Original Article

Population Ecology

, Volume 49, Issue 3, pp 191-200

First online:

Robustness and uncertainty in estimates of butterfly abundance from transect counts

  • Kevin GrossAffiliated withDepartment of Statistics, North Carolina State UniversityBiomathematics Program, North Carolina State University Email author 
  • , Eric J. KalendraAffiliated withDepartment of Statistics, North Carolina State University
  • , Brian R. HudgensAffiliated withDepartment of Zoology, North Carolina State University
  • , Nick M. HaddadAffiliated withDepartment of Zoology, North Carolina State University

Rent the article at a discount

Rent now

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access

Abstract

Many butterfly populations are monitored by counting the number of butterflies observed while walking transects during the butterfly’s flight season. Methods for estimating population abundance from these transect counts are appealing because they allow rare populations to be monitored without capture–recapture studies that could harm fragile individuals. An increasingly popular method for estimating abundance from transect counts relies on strong assumptions about the counting process and the processes that govern butterfly population dynamics. Here, we study the statistical performance of this method when underlying model assumptions are violated. We find that estimates of population size are robust to departures from underlying model assumptions, but that the uncertainty in these estimates (i.e., confidence intervals) is substantially underestimated. Alternative bootstrap and Bayesian methods provide better measures of the uncertainty in estimated population size, but are conditional upon knowledge of butterfly detectability. Because of these requirements, a mixed approach that combines data from small capture–recapture studies with transect counts strikes the best balance between accurate monitoring and minimal injury to individuals. Our study is motivated by monitoring studies for St. Francis satyr (Neonympha mitchelli francisci), a rare and relatively immobile butterfly occurring only in the sandhills region of south-central North Carolina, USA.

Keywords

Abundance Bayesian statistics Estimation Parametric bootstrap Population monitoring