Belowground microbial symbiont enhances plant susceptibility to a spider mite through change in soybean leaf quality
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Katayama, N., Nishida, T., Zhang, Z.Q. et al. Popul Ecol (2010) 52: 499. doi:10.1007/s10144-010-0207-8
To examine how rhizobia affect the chemical and nutrient status in leaves of soybean (Glycine max L.), and how rhizobia change plant susceptibility to a generalist spider mite (Tetranycus urticae), we cultivated root-nodulating soybeans (R+) and their non-nodulating mutant (R−) in a common garden. We experimentally fertilized the plants with nitrogen to examine effects of rhizobia on the plant traits and plant susceptibility to spider mites at different nitrogen levels. R+ plants produced more leaves containing greater nitrogen and less total phenolics than R− plants. Spider mites fed on R+ leaves produced more eggs than those fed on R− leaves. The positive effect of rhizobia on spider mite fecundity could be due to an increase in foliar N content and/or to a decrease in concentration of phenolics. Although root nodule mass did not differ among different nitrogen levels, ureide-N, an indicator of nitrogen provided by rhizobia, in xylem sap decreased at moderate and high soil nitrogen levels. Therefore, we expected that rhizobia effects on egg production of the spider mite would decrease in high soil nitrogen conditions. However, the effect of rhizobia was still maintained even at high soil nitrogen levels. Thus, soil nitrogen and rhizobia may independently affect the reproductive performance of the spider mite.
KeywordsAbove- and belowground interactions Glycine max Nitrogen Phenolics Rhizobia Ureide
Ecological communities are structurally organized into complex networks by direct and indirect interactions (Ohgushi 2005; Bascompte and Jordano 2007; Ohgushi et al. 2007; Ings et al. 2009). In terrestrial systems, plant-mediated indirect interactions are ubiquitous, and recent studies have revealed the importance of plant-mediated indirect interactions in population dynamics and/or community organization of arthropods (Van Zandt and Agrawal 2004; Ohgushi 2005, 2008; Poelman et al. 2008). Although we have made great advances in understanding direct and indirect plant-arthropod interactions, how microbial symbionts living in plant tissues affect aboveground plant-arthropod interactions still remains unclear. Because plants harbor various microbes that strongly influence the chemical and nutrient status of host plants (Clay 1988; Gange and West 1994; Chaneton and Omacini 2007), the microbial effects can expand to aboveground arthropod populations and communities through changes in plant traits (Omacini et al. 2001; Rudgers and Clay 2008; Hartley and Gange 2009).
Terrestrial plants have symbiotic mutualisms with belowground microbes such as mycorrhizal fungi and/or nitrogen-fixing bacteria (Smith and Read 1997; Patriarca et al. 2002). Mycorrhizal fungi provide nutrients (mainly nitrogen and phosphorus) to host plants (Edathil et al. 1996; Smith and Read 1997), and improve the chemical and nutrient status of leaves (Gange and West 1994; Goverde et al. 2000). These changes in host plant quality affect arthropod herbivores (Hartley and Gange 2009; Koricheva et al. 2009). For example, arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi increase carbon-based chemical defense substances (acucubin and catalpol) in leaves of plantain (Plantago lanceolata) and, as a result, reduce leaf-chewing herbivory (Gange and West 1994). Vicari et al. (2002) reported that larval survival of a noctuid moth (Phlogophora meticulosa) fed on perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) decreased when the plants were infected by mycorrhizal fungi. In contrast, the survival and body weight of larvae of the common blue butterfly (Polyommatus icarus) fed on mycorrhizal bird’s-foot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus) were greater than those of the same species fed on non-mycorrhizal plants (Goverde et al. 2000). Thus, there is a growing body of evidence that mycorrhizal fungi can positively or negatively affect the performance of aboveground arthropods (Gange 2007; Hartley and Gange 2009; Koricheva et al. 2009).
Nitrogen-fixing bacteria are another important group that has obligate symbiosis with plants. In particular, rhizobia live in root nodules of legume plants and provide synthesized nitrogen compounds (NH4 +) from N2 in the atmosphere to the host plant (Patriarca et al. 2002). In the root nodulation, there is a reciprocal signaling system between rhizobia and legume hosts (Miklashevichs et al. 2001). This nodulating process is regulated by multiple nod genes of the legumes and rhizobia (van Rhijn and Vanderleyden 1995). Therefore, legume mutants lacking nod genes cannot induce root nodules.
Although Kempel et al. (2009) first documented the positive effects of rhizobia on the body weight of lepidopteran caterpillars and the population growth of aphids in a greenhouse experiment, using root-nodulating and non-nodulating clovers (Trifolium repens L.), we know little about the effects of nitrogen-fixing bacteria on the performance of aboveground arthropod herbivores.
To learn more about such effects, we examined how rhizobia modify the chemical and nutrient status of leaves of soybean (Glycine max L.) and how rhizobia affect plant susceptibility to a generalist spider mite (Tetranycus urticae). We assessed the plant susceptibility to spider mites by measuring the egg production of mites fed on leaves of rhizobia associated plants. Previous studies have determined plant susceptibility to the spider mite evaluated by assessing the fecundity of female mites (Stonor and Stringfellow 1967; Choh et al. 2004; Saeidi and Mallik 2006). In this study, we experimentally fertilized soybeans with nitrogen to examine the effects of rhizobia on eggs laid by the mite at two or three nitrogen levels. This is because rhizobia-legume associations are influenced by soil nitrogen (Evans 1982; Hardarson and Zapata 1984). Since soil nitrogen usually inhibits root nodulation and/or rhizobia activity (Evans 1982; Hardarson and Zapata 1984), the effect of rhizobia on plant susceptibility to herbivores may depend on soil nitrogen conditions.
In this study we addressed the following questions: (1) Do rhizobia change plant biomass, carbon, nitrogen, or secondary metabolic substances (total phenolics) in leaves? (2) Do rhizobia influence egg production by spider mites? (3) How does rhizobia activity change, depending on the soil nitrogen level? (4) How does soil nitrogen influence the effect of rhizobia on the egg-laying of spider mites?
Soybean (G. max) is an annual legume and is a native plant in East Asia. In central Japan, soybean seeds are sown from late June to early July, and the plants begin to bear flowers in August. Soybean produces pods in September, and the pods gradually mature during autumn. Several bacteria, Bradyrhizobium japonicum, B. elkani, and Rhizobium fredii, form root nodules on soybean roots. We inoculated B. japonicum on soybean seeds (see detailed method in “Experimental design”). Bradyrhizobium japonicum (Konryukin Mame-Zo®) was provided by the Federation of Tokachi Agricultural Cooperative Association. In this study, we used two soybean strains to compare the rhizobia effect. One is a root-nodulating strain (cv. Fujimishiro: R+) and the other is a non-nodulating strain (cv. Touzan no. 90: R−). Touzan no. 90 was made by backcross to Fujimishiro after crossing between Fujimishiro and T201 which was another non-nodulating soybean (K. Takahashi, personal communication). T201 has a mutation in the rj 1 locus that is responsible for root hair-curling when taking rhizobium into the root (Williams and Lynch 1954; Mathews et al. 1987; Suganuma et al. 1991). Therefore, Touzan no. 90 is closely related to Fujimishiro except for root nodulation. Seeds of the soybean strains were provided by the Laboratory of Plant Breeding, Faculty of Agriculture, Kyoto University.
To determine plant susceptibility to the spider mite, we measured the number of eggs laid by spider mites (T. urticae). The spider mite is a generalist herbivore that is distributed throughout the world and feeds on more than 900 plant species (Navajas 1998). The spider mites had been reared on lima bean plants (Phaseolus lunatus L.) in a climate-controlled greenhouse (25 ± 2°C, 50–70% RH, and natural light condition) for more than 3 years.
We carried out a common garden experiment to examine the effects of rhizobia (R) on plant biomass, chemical and nutrient status of leaves, and rhizobia activity at three soil nitrogen levels (F−, F+, and F++), and a laboratory experiment to examine plant susceptibility to spider mites at two soil nitrogen levels (F− and F++). On June 15 in 2007, 150 and 250 surfaces of R+ and R− soybean seeds, respectively, were sterilized for 3 min in saturated 1% sodium hypochlorite solution and were germinated on wet cotton. We sprinkled lumps of soil containing B. japonicum on the surfaces of 5-day-old germinated seeds and transplanted them individually into polyethylene pots (5 cm in diameter and 5 cm in depth) filled with a 1:1 mixture of brunizen and sand, which had been autoclaved-sterilized at 127°C for 72 min. The black soil and sand are low in nutrients [available nitrogen (ammonium-N + nitrate-N) concentration: 55 ± 25 µg/soil-g (mean ± SE, n = 10), N. Katayama, unpublished data]. Two weeks later, we separately transplanted the seedlings into large polyethylene pots (20 cm in diameter and 20 cm in depth) filled with the autoclaved-sterilized soil. Phosphorus and potassium were applied into all pots prior to transplanting (calcium superphosphate 1.5 g per pot, K2SO4 1.5 g per pot). We added 0.3 g of ammonium nitrate to one-third of the pots (F+ treatment) and 0.6 g of ammonium nitrate to other one-third of the pots (F++ treatment). We did not add nitrogen fertilizer to the remaining pots (F− treatment).
On 29 June we randomly placed 101 pots of R+ plants and 171 pots of R− plants, which contained three different soil nitrogen levels (F−, F+ and F++), in eight lines in a common garden of the Center for Ecological Research of Kyoto University (34°58′17″N, 135°57′32″E, Otsu city, Japan). The lines were spaced at 80-cm intervals, and the pots within each line were spaced at 80-cm intervals. We additionally applied ammonium nitrate to each pot with F+ (0.3 g) and F++ (0.6 g) treatments on 18 July, 6 August, 25 August, and 14 September.
Analysis of xylem sap
On 4 September, we randomly selected 25, 24, 25, 14, 15, and 14 of the R−F−, R−F+, R−F++, R+F−, R+F+, and R+F++ plants, respectively. To collect xylem sap for assessing rhizobia activity, we cut the aboveground parts, leaving 5 cm of a stem, at 4 a.m., and covered the top of the stem with 1 g of cotton wool. The cotton wool was wrapped with cellophane film to prevent evaporation from the exuded xylem sap. After 5 h, we collected the cotton wool of the individual plants. Xylem sap was collected into a 100-ml centrifuge tube by spinning out the cotton, using a centrifuge (3,500 rpm, for 1 h). The collected xylem sap was filtered through a Millipore filter (0.20 µm) and transferred into a 1-ml tube. The samples were then stored in a freezer (−20°C) until chemical analysis.
In this study, we assessed rhizobia activity using the relative ureide method (Herridge and Peoples 1990). Soybean xylem sap contains nitrogen as ureides (allantoin and allantoic acid), amino acids (mainly asparagine and glutamine), and nitrate (Matsumoto et al. 1977). Using xylem sap collected from field-grown soybeans, Streeter (1979) reported that ureide was the principal form of nitrogen transported from nodulated roots to soybean shoots. In contrast, nitrate and amino acids in xylem sap are major forms of nitrogen derived from soil (Unkovich and Pate 2000). Therefore, we estimated rhizobia activity by determining the relative ureide concentration.
Ureide-N was determined by the Young-Conway method (Young and Conway 1942) using 50 µl of xylem sap. Amino-N was determined by the ninhydrin method (Herridge 1984) using 50 µl of xylem sap. Nitrate-N was measured by Cataldo’s method (Cataldo et al. 1974) using 50 µl of xylem sap.
Plant biomass and leaf quality
We brought the aboveground plant parts to a laboratory, and divided them into leaves and other parts (i.e., stems and reproductive organs including buds, flowers, and pods). After collection of the xylem sap, we dug up plant roots, separated the root nodules from the roots, and counted the number of root nodules.
Then, stems, reproductive organs, root nodules, and roots were oven-dried at 60°C for 48 h. The leaves were dried in a desiccator with silica gel at room temperature (22–25°C). After drying, we measured the total plant dry mass, dry mass of the root nodules, and dry mass of the leaves.
The dry leaf samples were powdered using a mill for leaf chemical analysis. The carbon and nitrogen contents of the leaves were measured using an elemental analyzer (CHN Corder MT-3, Yanaco, Kyoto, Japan) with 20 mg powder samples. Total phenolics in a 20-mg leaf powder sample were extracted with 50% methanol (10 ml) for 1 h in a 40°C ultrasonic bath, and the concentration (mg/g) was measured using the Folin-Ciocalteu method (Julkunen-Tiitto 1985).
Bioassay using spider mites
On 26 September in 2007 we collected a top leaf each from 6, 12, 6, and 9 of R−F−, R−F++, R+F−, and R+F++ plants cultivated in a common garden, respectively. Pieces from each sampled leaf were punched out using a cork borer to obtain 5–8 leaf discs 8 mm in diameter. One adult female mite was placed on each leaf disc on water-saturated cotton in a petri dish. The leaf discs inoculated with the mites were placed in an incubator (25 ± 2°C, 60–70% RH and 16L8D); 72 h after mite inoculation, we checked whether the spider mites were alive and counted the number of eggs on each leaf disc using a microscope. When inoculated mites had died during the experimental period, they were excluded from further analysis.
The number and dry mass of root nodules of R+ plants were compared between F treatments by one-way ANOVA. Ureide-N, amino acid-N, and nitrate-N in xylem sap were compared between R and F treatments by two-way ANOVA. The relative ureide ratio (RU, %) was arcsin-transformed, and was compared between F treatments by one-way ANOVA. Total biomass and leaf mass were compared between the R and F treatments by two-way ANOVA. Carbon, nitrogen, and total phenolics in leaves, and egg production of spider mite were compared between R and F treatments by two-way ANOVA. The survival rate of spider mites in the experimental period on each plant was compared between F and R treatments by a two-way nominal logistic regression analysis. The Tukey-Kramer test was used as a post hoc test for any parameters between treatments. In two-way ANOVAs, we conducted post hoc tests, using each treatment independent of R and F treatments when significant interactions were detected between R and F treatments (Zar 1999).
The numbers of root nodules of R+ plants were 73.4 ± 11.2 (mean ± SE), 82.5 ± 13.5, and 103.7 ± 21.6 for the R+F−, R+F+, and R+F++ treatments, respectively, and R− plants had no root nodules. Neither the number nor the dry mass of root nodules differed among F treatments (one-way ANOVA, number of root nodules: F 2,40 = 0.93, P = 0.404; dry mass: F 2,40 = 0.02, P = 0.983).
Nitrogen types in xylem sap
Chemical and nutrient status of leaves
Rhizobia effect on spider mite survival and oviposition
Effects of rhizobia on plant quality and susceptibility to spider mites
This study clearly demonstrated that rhizobia modified the chemical and nutrient status of soybean, leading to enhanced plant susceptibility to the spider mites. R+ plants produced a greater number of leaves with higher nitrogen and lower phenolics than R− plants. Spider mites fed on R+ leaves produced more eggs than those fed on R− leaves. The increased plant susceptibility may have been caused by at least two factors. First, rhizobia increased the nitrogen level in the plants. For many herbivorous arthropods, nitrogen is an important factor in determining their growth and/or reproduction (Mattson 1980; Mattson and Scriber 1987; White 1993). In fact, higher leaf nitrogen can increase the fecundity of spider mites (Wermelinger et al. 1985; Wilson et al. 1988). Therefore, high leaf nitrogen provides high-quality resources to spider mites. Second, rhizobia decreased the phenolics concentration in the leaves. Phenolics are defensive substances against many arthropod herbivores (Feeny 1970; Bryant et al. 1987; Dudt and Shure 1994), including spider mites (Larson and Berry 1984). Although we know little about the effects of rhizobia on the performance of aboveground arthropods, decreased phenolics and increased nitrogen levels might be underlying mechanisms responsible for the enhanced reproduction of the spider mites observed here.
It is practically impossible to completely remove rhizobia in potted soybeans during the experiment because belowground bacteria easily colonize in the field. Therefore, we used a closely related non-nodulating strain to the nodulating strain. Likewise, Kempel et al. (2009) examined the effects of rhizobia on performances of aboveground lepidopteran caterpillars and aphids, using a non-nodulating mutant of white clover. It is more likely that difference in the egg production of spider mites was caused by rhizobia, although a possibility that other traits of non-nodulating plants related to resistance to spider mites differ from those of nodulating plants is not excluded.
Recent studies have paid much attention to the effects of belowground symbiotic microbes on aboveground plant-arthropod interactions (Gange 2007; Hartley and Gange 2009). For example, it has been shown that reproductive traits of aboveground herbivorous arthropods can be positively or negatively affected by belowground arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (Gange et al. 1999; Goverde et al. 2000). In their meta-analysis using 34 studies, Koricheva et al. (2009) showed that performance of mesophyll feeders was decreased by mycorrhizal fungi colonization, but performance of sucking insects was increased. For example, Gange et al. (1999) reported that the fecundity of two species of aphids (Myzus persicae and M. ascalonicus) was enhanced when the aphids fed on mycorrhiza-infected Plantago. Likewise, spider mites (T. urticae) fed on mycorrhiza-infected plants showed increased egg production (Hoffmann et al. 2009) although this pattern was in contrast to the findings Koricheva et al. (2009). There is increasing evidence that mycorrhizal fungi influence reproductive traits of aboveground arthropods. However, to date we know little about the effects of nitrogen-fixing bacteria (but see Kempel et al. 2009).
Endophytes living in leaves directly provide defensive substances to host plants. For example, Neotyphodium endophyte produces alkaloids in the host plant and makes host plants toxic to herbivores (Carroll 1988; Bush et al. 1997). In contrast to the plant-endophyte interaction, rhizobia are not likely to produce toxic substances, but do provide nitrogen to host plants. Thus, modification of the nutrient status by rhizobia may indirectly influence the defensive status of host plants. It is known that the carbon-based chemical substances in leaves change depending on the resource availability in the soil (Bryant et al. 1983; Coley et al. 1985; Bazzaz et al. 1987; Denslow et al. 1990), and that nitrogen-fertilization reduces the concentrations of carbon-based secondary metabolites (Bryant et al. 1987). This is partly because of a metabolic trade-off between the syntheses of leaf proteins and carbon-based phenolics (protein competition model: Jones and Hartley 1999). Since rhizobia provide nitrogen to host plants, it is likely that an increase in foliar nitrogen by rhizobia association causes a decrease in foliar phenolics.
Rhizobia activity and its effects on spider mites at different soil nitrogen levels
In this study, we also evaluated the effect of soil nitrogen level on rhizobia activity by assessing nitrogen types in xylem sap. Although root nodule mass did not differ among F treatments, ureide-N, an indicator of nitrogen provided by rhizobia, in xylem sap decreased at moderate and high soil nitrogen levels. In contrast, amino acid-N in xylem sap, an indicator of nitrogen derived from soil, increased with increasing soil nitrogen levels. Nitrate-N in xylem sap, another indicator of nitrogen derived from soil, was not influenced by the soil nitrogen level, although its concentration was considerably lower than those of ureide-N and amino acid-N. Thus, the rhizobia activity is most likely to decrease with increasing soil nitrogen level. This result agrees with the conclusion that rhizobia activity decreased when fertilized (Evans 1982; Hardarson and Zapata 1984).
We expected that rhizobia effects on spider mite egg production would decrease in high soil nitrogen conditions. However, this was not the case; rather the effect of rhizobia was still maintained even at high soil nitrogen level with low rhizobia activity. In this study, the foliar nitrogen of R+ plant was significantly higher than that of R− plants at high soil nitrogen levels. Also, the total phenolics of R+ plants tended to be less than those of R− plants. Thus, soil nitrogen and rhizobia may independently affect the reproductive performance of the spider mite, or soil nitrogen may enhance the effects of rhizobia.
This result suggests that the effects of rhizobia on herbivore performance were not cancelled out at high soil fertility. Although modification of the nutrient status by rhizobia may indirectly increase or decrease the strength of host plant resistance, the positive effects of rhizobia may be not only due to simply an increase in the availability of nitrogen for the plant. Because Pozo and Azcón-Aguilar (2007) suggested that belowground mycorrhizal fungi directly promote plant defense systems by influencing the jasmonate-dependent signaling pathway, rhizobia may also influence plant resistance independent of the nitrogen supply to host plants. However, the underlying mechanisms of rhizobia-driven plant resistance related to nitrogen-based secondary compounds are little understood, and thus the effect of the nodulating gene on plant resistance remains unclear.
All legume plants have obligate symbiosis with rhizobia. It is known that legumes are key ecosystem drivers that determine ecosystem productivity (Aarssen 1997; Mulder et al. 2002) and influence arthropod diversity in terrestrial systems (Siemann 1998). Although recent studies have emphasized that rhizobia act as a determinant of plant community structure and diversity (van der Heijden et al. 2006, 2008), legume-rhizobia-aboveground arthropod interactions have remained poorly explored. Our study clearly demonstrated that rhizobia indirectly enhanced egg production of the spider mites through changes in plant quality. Future studies need to pay more attention to rhizobia effects to better understand aboveground plant-arthropod interactions.
We thank Dr. Takatoshi Tanisaka for providing soybean seeds, and Drs. Tatsuhiko Shiraiwa, Keisuke Katsura, Junko Sato, and Koji Takahashi for advising us on the cultivation of soybeans and how to analyze xylem sap. We thank the Federation of Tokachi Agricultural Cooperative Association for providing rhizobium. We also thank Drs. Hideki Kagata and Shunsuke Utsumi for helpful comments during this experiment, and Dr. Elizabeth Nakajima for correcting the English of this text. This study was supported by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (A-15207003 and B-20370010) to T. Ohgushi, the 21st Century COE program (A14) and the Global COE program (A06) to Kyoto University, and JSPS Research Fellowships for Young Scientist to N. Katayama and T. Nishida.