Cardiovascular molecular imaging of apoptosis
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Wolters, S.L., Corsten, M.F., Reutelingsperger, C.P.M. et al. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging (2007) 34: 86. doi:10.1007/s00259-007-0443-0
- 333 Views
Molecular imaging strives to visualise processes at the molecular and cellular level in vivo. Understanding these processes supports diagnosis and evaluation of therapeutic efficacy on an individual basis and thereby makes personalised medicine possible.
Apoptosis and molecular imaging
Apoptosis is a well-organised mode of cell suicide that plays a role in cardiovascular diseases (CVD). Apoptosis is associated with loss of cardiomyocytes following myocardial infarction, atherosclerotic plaque instability, congestive heart failure and allograft rejection of the transplanted heart. Thus, apoptosis constitutes an attractive target for molecular imaging of CVD. Our current knowledge about the molecular players and mechanisms underlying apoptosis offers a rich palette of potential molecular targets for molecular imaging. However, only a few have been successfully developed so far.
This review highlights aspects of the molecular machinery and biochemistry of apoptosis relevant to the development of molecular imaging probes. It surveys the role of apoptosis in four major areas of CVD and portrays the importance and future perspectives of apoptosis imaging. The annexin A5 imaging protocol is emphasised since it is the most advanced protocol to measure apoptosis in both preclinical and clinical studies.
KeywordsApoptosisMolecular imagingCardiovascular diseaseAnnexin A5
The term ‘apoptosis’ is derived from the Greek (apo = from and ptosis = falling, commonly pronounced ap-a-tow’-sis) and denotes a regulated process of cell suicide resulting in a cell corpse that is distinct from the necrotic cell [1, 2]. Whereas necrosis is manifested by cellular swelling, plasma membrane rupture and rapid release of intracellular constituents into the environment, causing an inflammatory response , apoptosis is characterised by cell shrinkage, long-lasting maintenance of plasma membrane integrity and lack of inflammatory responses in the vicinity of the dying cell . It has long been thought that apoptosis and necrosis are the only two modes of cell death counterbalancing mitosis . However, recent insights have taught us that cells can follow more roads to death than only apoptosis and necrosis. In 2001, Leist and Jaättelä suggested a model in which various forms of cell death could be positioned on a gliding scale between two extremes, apoptosis and necrosis . The mode of execution depends on the cell type and the cell death-inducing trigger. Most knowledge about various modes of cell death has been generated in the field of oncology, where cell death plays an important role in the progression and treatment of cancer . Several intermediate forms of cell death have been identified and characterised [6, 7], including mitotic catastrophe and autophagic cell death. Mitotic catastrophe can be the result of unsuccessful chromosome segregation, an event that requires malfunctioning of multiple cell cycle checkpoints. Catastrophic cells are large and non-viable cells with a compromised nuclear blueprint leading eventually to cell death . Mitotic catastrophe appears to be a rare event in cardiovascular diseases. Autophagic cell death is characterised by the total destruction of the cell through autophagy. It is a process in which cytoplasmic constituents are degraded through the lysosomal machinery . Autophagic cell death occurs both in oncology [10, 11] and in cardiovascular diseases . The various described modes of cell death differ in morphology and biochemistry . The caspase cascade is the most remarkable biochemical distinction . It is activated during apoptosis but hardly, or not at all, during other modes of cell death.
Biochemistry of apoptotic cell death
Two major biochemical routes dominate apoptotic cell death. They involve the activation of the caspase cascade through either death-receptor mediated signal transduction or stress-induced release of cytochrome C from mitochondria . Caspases involved in apoptosis can be grouped into initiator (caspases 8 and 9) and effector caspases (caspases 3 and 7). The principal event of the caspase cascade is the activation of an inactive procaspase into a proteolytically active caspase. Activation of initiator caspases occurs through auto-activation, catalysed by the interaction with ligated death receptors (procaspase 8) or cytochrome C-containing apoptosome (procaspase 9). Effector caspases are activated through intra-chain cleavage by active initiator caspases . In both cases, activation results in the exposure of active sites that selectively cleave peptide bonds after an aspartate residue in caspase substrates.
Several checks and balances exist that control burst of the caspase cascade if triggered by minor undesired initiating events. Inhibitors of apoptotic proteins (IAPs) suppress proteolytic activity by binding to activated caspases. Inhibition of IAPs is in turn required to allow execution of apoptosis. Smac/DIABLO residing in the mitochondria and co-released with cytochrome C inhibits IAPs and permits propagation and amplification of the proteolytic signal through the caspase cascade. Anti-apoptotic members of the Bcl-2 family such as Bcl-2 and Bcl-X prevent the release of cytochrome C and Smac/DIABLO from mitochondria. Pro-apoptotic members such as Bax and tBid, which is the result of Bid cleavage by activated caspase 8, neutralise the protective effects of the anti-apoptotic members and provoke mitochondria to release their pro-apoptotic cargo.
The intricate scheme of the apoptotic machinery offers several potential targets for molecular imaging. For example, knowledge about the mechanism of caspase activation has triggered the design of several strategies to measure apoptosis [17–19]. The hurdle these methods have to take is entrance of the reporter of caspase activity into the cell. Consequently, in vivo applications of such strategies face unfavourable biodistribution profiles and high background levels. Targets embedded in the plasma membrane encompass a more promising set of molecules for molecular imaging.
An essential part of the apoptotic program consists of the appearance of ‘eat me’ flags at the cell surface. Phagocytes recognise these flags and respond by engulfing the dying cell before it leaks pro-inflammatory components into the surrounding tissue. The ‘eat me’ flags are, alone or in combination, specific for the dying cell, allowing phagocytes to make the right choice in an environment filled with living cells.
In 1992, Valerie Fadok and co-workers reported that phosphatidylserine (PS) becomes exposed on the surface of apoptotic lymphocytes, where it functions as an ‘eat me’ signal for phagocytes . PS, a negatively charged aminophospholipid, is predominantly found in the cytofacial membrane leaflets of living cells. The exofacial plasma membrane leaflet contains predominantly phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin while PS is almost completely lacking. The PS asymmetry results from the ATP-dependent action of the aminophospholipid translocase that transports PS from the outer to the inner leaflet [21, 22]. During apoptosis the aminophospholipid translocase is inhibited and concomitantly a scramblase is activated. The combined action results in the surface expression of PS whilst the plasma membrane integrity remains intact.
Surface-expressed PS provides an attractive target for molecular imaging of apoptosis.
In the past decade, a molecular imaging protocol was established to detect and measure apoptosis in vitro and in vivo in animal models and patients [23–26]. This molecular imaging protocol is based upon the protein annexin A5 (Anx A5), which binds with high selectivity and with great affinity (Ka = 7 nM) [27, 28] to the PS abnormally expressed on the cell membrane of apoptotic cells [21, 22, 29]. Anx A5 is a member of a multiprotein family of more than 160 proteins that share the property of Ca2+-dependent binding to negatively charged phospholipid surfaces . The biophysical, biochemical and biological properties of Anx A5 and other members of the annexin family have been extensively described in a number of excellent reviews [30–34].
Detecting apoptosis with Anx A5
The development of annexin-based detection of apoptosis started in 1992 when Fadok et al. revealed that PS is expressed on the cell surface of apoptotic cells . This revelation led Koopman et al. to the design of an apoptosis detection assay on the basis of fluorescence (fluorescein isothiocyanate)-labelled Anx A5 . This Anx A5 affinity assay was further developed by labelling Anx A5 with biotin or with several radionuclides to facilitate various protocols for measuring apoptosis both in vitro  and in vivo [23–25, 37–41] in animal models. The availability of 99mTc-labelled Anx A5 produced under GMP regulations led to the first studies of non-invasive detection of apoptosis in patients [26, 42–46].
Detection of apoptosis using alternative methods
One such PS binding protein is the C2 domain of synaptotagmin I, which binds to anionic phospholipids in cell membranes . By conjugation of the C2 domain, synaptotagmin can be used for in vivo molecular imaging of apoptosis. Zhao and co-workers conjugated the C2 domain with superparamagnetic iron oxide (SPIO) particles, a very effective T2 relaxing MRI contrast agent, and injected the product in tumour-bearing mice. They revealed that a murine lymphoma (EL4) tumour model treated with cyclophosphamide and etoposide showed an increase in apoptotic cells from a basal value of 4% to 32% during chemotherapy. This was readily detected with C2-labelled SPIO particles and T2W MRI. Tumour regions with the greatest MRI changes correlated with regions having the highest proportion of apoptotic and necrotic cells . More recently, the same group labelled the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I radioactively (99mTc) or fluorescently (FITC) and used the labelled synaptotagmin in a reperfused acute myocardial infarction model (AMI) rat model. They found both ex vivo and in vivo accumulation of the radiotracer in the area at risk. Although some of the uptake was caused by passive leakage due to elevated vascular permeability in the area at risk, the majority was caused by specific binding to PS .
Both Anx A5 and synaptotagmin I detect apoptotic cells by selective binding to externalised PS. An alternative method to detect apoptosis may be to use a target more upstream in the apoptotic cascade, the effector caspases.
In one study the peptide-based irreversible pan-caspase inhibitor Z-VAD-fmk was radio-iodinated and suggested as a caspase imaging agent. However, due to poor cellular permeability, intracellular targeting of activated caspases was limited, preventing in vivo application . In more recent work, non-peptidyl caspase inhibitors of the 5-pyrrolidinylsulphonyl isatin-type were proposed instead of a peptide-based caspase, such as Z-VAD-fmk. These caspase binding radioligands (CBRs) may be capable of directly targeting apoptosis in vivo. CBRs are expected to form intracellular enzyme inhibitor complexes by means of binding to the activated caspases. Kopka and co-workers succeeded in labelling several 5-pyrrolidinylsulphonyl isatins with iodine-125 . However, none of these compounds have been used for non-invasive imaging in patients yet.
The ApoSense family is a group of low molecular weight amphipathic apoptosis markers targeting the cell membrane of apoptotic cells. ApoSense was developed by the Israel-based company NST. ApoSense has been used in vitro and in vivo in several disease models associated with cell death, such as radiation-induced lymphoma, renal ischaemia/reperfusion and cerebral stroke [51, 52]. However, it is still not known to which cell membrane target ApoSense exactly binds. Therefore, it remains a challenge to link ApoSense binding to the signalling cascades in apoptosis signalling.
Role and detection of apoptosis in CVD
Apoptosis of cardiomyocytes after myocardial infarction
Several forms of cell death have been observed in the infarcted myocardium. The central ischaemic zone is dominated by necrotic cell death, whereas in the periphery of the area at risk mainly apoptotic cell death is observed. Apoptotic cell death in the infarct periphery is not the exclusive domain of the cardiomyocyte. Also non-myocytes, including endothelial cells, macrophages and blood cells, contribute to a comparable degree to apoptotic cell death . Since the process of cell death can be pharmaceutically manipulated, thereby limiting the extent of myocardial cell loss, detection and quantification of apoptotic cells are of importance for determination of the full extent of reversible myocardial damage. Once the apoptotic program is activated, several targets are present both for imaging apoptosis and for therapeutic interventions.
As described earlier, the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I binds to the exposed PS on apoptotic cells. Zhao and co-workers developed a radiotracer for PS expression by labelling synaptotagmin via 2-iminothiolane thiolation with 99mTc, forming a technetium C2A glutathione S-transferase complex (99mTc-C2A-GST) . In vivo planar imaging of AMI in rats was performed on a gamma camera using a parallel-hole collimator. The uptake of 99mTc-C2A-GST within the area at risk was quantified by direct gamma counting. The foremost finding was that in seven of seven rats the infarct was clearly identifiable as focal uptake in planar images. This and other findings led the authors to conclude that the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I labelled with a radioisotope binds to both apoptotic and necrotic cells. Ex vivo and in vivo data indicate that, because of elevated vascular permeability, both specific binding and passive leakage contribute to the accumulation of the radiotracer in the area at risk. However, the latter component alone is insufficient to achieve detectable target-to-background ratios using in vivo planar imaging.
Annexin A5 has been more widely used to target PS exposure. Hiller and co-workers  recently reported on a new Anx A5-based T1 contrast agent. They linked Anx A5 to gadolinium diethylenetriamine penta-acetate (Gd-DTPA)-coated liposomes. In their model of perfused isolated rat heart, ligation of the left coronary artery for 30 min was followed by reperfusion. T1 and T2* images were acquired using an 11.7-T magnet before and after intracoronary injection of the contrast agent. A significant increase in signal intensity, visible in those regions containing cardiomyocytes in the early stage of apoptosis, was found. The group of Weissleder also reported on Anx A5-based MRI contrast agents , demonstrating the construction of a magneto-optical nanoparticle AnxCLIO-Cy5.5, which was tested in a murine model of transient coronary artery (LAD) occlusion. The synthesis of the probe was achieved in three steps. First, the amino-CLIO nanoparticle was labelled with Cy5.5 and activated with SPDP [N-succinimidyl 3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate], to yield a compound termed 2PySS-CLIO-Cy5.5. Second, Anx A5 was reacted with SATA (N-succinimidyl S-acetylthioacetate). In the final step of the process, SATAylated Anx A5 was linked with 2PySS-CLIO-Cy5.5 to yield the multimodal AnxCLIO-Cy5.5 nanoparticle. It was demonstrated that it is feasible to obtain high-resolution MR images of cardiomyocyte apoptosis in vivo with the use of the nanoparticle AnxCLIO-Cy5.5.
Atherosclerotic lesions and plaque instability
Extensive histopathological studies and investigations on the initiation of atherosclerosis in transgenic mice have generated a quite detailed picture of the development of atherosclerosis in the various stages of disease [56–63]. The onset of plaque formation is characterised by circulating levels of oxidised low-density lipoproteins, which are capable of penetrating the endothelial border while inflicting oxidative damage on the endothelial cells in the process. Subsequently, the reactionary expression of inflammatory markers on the endothelial cell surface attracts circulating monocytes to the site of injury, which, upon arrival at the scene, differentiate into macrophages and start ingesting the available lipid and other oxidised particles. Uninhibited intracellular lipid accumulation compromises the function of macrophages and converts them into foam cells . The accompanying secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines and matrix-metalloproteinases (MMP) likely contributes to the hostility of the plaque environment and weakening of collagen matrix structures, both indirectly through loss of smooth muscle cells and directly through MMP activity . At a certain point, excess damage to macrophages and smooth muscle cells induces apoptosis, causing remnants of lipid-laden dead cells to form small extracellular lipid droplets.
A luxating moment in atherogenesis is thought to occur when the remaining population of functional phagocytes becomes unable to engulf all apoptotic remnants of dying cells in the environment . Once the lesion contains a large, necrotic, lipid pool that is covered by a fibrous cap, primarily consisting of SMCs and extracellular matrix, it is named an atheroma.
A critical finding for vascular risk prediction is that although plaque rupture generally requires progression of lesion size, acute events resulting from rupture may just as well originate from only mildly stenotic lesions . Coronary catheterisation studies in patients admitted with acute coronary syndromes have shown that most of the culprit lesions are below the 50% stenosis threshold [67–69]. In reality, the extent of the lesion may be underestimated, since conventional coronary catheterisation does not take the extent of outward remodelling of the coronary artery at the site of atherosclerotic lesions into account. The emerging cardiac multislice CT technology may be better equipped to take outward remodelling into account and to assess the total coronary plaque burden in patients. Nevertheless, these data imply that though plaque dimensions will in general be sufficient for imaging-target visualisation, focussing on mere plaque size entails unsatisfactory prognostic information for clinical use. From a biological perspective, several inflammatory parameters are associated with vulnerable lesions, such as elevated extracellular levels of MMP and pro-inflammatory cytokines, including a variety of interleukins and chemotactic proteins, as has been shown in both experimental and clinical studies [70–73]. Moreover, high-risk lesions are notorious for displaying high levels of inflammation and apoptotic cells; in particular, large amounts of apoptotic macrophages have been found to reside in fragile and ruptured fibrous caps [59, 65, 74]. In 2000, Kolodgie et al.  examined 40 culprit lesions from cases of sudden coronary death and reported apoptotic macrophages to constitute up to 50% of the total macrophage population, preferentially localising at the site of rupture. Also, once atheromas have formed, plaques have been found to be far more sensitive to SMC death than regular arterial walls, as recently demonstrated by the group of Bennett . Since all these features share their relation to inflammation and more specifically apoptosis, detection of apoptosis in vivo seems a sensible approach to vulnerable plaque identification. This approach builds on the pivotal role that apoptosis plays in promoting plaque progression and disruption; however, the underlying mechanism is a complex interplay in which apoptosis affects endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells and macrophages in a different manner and with different consequences.
The expanding knowledge about plaque biology has led to the identification of a variety of potentially suitable molecular markers for vulnerable plaque imaging . Studies have been reported on the targeting of several inflammation-related molecular targets, including vascular adhesion molecules (ICAM1, VCAM1, E-selectin), neoangiogenesis molecules (αvβ3 integrin), scavenger receptors on macrophages, MMP proteolytic activity, macrophage metabolic activity and apoptosis (PS) [60, 62, 75–83]. Although some of these approaches have yielded promising experimental data, there is still a paucity of clinical studies confirming the feasibility of these targeted approaches in humans.
Of the clinical results available, the most impressive have been achieved using 99mTc-Anx A5 SPECT imaging and [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose (18FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) imaging. The latter has been used for many years to detect metabolically hyperactive processes in nuclear oncology. Since the glucose analogue 18FDG is a marker for foci of increased metabolic activity  and it is known that macrophages involved in atherosclerotic plaques have a high metabolic rate, there is sound logic behind this strategy. In addition, 18FDG imaging capitalises on the merits of oncological medicine since 18FDG is a clinically approved tracer that can be detected with high sensitivity and accuracy by PET technology, whereas PET conjugates for most alternative plaque imaging targets are still in the process of development. 18FDG imaging of arterial inflammation has been performed with rather promising results in retrospective studies of oncological 18FDG scans, in experimental settings and in in vivo clinical studies by Rudd and colleagues [76, 82, 85, 86]. In an eight-patient pilot study, they were able to correlate 18FDG uptake in carotid lesions of patients scheduled for endarterectomy with histologically assessed macrophage density (p < 0.005). However, a practical difficulty of performing 18FDG imaging in the search for coronary lesion instability lies in the physical activity of the cardiac muscle, which results in high glucose requirements and thus severe background signal.
Among the discussed imaging modalities for vulnerable plaque detection, nuclear imaging (PET in particular) is far superior to MRI, being capable of detecting probes at the picomolar range . PET further outperforms SPECT imaging regarding spatial resolution, with 4- to 6-mm versus 10- to 15-mm resolution in the centre of the field. The major difficulty in evaluating PET or SPECT usually originates from orientation and localisation of the measured signal in the body. To overcome this, nuclear imaging modalities can be co-registered and overlaid with conventional CT or MRI imaging, hence providing anatomical landmarks in relation to molecular information. Improvements in the availability and costs of PET/CT or PET/MRI imaging devices will therefore imply great advantages. Given the high costs of imaging, diagnostic algorithms in the future most likely will combine relatively cheap serum biomarkers that indicate plaque instability with the subsequent use of expensive imaging technology in selected cases. This indicates that the specific niche for both serum and imaging biomarkers needs to be defined in large prospective studies. In addition, much is to be gained from refinements of the radioligand with regard to blood clearance and biodistribution, since molecular imaging typically requires fast binding of the probe to the target, rapid subsequent clearance from the blood and not too short radioactive half-lives.
Heart failure (HF) is growing to epidemic proportions, partially due to the better treatment of AMI. The pathogenesis of heart failure is still poorly understood. There may be an important role for cell death in the progression of congestive HF. A number of papers have reported on the differences in the amount of cell death in healthy and failing hearts. The baseline rate of apoptosis in healthy human hearts is around one to ten cardiac myocytes per 105 nuclei. On the other hand, 80–250 heart muscle cells per 105 cardiac nuclei undergo apoptosis at any given time in late-stage dilated cardiomyopathy. However, it remains unclear whether this cell death is a coincidental finding, a protective process or a causal component in the pathogenesis. In work done by Wencker and co-workers, the uncertainty of the role of cell death was addressed. In a transgenic mouse model with a conditionally active caspase expressed exclusively in the myocardium, they demonstrated that even very low levels of cardiomyocyte apoptosis (23 per 105 nuclei, compared with 1.5 per 105 nuclei in controls) caused a lethal dilated cardiomyopathy. Inhibition of this active caspase largely prevented the development of cardiac dilation and contractile dysfunction. These and other data suggest that cardiomyocyte apoptosis and necrosis may be a causal mechanism of heart failure, contributing to adverse left ventricle (LV) remodelling. Inhibition of this cell death process may constitute the basis for novel therapies. Consequently, anti-apoptotic agents have been developed and tested in animal models of HF with promising results .
In addition to imaging of apoptosis, the detection of the molecular substrates of early-stage alterations leading to HF, such as vascular remodelling in infarcted tissue, is an emerging technique. Vascular remodelling is associated with non-contractile scar tissue formation that may contribute to adverse LV remodelling. However, none of these molecular techniques has reached the clinical stage yet.
Cardiac allograft rejection
Until 1997, almost 46,300 heart transplantations had been carried out worldwide . Despite this encouraging number, only 50% of cardiac transplant recipients will survive 10 years and almost all will die within 20 years unless re-transplantation is preformed . One of the possible complications for patients who have received a donor heart is transplant rejection. Under the current medical guidelines, endomyocardial biopsies (EMBs) are recommended 15–20 times in the first year after transplantation to monitor potential allograft rejection. EMB is an invasive diagnostic procedure and not without risk of complications. Allograft rejection is pathologically characterised by perivascular and interstitial mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltration associated with myocyte necrosis and apoptosis [91, 92]. Because the process of apoptosis can be pharmaceutically manipulated, identifying apoptosis non-invasively is of critical importance .
Of all the apoptotic imaging agents, Anx A5 has made the most successful transition from the test tube to the clinical arena. Novel imaging modalities like PET/CT and SPECT/CT are making a significant contribution to the growing role of molecular imaging. The combination of anatomical imaging with CT and biological imaging using SPECT or PET yields a new synergistic imaging modality that provides detailed information on the molecular (patho)physiological processes in relation to exact anatomical orientation.
The next challenge is to assess the incremental clinical value of molecular imaging and its ability to change patient management decisions. For this purpose, prospective cohort studies need to be designed to evaluate the clinical meaning of molecular imaging scan results in relation to the progression of the underlying disease. For instance, data on the association between Anx A5 uptake in plaques in the carotid arteries and clinical event rate are still lacking. The availability of such large clinical datasets may allow for better stratification of patients and therefore more optimal treatment decisions.
Finally, we and others have found that not only apoptotic cells but also viable cells are detectable with Anx A5. Our work on the vulnerable plaque showed that several processes leading to plaque instability are associated with PS expression, such as activated macrophages (inflammation) and aging red blood cells (intra-plaque haemorrhage). This ability of Anx A5 to visualise exposed PS in different biological conditions opens novel opportunities for imaging.