Multisensor Monitoring System for Assessment of Locust Hazard Risk in the Lake Balkhash Drainage Basin
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Propastin, P. Environmental Management (2012) 50: 1234. doi:10.1007/s00267-012-9950-2
Satellite and ground-based data were combined in a monitoring system to quantify the link between climate conditions and the risk of locust infestations in the southern part of Lake Balkhash’s drainage basin in the Republic of Kazakhstan. In this monitoring system, the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), derived from the SPOT-VGT satellite, was used for mapping potential locust habitats and monitoring their area throughout 1998 to 2007. TOPEX/Poseidon and Jason 1 altimeter data were used to track the interannual dynamics of water level in Balkhash Lake. Climate conditions were represented by weather records for air temperature and precipitation during the same period. The classification procedure, based on an analysis of multitemporal dynamics of SPOT-VGT NDVI values observed by individual vegetation classes, generated annual areas of ten land-cover types, which were then categorized as areas with low, medium, and high risk for locust infestation. Statistical analyses showed significant influences of the climatic parameters and the Balkhash Lake hydrological regime on the spatial extend of annual areas of potential locust habitats. The results also indicate that the linkages between locust infestation risk and environmental factors are characterized by time lags. The expansion of locust risk areas are usually preceded by dry, hot years and lower water levels in Balkhash Lake when larger areas of reed grass are free from seasonal flooding. Years with such conditions are favourable for locust outbreaks due to expansion of the habitat areas suitable for locust oviposition and nymphal development. In contrast, years with higher water levels in Balkhash Lake and lower temperature decrease the potential locust habitat area.
KeywordsLocust riskLake BalkhashRiver IliWater tableVegetation dynamicsRemote sensing
With respect to the Republic of Kazakhstan, the permanent breeding area in the drainage basin of Lake Balkhash in Southeast Kazakhstan most economically important with respect to damage incurred (Toleubayev and others 2007). The total area of the River Ili delta in the southern part of the Lake Balkhash is approximately 1 million ha, and > 0.3 million ha within this total area are susceptible to locust infestations (Tsyplenkov 1970). Under favourable ecological conditions, this area produces large swarms of the Asian migratory locust, which causes devastating damage to ecosystems in the region. With a periodicity of 2 to 10 years, swarms of the Asian migratory locust endanger agricultural production in the region (Kambulin 1992; Toleubayev and others 2007; Khasenov 2001). Commonly, the outbreaks occur after abnormally dry years, when larger areas in the River Ili delta are free from flooding water. Such areas represent suitable habitats for locust oviposition (Latchininsky and others 2007; Sivanpillai and others 2006).
Remote sensing is an effective technology for collecting information on vegetation and earth surface conditions at several scales. Modern monitoring of the locust hazard, based on remote-sensing techniques, enables mapping of locust habitats, postdamage assessment, and observation of locust population dynamics at the scales from local to national (Latchininsky & Sivanpillai 2010). Remote-sensing techniques have been applied for forecasting infestation by locusts and damage assessment in Africa (Voss & Dreiser 1997; Despland and others 2004; Tratalos & Cheke 2006; Ceccato and others 2007; Tappan and others 1991), Asia (Ji and others 2005; Ma and others 2005; Sivanpillai and others 2006; Tian and others 2008; Liu and others 2008) and Australia (Deveson and others 2005; Hunter and others 2008).
Fine spatial-resolution data (30 m) from Landsat MultiSpectral Scanner and Thematic Mapper (TM) sensors have been used for mapping locust habitats at a local or subregional scale (Sivanpillai and others 2006; Ma and others 2005; Voss & Dreiser 1997). Commonly, the result of such studies is a single map of potential locust habitats based on satellite data classification (Latchininsky and others 2007; Latchininsky and Sivanpillai 2010; Sivanpillai and others 2006). However, due to considerable temporal heterogeneity of rainfall in drylands, mapping of locust habitats in semidesert and desert environments without taking into account the intra-annual and interannual rainfall dynamics has had only limited success (Latchininsky and others 2007).
To overcome this constraint, multitemporal satellite data (data collected at different times) can be used for mapping land-cover using vegetation seasonal (within year) and interseasonal (across several years) change information (Friedl and others 2002; Fensholt 2004). Such studies generally demand moderate- and coarse-resolution data with high repetition time of data acquisition. Data sets with global coverage originating from a number of satellite systems, such as Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR), Satellite Pure Observation d’Tierra (SPOT), and Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), have become available to the remote-sensing community in recent years. A number of studies showed good suitability of coarse- and moderate-resolution data for mapping locust habitats and monitoring habitat conditions in various regions (Sivanpillai & Latchininsky 2007; Ji and others 2005).
Recently, NDVI data sets with global coverage are routinely produced from AVHRR, SPOT, and MODIS sensors. These data sets are freely available to the remote-sensing community. A number of studies showed suitability of the NDVI time-series for monitoring the dynamics of insect populations, mapping of locust habitats, and damage assessment (Tratalos & Cheke 2006; Thomson & Connor 2000; Despland and others 2004; Li and others 2005; Zha and others 2005). Currently, there are a number of routine and operational locust forecasting systems based on the incorporation of locust survey information and the monitoring of habitat conditions using remote-sensing and geographic information systems (GIS), which have already been established and promoted by the Food and Agricultural Organization (Magor & Pender 1997; Latchininsky & Sivanpillai 2010).
During last two decades, some progress has been achieved in the remote sensing–based monitoring of potential locust hazard in Central Asia (Latchininsky 2007; Latchininsky and others 2007; Sivanpillai and others 2006, 2009). However, considering the importance of this region to global change and global food security (Henebry 2009), the achieved progress is not enough to close the existing research gap. Monitoring of locust hazard and the assessment of regions after damage have great importance with respect to recent efforts toward mapping carbon sequestration in the drylands of Kazakhstan (Propastin and others 2012).
This study aimed to contribute to the current research of locust hazard in the largest country of Central Asia: Kazakhstan. The article introduces a satellite-based monitoring system for the assessment of locust infestation risk in the Balkhash Lake region in Kazakhstan. In doing so, this study is not unique: Examples of this type of research have been reported from various regions (e.g., Hunter and others 2008; Tian and others 2008; Liu and others 2008) and also from the Balkhash Lake drainage basin (Sivanpillai and others 2006). Instead, using well-established approaches for remote sensing–based mapping of locust habitats using single-date (Sivanpillai and others 2006; Ma and others 2005) or multitemporal data (Sivanpillai & Latchininsky 2007), the present study strived to make a contribution to current literature through the introduction and testing of a novel monitoring technique. The novelty of the proposed monitoring system is that it uses data from diverse satellite sources, e.g., satellite-based multitemporal NDVI, and satellite altimetry data, which are combined with ground measurements of climatic variables. The developed monitoring system is employed for (1) mapping and interannual monitoring the spatial distribution of breeding areas of L. migratoria migratoria in the Balkhash Lake drainage basin; and (2) quantifying the impact of climate factors and hydrological regimen of Balkhash Lake on the interannual variability of potential locust habitats.
Study Area and its Environments
Lake Balkhash, the world’s fifth largest isolated water reservoir, has a volume of approximately 90 km³ and a catchment area >0.5 million km² (Fig. 1). The lake is situated in the Balkhash-Alakol depression and has a length of 605 km and a width varying between 4 and 74 km. The Lake Balkhash basin is internally drained, with the major loss of inflow water being evaporation from the lake surface. The main contributors to the Balkhash Lake are the Ili (78.2 % of the total surface inflow), the Karatal (15.1 %), the Aksu (0.13 %), and the Lepsy rivers (5.4 %). Long-term periodic fluctuations in the Balkhash Lake water levels have been suggested to be conditioned primarily climatically (but also, to a smaller degree, anthropogenically) and demonstrate their intimate connection with components of its water regime, especially runoff from the Ili River (Petr 1992; Piven 1990; Djanalieva & Bogachev 1992).
The climate in the region is strongly continental, with low annual precipitation (< 180 mm) and severe daily and annual temperature variations. The Lake Balkhash basin ecosystems comprise several plentiful wetlands in the deltas of its inflows. Floodplains of these wetlands are covered by thickets of reed grass (species Phragmates communis and Calamagrostis pseudophragmates). These ecosystems are very fragile and directly correlate with the Lake Balkhash inflow from contributing rivers as well as its water level (Petr 1992; Tlenbekov & Piven 1993; Propastin 2008).
The construction of the Kaptchagay dam in the upper part of Ili River in 1970 took place during the last downward fluctuation in flow and lead to the steepest decrease in the lake’s water level since the initiation of measurement. This additionally affected the fragile ecosystems of Balkhash Lake and its environments (Tlenbekov & Piven 1993; Petr & Mitrofanov 1998).
Problem of Locust Hazard in the Study Area
Asian migratory locusts have four development stages: hatching, fledging, wing-growth instars, and nymph. L. migratoria migratoria feeds on approximately ten plant species with a preference for two reed grass species, P. communis and C. pseudophragmates, which dominate the vegetation communities in floodplains of the river delta in the Lake Balkhash drainage basin. For that reason, the developmental stages of the Asian migratory locust in the Balkhash Lake region strongly coincide with the growing period of reed grass in the river’s deltas. Because the interannual and seasonal vegetation dynamics in the Lake Balkhash region are strongly correlated with the discharge of the Lake Balkhash inflow rivers and water level (Propastin and others 2007; Propastin 2008), the developmental pattern and population dynamics of the Asian migratory locust are synchronized with the hydrological regimen of its breeding areas (Kambulin 1992; Sivanpillai and others 2006).
The region of the formerly Soviet Central Asia includes five republics—Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, and Tajikistan—which obtained independence after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 brought enormous and rapid changes in the economies of the post-Soviet republics. The former state system of preventing and combating locust hazard has been devastated (Latchininsky 2007). Locust survey and antilocust treatments were decreased to a minimum. Since the early 1990 s, monitoring and control of the Asian migratory locust in the Balkhash Lake drainage basin have been implemented at very low levels, and almost no control was applied until 1999. Together with continuing drought, these factors led to a build-up of locust populations, which required extensive control operations during 2000–2003 (Khasenov 2001; Toleubayev and others 2007). From this background, the development of effective, low-cost systems for monitoring locust hazard risk in the formerly Soviet Central Asia is of great importance. However, there is a gap in the state-of-the-art research in this region (Toleubayev and others 2007).
Data Used in the Study
The VEGETATION (VGT) sensor, on board the SPOT-4 satellite, has four spectral bands, blue (430 470 nm), R (610–680 nm), NIR (780–890 nm), and short-wave infrared (1580 to 1750 nm), of which R and NIR are used to calculate the NDVI. The SPOT-VGT provides daily global images at 1-km spatial resolution. These data are archived and used to generate global 10-day synthesis NDVI maps. The compositing method for generating 10-day NDVI data is to select an observation with the maximum NDVI value within a 10-day period (Holben 1986). This way, nonvegetated features, such as clouds and shadows, originally presented in the raw data were significantly decreased. The standard 10-day composite data are freely available to the public (http://free.vgt.vito.be).
For this study, we acquired SPOT-VGT NDVI data for the growing season (April through October) from 1998 through 2004 over the study area. Remaining noisy pixels in the NDVI data set were removed by employing a spatio-temporal filter, which calculated a new value for each noisy pixel from values of neighbouring non-noisy pixels (Chen and others 2004).
TOPEX/Poseidon and Jason 1 Altimeter Data
Satellite altimetry observations provide a unique opportunity to monitor the ocean and sea evolution in real time, accurately, with high temporal resolution and at the global scale. Radar altimetry was initially developed for oceanographic purposes, but in recent years it has been used as a powerful tool for monitoring inland water sources.
The main product of altimetry missions is surface-level height data (in the case of studies on inland water it is lake-level height data). Two altimetry data sets have been widely exploited in oceanographic and hydrological studies: TOPEX/Poseidon (T/P) in its original orbit with a 9.915625-day repetition time, and Jason 1, the follow-up mission to T/P, which was launched in 2001. Similar to T/P, Jason 1’s orbital repeatability is every 9.915625 days with the same global coverage.
Ten-day records of air temperature and precipitation for 1998 through 2007 at 10 weather stations located in the study area (Fig. 1b) were used for the analysis of climatic conditions in the Balkhash Lake drainage basin. From these data, we calculated mean growing season temperature and average annual precipitation for the study region.
Ground Truth and Verification Data
Ground surveys were performed during our trips to the study area in summer 2004 to summer 2008 to collect field data for image classification and accuracy assessment. Altogether 120 locations within different vegetation-cover classes were collected using a GPS receiver (Garmin Ltd, Olathe, KS). The accuracy of geolocation measurements with the GPS devise was \( \pm \)5–8 m. In addition, information about changes in land cover was obtained through interviews with local authorities and specialists. We also analysed topographic maps at the scale 1:100,000 and fine-resolution Landsat TM (path 151–152, row 028–029, acquisition date July 15 1994, September 20 1992) and ETM+ (path 151–152, row 028–029, acquisition date May 23 2006, June 05 2006, August 02 2001) images with respect to the distribution of land-cover classes in the study area.
Monitoring System for Locust Infestation Risk
Risk of locust infestation for different vegetation classes in the Balkhash Lake basin
Risk of locust infestation
Classification procedure was performed using ENVI 4.8 image analysis software (ITT Corp). We selected areas of known vegetation types to be used as a classification-training area based on the field data and agreement among various cartographic data sets. These training areas, which represented small percentage of the total area of the Balkhash Lake basin, were used to label the feature space formed between the first and second PCs for each pixel of the study area. Boundaries of the various vegetation types were determined on the basis of the location of the training areas in the feature space and the classification image produced. The mapping process was repeated for every year from 1998 through 2007.
Accuracy of the classification procedure was examined using geo-referenced ground-collected data, comprising ground truth points, topographic maps, and fine-resolution satellite images (see Section Ground Truth and Verification Data). The Kappa coefficient was used as a guide to assess classification accuracy.
Assessing the Risk of Locust Infestations for Vegetation Classes
We used a three-category (low, medium, and high) scale to assess vegetation areas with respect to their susceptibility to be infected by locust swarms (Table 1). Susceptibility of individual vegetation classes to locust infestation risk was taken from previous works in the region (Sivanpillai and others 2006; Kambulin 1992). The highest risk was associated with reed stands. Such habitats provide favourable conditions for locust feeding and egg-laying. Vegetation complexes in river valleys (Tugay forests), where reeds are mixed with trees and grasses, were assigned a medium risk. Medium-risk habitats included grasses, forbs, and shrubs (vegetation class “grassland”). Finally, solonchaks (strongly salinized areas), reed stands submerged in water (flooded reeds), and sand dunes represent the habitats with low risk of locust infestation.
Analysing the Impact of Environmental Factors on Risk of Locust Infestations
To examine influence of climatic and hydrological factors on risk of locust infestations in the study area, we analysed the spatial extent of potential habitats of L. migratoria migratoria for its response to climate dynamics. The first part of the infestation dynamics assessment was quantified with correlation analysis between different degrees of locust infestation risk in individual years and climatic variables. We also examined the association between the hydrological regimen of the Balkhash Lake and locust risk. In this analysis, the spatial extent of potential locust habitats was compared with the water level in the Balkhash Lake obtained from the altimetry data.
Statistical significance and strength of the associations between the environmental factors and spatial extent of the potential locust habitats was tested by Student t test. The criterion for significance was set to P < 0.05. Finally, multivariable three-dimensional diagrams were generated to summarize and examine the evolution of the areas associated with locust habitats during the period from 1998 through 2007.
Growing-Season Dynamics of NDVI in Individual Vegetation Classes
The data depicted in Fig. 4 show growing season profiles of NDVI for five of the seven individual vegetation classes from the study area. All presented vegetation classes demonstrate considerable variation in seasonal NDVI dynamics. However, the amplitude and patterns of these variations differ between the vegetation classes. Vegetation-free solonchaks were the only area observed to be temporally invariant. There are also differences between vegetation types regarding greening-up and peaking time. Sand dunes and grassland have their growth peak at the end of May to the beginning of June, whereas other vegetation types show the greatest growth significantly later at the end of June to the beginning of July.
Thus, the NDVI curves of Tugay forests show profiles with only one sharp peak at the middle of July, whereas reed grass exhibit a more rounded profile with a prolonged period of the greatest growth (from the beginning of June through the end of July). Tugay forests are associated with distinctly greater NDVI values in the beginning of the growing season (April through May) than the other presented vegetation types. The temporal NDVI profile of reeds submerged in water is similar to that of reeds only during the third part of the growing season (the end of July through October), when the flooding time is finished, and the largest part of reed plants stays above the remaining water. During the first and second parts of the growing season, the flooded reed plants are characterized by low NDVI values because most of the plant is submerged in water.
Classification of Vegetation Cover and Areas of Locust Infestation Risk
Satellite-based estimation of areas for various vegetation-cover classes (km²) averaged from 1998–2007
Risk of locust infestation
% of total
Nonlinear R² between spatial extensions of areas associated with high to medium risk for locust infestation and environmental variables using third-order polynomial regression
Risk of locust infestation
Tugay + reeds
High to medium
Together, the areas of high and medium risk represented >13.5 % of the Balkhash Lake drainage basin, which should become a focus for locust population monitoring and management activities. Pixels classified as grassland vegetation constituted 10.07 % of the study region area. They were identified as medium to low risk for potential locust habitats.
Reeds submerged in water were termed low risk for potential locust habitats and occupied 1.5 % of the total area. Other vegetation classes, such as solonchaks and vegetation of sands, occupy 74 % of the study region and represent low risk for locust infestation. Figure 5b depicts the average vegetation class distribution as it relates to potential locust infestation risk for 1998 through 2007.
Dynamics of Locust Habitat Extension and Environmental Factors
Years with particularly high temperature and low precipitation (1997, 2000, and 2005) preceded years with the greatest risk of potential locust habitats (1998, 2001, and 2006). There also is a relationship between the water level of Balkhash Lake and the areas (Fig. 6a). However, this relationship is not as obvious as in the case of temperature. Indeed, during 1998 through 2002, an increase in water level was not accompanied by an increase of areas. In contradiction, the area of potential locust habitat temporarily decreased from 1998 through 2002. During the second part of the study period (2003 through 2007), the area of high to medium risk seems to be proportional to the water level of Balkhash Lake. We suggest that the relationship between water level and area of potential locust habitat is nonlinear. Therefore, in this case linear correlation analysis would be confusing.
Relation Between Environmental Factors and Risk for Locust Infestation
To quantify the relationship between locust infestation risk area and environmental factors, we calculated the coefficient of determination (R²) between variables performing bivariate nonlinear regression analysis (third-order polynomial). The analysis was performed on a concurrent basis using coherent time series of the variables, with a single-year time lag when inputted into the statistical regression. The results of the regression analysis are listed in Table 3. Indeed, temperature correlates with each of the vegetation types; however, we should take into account two different impacts of temperature on vegetation growth.
For analysis at the concurrent basis, the results, as might be expected, indicate that temperature is one of the major climatic factors enforcing plant growth in this area: Above a certain base value, a plant’s growth rate is proportional to temperature. For Tugay, reeds, and Tugay + reeds, the results demonstrate that influence of temperature from the preceding year is stronger than from the concurrent year. In this case, we must assume that the impact of temperature is indirect: Temperature influences other variables that have a direct impact on vegetation growth during the concurrent year.
Recent literature reported about the consistency of temperature with the hydrological regime of the Balkhash Lake’s contributing rivers (Tlenbekov & Piven 1993). Dry years with high temperature cause a significant decrease in rainfall and snow accumulation in the Balkhash Lake drainage basin, which, as a consequence, results in a decrease of run-off during the following year. From that reason, larger areas are free from seasonal flooding in the deltas of the Ili River and other rivers, thus expanding the habitat suitable for locust oviposition and subsequent nymphal development during the next year. These results support the previous observation by visual analysis of Fig. 6.
The statistically significant R² values for the analysis with one lag show the general impact of the preceding year’s precipitation on the subsequent year. Nonetheless, the influence of rainfall is much weaker than that of temperature. The results show that in the analysed vegetation categories, the major source of water available for plant growth is surface water from periodic flooding. These vegetation types show strong correlations with the water level of Balkhash Lake. The dynamics of the water level explain >80 % of the variance in reed areas. For Tugay forest, the explanatory power is somewhat lower (R² = 0.78). The results associated with Tugay and reeds suggest that precipitation also plays a role in plant growth of these vegetation classes, even although this role is small.
It was found that averaged over the study period from 1998 through 2007, only approximately 13.5 % of the total area of the Balkhash Lake basin was subject to locust infestation. Approximately 10 % of the total area was assigned a medium to low risk of locust infestation. The remaining area represented habitats with low risk of locust infestation. The present study used similar classes related to the risk of potential locust infestation similar as Sivanpillai and others (2006) for the Ili River delta. However, the percentages of areas with risk of locust infestation obtained in our study were incomparable with those reported by Sivanpillai and others (2006) because the study area of the presented investigation was approximately 10 times greater than the Ili River delta (Sivanpillai and others 2006).
Because the area of potential locust habitats correlates positively with temperature, ongoing global climate change prompts locust hazard risk. However, the issue of contemporary warming has only been infrequently discussed in the content of climate impact on locust vulnerability. The international society and policy-makers should also recognize this issue of climate change. At the scale of the Balkhash Lake region, climate conditions should be extensively monitored regarding forecast outbreaks of Asian migratory locusts. The results of this study show that temperature and precipitation can be used as effective indicators of locust risk. Higher temperature and lower precipitation amounts, in combination with a lower water level in Balkhash Lake, are reliable signs for high risk of a locust outbreak.
However, the network of meteorological stations in the region of Balkhash Lake is not sufficiently dense, and the quality of climate observations at stations shows many deficiencies in measurements and reports. The constitutional change had a negative influence on the collection of climate data in Kazakhstan as a whole and in the region of Balkhash Lake in particular. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, a number of climate stations in the region were abandoned because of diminished financial support. Similar problems are found in the observation of Lake Balkhash water levels. Regular lake-level gauge measurements are practically absent from 1993 to the present. In this sense, satellite-altimetry observations provide a unique opportunity to establish a monitoring system of the water levels in Balkhash Lake.
Obviously, the locust control system was negatively affected by the transformation of the political system in Kazakhstan during the 1990 to 2000 s. The new socioeconomic system gave/gives low priority to meteorological and hydrological observations as well as plant protection service, which are indispensable for effective locust control. Once locusts infected huge areas in southern and northern Kazakhstan and destroyed a large part of cereal crop yield during the locust plague from 1998 to 2001, decision makers realized that the locust-control system requires strong support by the state as well as collective action (Latchininsky and others 2007; Toleubayev and others 2007). However, efforts to establish an ecological view of locust control, as well as the ability to understand relationships between climate, hydrological regime, land-use change, and locust hazard risk, are incomplete.
This study investigated the link between environmental conditions and areas of potential locust infestation. For this purpose, the 10-day time series of the NDVI, derived from SPOT-VGT satellite, was used for mapping potential locust habitats and monitoring their area during the period from 1998 though 2007. Environmental conditions were represented by 10-day climatic data from a climate station located in the study area, and the water level in Balkhash Lake was derived from satellite altimetry observations (T/P/Jason 1).
The results demonstrate that SPOT-VGT data are a powerful tool for mapping areas threatened by locust hazard and monitoring their interannual dynamics over large regions. Because of low precipitation and air humidity in the study region, most of the used SPOT-VGT composites were cloud-free. Existing noisy composites in the data set were corrected using a spatio-temporal filtering procedure (Chen and others 2004) that calculated new values for the noisy pixels using their spatial and temporal neighbours. This data-preprocessing step may be one of the reasons for some resulting misclassification. Certainly, future progress in this research field will improve the accuracy of classification.
The presented combination of SPOT-VGT data with altimetry data from T/P/Jason 1 promises great potential for establishing a low-cost and effective multisensor monitoring system for mapping locust habitats in the Lake Balkhash drainage basin. Moreover, because areas for locust breeding are closely linked to the water level and temperature of a previous year, forecasting locust hazard risk is absolutely possible.
This research work has been performed as part of the research project “Dry Lands Management in Kazakhstan,” which was funded by the World Development Bank and the Government of Kazakhstan. The work of the author was supported by a grant from the Space Research Institute of the Science Academy of Kazakhstan. The author gratefully acknowledges all colleges from the Space Research Institute and particularly the head of the institute, N. R. Muratova, for helpful recommendations and approvals.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.