Polymer-based microfluidic device for measuring membrane protein activities
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Hutter, I., Müller, E., Kristiansen, P.M. et al. Microfluid Nanofluid (2013) 14: 421. doi:10.1007/s10404-012-1061-0
- 1.5k Downloads
Functional assays of membrane proteins are becoming increasingly important, both in research and drug discovery applications. The majority of current assays use the patch-clamp technology to measure the activity of ion channels which are over-expressed in cells. In future, in vitro assay systems will be available, which use reconstituted membrane proteins in free-standing lipid bilayers suspended in nano- or micrometer-sized pores. Such functional assays require (1) expression, purification and reconstitution of the membrane protein of interest, (2) a reliable method for lipid bilayer formation and membrane protein integration, and (3) a sensitive detection system. For practical applications, especially for automation, the reliable and controllable transport of fluids is essential. In order to achieve a stable free-standing lipid bilayer, a pore diameter in the micro- to nanometer range is essential. Novel microfluidic devices were developed by bonding a thick (300 μm) polyether ether ketone foil, bearing a channel structure, to a thin (12 μm) foil with a micropore of about 10 μm diameter and then utilized for the formation of stable, free-standing lipid bilayers within the pore. A bacterial voltage-gated potassium channel is integrated therein by fusion and the ion channel activity detected by voltage clamp.
Proteins in the cell membrane are gatekeepers of various vital functions: they control the transport of ions and molecules across the cell membrane and they initiate—upon activation—the transduction of external signals to the intracellular biochemical machinery and thus regulate many cell functions. Due to their pivotal importance, membrane proteins are major targets for drugs which directly or indirectly regulate cell processes. Therefore, quantitative functional assays of membrane proteins are urgently needed in biological research as well as in drug discovery.
In order to assure full functionality of these fragile proteins, in vitro assays should be performed in a suitable environment, which mimics the biological membrane as closely as possible (Nielsen 2009). Free-standing lipid bilayers with a membrane protein of interest integrated therein allow us to directly monitor protein activity. For instance, the ion flow across membranes mediated by ion channels can be measured electrically. The development of such analytical devices comprises several crucial steps: (1) most importantly, making available the functional membrane protein of interest in a sufficient quantity, (2) establishing reliable procedures for stable lipid bilayer formation, (3) identifying robust methods to integrate the protein of interest into the lipid bilayer, and (4) developing sensitive detection methods. Furthermore, (5) the microfluidic system itself has three important functions: (a) reliable transport of fluids, (b) generation of stable lipid bilayer membranes with integrated membrane proteins separating two compartments and (c) integration of detection systems that allow electrophysiological measurements of membrane protein activities.
Silicon technology is highly reproducible and permits mass fabrication. Well-defined nanopores in ultrathin diaphragms have been fabricated and used for preparation of stable free-standing lipid bilayer membranes (Kresak et al. 2009; Danelon et al. 2006). They are stable for days in pores of diameters in the range of 200–400 nm (Han et al. 2007). The advantage of increased lipid bilayer stability in nanopores is opposed by the fact that the electrical capacitance of the ultrathin (300 nm) silicon nitride diaphragm is unacceptably high, hampering voltage-clamp measurements of single ion channels.
Alternatively, devices made of polymers for monitoring membrane protein activities have recently been presented by several groups (Suzuki and Takeuchi 2008; Hirano-Iwata et al. 2008; Estes et al. 2006; Malmstadt et al. 2006; Kawano et al. 2010). However, the combination of a micro- to nanometer-sized pore in a polymer foil of some micrometer thickness with a system of microfluidic channels in a macroscopic device remains a big challenge. For high throughput applications, the fabrication processes should be simple, cost-effective and enable mass production. In drug discovery, such devices are needed for the parallel detection of the ion channel activity of interest. In this paper, we describe a microfluidic device for the investigation of membrane proteins, which is entirely composed of polyether ether ketone (PEEK). PEEK, which is widely used for biomedical applications, provides a quite unique property spectrum: resistance to a wide range of chemicals and radiation, low moisture absorption, excellent barrier properties, electrical stability, a low dielectric constant and, most importantly, biocompatibility and low protein adsorption.
This PEEK-based microfluidic device can be used (1) for bilayer formation and (2) for the measurement of protein-mediated ion flow across lipid bilayer membranes. In bioanalytical devices, fragile lipid bilayers are generally formed just before the analysis, as their stability is limited. The development of microstructured materials and methods for handling small volumes has a long history (Zagnoni 2012).
The central part of a sensor device is the target molecule. In cells, ionic currents through over-expressed membrane channels or transporters of interest are routinely measured using patch-clamp techniques. The preparation of purified membrane proteins, however, includes many additional steps: expression, solubilization, purification and reconstitution (Demarche et al. 2011). The membrane protein can either be directly reconstituted within a planar lipid bilayer or in a liposome which is then fused by a second step into a preformed lipid bilayer. Upon application of an electrochemical potential across the planar proteobilayer, voltage-gated ion channels open within milliseconds. This opening can be detected as an ion current in the low pA-range. The archaebacterial voltage-gated K+ channel (KvAP) is a robust model membrane protein used here to demonstrate the feasibility of the concept.
2.1 PEEK-foil device
2.1.1 Microstructuring and bonding
APTIV® PEEK™ foils of 12 μm (thin foil) and 300 μm (thick foil) thickness, respectively, were kindly provided by Victrex® Polymer Solutions. Pores in the thin PEEK foil were ablated using a Duetto pico second pulsed laser from Time Bandwidth (15 W, pulses of 12 ps, 355 nm). Entry holes for the micro-channels were generated by ablating a circled line in the thin foil using 0.34 μJ at 1 MHz and 300 mm/s. Full ablation of the PEEK-material by applying a pulse on demand for 60 s at 10 kHz resulted in round micropores.
Micro-channels with rectangular cross sections (height 200 μm, width 500 μm) were prepared by hot embossing (HEX03, Jenoptik) of the thick foil using a polished brass stamp negative and applying a pressure of 200 kN for 20 min at 155 °C. The channels showed good replication of the rectangular profile, which is an important prerequisite to achieve a good sealing and to ascertain laminar, homogeneous flow of liquids therein. Bonding of the thick to the thin foil was achieved by applying a pressure of 2 kN at 140–150 °C for 16 h. Plasma activation of the foils before bonding improved the bonding quality, but this was not investigated further.
2.1.2 Device assembly
2.2 Protein expression, purification and reconstitution
KvAP (from Aeropyrum pernix) cloned into pET-26b(+) (Ruta et al. 2003) was provided by the lab of Klaus Fendler at MPIBP Biophysics in Frankfurt. The KvAP channel protein was expressed in C43 DE3 cell cultures grown in LB-Lennox medium supplemented with 10 mM BaCl2 on induction with 1 mM isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG) (at OD ~ 0.6) for 5 h at 37 °C. Cells were harvested and lysed in 20 mM KH2PO4, 20 mM imidazole, 500 mM KCl, pH 8.0 and 10 % glycerol (v/v) containing protease inhibitors (protease inhibitor cocktail completely EDTA-free, Roche) and deoxyribonuclease I (crude preparation from bovine pancreases, Sigma-Aldrich). Protein was then extracted from the cell lysate at 4 °C overnight in the above solution by adding decylmaltoside (DM from Anatrace Inc., Maumee OH, USA) to a final concentration of 2 %, purified on a Ni-column (HisTrap™), and eluted with 20 mM KH2PO4 pH 8.0, 400 mM imidazole, 500 mM KCl, 10 % glycerol (v/v), and 0.2 % DM. To remove the imidazole a buffer exchange was performed by a PD10 column and the protein eluted with 20 mM KH2PO4, pH 8.0, 500 mM KCl, 10 % glycerol (v/v), and 0.2 % DM. The yield from 12 L cultures was about 0.6 mg protein. The protein after IMAC-column was essentially pure (Fig. S5) as confirmed by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). The tetrameric protein was reconstituted with 1,2-diphytanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPhPC, Avanti Polar Lipids, Alabaster, AL, USA) with a protein/lipid ratio of 1:20 (w/w) using 100 mg Biobeads SM2 (Biorad) in 200 μL solution resulting in proteoliposomes.
2.3 Lipid bilayer formation and protein integration
To form lipid bilayers across the micropore in the micro-channel, buffers and lipids dissolved in decane were transported through the microfluidic device via tubes connected to a NEMESYS pump system, which was externally controlled by its software. The device was first filled with buffer (150 mM KCl, 10 mM 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid (HEPES), pH 7.4) by applying negative pressure with the pumps (at a speed of 0.2 μL s−1), Ag/AgCl electrodes put in place and the current through the micropore measured. 2–3 μL of the lipid mixture 1,2-dioleoyl-glycero-3-phosphoglycerol and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPG:POPE, 1:3 (v/v), 10 mg mL−1 in decane) were directly injected into the micro-channel through a valve and transported to the micropore by applying negative pressure. Moving lipids across the pore two to three times, usually resulted in the formation of a lipid bilayer membrane (the so called painting method). Formation of a lipid bilayer membrane was confirmed through impedance spectroscopy, voltage breakdown and peptide or protein integration (see below). To incorporate the KvAP ion channel protein, a lipid bilayer was painted and the bilayer positioned horizontally. 2 μL of KvAP reconstituted in DPhPC liposomes were added from above, followed by 2 μL of a 3 M KCl solution to force the proteoliposomes to fuse with the bilayer. If channels could not be detected after a few minutes, the bilayer was destroyed and a new one was formed.
2.4 Electrical measurements
Voltage breakdown experiments were performed by applying a linear voltammetry scan using an Autolab Potentiostat PG12 (Ecochemie, Utrecht, The Netherlands) equipped with a FRA module. The potential across the membrane was increased from 0 to 3,000 mV at a scan rate of 10 mVs−1 and a step potential of 1 mV. If membranes did not break, they were considered as lipid plugs. Single lipid bilayer formation was further confirmed through impedance spectroscopy. Samples were positioned in a Faraday cage and electrical impedance spectra (EIS) recorded from 1 MHz to 0.01 Hz at 0 V offset potential, applying 10 mV signal amplitude between the two Ag/AgCl electrodes. In a further series of experiments, lipid bilayer membrane formation was confirmed by adding the peptide melittin (Fluka, Buchs, Switzerland) to an end concentration of 10 μg mL−1. A continuous potential of 80 mV was applied across the membrane and the membrane permeability monitored.
KvAP activity was measured with a single channel amplifier (Axopatch 200B, Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA, USA), applying a potential alternatingly in the range of +200 to −200 mV. The Ag/AgCl electrodes were made from Ag wires (diameter 1 mm) and daily conditioned using 2.6 % Javelle water (NaClO).
3 Results and discussion
3.1 Microfluidic device
A PEEK-based microfluidic device (Fig. 1) was fabricated using three key fabrication technologies: (1) laser ablation in a thin (12 μm) PEEK foil to generate micropores, (2) hot embossing of microstructures in a thick (300 μm) PEEK foil and (3) thermal bonding of the two structured foils to form a closed channel structure. The bonded foils (Fig. 1a) were then assembled between two PMMA plates (Fig. 1b), connected via PEEK tubes to pumps and the fluid transport automatically controlled (Fig. 1c). Thus, only PEEK surfaces come into contact with the organic and aqueous solvents. This biocompatible material is resistant to most solvents and shows low moisture uptake and adsorption of biomolecules, an excellent prerequisite for the intended bioanalytical application.
3.1.1 Micropore fabrication
3.1.2 Microfluidic channel preparation
3.1.3 Bonding the micro-structured foils
PEEK is an inert material with a glass transition temperature of 145 °C and a melting point of 343 °C. In order to achieve effective adhesive-free bonding, the polymer temperature needs to be raised just above Tg to allow sufficient interdiffusion of polymer chains between the two foils to be bonded. At the same time, recrystallization of the polymer may occur in this temperature regime, which may render the process slightly more difficult. Thus, a careful choice of temperature and pressure is required in order to achieve a defect-free and tight contact between the two foils, simultaneously preserving the cross-sectional shape of the microchannels that should not be impaired by the bonding process. In a series of experiments, the following suitable conditions were established (Fig. S2): applying 2 kN pressure for 12 h at 145 °C, followed by decreasing the temperature and simultaneously increasing the pressure to 3 kN for 20 min. This procedure resulted in sufficiently accurate devices (see Fig. 1a), having channels with a rectangular cross section (Fig. S3). Alignment of the micropore in the thin PEEK foil to the channels of 500 μm width, was achieved manually before bonding (Fig. S4b). Alignment of smaller channels will be more demanding and may require alignment markers. For practical applications, the above reported bonding time is far too long. However, using laser welding for bonding of the foils promises significant reduction of the bonding time. In addition, plasma activation of the PEEK surfaces prior to bonding will considerably enhance the adhesion between the two foils and, in addition, may likely reduce the bonding time. In summary, three critical parameters for the thermal bonding of PEEK to PEEK have been identified and determined for this prototype: temperature, pressure and time. Successful thermal bonding of the PEEK prototype setup could be achieved at temperatures just above Tg (145–150 °C), applying low pressure forces (few kN) and sufficiently long bonding times (>10 h).
3.1.4 PEEK-microfluidic device assembly
The bonded PEEK foils have been assembled to a functional microfluidic device using two PMMA-plates and the nanoport system using fitting rings (Fig. 1c). Connection to the syringe pump system using PEEK ports allows air-tight transport of fluids. Lipids were added to the system through injection of some microlitre of lipid solutions through a sixfold valve.
3.2 Membrane formation and ion channel measurements
3.2.1 Automated formation of lipid bilayers in micropores
For the practical use of such devices, stability of the notoriously fragile membrane is a major issue. In this study, the stability of painted lipid bilayers was assessed according to a previously reported method (Meier et al. 2000). The breaking point of bilayers was assessed by continuously increasing the electrical potential to a point where it breaks and a rapid increase in current is observed. This potential provides a measure of bilayer stability. Breaking does not occur always at the same point; here the lowest observed breaking point (Fig. 7a) in a series of six experiments is shown, with the highest ones being above 1,000 mV. This value is reasonably high for practical applications and in full agreement with the published data of about 400 mV for a Teflon support with a pore of similar size (Mayer et al. 2003).
The stability of the lipid bilayer may be partially related to moving lipids dissolved in a residual solvent reservoir in the annulus (see Fig. 5) of the pore rim. Furthermore, surface properties of the support, such as roughness, shape and contact angle can influence the stability and sealing of suspended bilayers. From experiments using several prototype devices, we conclude that pore diameters ranging from 5 to about 12 μm, even if not circular, are suitable for lipid bilayer formation. The smooth surface around the pores probably favors a good sealing but this has not yet been investigated in detail. However, in this study the mentioned factors have not been systematically investigated. It is assumed that the most important factor for stable lipid bilayers is a hydrophobic surface, i.e. a contact angle above 90°. The PEEK foil used here has a contact angle close to this value. Bilayers in nanometer-sized pores in silicon nitride membranes have been shown to be stable for days (Tiefenauer and Studer 2008). A sufficiently high break-down voltage value in the micrometer-sized polymer support could be demonstrated in this study using pores of about 10 μm diameter. Whereas the electrical capacitance of thick foils is low and their mechanical stability is high, pores of smaller diameters can be made in thinner foils resulting in enhanced bilayer stability. Considering these contradictory factors, a pore diameter of 5–10 μm is suitable for practical applications. In summary, a sufficient stability of the bilayers in micropores has been achieved, which can be further improved.
A final experiment to proof bilayer formation (Fig. 7b) was the monitoring of melittin incorporation into the lipid bilayer membrane as discussed in a previous paper (Studer et al. 2009). Melittin-formed pores can be detected as intermediate current peaks. The lag time depends on the peptide concentration and the peak height can vary. The trace in Fig. 7b corresponds to previously observed data and a break after about 130 min, due to a high number of pores, further indicates that a lipid bilayer membrane has been formed.
3.2.2 Ion channel activity determination
Integration of the membrane protein into lipid bilayer membranes formed in micropores is one of the most difficult steps (Zagnoni et al. 2007). It is well known that electrostatic repulsion, due to charged lipid head groups, prevents fusion of bilayers, e.g. of two liposomes. This unwanted repulsion can be minimized at high ion concentration, since the cations are shielding the negative charges. We used here a 3 M KCl solution to facilitate fusion of proteoliposomes with the preformed painted lipid bilayer. Proteoliposomes added in a small volume (<5 μl) of this high density solution sink by gravity to the surface. However, this procedure requires a horizontal setup. A previously presented alternative procedure, based on the nystatin–ergosterol system (Zagnoni et al. 2007), is orientation independent, however, shows other limitations, such as predefined lipid composition and low fusion rates. Furthermore, it is limited to pores larger than 6 μm in diameter (Studer et al. 2011). In the future, more effective methods using suitable surface modifications can further improve this step and the transport of small volumes containing proteoliposomes to a micropore can also be controlled by the microfluidic system.
We have demonstrated the fabrication of a versatile PEEK-based microfluidic device prepared by thermal bonding of PEEK foils comprising a micropore and a microfluidic channel structure, respectively. The mechanical stability of 12 μm thin PEEK foils is sufficient for micropore generation by pulsed laser ablation and subsequent bonding to 300 μm thick foils containing the microfluidic channel. The fabrication processes for such devices are relatively simple, and first results demonstrate the feasibility of the concept, i.e. these devices can be used as tools to measure activities of membrane proteins integrated in planar free-standing lipid bilayers. In principle, any membrane protein of interest can be integrated using available methods (Demarche et al. 2011). Optimization of the manufacturing processes will allow us to further exploit the potential of the presented concept.
Based on these findings, polymer-based bioanalytical systems with parallel detection of membrane proteins can be realized (Müller et al. 2011). Such devices are useful tools for monitoring the activity of membrane proteins relevant in research and drug discovery.
The authors thank Armin Stumpp (FHNW) for support with pulsed laser ablation, Jens Gobrecht and Helmut Schift for discussing the concept and Mirco Altana and, Konrad Vogelsang (all from Laboratory for Micro- and Nanostructures, PSI) for help with hot embossing. The support of Patrick Schulz (MPIBP) in preparing and providing KvAP samples and KvAP-gene harboring vectors, Raimund Dutzler (University of Zurich) for kind help regarding liposome fusion, Valerie Panneels (BMR) for protein expression and purification and Sophie Demarche and David Langenegger (BMR) for experimental support and discussions is appreciated. This work was partially funded by the EU FP7 project ASMENA CP-FP 214666-2.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.