The persistence of the snow petrel (Pagodroma nivea) in Dronning Maud Land (Antarctica) for over 37,000 years
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Thor, G. & Low, M. Polar Biol (2011) 34: 609. doi:10.1007/s00300-010-0912-y
- 389 Views
Two samples of snow petrel Pagodroma nivea mumiyo (solidified stomach oil) from Heimefrontfjella (74°34′36″S, 11°13′24″W) in Dronning Maud Land, Antarctica, were radiocarbon dated at 37,400 ± 1,500 and 3,120 ± 70 years old (dates are corrected for the ‘reservoir effect’). The age of the older sample provides further evidence that snow petrel colonies have existed in the mountain peaks of Dronning Maud Land since before the last glacial maximum (approx. 20,000–16,000 years ago). This finding also pushes back the estimated timing of establishment of snow petrel breeding colonies in this part of the continent by several thousand years. The variation in the accumulation rates of these two samples (1.6 and 35.2 mm per millennium, respectively) supports previous observations that mumiyo accumulation rates are highly variable and probably relate to site-specific factors affecting accumulation and degradation of the oil. Studies that help us understand historical bird population distributions in continental Antarctica can significantly aid the development and refinement of models that explain glacial advancement and retreat, the relationship between sea ice and population viability and, perhaps, predict species responses to future climate shifts.
KeywordsAntarcticaRadiocarbon datingSeabird coloniesSouth Polar SkuaNest occupancy
The analysis of accumulated organic material around the nests of species exhibiting multi-generational site fidelity can yield important information on long-term population and environmental parameters (Houston and Nager 2009). In extreme cases, this build-up of material at bird nesting sites may represent thousands of years of occupancy, with stable-isotope analysis revealing colonisation patterns and changes in prey selection and foraging habitat over long periods of time (e.g. snow petrels Pagodroma nivea—Ainley et al. 2006; Adélie penguins Pygoscelis adeliae—Emslie et al. 2007; gyrfalcons Falco rusticolus—Burnham et al. 2009). For species that nest at high latitudes, such information is not only of interest to biologists but also to glaciologists, climatologists and oceanographers. This is because these birds can only nest on ice-free areas; thus, by using 14C-isotope analysis to date organic deposits, important information on the extent of ice cover during the late Pleistocene and Holocene epochs can be deduced (Ryan et al. 1992; Verkulich and Hiller 1994; Ainley et al. 2006; Thatje et al. 2008; Kiernan et al. 2009).
Breeding sites of the Antarctic snow petrel are a particular source of organic material for such analyses because of the bird’s anti-predator defence behaviour, whereby it spits stomach oil at intruders. As a result of the cold and dry Antarctic environment, this oil solidifies around the entrance of snow petrel nest cavities, forming a stratified wax-like yellowish brown deposit known as ‘mumiyo’ (Warham 1977). Basal mumiyo layers (i.e. the first deposited and therefore the oldest) in many colonies have been found to be many thousands of years old (Verkulich and Hiller 1994; Ainley et al. 2006); the oldest deposits being found in (1) the Wohlthat Mountains (Untersee Oasis and Insel Range: approx. 71°S, 12°E) in Dronning Maud Land, and radiocarbon dated to 32,600 ± 3,020 and 31,180 ± 740 years before the present (BP) (reservoir effect-corrected values; Hiller et al. 1988, 1995) and (2) Svarthamaren (71°53′S, 5°10′E) in central Dronning Maud Land (32,520 ± 1,700 years BP—reservoir-corrected values; Steele and Hiller 1997). The subfossil mumiyo deposits from these nunataks provide evidence that snow petrels colonised continental Antarctica before and during the last glacial maximum, probably utilising nearby polynyas in the Weddell Sea to find food (Thatje et al. 2008).
Observation and collection of mumiyo deposits were made by GT in 1991/92. In Vestfjella, only the northernmost nunataks around the Swedish station Wasa (73°02′S, 13°25′W) were visited (i.e. Basen and Fossilryggen), which were occupied by 200–500 breeding pairs (Johansson and Thor 2004). In Heimefrontfjella, the area around Scharffenbergbotnen in northern Sivorgfjella, where the Swedish field station Svea is located (74°34′S, 11°13′W), was surveyed; in addition, three high peaks were also surveyed (i.e. Engenhovet, Wrighthamaren and Paalnibba; for more details, see Johansson and Thor 2004). The number of snow petrels nesting in these areas was estimated to be 2,300–4,050 (Johansson and Thor 2004).
Mumiyo collection and 14C dating
Mumiyo was frequently observed at snow petrel nests in the surveyed areas of Vestfjella and Heimefrontfjella; these were often mixed with rock fragments, feathers and guano. However, only in Heimfrontfjella were mumiyo deposits greater than a few centimetres thick observed. Three larger deposits that were located on bedrock were collected from two sites on the northern end of the Haldorsentoppen nunatak in Sivorgfjella, Heimefrontfjella. Site 1 (visited 4 January 1992) was located at the eastern end of the fourth small hill south of the Swedish field station Svea (1,245 m above sea level; 74°34′36″S, 11°13′24″W) at the base of a 20-m deep wind scoop approximately 25 cm above the snow level; site 2 (visited 30 January 1992) was located 200–300 m from site 1, on exposed rock at the top of the second hill south of Svea. Two deposits were collected from site 1: C93/8003 (Swedish Museum of Natural History reference number), dimensions 15 × 10 × 6 cm, weight 300 g; C93/8002, dimensions 10 × 10 × 3 cm, weight 200 g; one deposit was collected from site 2: C93/8001, dimensions 18.5 × 18.5 × 11 cm, weight 1,500 g.
The mumiyo samples were removed from the rock using a hammer and chisel; they were then wrapped in aluminium foil, sealed in a plastic bag and frozen at −20°C for transport to Sweden. The specimens were kept frozen during shipment in early 1992 and are currently in cold storage at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences in Uppsala. The basal layer of the two largest samples (C93/8003 and C93/8001) was 14C dated at the Laboratory for Isotope Geology at the Swedish Museum of Natural History (laboratory reference numbers for the two samples: ST14178 and ST14177, respectively). The conventional 14C ages for each sample were then corrected for isotopic fractionation of ™13C [−29.0 ‰ (sample 1) and to −30.6 ‰ (sample 3)]. These ™13C values from Heimefrontfjella were similar to other reports from Dronning Maud Land (Hiller et al. 1988; Ryan et al. 1992). Because of depletion of 14C content in Antarctic waters, radiocarbon dating of mumiyo deposits tends to overestimate their age (the reservoir effect; Wand and Hiller 1987, Hiller et al. 1988); this has been estimated for this region of Antarctica at 850 ± 300 years (Hiller et al. 1988) and 1,300 ± 200 years (Ryan et al. 1992). Thus, all reported radiocarbon dates in this study have been corrected by applying a conservative correction factor of −1,300 years (see also Hiller et al. 1995; Steele and Hiller 1997; Ainley et al. 2006).
The basal layer of the 6-cm-thick sample (C93/8003) was radiocarbon dated to 37,400 ± 1,500 years (uncorrected estimate = 38,700 years), while the basal layer of the 11-cm-thick sample (C93/8001) was radiocarbon dated to 3,120 ± 70 year (4,420 year uncorrected). This represents a growth in thickness of these two samples of 1.6 and 35.2 mm per millennium, respectively.
The age of mumiyo sample C93/8003 (37,400 years) provides further evidence that snow petrel colonies existed in the mountain peaks of Dronning Maud Land during the last glacial period (70 to10 ka; Thatje et al. 2008). This finding also pushes back the estimated timing of establishment of snow petrel breeding colonies in this part of the continent by several thousand years (Hiller et al. 1988; Steele and Hiller 1997; Thatje et al. 2008) and shows that these pioneering colonies were widely distributed in Dronning Maud Land (Hiller et al. 1988, 1995; Steele and Hiller 1997; this study).
The largest mumiyo deposits in the study area were observed at Haldorsentoppen in Heimefrontfjella (where the samples were taken), up to a maximum 110-mm high. The sizes of these deposits were similar to those reported from the Untersee Oasis colony that has also been occupied for >30,000 years; the thickness of mumiyo in Hiller et al. (1988) ranged from 15 to 145 mm with the oldest deposit (32,600 years) being only 70-mm thick (60 mm in this study); in Steele and Hiller (1997), the 32,520 year BP sample was also only 70-mm thick. Indeed, this range of thicknesses for mumiyo deposits is similar for other studies where the radiocarbon dates were much younger (Verkulich and Hiller 1994) and supports previous observations that accumulation rates for mumiyo based on radiocarbon age are highly variable (Verkulich and Hiller 1994; Hiller et al. 1995).
Although the thinner observed mumiyo deposits at Basen in the Vestfjella may indicate a younger occupancy time for this area, there are other factors that probably contribute to the size difference in the deposits between these two locations. Nest occupancy and predation risk are generally the factors considered to be most important in influencing the highly variable growth of mumiyo deposits (accumulation rates can span two orders of magnitude; e.g. Hiller et al. 1995), because they directly determine the amount of stomach oil ejected onto these sites (Warham 1977; Verkulich and Hiller 1994). However, liquefaction and degradation of the deposits may also play a role in limiting mumiyo growth—this would be expected to occur when temperatures rise above freezing. The Vestfjella differs from the Heimfrontfjella in that the rocks and air temperature in the nesting area are warmer during the breeding season because: (1) the Vestfjella is at a lower altitude and closer to the coast and (2) the bedrock at Basen is usually black (basalt and diabase with dolerite dikes), whereas in Heimefrontfjella, it is usually red or grey (weakly metamorphic red granite and grey augengneiss); dark rock can attain a surface temperature approximately 10°C higher than light-coloured gneiss of similar aspect (Engelskjøn 1986). Owing to the high intensity of solar radiation during the summer months in Dronning Maud Land, even during overcast conditions, as well as to the low albedo and the reflection of short-wave radiation from adjacent snow and ice surfaces, the surface temperatures of the nunataks can be considerably higher than air temperatures and must often be above freezing (Engelskjøn 1986; Jonsson 1988). Thus, any mumiyo degradation would be expected to be higher in Vestfjella than in Heimefrontfjella. It is also worth noting that for the sampling locations in the Heimefrontfjella, the slow-accumulating older sample was from a wind-exposed site at the bottom of a wind scoop. Future studies interested in factors affecting mumiyo accumulation should also consider the effect of wind and temperature on dispersal of the stomach oil and how this might affect mumiyo accumulation.
This study provides additional evidence for the understanding of historical bird population distributions in continental Antarctica. Together, similar studies can significantly aid the development and refinement of models that explain glacial advancement and retreat (Ryan et al. 1992), the relationship between sea ice and population viability (Thatje et al. 2008) and, perhaps, help predict species responses to future climate shifts.
The Swedish Polar Research Secretariat funded both the visit by GT to Heimefrontfjella and Vestfjella in 1991/1992, and the 14C analysis. Magnus Hedberg at the Laboratory for Isotope Geology at the Swedish Museum of Natural History kindly made the 14C analysis.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.