Food assistance through “surplus” food: Insights from an ethnographic study of food bank work
Cite this article as: Tarasuk, V. & Eakin, J.M. Agric Hum Values (2005) 22: 177. doi:10.1007/s10460-004-8277-x Abstract.
In Canada, food assistance is provided through a widespread network of extra-governmental, community-based, charitable programs, popularly termed “food banks”. Most of the food they distribute has been donated by food producers, processors, and retailers or collected through appeals to the public. Some industry donations are of market quality, but many donations are “surplus” food that cannot be retailed. Drawing on insights from an ethnographic study of food bank work in southern Ontario, we examined how the structure and function of food banks operate to facilitate the distribution of foods not marketed through the retail system. Our findings indicate that the handling of industry donations of unsaleable products is a labor-intensive activity, made possible by the surfeit of unpaid labor in food banks, the neediness of food bank clients, and clients’ lack of rights in this system. The marshalling of volunteer labor to serve a corporate need might be construed as a “win-win” situation because the work of salvaging edible foodstuffs from among industry “surplus” helps to “feed the hungry” while also diminishing the amount of refuse deposited in landfill sites, sparing corporations disposal costs and landfill tipping fees, and helping them forge an image of good corporate citizenship. However, the reliance of food banks on industry donations means that food assistance becomes defined as that which the corporate sector cannot retail. Moreover, the intertwining of food bank work with corporate needs may function to further entrench this ad hoc secondary food system and mitigate against initiatives to develop more effective responses to problems of hunger and food insecurity in our communities.
Keywords Canada Corporate donations Ethnography Food banks Food charity Food insecurity Surplus food Volunteer work References Agriculture Agri-Food, Canada 1998Canada’s Action Plan for Food Security: A Response to the World Food Summit Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada Ottawa, ON Google Scholar Allen, P. 1999 Reweaving the food security safety net: Mediating entitlement and entrepreneurship
Agriculture and Human Values 16 117 129 Google Scholar Bauman, Z. 1998Work, Consumerism and the New Poor Open University Press Buckingham, UK Google Scholar Cooper, J. 1997 Partnerships for change” Canadian Grocer 3 13 17 Google Scholar Daily Bread Food Bank 1999Still Hungry for Change: Fifteen Years of Daily Bread Daily Bread Food Bank Toronto, Canada Google Scholar Danermark, B., Ekstrom, M., Jakobsen, L., Karlsson, J. 1997Explaining Society: Critical Realism in the Social Sciences Routledge London Google Scholar DeLind, L. B. 1994
Celebrating hunger in Michigan: A critique of an emergency food program and an alternative for the future” Agriculture and Human Values 11 58 68 CrossRef Google Scholar Denzin, N. K., Lincoln, Y. S. 1994Handbook of Qualitative Research Sage Thousand Oaks, California Google Scholar Dowler, E., Leather, S. 2000 Spare some change for a bite to eat?’ From primary poverty to social exclusion: The role of nutrition and food” Bradshaw, J. Sainsbury, R. eds. Experiencing Poverty Ashgate Aldershot, UK 200 218 Google Scholar Eakin, J. M., MacEachen, E. 1998 Health and the social relations of work: A study of the health-related experiences of employees in small workplaces” Sociology of Health & Illness 20 896 914 Google Scholar
Emes, J. and A. Kreptul (1999).
The Adequacy of Welfare Benefits in Canada. Retrieved from the Fraser Institute, www.fraserinstitute.ca/publications, February 28, 2000. Food and Consumer Products Manufacturers of Canada 1999Caring & Contributing: How Our Industry is Making a Difference Food and Consumer Products Manufacturers of Canada Toronto, ON Google Scholar Glaser, B., Strauss, A. 1967The Discovery of Grounded Theory Aldine Press Chicago, IL Google Scholar Hamelin, A. M., Beaudry, M., Habicht, J. P. 2002 Characterization of household food insecurity in Québec: Food and feelings” Social Science & Medicine 54 119 132 Google Scholar Hamelin, A. M., Habicht, J. P., Beaudry, M. 1999 Food insecurity: Consequences for the household and broader social implications” Journal of Nutrition 129 525S 528S PubMed Google Scholar Hammersley, M., Atkinson, P. 1983Ethnography: Principles in Practice Tavistock London, UK Google Scholar Hawkes, C., Webster, J. 2000Too Much and Too Little? Debates on Surplus Food Redistribution Sustain London, UK Google Scholar Hitchman, C., Christie, I., Harrison, M., Lang, T. 2002Inconvenience Food Demos London, UK Google Scholar Hobbs, K., MacEachern, W., McIvor, A., Turner, S. 1993 Waste of a nation: Poor people speak out about charity” Canadian Review of Social Policy 31 94 104 Google Scholar Jacobs Starkey, L. 1994 An evaluation of emergency food bags” Journal of the Canadian Dietetic Association 55 175 178 Google Scholar Jacobs Starkey, L., Kuhnlein, H., Gray-Donald, K. 1998 Food bank users: Sociodemographic and nutritional characteristics” Canadian Medical Association Journal 158 1143 1149 PubMed Google Scholar Jacobs Starkey, L., Gray-Donald, K., Kuhnlein, H. V. 1999 Nutrient intake of food bank users is related to frequency of food bank use, household size, smoking, education and country of birth” Journal of Nutrition 129 883 889 PubMed Google Scholar Joint Steering Committee 1996Nutrition for Health: An Agenda for Action Health Canada Ottawa, ON Google Scholar Kainer, M., Pearlston, K. 1997Liability of Food Banks Notes for presentation to the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Association of Food Banks Toronto, ON Google Scholar Kantor, L. S., Lipton, K., Manchester, A., Oliveira, V. 1997 Estimating and addressing America’s food losses” Food Review 20 1 10 Google Scholar Kennedy, A., Sheeshka, J., Smedmor, L. 1992 Enhancing food security: A demonstration support program for emergency food centre providers” Journal of the Canadian Dietetic Association 53 284 287 Google Scholar Kvale, S. 1996Interviewing Sage Thousand Oaks, California Google Scholar Lang, T. 1997 Dividing up the cake: Food as social exclusion” Walker, A. Walker, C. eds. Britain Divided CPAG London, UK 213 227 Google Scholar Leather, S. 1996The Making of Modern Malnutrition The Caroline Walker Trust London, UK Google Scholar Oderkirk, J. 1992 Food banks” Canadian Social Trends 24 6 14 Google Scholar Pamphilon, B. 1999 “The zoom model: A dynamic framework for the analysis of life histories” Qualitative Inquiry 5 393 410 Google Scholar Poppendieck, J. 1998Sweet Charity? Emergency Food and the End of Entitlement Penguin Putnam New York Google Scholar Riches, G. 1986Food Banks and the Welfare Crisis Canadian Council on Social Development Ottawa, ON Google Scholar Riches, G. 1997 Hunger in Canada: Abandoning the right to food” Riches, G. eds. First World Hunger, Food Security and Welfare Politics Macmillan Press Ltd London, UK 46 77 Google Scholar Riches, G. 2002 “Food banks and food security: Welfare reform, human rights and social policy Lessons from Canada?” Social Policy & Administration 36 648 663 Google Scholar Seidel, J., Friese, S., Leonard, D. C. 1995The Ethnograph v4.0: A User’s Guide Qualis Research Associates Amherst, Massachusetts Google Scholar Smith, D. E. 2002 “Institutional ethnography” May, T. eds. Qualitative Research in Action. Sage Thousand Oaks, California 17 52 Google Scholar Strauss, A., Corbin, J. 1994 Grounded theory methodology. Anoverview”. Denzin, N.K. Lincoln, Y.S. eds. Handbook of Qualitative Research Sage Thousand Oaks, California 273 285 Google Scholar Tarasuk, V., Davis, B. 1996 Responses to food insecurity in the changing Canadian welfare state” Journal of Nutrition Education 28 71 75 Google Scholar Tarasuk, V., Eakin, J. M. 2003 “Charitable food assistance as symbolic gesture: An ethnographic study of food banks in Ontario” Social Science & Medicine 56 1505 1515 Google Scholar Tarasuk, V. S. 2001 “Household food insecurity with hunger is associated with women’s food intakes, health and household circumstances” Journal of Nutrition 131 2670 2676 PubMed Google Scholar Tarasuk, V. S., Beaton, G. H. 1999a Household food insecurity and hunger among families using food banks” Canadian Journal of Public Health 90 109 113 Google Scholar Tarasuk, V.S., Beaton, G.H. 1999b “Women’s dietary intakes in the context of household food insecurity” Journal of Nutrition 129 672 679 Google Scholar Tarasuk, V. S., Maclean, H. 1990 The institutionalization of food banks in Canada: A public health concern” Canadian Journal of Public Health 81 331 332 Google Scholar Teron, A. C., Tarasuk, V. S. 1999 Charitable food assistance: What are food bank users receiving?” Canadian Journal of Public Health 90 382 384 Google Scholar Vozoris, N., Davis, B., Tarasuk, V. 2002 “The affordability of a nutritious diet for households on welfare in Toronto” Canadian Journal of Public Health 93 36 40 Google Scholar Wetherall, M., Taylor, S., Yates, S. 2001Discourse as Data Sage Thousand Oaks, California Google Scholar Wilson, B. 1999HungerCount 1999 Canadian Association of Food Banks Toronto, ON Google Scholar Wilson, B., Steinman, C. 2000HungerCount 2000: A Surplus of Hunger Canadian Association of Food Banks Toronto, ON Google Scholar Wilson, B., Tsoa, E.. 2002HungerCount 2002 Eating Their Words: Government Failure on Food Security. Canadian Association of Food Banks Toronto, ON Google Scholar