et al. 2005), are characterised by slow juvenile growth (small at age 2) and late maturity. Whereas, potentially invasive pumpkinseed populations, such as reported for southern Europe (Fox et al. 2007), are characterised by fast juvenile growth (large at age 2) and early maturity. In the present study, we identified the position of each pumpkinseed population in northwestern European on the age at maturity versus juvenile growth rate axis, and evaluated whether each population was likely to be ‘non-invasive’, in the ‘transitional’ phase or ‘potentially invasive’ based on its position on the axis and the available knowledge on each population.
For pumpkinseed populations in northwestern Europe, the site (see Table 1 for codes), total number of specimens (nT), sex ratio (number of males ÷ number females); number of specimens subjected to age analysis (nA), the back-calculated TL at age (mm) and annual length increments for ages 1–2 (L1–L2) and 2–3 (L2–L3), mean body condition factor (KLC, Le Cren 1951), generalised condition (b, slope of total length (TL) vs. weight relationship), mean age (AM, in years) and total length (TLM, in mm) at maturity, and mean gonado-somatic index (GSI, in %)
Mean TL at age
Statistics of the linear regressions (y = bx + a) between latitude (lat) and juvenile growth rate (total length at age 2; TLL2), adult growth increment (TLL2–3), age at maturity (AM) and gonado-somatic index (GSI) and between juvenile growth rate and age at maturity of pumpkinseed in northwestern Europe and Europe
Life-history traits, and in particular age at maturity and juvenile growth rate, have been advocated as a means of predicting the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed in Europe (Copp and Fox 2007). As predicted, pumpkinseed populations in northwestern Europe exhibited slower growth with increasing latitude, though this was restricted to the age 2–3 growth interval. This is consistent with the pattern of faster centrarchid growth in warmer waters reported elsewhere (McCauley and Kilgour 1990; Fox and Crivelli 2001). However, juvenile growth was not related to latitude when only the northwestern European populations were considered, whereas a significant relationship was established when the entire Europe level dataset was considered. This discrepancy might support the notion that environmental factors other than temperature become more important when considering a smaller latitudinal range.
The present study extends considerably the latitudinal range of current knowledge on the growth variability of introduced pumpkinseed, providing also information on sex ratio (not reported in previous studies). Sex ratio has been found to be a distinguishing, environmentally-linked character in another species invading northern Europe, the gibel carp Carassius gibelio (Vetemaa et al. 2005). However, in pumpkinseed, a species in which gynogenetic reproduction has not been reported, sex ratio did not vary with latitude in northwestern populations. As well, the present study provides information on pumpkinseed body condition, which has been reported elsewhere in Europe to vary greatly in pumpkinseed according to local conditions (Villeneuve et al. 2005), and this also appears to be the case in the northwestern parts of Europe (Table 2).
Assuming that latitude is an reasonable surrogate measure of general climatic conditions (water temperature and air temperature during the growing season), the results of the present and recent studies (Copp and Fox 2007) suggest that metabolism and growth performance changes with higher water temperature and longer growing seasons (e.g. higher food intake, higher food assimilation efficiency and/or lower energy expenditure; see also Dembski et al. 2006). Also as predicted, pumpkinseed populations in northwestern Europe exhibited a trend of later age at maturity than populations at lower latitude (Table 3), and this relationship was significant when all available data for Europe were included. The latitudinal clines in juvenile growth and age at maturity proposed previously (Copp et al. 2002; Villeneuve et al. 2005) were only partially corroborated in the present study, as juvenile growth was not related to latitude when only the northwestern European populations were considered, nor to gonado-somatic index with either population database. This suggests that age at maturity is a more useful (and reliable) means of assessing, even in smaller data sets such as this (Table 2), the reproductive response of pumpkinseed to environmental variability than other reproductive indices, such as GSI or length at maturity (Copp and Fox 2007). As such, age at maturity should be a good parameter for estimating the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed by virtue of its rapid response to growth potential. Whereas, the lack of relationship between GSI and latitude is in contrast to the initial assessment for pumpkinseed in Europe (Copp et al. 2002). Also, one-off assessments of GSI can misrepresent the true allocation to reproduction (Copp and Fox 2007), since the species is known to spawn over shorter periods, and with fewer batches, in colder water (Fox and Crivelli 2001). Therefore, further investigation of reproductive investment, undertaken throughout the spawning season, is needed to better understand the influence of environmental factors on this life-history trait.
Despite its relatively specialized reproductive strategy (polyphilous nest-guarder, sensu Balon 1975), the pumpkinseed exhibits great plasticity, even ‘opportunism’ in its range of life-histories (Fox et al. 2007), tolerating a wide range of environmental conditions (Vila-Gispert et al. 2002). The ability to switch to a more opportunistic life-history strategy may facilitate the expansion of an invading species, even though the primary life-history strategy of the species is equilibrium (Fox et al. 2007). The parental care that is exhibited by the pumpkinseed and which is typical of many equilibrium strategists has been associated with successful invaders (e.g. Olden et al. 2006; Statzner et al. 2008), even though at least some of these invaders appear to adapt to the novel environment by putting more effort into reproduction (Fox et al. 2007).
Strong juvenile growth and precocious maturity, and thus shorter life-span, appear to be adaptive responses to elevated water temperatures, as is predicted for most ectotherms (Atkinson 1994). The distribution, age structure and invasiveness potential of pumpkinseed populations in Europe are expected to change under conditions of climate warming (Klaar et al. 2004; Villeneuve et al. 2005; Dembski et al. 2006). Indeed, fish life-history traits have been used as correlates of introduction success and extirpation events (review in Olden et al. 2006). Growth and maturation characteristics of a population are influenced by ambient environmental conditions (e.g. climate, food and habitat availability, absence/presence of predators and of other fish species—see Belk and Hales 1993; Fox 1994; Fox and Crivelli 2001; Dembski et al. 2006). The model proposed by Copp and Fox (2007) is based on the relationship between juvenile growth and maturation, which is predicted for animals in general (Stearns 1992) and fish in particular (Fox 1994). It provides a useful means for assessing the potential invasiveness of pumpkinseed populations in Europe (Fig. 2). Indeed, almost all of the populations from southern Europe, where the species is considered invasive, exhibit fast juvenile growth and early maturity, i.e. the highest potential for population expansion by virtue of their short generation time (Copp and Fox 2007).
Within this context, two pumpkinseed populations located in the lower latitudes of the northwest Europe dataset (BHP, FBM) expressed AM and juvenile growth characteristic of ‘potentially invasive’ populations (Fig. 2), and at both locations pumpkinseed were present in high densities. In contrast, the populations of two nearby sites (BHS, FGL) had AM and juvenile growth values characteristic of non-invasive and transitional populations, respectively; and the densities of pumpkinseed at these sites were lower than the other nearby locations. In Belgium, this result may be due to the ecosystem characteristics (i.e. stream versus pond). Consistent with the original model (Copp and Fox 2007), the three studied English populations (ECS, EBS, EAP) fell into the non-invasive category, though the latter population borders the ‘transition’ zone (Fig. 2).
At present, neither of the most northerly populations (NEP, HSP) can be classified due to missing values and small sample sizes (see Table 2). Both of these populations were in very low abundance and shared their respective ponds with few or no other fish species at the time of sampling. The site near Oslo (NEP) is a recently introduced population (Sterud and Jørgensen 2006) and therefore may be at the start of an expansive establishment phase. And the site in northern Netherlands (HSP) had been subjected to an attempted eradication the year before sampling and therefore had been reduced by this human intervention to a status similar to that of the Norwegian population.
In conclusion, the use of the model proposed by Copp and Fox (2007), based on the relationship between juvenile growth and age at maturity, appeared to predict reasonably the status of pumpkinseed in Europe. However, other life-history characteristics (e.g. mortality rate, plasticity, reproductive strategy) are also likely to affect invasiveness (Olden et al. 2006; Statzner et al. 2008) and the model presented here undoubtedly does not capture all of the important biotic factors relating to invasive potential. As well, the alteration of the environment by human activities might increase species invasiveness (Vila-Gispert et al. 2005; Olden et al. 2006). Integrative tools are needed to predict species invasiveness (Kolar and Lodge 2001) and the applicability of this model to other species should be investigated. However, reliable growth and reproductive data for other species across their introduced range should be collected and the relationships between life-history traits and population invasiveness should be determined at the specific level.
We thank the following persons for assisting in the collection and processing of pumpkinseed in Belgium (Y. Maes, I. Lambeens, M. De Wit, S. Buekenhout), England (J. Foster, D. Langley, D. Reeves), France (J.-M. Paillisson, A. Carpentier, J.-P. Damien), and Norway (A.T. Sterud, S.T. Sterud). Thanks also to D. Hogan for assistance with the scale reading. This study, which evolved from work initiated as part of a N.A.T.O. Collaborative Linkage Grant, was supported by research contracts/grants to G.H. Copp (UK Defra), to M.G. Fox (National Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada) and to E. Záhorská (Slovak Scientific Grant Agency grant to V. Kováč, Projects No. 1/2341/05 and 1/0226/08). We are grateful to two anonymous referees for providing insightful comments into an earlier version of the manuscript.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.