Reevaluation of the Evolutionary Position of Opalinids Based on 18S rDNA,and α- and β-Tubulin Gene Phylogenies Article First Online: 25 May 2005 Received: 11 May 2004 Accepted: 02 February 2005 DOI:
10.1007/s00239-004-0149-x Cite this article as: Nishi, A., Ishida, K. & Endoh, H. J Mol Evol (2005) 60: 695. doi:10.1007/s00239-004-0149-x Abstract
Opalinids are enigmatic endosymbiotic protists principally found in the large intestine of anuran amphibians. They are multinucleates and uniformly covered with numerous flagella (or cilia). Their appearance is somewhat similar to that of ciliates, leading to opalinid’s initial classification as ciliates, or later as protociliates. However, on the basis of their monomorphic nuclei, absence of a ciliate-like life cycle characterized by conjugation, and an interkinetal fission mode, opalinids were subsequently transferred in the zooflagellates. As several common ultrastructural characteristics shared with proteromonads were elucidated, in particular of the flagellar base, such as their double-stranded flagellar helix, an alliance with proteromonads was widely accepted. Thus, opalinids are currently favored to be placed in the class Opalinea, within the heterokont kingdom Chromista. However, the question of their classification has not been fully resolved, because of a lack of molecular information. Here, we report their phylogenetic position inferred from 18S rDNA, and α- and β-tubulin gene sequences. The 18S rDNA tree gives the opalinids an ancestral position in heterokonts, together with proteromonads, as suggested by the morphological studies. In great contrast, α- and β-tubulin gene analyses suggest an affiliation of opalinids to alveolates, not to heterokonts. However, the AU test implies that opalinids are not closely related with any of other three phyla in the alveolates, suggesting an occupation of an ancestral position within the alveolates. Based on the present molecular information, in particular rDNA phylogeny, and the ultrastructural character of the double helix common to heterokonts, we conclude that opalinids would have a common origin with heterokonts, although analyses based on two tubulin genes do not as yet completely deny a possible placement outside heterokonts. The ambiguity of the evolutionary position shown by the discrepancy between rDNA and tubulin genes phylogenies might reflect an early emergence of opalinids in ancestral chromalveolates, and an extreme specialization during a lengthy history of parasitism, as suggested by a long branch in the rDNA tree.
Keywords Opalinids Heterokonts Alveolates Chromalveolates 18S rDNA Tubulin genes Opalina Protoopalina Cepedea Reviewing Editor: Dr. Patrick Keeling References Bardele, CF 1981 Functional and phylogenetic aspects of the ciliary membrane: a comparative freeze-fracture study BioSystems 14 403 421 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Brugerolle, G, Joyon, L 1975 Étude cytologique ultrastructurale des genres Proteromonas et Karotomorpha (Zoomastigophorea Proteromonadida GRASSÉ 1952) Protistologica 11 531 546 Google Scholar Calkins, GN 1933The biology of the protozoa2 Lea & Febiger Philadelphia Google Scholar Cavalier-Smith, T 1991 Cell diversification in heterotrophic flagellates Patterson, DJ Larsen, J eds. The biology of free-living heterotrophic flagellates Clarendon Press Oxford 113 131 Google Scholar Cavalier-Smith, T 1998 A revised six-kingdom system of life Biol Rev 73 203 266 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Cavalier-Smith, T, Allsopp, MTEP, Chao, EE 1994 Thraustochytrids are chromist, not fungi: 18S rRNA signatures of Heterokonta Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 346 387 397 Google Scholar Chen, TT 1948 Chromosomes in Opalinidae (Protozoa Ciliata) with special reference to their behavior, morphology individually, diploidy, haploidy, and association with nucleoli J Morph 83 281 359 CrossRef Google Scholar Corliss, JO 1955 The opalinid infusorians: Flagellates or ciliates? J Protozool 2 107 114 Google Scholar Corliss, JO 1982 Numbers of phyla of “protozoa” and other protists: new look at an old problem J Protozool 29 482 483 Google Scholar Corliss, JO 1990 Phylum Zoomastigina class Opalinata Margulis, L Corliss, JO Melkonian, M Chapman, DJ eds. Handbook of protoctista Jones and Barlett Boston 239 245 Google Scholar Delvinquier, BLJ, Patterson, DJ 1989 The fine structure of the cortex of the Protoopalina australlis (Slopalinida, Opalinidae) from Litoria nasuta and Litoria inermis (Amphibia: Anura: Hylidae) in Queensland Australia J Protozool 37 449 455 Google Scholar Delvinquier, BLJ, Patterson, DJ 2002 Order Slopalinida Lee, JJ Leedale, GF Bradbury, P eds. An illustrated guide to the Protozoa2 Society of Protozoologists Lawrence, KS 754 759 Google Scholar Fast, NM, Xue, L, Bingham, S, Keeling, PJ 2002 Re-examining alveolate evolution using multiple protein molecular phylogenies J Eukaryot Microbiol 49 30 37 PubMed Google Scholar Felsenstein, J 2002PHYLIP, phylogeny inference package. Version 3.6a3 Department of Genome Sciences, University of Washington Seattle Google Scholar
Guillou L, Chrétiennot-Dinet M-J, Boulben S, Moon der Staay SY, Vaulot D (1999)
Symbiomonas scintillans gen
et sp. nov. (Heterokonta):two new heterotrophic flagellates of Picoplanktonic size Protist 150:383–393 Hanamura, K, Endoh, H 2001 Binary fission and encystation of Opalina sp. in axenic medium Zool Sci 18 381 387 CrossRef Google Scholar Hara, Y 1934 Studies on general morphology and neuromotor system of Protoopalina axonucleata Metcalf parasitizing in Rana nigromaculata Bot Zool 2 2015 2022 Google Scholar Hasegawa, M, Hashimoto, T, Adachi, J, Iwabe, N, Miyata, T 1993 Early branchings in the evolution of eukaryotes: Ancient divergence of Entamoeba that lacks mitochondria revealed by protein sequence data J Mol Evol 36 380 388 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Honigberg, BM, Balamuth, W, Bovee, EC, et al. 1964 A revised classification of the phylum protozoa J Protozool 11 7 20 PubMed Google Scholar Karpov, SA 2000 Ultrastructure of the aloricate bicosoecid Pseudobodo tremulans, with revision of the order Bicosoecida Protistologica 1 101 109 Google Scholar Karpov, SA, Sogin, ML, Silberman, JD 2001 Rootlet homology, taxonomy, and phylogeny of bicosoecids based on 18S rRNA gene sequences Protistologica 2 34 47 Google Scholar Keeling, JP, Luker, MA, Palmer, JD 2000 Evidence from beta-tubulin phylogeny that microsporidia evolved within the fungi Mol Biol Evol 17 23 31 PubMed Google Scholar Lake, JA 1994 Reconstructing evolutionary trees from DNA and protein sequences: paralinear distances Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91 1455 1459 PubMed Google Scholar Leeuwenhoek, A 1683Cited in: Antony van Leeuwenhoek and his “little animals” (C Dobell) Rusell & Rusell New York 233 Google Scholar Maddison, WP, Maddison, DR 1999MACCLADE: Analysis of pylogeny and character evolution. Version 3.08 Sinauer Sunderland, MA Google Scholar Metcalf, MM 1918 Opalina and the origin of the Ciliata Anat Rec 14 88 89 Google Scholar Metcalf, MM 1923 The Opalinid ciliate infusorians Bull US Nat Mus 120 1 484 Google Scholar Moreira, D, Guyader, HL, Philippe, H 2002 Unusually high evolutionary rate of the elongation factor 1α genes from the Ciliophora and its impact on the phylogeny of eukaryotes Mol Biol Evol 16 234 245 Google Scholar Moriya, M, Nakayama, T, Inouye, I 2000 Ultrastructure and 18S rDNA sequence analysis of Wobblia lunata gen. et sp. nov., a new heterotrophic flagellate (stramenopiles, Incerate sedis) Protist 151 41 55 PubMed Google Scholar Moriya, M, Nakayama, T, Inouye, I 2002 A new class of the stramenopiles, Placididea Classis nova: description of Placidia cafeteriopsis gen. et sp. nov Protist 153 143 156 PubMed Google Scholar Patterson, DJ 1985 The fine structure of Opalina ranarum (family Opalinidae): Opalinid phylogeny and classification Protistologica 21 413 428 Google Scholar Patterson, DJ 1988 Fine structure of the cortex of the protist Zelleriella antilliensis (Slopalinida, Opalinidae) from Bufo marinus in Fiji Microbios 54 71 80 Google Scholar Patterson, DJ 1989 Stramenopiles, chromophytes from a protistan perspective Green, JC Leadbeater, BSC Diver, WL eds. The chromophyte algae, problems and perspectives Clarendon Press Oxford 357 379 Google Scholar Patterson, DJ 1990 The fine structure of the cortex of the protist Protoopalina australis (Slopalinida, Opalinidae) from Litoria nasuta and Litoria inermis (Amphibia; Anura: Hylidae) in Queensland, Australia J Protozool 37 449 455 Google Scholar Patterson, DJ 2002 Changing views of protistan systematics: the taxonomy of protozoa—An overview Lee, JJ Leedale, GF Bradbury, P eds. An illustrated guide to the Protozoa2 Society of Protozoologists Lawrence, KS 2 9 Google Scholar Phillippe, H, Adoutte, A 1996 The molecular phylogeny of Eukaryota: solid facts and uncertainties Coombs, GH eds. Evolutionary relationships among Protozoa Kluwer Academic London 25 56 Google Scholar Prescot, DM 1994 The DNA of ciliated protozoa Microbiol Rev 58 233 267 Google Scholar Roger, AJ, Sandblom, O, Doolittle, WF, Philippe, H 2002 An evaluation of elongation factor 1α as a phylogenetic marker for eukaryotes Mol Biol Evol 16 218 233 Google Scholar Sandon, H 1976 The species problem in the opalinids (Protozoa, Opalinata), with special reference to Protoopalina Trans Am Microsc Soc 95 357 366 Google Scholar Schmidt, HA, Strimmer, K, Vingron, M, Haeseler, A 2002 TREE-PUZZLE: maximum likelihood phylogenetic analysis using quartets and parallel computing Bioinformatics 18 502 504 PubMed Google Scholar Shimodaira, H 2002 An approximately unbiased test of phylogenetic tree selection Syst Biol 51 492 508 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Shimodaira, H, Hasegawa, M 2001 CONSEL: for assessing the confidence of phylogenetic tree selection Bioinformatics 17 1246 1247 PubMed Google Scholar Steel, MA 1994 Recovering a tree from the leaf colourations it generates under a Markov model Appl Math Lett 7 19 23 CrossRef MathSciNet Google Scholar Thompson, JD, Plewniak, F, Poch, O 1999 A comprehensive comparison of multiple sequence alignment programs Nucleic Acids Res 27 2682 2690 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Wessenberg, HS 1961 Studies on the life cycle and morphogenesis of Opalina Univ Press Calif 61 315 370 Google Scholar Wessenberg, HS 1978 Opalinata Parasitic Protozoa 2 551 581 Google Scholar Yang, Z 1997 PAML: a program for package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood CABIOS 15 555 556 Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005