Abstract
We used Life Cycle Assessment to scenario model the potential reductions in cumulative energy demand (both fossil and renewable) and global warming, acidifying, and ozone-depleting emissions associated with a hypothetical national transition from conventional to organic production of four major field crops [canola (Brassica rapa), corn (Zea mays), soy (Glycine max), and wheat (Triticum aestivum)] in Canada. Models of these systems were constructed using a combination of census data, published values, and the requirements for organic production described in the Canadian National Organic Standards in order to be broadly representative of the similarities and differences that characterize these disparate production technologies. Our results indicate that organic crop production would consume, on average, 39% as much energy and generate 77% of the global warming emissions, 17% of the ozone-depleting emissions, and 96% of the acidifying emissions associated with current national production of these crops. These differences were almost exclusively due to the differences in fertilizers used in conventional and organic farming and were most strongly influenced by the higher cumulative energy demand and emissions associated with producing conventional nitrogen fertilizers compared to the green manure production used for biological nitrogen fixation in organic agriculture. Overall, we estimate that a total transition to organic production of these crops in Canada would reduce national energy consumption by 0.8%, global warming emissions by 0.6%, and acidifying emissions by 1.0% but have a negligible influence on reducing ozone-depleting emissions.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexandratos N (1999) World food and agriculture: outlook for the medium and longer term. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 96:5908–5914
Badgley C, Moghtader J, Quintero E et al (2007) Organic agriculture and the global food supply. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 22:86–108
Bhat M, English B, Turhollow A et al (1994) Energy in synthetic fertilizers and pesticides: revisited. NRNL/Sub/90-99732/2. National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA
Brentrup F, Kusters J, Kuhlman H et al (2001) Application of the Life Cycle Assessment methodology to agricultural production: An example of sugar beet production with different forms of nitrogen fertilizers. European Journal of Agronomy 14:221–233
Canadian General Standards Board (2006) Canada organic production systems permitted substances lists. Retrieved May, 2006, from http://www.pwgsc.gc.ca/cgsb/on_the_net/organic/032_0311_2006-e.pdf
Canadian Council of Ministers (2001) National action plan for the environmental control of ozone-depleting substances and their halocarbon alternatives: May 2001 update. Retrieved January, 2007, from http://www.ccme.ca/assets/pdf/nap_update_e.pdf
CANSIM (2007) Average yield of principal field crops in Canada. Retrieved January, 2007, from http://cansim2.statcan.ca/
Carpenter S, Caraco N, Correl D et al (1998) Non-point pollution of surface waters with phosphorus and nitrogen. Ecological Applications 8(3):559–568
Carvalho F (2006) Agriculture, pesticides, food security and food safety. Environmental Science and Policy 9(7–8):685–692
Cassman K (1999) Ecological intensification of cereal production systems: yield potential, soil quality, and precision agriculture. Proceedings of the National Academy of ScienceUSA 96:5952–5959
CML (2001) CML 2 Baseline Method 2000. Centre for Environmental Studies, University of Leiden, Netherlands
Cox T, Glover J, Van Tassel D et al (2006) Prospects for developing perennial grain crops. BioScience 56(8):649–659
Crews T, Peoples M (2004) Legume versus fertilizer sources of nitrogen: ecological tradeoffs and human needs. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 102:279–297
Dobbie K, McTaggart I, Smith K (1999) Nitrous oxide emissions from intensive agricultural systems: variations between crops and seasons, key driving variables, and mean emission factors. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 105(21):26891–26899
EcoInvent (2007) Swiss centre for life cycle inventories. Available at http://www.ecoinvent.ch/
El-Hage Scialabba N, Hattam C (eds) (2002) Organic agriculture, environment and food security. Environment and Natural Resources Service Sustainable Development Department, UNFAO, Rome. Retrieved September, 2005, from http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/005/Y4137E/y4137e01.htm#P0_0
Environment Canada (2006) National Inventory Report 1990–2004: greenhouse gas sources and sinks in Canada. Retrieved January, 2007, from http://www.ec.gc.ca/pdb/ghg/inventory_report/2004_report/2004_report_e.pdf
Environment Canada (2007) Acid rain and the facts. Retrieved January, 2007, from http://www.ec.gc.ca/acidrain/acidfact.html
Ess D, Vaughan D, Luna J et al (1994) Energy and economic savings from the use of legume cover crops in Virginia corn production. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 9(4):178–185
Fournier J (1999) Pesticides: are they pests or blessing? Actualite Chimique 11:34–39
Gerhardt R (1997) A comparative analysis of the effects of organic and conventional farming systems on soil structure. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 14:139–157
Guinee J, Gorree M, Heijungs R et al (2001) Life cycle assessment: an operational guide to the ISO Standards Part 2. Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment, The Hague, Netherlands. Retrieved January, 2006, from http://www.leidenuniv.nl/cml/ssp/projects/lca2/part1.pdf
Hall C, Klitgaard K (2006) The need for a new, biophysical-based paradigm in economics for the second half of the age of oil. International Journal of Transdisciplinary Research 1(1):4–22
Haas G, Wetterich F, Köpke U (2001) Comparing intensive, extensified and organic grassland farming in southern Germany by process life cycle assessment. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 83:43–53
Hoeppner J (2001) The effects of legume green manures, perennial forages, and cover crops on non-renewable energy use in western Canadian cropping systems. Master’s thesis, Department of Plant Science, University of Winnipeg, Canada
Hoeppner J, Entz M, McConkey B et al (2006) Energy use and efficiency in two Canadian organic and conventional crop production systems. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 21:60–67
IPCC (2006) Guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. Intergovernmental panel on climate change. Retrieved September, 2006, from http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/index.htm
Jordan N, Boody G, Broussard W et al (2007) Environment: sustainable development of the agricultural bio-economy. Science 316(5831):1570–1571
Killpack S, Buchholz D (1993) Nitrogen replacement value of legumes. University of Missouri Extension. Retrieved September, 2006, from http://www.extension.missouri.edu/explore/envqual/wq0277.htm
Korol M (2002) Canadian fertilizer consumption shipments and trade 2001/2002. Agriculture and Agri-food Canada. Retrieved January, 2006, from http://www.agr.gc.ca/pol/pub/canfert/pdf/canfert01_02_e.pdf
Leikem D, Lamond R, Bonczkowski L et al (2007) Using legumes in crop rotations. Kansas State University. Retrieved January, 2008, from http://www.oznet.ksu.edu/library/crpsl2/l778.pdf
Levelton Engineering Ltd., (S&T)2 Consultants Inc (1999) Assessment of net emissions of greenhouse gases from ethanol-gasoline blends in southern Ontario. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Policy Branch, Ottawa. Retrieved January, 2006, from http://www.oregon.gov/ENERGY/RENEW/Biomass/docs/FORUM/GHG_Eth.PDF
Lockeretz W, Shearer G, Sweeney S et al (1980) Maize yields and soil nutrient levels with and without pesticides and standards commercial fertilizers. Agronomy Journal 72:65–72
Mattsson B (1999) LCA of carrot puree: case studies of organic and integrated production. Swedish Institute for Food and Biotechnology Report No. 653, Gothenburg, Sweden
MEA (2005) Ecosystems and human well-being. Volume 1. Current state and trends. Findings of the Conditions and Trends Working Group. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, Island Press, Washington, DC
Offerman F, Nieberg H (2000) Economic performance of organic farms in Europe. Organic Farming In Europe: Economics and Policy 5, University of Hohenheim, Germany
Pelletier N, Tyedmers P (2007) Feeding farmed salmon: is organic better? Aquaculture 272:399–416
Pelletier N, Ayer N, Tyedmers P et al (2007) Impact categories for life cycle assessment research of seafood production: review and prospectus. International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 12(6):414–421
Pennington D, Potting J, Finnveden G et al (2004) Life cycle assessment part 2: current impact assessment practice. Environment International 30:721–739
Pimentel D, Pimentel M (2006) Global environmental resources versus world population growth. Ecological Economics 59:195–198
Pimentel D, Hepperly P, Hanson J et al (2005) Environmental, energetic and economics comparisons of organic and conventional farming systems. Bioscience 55(7):573–582
PRé (2006) SimaPro 7.0. PRe consultants, Netherlands. Retrieved January, 2006, from http://www.pre.nl
Rhem G, Schmitt M, Eliason R (2002) Fertilizer recommendations for edible beans in Minnesota. University of Minnesota Extension. Retrieved September, 2006, from http://www.134.84.92.126/distribution/cropsystems/DC6572.html
Robertson G, Paul E, Harwood R (2000) Greenhouse gases in intensive agriculture: contributions of individual gases to radiative forcing of the atmosphere. Science 289:1922–1925
Shelley K (2004) Nitrogen fertilizer rates and application timing for winter wheat in Wisconsin—What are the economic optimums? University of Wisconsin Extension Services. Retrieved September, 2006, from http://www.soils.wisc.edu/extension/FAPM/2004proceedings/Shelley.pdf
Smil V (2001) Feeding the world. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Smolik J, Dobbs T, Rickerl D (1995) The relative sustainability of alternative, conventional, and reduced-till farming systems. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 10(1):25–35
Stanhill G (1990) The comparative productivity of organic agriculture. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 30:1–26
State J, Posner J (1995) Legume cover crops as a nitrogen source for corn in an oat–corn rotation. Journal of Production Agriculture 8(3):385–390
Statistics Canada (2007) Seeded area of field and speciality crops in Canada. Retrieved January, 2007, from http://www40.statcan.ca/l01/cst01/prim11a.htm
Stolze M, Priorr A, Haring A et al (2000) The environmental impacts of organic farming in Europe. Organic farming in Europe: economics and policy 6. University of Hohenheim, Germany. Retrieved February, 2006, from http://www.uni-hohenheim.de/i410a/ofeurope/organicfarmingineurope-vol6.pdf
(S&T)2 Consultants Inc (2003) The addition of ethanol from wheat to GHGenius. Natural Resources Canada, Office of Energy Efficiency, Ottawa. Retrieved February, 2006, from http://www.gov.mb.ca/est/energy/ethanol/wheat-ethanolreport.pdf
(S&T)2 Consultants Inc (2005) Biodiesel GHG emissions using GHGenius: An update. Natural Resources Canada, Office of Energy Efficiency, Ottawa. Retrieved January, 2006, from http://www.studio255.com/crfa/pdf/res/20050311_NRCan_Biodiesel_GHG_Emissions.pdf
Thomassen M, van Calker K, Smits M et al (2008) Life cycle assessment of conventional and organic milk production in the Netherlands. Agricultural Systems 96:95–107
VDI (1997) Cumulative energy demand: terms, definitions, methods of calculation. VDI-Richtlinien (4600) Verein Deutscher Ingenieure, Düsseldorf
Williams A, Audsley E, Sandars D (2006) Determining the environmental burdens and resource use in the production of agricultural and horticultural commodities. Main Report. DEFRA Research Project IS0205, Cranfield University. Retrieved January, 2007 from www.silsoe.cranfield.ac.uk
Wood R, Lenzen M, Lundie S (2006) A comparative study of some environmental impacts of conventional and organic farming in Australia. Agricultural Systems 89:324–348
Acknowledgments
This work was generously supported by the Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada, the Killam Trust, and the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada. We also acknowledge the thoughtful and constructive input of three reviewers. Any errors are, of course, the sole responsibility of the authors.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pelletier, N., Arsenault, N. & Tyedmers, P. Scenario Modeling Potential Eco-Efficiency Gains from a Transition to Organic Agriculture: Life Cycle Perspectives on Canadian Canola, Corn, Soy, and Wheat Production. Environmental Management 42, 989–1001 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-008-9155-x
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-008-9155-x