Co-occurrence of eating disorders and alcohol use disorders in women: a meta analysis
First Online: 29 May 2007 Received: 08 January 2007 Accepted: 05 May 2007 DOI:
Cite this article as: Gadalla, T. & Piran, N. Arch Womens Ment Health (2007) 10: 133. doi:10.1007/s00737-007-0184-x Summary
This meta analysis involved 41 studies published between January of 1985 and May of 2006, which examined the co-occurrence of eating disorders (ED) and alcohol use disorders (AUD) in women. Studies were reviewed and a quantitative synthesis of their results was carried out via the calculation of standardised effect sizes. Direction and strength of the relationships between AUD and specific disordered eating patterns were examined. Heterogeneity of reported results was also assessed and examined. Only 4 out of 41 studies reported negative associations between ED and AUD. The magnitude of the associations between eating-disordered patterns and AUD ranged from small to medium size and were statistically significant for any ED, bulimia nervosa (BN)/bulimic behavior, purging, binge eating disorder (BED) and eating disorders not otherwise specified (EDNOS). No association was found between anorexia nervosa (AN) and AUD. The magnitude of the association between BN and AUD was the most divergent across studies and those between each of BED and dietary restriction and AUD were the most consistent across studies. Reported associations of different patterns of disordered eating and AUD were generally weakest and most divergent when participants were recruited from clinical settings and strongest and most homogeneous when participants were recruited from student populations.
Keywords: Eating disorders; alcohol use disorders; women; co-occurrence; meta analysis References American Psychiatric Association (APA) 1987Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders3rd revised DSM-III-R. APA Washington, DC
American Psychological Association Research agenda for psychosocial and behavioral factors in women’s health: Health behaviours (2005) Recommendations from the Advisory Committee of the Psychosocial and Behavioral Factors in Women’s Health: Creating an Agenda for the 21st Century Conference. Downloaded May 15, 2005 from
http://www.apa.org/pi/wpo/behavior.html#alcohol Bulik, CM, Sullivan, PF, Carter, FA, Joyce, PR 1997 Lifetime co-morbidity of alcohol dependence in women with bulimia nervosa Addict Behav 22 437 446 PubMed CrossRef Corcos, M, Nezelof, S, Speranza, M, Topa, S, Girardon, N, Guilbaud, O, Taïeb, O, Bizouard, P, Halfon, O, Venisse, JL, Perez-Diaz, F, Flament, M, Jeammet, P 2001 Psychoactive substance consumption in eating disorders Eat Behav 2 27 38 PubMed CrossRef Deeks, JJ, Altman, DG, Bradburn, MJ 2001 Statistical methods for examining heterogeneity and combining results from several studies in meta-analysis Eggar, M Smith, GD Altman, DG eds. Systematic reviews in health care: meta-analysis in context2 BMJ London 285 312 Higgins, JPT, Thompson, SG 2002 Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis Statist Med 21 1539 1558 CrossRef Holderness, C, Brooks-Gunn, J, Warren, M 1994 Co-morbidity of eating disorders and substance abuse, review of the literature Int J Eat Disord 16 1 34 PubMed CrossRef Huedo-Medina, TB, Sanchez-Meca, J, Marin-Martinez, F, Botella, J 2006 Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I 2 index? Psychol Methods 11 193 206 PubMed CrossRef Lipsey, MW, Wilson, DB 2001Practical meta-analysis Sage Thousand Oaks
National Center on Addiction and Substance Use at Columbia University (2001) Food for thought: substance abuse and eating disorders Conference. Available via
http://www.casacolumbia.org/absolutenm/templates/article.asp?articleid=296&zoneid=40 Stewart, SH, Angelopoulos, M, Baker, JM, Boland, FJ 2000 Relations between dietary restraint and patterns of alcohol use in young adult women Psychol Addict Behav 14 77 82 PubMed CrossRef
Streiner DL (2003) Meta-analysis: A 12-step program. Electronic Journal of Gambling Issues 1(9).
. Retrieved April 3, 2007
Wiederman, MW, Pryor, T 1996a Substance use among women with eating disorders Int J Eat Disord 20 163 168 CrossRef Wiederman, MW, Pryor, T 1996b Substance use and impulsive behaviors among adolescents with eating disorders Addict Behav 21 269 272 CrossRef Wolfe, WL, Maisto, SA 2000 The relationship between eating disorders and substance use: moving beyond co-prevalence research Clin Psychol Rev 20 617 631 PubMed CrossRef Articles included in the meta analysis: Anderson, DA, Martens, MP, Cimini, MD 2005 Do female college students who purge report greater alcohol use and negative alcohol-related consequences? Int J Eat Disord 37 65 68 PubMed CrossRef Bulik, CM 1987 Drug and alcohol abuse by bulimic women and their families Am J Psychiatry 144 1604 1606 PubMed Cochrane, C, Malcolm, R, Brewerton, T 1998 The role of weight control as a motivation for cocaine abuse Addict Behav 23 201 207 PubMed CrossRef Croll, J, Neumark-Sztainer, D, Story, M, Ireland, M 2002 Prevalence and risk and protective factors related to disordered eating behaviors among adolescents: relationship to gender and ethnicity J Adolesc Health 31 166 175 PubMed CrossRef Dansky, BS, Brewerton, TD, Kilpatrick, DG 2000 Comorbidity of bulimia nervosa and alcohol use disorders: result from the National Women’s Study Int J Eat Disord 24 605 611 Davis, TM, Bush, KR, Kivlahan, DR, Dobie, DJ, Bradley, KA 2003 Screening for substance abuse and psychiatric disorders among women patients in a VA Health Care System Psychiatr Serv 54 214 218 PubMed CrossRef Dunn, EC, Larimer, ME, Neighbors, C 2002 Alcohol and drug-related negative consequences in college students with bulimia nervosa and binge eating disorder Int J Eat Disord 32 171 178 PubMed CrossRef Frank, RE, Serdula, MK, Adamo, D 1991 Weight loss and bulimic eating behavior: changing patterns within a population of young adult women Southern Med J 84 457 460 CrossRef PubMed Garfinkel, PE, Lin, E, Goering, P, Spegg, C, Goldbloom, DS, Kennedy, S, Kaplan, AS, Woodside, DB 1995 Bulimia nervosa in a Canadian community sample: prevalence and comparison of subgroups Am J Psychiatry 152 1052 1058 PubMed Granillo, T, Jones-Rodriguez, G, Carvajal, SC 2005 Prevalence of eating disorders in Latina dolescents: associations with substance use and other correlates J Adolesc Health 36 214 220 PubMed CrossRef Granner, ML, Abood, DA, Black, DR 2001 Racial differences in eating disorder attitudes, cigarette, and alcohol use Am J Health Behav 25 83 99 PubMed Grilo, CM, Levy, KN, Becker, DF, Edell, WS, McGlashan, TH 1995 Eating disorders in female inpatients with versus without substance use disorders Addict Behav 20 255 260 PubMed CrossRef Hudson, JI, Pope, HG, Yurgelon-Todd, D, Jonas, JM, Frankenburg, FR 1987 A controlled study of lifetime prevalence of affective and other psychiatric disorders in bulimic outpatients Am J Psychiatry 144 1283 1287 PubMed Jager, B, Liedtke, R, Kunsebeck, HW, Seide, L, Lempa, W 1991 Everday addoctive behavior of bulimic women Psychother Psychomat 56 64 69 CrossRef Keck, PE, Pope, HG, Hudson, JL, McElroy, SL, Yurgelun-Todd, D, Hundert, EM 1990 A controlled study of phenomenology and family history in outpatients with bulimia nervosa Comprehens Psychiatry 31 275 283 CrossRef Keel, PK, Klump, KL, McGue, M, Iacono, WG 2005 Shared transmission of eating disorders and anxiety disorders Int J Eat Disord 38 99 105 PubMed CrossRef Killen, JD, Taylor, CB, Telch, MJ, Robinson, TN, Maron, DJ, Saylor, KE 1987 Depressive symptoms and substance use among adolescent binge eaters and purgers: a defined population study Am J Public Health 77 1539 1541 PubMed Koepp, W, Schildbach, S, Schmager, C, Rohner, R 1993 Borderline diagnosis and substance abuse in female patients with eating disorders Int J Eat Disord 14 107 110 PubMed CrossRef Krahn, D, Kurth, C, Demitrack, M, Drewnowski, A 1992 The relationship of dieting severity and bulimic behaviors to alcohol and other drug use in young women J Subst Abuse 4 341 353 PubMed CrossRef Krahn, DD 1991 The relationship of eating disorders and substance abuse J Subst Abuse 3 239 253 PubMed CrossRef Krahn, DD, Kurth, CL, Gomberg, E, Drewnowski, A 2005 Pathological dieting and alcohol use in college women – a continuum of behaviors Eat Behav 6 43 52 PubMed CrossRef Lock, J, Reisel, B, Steiner, H 2001 Associated health risks of adolescents with disordered eating: how different are they from their peers? Results from a high school survey Child Psychiatry Hum Dev 31 249 265 PubMed CrossRef Neumark-Sztainer, D, Hannan, PJ 2000 Weight-related behaviors among adolescent girls and boys: results from a national survey Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 154 569 577 PubMed Neumark-Sztainer, D, Story, M, Dixon, LB, Murray, DM 1998 Adolescents engaging in unhealthy weight control behaviors: are they at risk for other health-compromising behaviors? Am J Public Health 88 952 955 PubMed Penas-Lledo, E, Sancho, L, Waller, G 2002 Eating attitudes and the use of alcohol, tobacco, and exercise among male and female adolescents Eat Behav 3 101 111 PubMed CrossRef Piran, N, Gadalla, T 2006 Eating disorders and substance abuse in Canadian women: a national study Addictions 102 105 113 CrossRef Piran, N, Robinson, S 2006a Associations between disordered eating behaviours and licit and illicit substance use and abuse in a university sample Addict Behav 31 1761 1775 CrossRef Piran, N, Robinson, S 2006b The association between disordered eating and substance use and abuse in women: a community-based investigation Women Health 44 1 20 CrossRef Ross, HE, Ivis, F 1999 Binge eating and substance use among male and female adolescents Int J Eat Disord 26 245 260 PubMed CrossRef Schuckit, MA, Tipp, JE, Anthenelli, RM, Bucholz, KK, Hesselbrock, VM, Nurnberger, JI, Jr 1996 Anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa in alcohol-dependent men and women and their relatives Am J Psychiatry 153 74 82 PubMed Sinha, R, Robinson, J, Merikangas, K, Wilson, GT, Rodin, J, O’Malley, S 1996 Eating pathology among women with alcoholism and/or anxiety disorders J Alcoholism Clin Experi Res 20 1184 1191 CrossRef Stock, SL, Goldberg, E, Corbett, S, Katzman, DK 2002 Substance use in female adolescents with eating disorders J Adolesc Health 31 176 182 PubMed CrossRef Stuart, GW, Laraia, MT, Ballenger, JC, Lydiard, RB 1990 Early family experiences of women with bulimia and depression Arch Psychiatr Nurs 4 43 52 PubMed CrossRef Suzuki, K, Takeda, A, Matsushita, S 1995 Coprevalence of bulimia with alcohol abuse and smoking among Japanese male and female high school students Addiction 90 971 975 PubMed CrossRef Telch, CF, Stice, E 1998 Psychiatric comorbidity in women with binge eating disorder: prevalence rates from a non-treatment-seeking sample J Consult Clin Psychol 66 768 776 PubMed CrossRef Timmerman, MG, Wells, LA, Chen, S 1990 Bulimia nervosa and associated alcohol abuse among secondary school students J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychsiatry 29 118 122 CrossRef Toner, BB, Garfinkel, PE, Garner, DM 1986 Long-term follow-up of anorexia nervosa Psychosomat Med 48 520 529 Von Ranson, KM, Iacono, WG, McGue, M 2002 Disordered eating and substance use in an epidemiological sample: I. Associations within individuals Int J Eat Disord 31 389 403 PubMed CrossRef Wade, TD, Bulik, CM, Prescott, CA, Kendler, KS 2004 Sex influences on shared risk factors for bulimia nervosa and other psychiatric disorders Arch Gen Psychiatry 61 251 256 PubMed CrossRef Welch, SL, Fairburn, CG 1996 Impulsivity or comorbidity in bulimia nervosa: a controlled study of deliberate self-harm and alcohol and drug misuse in a community sample Br J Psychiatry 169 451 458 PubMed CrossRef