Testing the optimal defence hypothesis for two indirect defences: extrafloral nectar and volatile organic compounds
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Radhika, V., Kost, C., Bartram, S. et al. Planta (2008) 228: 449. doi:10.1007/s00425-008-0749-6
- 689 Views
Many plants respond to herbivory with an increased production of extrafloral nectar (EFN) and/or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) to attract predatory arthropods as an indirect defensive strategy. In this study, we tested whether these two indirect defences fit the optimal defence hypothesis (ODH), which predicts the within-plant allocation of anti-herbivore defences according to trade-offs between growth and defence. Using jasmonic acid-induced plants of Phaseolus lunatus and Ricinus communis, we tested whether the within-plant distribution pattern of these two indirect defences reflects the fitness value of the respective plant parts. Furthermore, we quantified photosynthetic rates and followed the within-plant transport of assimilates with 13C labelling experiments. EFN secretion and VOC emission were highest in younger leaves. Moreover, the photosynthetic rate increased with leaf age, and pulse-labelling experiments suggested transport of carbon to younger leaves. Our results demonstrate that the ODH can explain the within-plant allocation pattern of both indirect defences studied.
KeywordsExtrafloral nectarIndirect defenceOntogenyOptimal defence hypothesisVolatile organic compounds
International Atomic Energy Agency
Isotope ratio mass spectrometry
Least significant difference
Optimal defence hypothesis
Photosynthetic active radiation
Vienna Peedee belemnite
Volatile organic compounds
Herbivores exert an immense selection pressure on plants, and the resulting arms-race has led to the evolution of an enormous variety of plant defences against herbivores (Walling 2000; Kessler and Baldwin 2002). Defences, which directly target the performance or survival of the herbivore, are generally referred to as ‘direct’ defences. In contrast, plant traits that do not directly affect the herbivore but rather function via the attraction, nourishment or housing of predatory organisms, thereby increasing the predation pressure on herbivores, are termed ‘indirect’ defences (Heil 2008). These plant defences, albeit often significantly contributing to the plant’s ecological success, do however, not come without fitness costs (Gulmon and Mooney 1986).
From an evolutionary perspective, any organism should respond to the resulting trade-offs in a way that maximises its reproductive output and minimises any investment in non-reproductive traits—even if they are essential for its survival. One example for such an evolutionary optimisation response that is generally regarded as a cost-saving strategy are herbivore-induced plant defences, which are activated only in case of an herbivore attack (Karban and Baldwin 1997; Dicke and Hilker 2003). The drawback of inducible defences, however, is the lag-time, which is the time required for the induction of the defence after the first contact with the herbivore, during which the plant remains vulnerable (Heil and Baldwin 2002; Zangerl 2003). Since most plant defences are neither consistently expressed throughout a plant’s life nor evenly distributed within a plant (Zangerl and Rutledge 1996), several hypotheses have been suggested to predict their phenotypic variation depending on environmental or genetic factors (Karban and Baldwin 1997; Herms and Mattson 1992; Stamp 2003).
The optimal defence hypothesis (ODH) states that organisms evolved to allocate their defences in a way that maximises fitness (McKey 1974, 1979; Rhoades 1979). The underlying assumption is that defence is costly and thus, the spatio-temporal patterns of an adaptive defence allocation among plant parts should reflect the fitness-value of these organs (McKey 1974, 1979). In other words, the theoretical expectations of the ODH are that within a plant, young, still developing leaves should be better defended than older leaves.
However, physiological constraints may operate on plants, thereby causing them to deviate from these theoretical predictions. Empirical tests of the ODH are therefore required and many validating reports of this theory are indeed known for direct defences (Zangerl and Rutledge 1996; Ohnmeiss and Baldwin 2000; Barto and Cipollini 2005). Very little information, however, is available on the allocation pattern of indirect defensive strategies of plants.
This study aims at testing the predictions made by the ODH for two particularly widespread indirect defence traits: extrafloral nectar (EFN) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are both involved in mediating the interaction between herbivore-damaged plants and members of the third trophic level (Arimura et al. 2005; Heil 2008). By offering EFN as a carbohydrate-rich reward (Bentley 1977; Koptur 1992) or by emitting VOCs that indicate the increased presence of potential prey to predators and parasitoids (Turlings et al. 1990; Pare and Tumlinson 1997), plants defend themselves indirectly against herbivores. Both EFN and VOCs are inducible traits, i.e. their production rate increases in response to herbivory or mechanical damage and this response is known to be regulated by the octadecanoid pathway, in which the phytohormone jasmonic acid (JA) plays a key role (Hopke et al. 1994; Heil et al. 2001). Exogenous treatment of plants with JA results in increased production rates of both EFN and VOCs, which closely resemble the plant’s response induced by herbivore feeding in terms of quality and quantity (Dicke et al. 1999; Heil 2004).
Both constitutive (i.e. untreated) and induced levels of EFN secretion and VOC emission are higher in younger leaves.
The ontogenetic pattern of indirect defence production (both EFN and VOCs) cannot be explained solely by the photosynthetic rate of the respective leaves.
Allocation of these defences to younger leaves is mediated by transporting newly assimilated carbohydrates from older source to younger sink leaves.
Materials and methods
Plant material and growth conditions
Plants of P. lunatus L. (lima bean) were cultivated from seeds derived from a native population growing in the coastal area near Puerto Escondido in the state of Oaxaca, Mexico. The parental plants have been used previously in field experiments on indirect plant defences (Heil 2004; Kost and Heil 2005, 2008). Ricinus communis L. plants (castor oil plant) were grown from seeds (Weber Seeds, Römhild, Germany) harvested from greenhouse-grown plants. Growing conditions were 20–22°C, 30–55% humidity during a 16 h photoperiod. Experiments were performed with 4-week-old plants (i.e. 5–6 leaf stage for P. lunatus and 4 leaf stage for R. communis). To study the ontogenetic pattern, both plants were grown in Klasmann clay substrate (Klasmann-Deilmann, Geeste, Germany). All experiments were performed in the greenhouse.
Measurement of EFN secretion rates
To ensure that no nectar was present at the onset of the experiment, extrafloral nectaries were rinsed thoroughly with tap water and allowed to dry. EFN secretion was quantified one day after spraying either tap water (control treatment) or an aqueous solution of 1 mM JA (JA treatment) on all the leaves until runoff. Plants were treated twice at an interval of 30 min and after that leaves were allowed to dry for 1 h before plants were placed back into the greenhouse. The EFN produced after 24 h was quantified as the amount of secreted soluble solids (i.e. sugars and amino acids) using a temperature-compensated refractometer (ATAGO N-10E refractometer, Leo Kübler GmbH, Karlsruhe, Germany) as described by Heil et al. (2000, 2001). EFN was quantified as amount of soluble solids per dry weight of the secreting leaf material per 24 h.
Measurement of photosynthetic rate
The photosynthetic rate was measured with a portable open-mode photosynthesis system LI-6400 (LI-COR, Lincoln, NE, USA) using the 6400-15 Arabidopsis chamber on leaves attached to the plant. Measurements were taken between 9:00 a.m. and 2:00 p.m. using 360 μl l−1 CO2 in the reference stream under approximately 900 μM m−2 s−1 PAR.
Collection and analysis of VOCs
The VOC emission as a function of leaf age in lima bean plants was measured by bagging all leaves individually in PET hoses (Toppits® ‘Bratschlauch’, Melitta, Minden, Germany) that do not emit detectable volatiles by themselves. VOCs emitted from each individual leaf were collected continuously for 24 h on charcoal traps (1.5 mg charcoal, Gränicher and Quartero, Daumazan sur Arize, France) by pulling air at about 500 ml min−1 using a 12 V vacuum pump (Gast Manufacturing, Benton Harbor, MI, USA). The traps were eluted with 2 × 20 μl of dichloromethane containing 200 ng μl−1 of 1-bromodecane as an internal standard. The leaves were dried for dry weight determination. VOC samples were analysed on a Thermo Finnigan Trace GC-MS (Thermo, Bremen, Germany) equipped with a fused silica Alltech EC5 column (15 m × 0.25 mm internal diameter × 0.25 μm film thickness) using 1.5 ml min−1 helium as carrier gas. Separation was achieved under programmed conditions (45°C for 2 min, 10°C min−1 to 200°C, then 30°C min−1 to 280°C for 1 min; injector temperature: 220°C). MS analysis was performed on a TraceMS in electron impact full-scan mode at 70 eV with source temperature at 200°C and GC interface temperature at 280°C. Individual compounds were quantified with respect to the peak area of the internal standard and related to the dry weight of the leaf. The ten most dominantly emitted compounds, namely (Z)-3-hexenyl-acetate, (E)-β-ocimene, (R)-(−)-linalool, (E)-4,8-dimethylnona-1,3,7-triene (DMNT), (E)-2,6-dimethyloctatetraene (C10H14), methyl salicylate (MeSA), 2,6-dimethyl-3,5,7-octatriene-2-ol (C10H16O), cis-jasmone, (E)-β-caryophyllene, and (E,E)-4,8,12-trimethyltrideca-1,3,7,11-tetraene (TMTT), were summed up to test for a putative effect of leaf position on total VOC emission.
In order to follow the internal transport of newly assimilated carbon, experiments were performed using synthetically premixed air containing 13CO2 instead of 12CO2 at a natural concentration of 380 ppm. In all cases, the air with 13CO2 was purged for 24 h after induction with 1 mM JA solution. For each plant, each of five leaves were bagged individually in a PET hose (i.e. ‘Bratschlauch’, see above) and in each case, one of the five leaves was purged with labelled air, while all the other four leaves were purged with normal air. After 24 h, the 13C content in the tissue of all five leaves as well as in the EFN secreted from this leaf was quantified using an isotope ratio mass spectrometer (IRMS). This procedure was applied to a total of eight replicates of four plants each, with one of the five leaves having experienced the 13CO2-treatment until each leaf position within the four-plant group had received the 13C treatment once. Due to technical reasons, we focussed this analysis on leaves in positions 1–3 and 5.
For IRMS measurements of EFN, nectar samples were filled in small 0.04 ml tin capsules for liquid samples (d: 3.5 mm, l: 5.5 mm; part. No. 184.9915.26, Lüdi AG, Flawil, Switzerland), dried in a desiccator filled with P2O5 as drying agent, and weighed before further analysis. For the solid leaf sample measurements, dried and powdered leaf material was weighed in 0.07 ml tin capsules (d: 4.0 mm, l: 6.0 mm; part. No. 176.1305.53, Lüdi AG). Capsules were sealed and combusted (oxidation at 1,020°C, reduction at 650°C) in a constant helium stream (80 ml min−1) quantitatively to CO2, N2, and H2O using an elemental analyzer (EuroEA CN2 dual, HEKAtech, Wegberg, Germany). After passing a water trap (MgClO4), the gases were separated chromatographically at 85°C and transferred via an open split to a coupled isotope ratio mass spectrometer (IsoPrime, Micromass, Manchester, UK). Our laboratory working standard (acetanilide) has been calibrated on the VPDB scale using IAEA reference material, NBS 22, with a δ 13C value of −29.78‰ (Werner and Brand 2001). All isotope ratios are given as δ 13C values: δ 13C (‰) = [(Rsample/Rstandard) − 1] × 103, where R corresponds to the 13C/12C ratio of the sample and the standard.
All experiments were analysed with linear mixed-effect models with ‘treatment’ as fixed and ‘plant individual’ as random factor. Values of EFN secretion and total VOC emission have been log-transformed to meet the test assumptions of normality and homogeneity of variances. Global LSD post hoc tests were applied to the measured values for EFN secretion, VOC emission, and photosynthetic rates to test for between-group differences between all factor combinations of leaf position and treatment. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS 13.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). To control for multiple testing in comparing qualitative differences in the VOCs blend with leaf age, false-discovery rate (FDR) procedure was used.
Ontogenetic pattern of EFN production
In both, P. lunatus and R. communis, the youngest leaf (i.e. leaf position 1) secreted the highest amount of EFN in undamaged controls as well as in JA-treated plants and the EFN secretion rate significantly decreased with leaf age (Fig. 1b, e, LSD post hoc test after univariate ANOVA: P < 0.01, n = 9 and 7, respectively). In case of lima bean, the mean amount of EFN secreted from the youngest leaf exceeded that of the oldest leaf about fivefold. In this species, the two youngest leaves secreted on average two times more EFN than the two older leaves. An analysis of the inducibility with respect to leaf age indicated that in both plant species the youngest leaf did not only show the highest level of constitutive EFN secretion, but was also inducible to higher defence levels than the older leaves (LSD post hoc test after univariate ANOVA, P < 0.05, n = 9 in lima bean and n = 7 in R. communis).
Ontogenetic pattern of photosynthetic rate
Quantification of the photosynthetic rate indicated that younger leaves showed a lower gas exchange capacity than older ones in both control and JA-treated plants (Fig. 1c, f, LSD post-hoc test after univariate ANOVA: P < 0.02, n = 6 and 7, respectively), thus indicating a negative relation between EFN production and photosynthetic capacity. JA treatment did not significantly alter the photosynthetic rate in both plant species investigated (univariate ANOVA, P > 0.05, n = 7 in lima bean and n = 6 in R. communis).
No increase of 13C in the tissue and the EFN of leaf 4 could be detected, not even after treatment of leaf 5. In all experiments, the δ13C values of leaf 4 were in the range of the natural abundance level. The amount of 13C incorporated into EFN was on average about ninefold higher than that observed for the leaf tissue. Taken together, this experiment revealed a unidirectional transport of photosynthates from older source to younger sink leafs. Furthermore, no photosynthetic products were transported to leaf 4 and no transport occurred downstream to older leaves.
Ontogenetic pattern of VOC emission
The ODH predicts that the spatial allocation of defensive traits within a plant should favour more valuable and vulnerable plant parts (McKey 1974, 1979; Rhoades 1979). In line with these predictions, the young leaves of both lima bean and castor showed the highest level of the two indirect defences, EFN secretion and VOC emission (Figs. 1b, e, 3). Young leaves are generally important for future plant fitness since they already have caused high construction costs without having contributed very much yet to the plant’s pool of photo-assimilates. Consequently, they have the highest future life span and can therefore be expected to contribute bulk to the prospective photosynthetic assimilation. Moreover, very young leaves usually still lack effective mechanical defences (Harper 1989) and indeed it has been shown for several plant species that young leaves, which are more nutritious (Slansky 1993), suffer more from herbivory than older ones within the same plant (Kursar and Coley 1991; Boege and Marquis 2006). Our results show that the young leaves are defended more, both before and after induction (Fig. 1). This observation is in line with the interpretation that EFN and VOCs are allocated based on the value and probability of attack of the leaves, as predicted by the ODH (Anderson and Agrell 2005). Also in the lima bean, which is a cyanogenic plant species, similar patterns have already been demonstrated for its direct defence, as young leaves were characterised by increased amounts of cyanide-containing precursors and higher capacities to release HCN per time unit than mature leaves (Ballhorn et al. 2005).
Our study lends support to previous findings where more valuable plant parts showed increased defence levels upon herbivore feeding (Heil et al. 2000; Wäckers and Bonifay 2004; Rostas and Eggert 2008). Furthermore, it is known that in myrmecophytes, ants preferably patrol and defend young leaves (Heil et al.2001). In obligate ant-plants, however, this pattern is not necessarily caused by the spatial distribution of ant rewards (i.e. food bodies and EFN; Heil et al. 1997), but could also be achieved by special behavioural adaptations of the ants (Heil et al. 2004). In contrast, optimal distributions of defenders in facultative interactions with unspecialised animals require that the plants distribute the attractive traits accordingly (Downhower 1975; Heil et al. 2000).
Indeed, the overall emission rate of VOCs increased from young to older leaves, while the qualitative composition of the emitted blend changed only slightly. Both the quantitative and qualitative emission of VOCs have been shown to be highly variable depending on several interacting factors such as plant and herbivore species, type of damage (chewing vs. piercing-sucking) and abiotic factors like rainfall and light intensity (for review, see Arimura et al. 2005). Our finding that VOCs are emitted more from younger leaves could be interpreted as a strategy of a directional attraction of parasitoids or other arthropod predators to younger leaves (Hazarika et al. 2007)—a hypothesis that remains to be tested in future studies.
The consistent release patterns of EFN and VOCs give rise to the question whether both traits contribute equally to the plant’s protection. Since it was recently shown for lima bean that VOCs act as airborne signals and induce EFN secretion in undamaged plant parts (Kost and Heil 2006; Heil and Silva Bueno 2007), an alternative scenario to the defense hypothesis could be that the primary function of the emitted VOCs is to induce EFN. In this case, parasitoids and other insect predators learning to associate increased VOC levels with an increased presence of herbivores could be a secondary function of the emitted VOCs.
Furthermore, the cost of these two indirect defences remains elusive, though VOCs have been estimated to cause low costs in corn plants (Hoballah et al. 2004). VOCs and EFN are carbon-based defences and thus might even compete for a common pool of metabolites. The amount of VOCs emitted ranges orders of magnitudes below the amount of carbohydrates that is secreted as EFN. In case of the lima bean for example, a young leaf emits only 1.9 ng/24 h g−1 dry weight of mainly carbon-based VOCs, while the same leaf secretes 1.3 mg EFN/24 h g−1 dry weight as sugars. It is thus likely that EFN accounts for higher metabolic costs than VOCs. However, further investigation is needed to fully understand the partitioning of plant metabolites for these two indirect defences and future studies must be directed to assess these costs and benefits of both VOC emission and EFN secretion under different herbivore pressures and inductive situations.
Despite being shaped by evolution as an adaptive response, the spatio-temporal distribution of defence traits within plants has to obey limitations in organ-wide or plant-wide resource availabilities. EFN and VOCs are primarily carbon-based defences, and differences in photosynthetic C-assimilation among organs may thus also cause different production rates of these defensive traits. However, patterns in C-assimilation did not entirely match those observed for EFN and VOCs production, as older leaves were generally characterised by higher photosynthetic rates than younger leaves. On average, younger leaves showed a negative photosynthesis (Fig. 1c, f), i.e. respiration rate was higher than the rate of C-assimilation.
Leaf photosynthesis is the main source for the sugars secreted as EFN (Wardlaw 1990). Young, still developing leaves were characterised by low photosynthetic rates (Fig. 1c, f) and presumably had very low reserves for producing defensive compounds (Larson and Gordon 1969). Thus, they act as physiological sinks and import nutrients until they become competent enough to synthesize defence compounds on their own (Lalonde et al. 2004). Indeed, our 13C labelling experiment in lima bean plants indicated a net transport of C assimilated by leaf 5 to younger leaves (1–3; Fig. 2) when all leaves were treated with JA. This result illustrates the transport of photosynthates within the plant from mature to young leaves, where protection is most essential. This finding is in line with previous studies showing that plants can metabolically reorganize in response to herbivory by reallocating resources to growing plant parts (Strauss and Agrawal 1999; Hui et al. 2003) as well as by making younger leaves stronger sinks for defensive metabolites (Arnold and Schultz 2002).
Transport of photosynthates depends on the vascular architecture, and studies have shown that the systemic induction of plant defences can depend on the way the leaves are connected by the vascular system (Davis et al. 1991; Orians et al. 2000; Schittko and Baldwin 2003; Orians 2005; Gomez and Stuefer 2006). In our study, we mimicked herbivory on a plant-wide level by spraying JA on all leaves. In this inductive situation, all the observed pattern could be explained with the ODH.
In summary, we have tested the predictions made by the ODH for two of the most widely distributed indirect plant defences, secretion of EFN and emission of VOCs. We have shown that the plant’s induced defensive strategy involves channelling resources in a way that maximises the protection of its most valuable parts. This result is consistent with the ODH in that the youngest leaf, which is a greater contributor towards future plant fitness, enjoys higher defence levels by importing carbohydrates from older leaves. To our knowledge, this is the first report verifying that the within-plant distribution pattern of these two indirect defences does not simply reflect patterns of carbon assimilation, but actually represents an optimal defence strategy.
The authors thank Dr. Willi A. Brand and Heike Geilmann for support with standards for the IRMS measurements as well as Henry Busch, Jens Burkhardt, and Anja David who helped with preliminary experiments. Financial support by the International Max-Planck Research School (IMPRS) and the Max-Planck Society (MPG) is gratefully acknowledged.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.