Diagnostic accuracy of the Barr and Blethyn radiological scoring systems for childhood constipation assessed using colonic transit time as the gold standard
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Constipation is a common childhood symptom and abdominal radiography is advocated in diagnosis and management.
To assess the reproducibility and diagnostic accuracy of the Barr and Blethyn systems for quantifying constipation on abdominal radiographs in children.
Materials and methods
Radiographs were scored by three observers of increasing radiological experience (student, junior doctor, consultant). Abdominal radiographs produced during measurement of colonic transit time (CTT) were classified as constipated or normal based on the value of the transit time, and were scored using both systems by observers blinded to the CTT. Abdominal radiographs obtained in children for reasons other than constipation were classed as normal and similarly scored. Reproducibility was measured using the kappa statistic. Diagnostic accuracy was measured using the area under the curve (AUC) for the receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve.
Using either system, scores were higher for constipated children (P<0.01). The consultant produced higher scores than the other observers (P<0.01). Interobserver reproducibility was moderate with the best kappa value only 0.48. The best correlation between score and CTT was 0.51 (junior doctor scores). Diagnostic accuracy of the scores was only moderate, with the largest AUC for a ROC curve of 0.84 for the consultant using the Barr score.
Scoring of abdominal radiographs in the assessment of childhood constipation should be abandoned because it is dependent on the experience of the observer, is poorly reproducible, and does not accurately discriminate between constipated children and children without constipation.
- Loening-Baucke, V (1993) Constipation in early childhood: patient characteristics, treatment, and longterm follow up. Gut 34: pp. 1400-1404 CrossRef
- Baker, SS, Liptak, GS, Colletti, RB (1999) Constipation in infants and children: evaluation and treatment. A medical position statement of the North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 29: pp. 612-626 CrossRef
- Rockney, RM, McQuade, WH, Days, AL (1995) The plain abdominal roentgenogram in the management of encopresis. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 149: pp. 623-627
- Barr, R, Levine, M, Wilkinson, R (1979) Chronic and occult stool retention. Clin Pediatr (Phila) 18: pp. 674-686 CrossRef
- Blethyn, AJ, Verrier Jones, K, Newcombe, R (1995) Radiological assessment of constipation. Arch Dis Child 73: pp. 532-533 CrossRef
- Bosch, M, Graafmans, D, Nievelstein, R (2006) Systematic assessment of constipation on plain abdominal radiographs in children. Pediatr Radiol 36: pp. 224-226 CrossRef
- Benninga, MA, Buller, HA, Staalman, CR (1995) Defaecation disorders in children, colonic transit time versus the Barr-score. Eur J Pediatr 154: pp. 277-284 CrossRef
- The Royal College of Radiologists (2007) Making the best use of clinical radiology services, 6th edn. The Royal College of Radiologists, London
- Metcalf, AM, Phillips, SF, Zinmeister, AR (1987) Simplified assessment of segmental colonic transit. Gastroenterology 92: pp. 40-47
- Zaslavsky, C, Silveira, TR, Maguilnik, I (1998) Total and segmental colonic transit time with radio-opaque markers in adolescents with functional constipation. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 27: pp. 138-142 CrossRef
- Lorijn, F, Rijn, RR, Heijmans, J (2006) The Leech method for diagnosing constipation: intra- and interobserver variability and accuracy. Pediatr Radiol 36: pp. 43-49 CrossRef
- Altman, D, Machin, D, Bryant, T (2000) Statistics with confidence. BMJ, London
- Cohen, J (1960) Coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 20: pp. 37-46
- Sackett, D, Haynes, R, Guyatt, G (1991) The clinical examination. Clinical epidemiology: a basic science for clinical medicine. Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia
- Collinson, P (1998) Of bombers, radiologists, and cardiologists: time to ROC. Heart 80: pp. 215-217
- Benninga, MA, Buller, HA, Tytgat, GN (1996) Colonic transit time in constipated children: does pediatric slow-transit constipation exist?. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 23: pp. 241-251 CrossRef
- Leech, SC, McHugh, K, Sullivan, PB (1999) Evaluation of a method of assessing faecal loading on plain abdominal radiographs in children. Pediatr Radiol 29: pp. 255-258 CrossRef
- Lorijn, F, Wijk, MP, Reitsma, JB (2004) Prognosis of constipation: clinical factors and colonic transit time. Arch Dis Child 89: pp. 723-727 CrossRef
- Boccia, G, Manguso, F, Coccorullo, P (2007) Functional defecation disorders in children: PACCT criteria versus Rome II criteria. J Pediatr 151: pp. 394-398 CrossRef
- Diagnostic accuracy of the Barr and Blethyn radiological scoring systems for childhood constipation assessed using colonic transit time as the gold standard
Volume 39, Issue 7 , pp 664-667
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Department of Paediatric Surgery, The Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
- 2. Department of Radiology, The Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
- 3. School of Clinical Medical Sciences (Child Health), Sir James Spence Institute, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 4LP, UK