Abstract
In this article, a dataset from a collaborative non-target screening trial organised by the NORMAN Association is used to review the state-of-the-art and discuss future perspectives of non-target screening using high-resolution mass spectrometry in water analysis. A total of 18 institutes from 12 European countries analysed an extract of the same water sample collected from the River Danube with either one or both of liquid and gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry detection. This article focuses mainly on the use of high resolution screening techniques with target, suspect, and non-target workflows to identify substances in environmental samples. Specific examples are given to emphasise major challenges including isobaric and co-eluting substances, dependence on target and suspect lists, formula assignment, the use of retention information, and the confidence of identification. Approaches and methods applicable to unit resolution data are also discussed. Although most substances were identified using high resolution data with target and suspect-screening approaches, some participants proposed tentative non-target identifications. This comprehensive dataset revealed that non-target analytical techniques are already substantially harmonised between the participants, but the data processing remains time-consuming. Although the objective of a “fully-automated identification workflow” remains elusive in the short term, important steps in this direction have been taken, exemplified by the growing popularity of suspect screening approaches. Major recommendations to improve non-target screening include better integration and connection of desired features into software packages, the exchange of target and suspect lists, and the contribution of more spectra from standard substances into (openly accessible) databases.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Krauss M, Singer H, Hollender J (2010) LC-high resolution MS in environmental analysis: from target screening to the identification of unknowns. Anal Bioanal Chem 397(3):943–951
Hernandez F, Pozo OJ, Sancho JV, Lopez FJ, Marin JM, Ibanez M (2005) Strategies for quantification and confirmation of multi-class polar pesticides and transformation products in water by LC-MS2 using triple quadrupole and hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight analyzers. TraC Trends Anal Chem 24(7):596–612
Schymanski EL, Singer HP, Longree P, Loos M, Ruff M, Stravs MA, Ripolles Vidal C, Hollender J (2014) Strategies to Characterize Polar Organic Contamination in Wastewater: Exploring the Capability of High Resolution Mass Spectrometry. Environ Sci Technol 48(3):1811–1819
Zedda M, Zwiener C (2012) Is nontarget screening of emerging contaminants by LC-HRMS successful? A plea for compound libraries and computer tools. Anal Bioanal Chem 403(9):2493–2502
Hug C, Ulrich N, Schulze T, Brack W, Krauss M (2014) Identification of novel micropollutants in wastewater by a combination of suspect and nontarget screening. Environ Pollut 184:25–32
European Commission (2002) Commission Decision of 12 August 2002 Implementing Council Directive 96/23/EC concerning the performance of analytical methods and the interpretation of results. Official Journal of the European Communities L221:29 http://old.eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2002:221:0008:0036:EN:PDF. Accessed 30 Jan 2015
Schymanski EL, Jeon J, Gulde R, Fenner K, Ruff M, Singer HP, Hollender J (2014) Identifying Small Molecules via High Resolution Mass Spectrometry: Communicating Confidence. Environ Sci Technol 48(4):2097–2098
Creek DJ, Dunn WB, Fiehn O, Griffin JL, Hall RD, Lei ZT, Mistrik R, Neumann S, Schymanski EL, Sumner LW, Trengove R, Wolfender JL (2014) Metabolite identification: are you sure? And how do your peers gauge your confidence? Metabolomics 10(3):350–353
Letzel T, Lucke T, Schulz W, Sengl M, Letzel M (2014) OMI (Organic Molecule Identification) in water using LC-MS(/MS): Steps from “unknown” to “identified”: a contribution to the discussion. Lab More Int 4:24–28
Sumner LW, Amberg A, Barrett D, Beale MH, Beger R, Daykin CA, Fan TW, Fiehn O, Goodacre R, Griffin JL, Hankemeier T, Hardy N, Harnly J, Higashi R, Kopka J, Lane AN, Lindon JC, Marriott P, Nicholls AW, Reily MD, Thaden JJ, Viant MR (2007) Proposed minimum reporting standards for chemical analysis Chemical Analysis Working Group (CAWG) Metabolomics Standards Initiative (MSI). Metabolomics 3(3):211–221
NIST/EPA/NIH (2011) NIST Mass Spectral Library, various editions. National Institute of Standards and Technology. US Secretary of Commerce, USA
McLafferty FW (2000) Wiley Registry of Mass Spectral Data, 7th edn, ISBN-10: 0471440981
Stein S (2012) Mass Spectral Reference Libraries: An Ever-Expanding Resource for Chemical Identification. Anal Chem 84(17):7274–7282. doi:10.1021/ac301205z
Kind T, Fiehn O (2010) Advances in structure elucidation of small molecules using mass spectrometry. Bioanal Rev 2(1–4):23–60
Scheubert K, Hufsky F, Bocker S (2013) Computational mass spectrometry for small molecules. J Cheminform 5(12). doi:10.1186/1758-2946-5-12
Portoles T, Mol JGJ, Sancho JV, Hernandez F (2014) Use of electron ionization and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization in gas chromatography coupled to time-of-flight mass spectrometry for screening and identification of organic pollutants in waters. J Chromatogr A 1339:145–153
Hernandez F, Ibanez M, Portoles T, Cervera MI, Sancho JV, Lopez FJ (2015) Advancing towards universal screening for organic pollutants in waters. J Hazard Mater 282:86–95
Helbling DE, Hollender J, Kohler HPE, Singer H, Fenner K (2010) High-Throughput Identification of Microbial Transformation Products of Organic Micropollutants. Environ Sci Technol 44(17):6621–6627
Kern S, Fenner K, Singer HP, Schwarzenbach RP, Hollender J (2009) Identification of Transformation Products of Organic Contaminants in Natural Waters by Computer-Aided Prediction and High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry. Environ Sci Technol 43(18):7039–7046
Huntscha S, Hofstetter TB, Schymanski EL, Spahr S, Hollender J (2014) Biotransformation of benzotriazoles: insights from transformation product identification and compound-specific isotope analysis. Environ Sci Technol 48(8):4435–4443
Moschet C, Piazzoli A, Singer H, Hollender J (2013) Alleviating the Reference Standard Dilemma Using a Systematic Exact Mass Suspect Screening Approach with Liquid Chromatography-High Resolution Mass Spectrometry. Anal Chem 85(21):10312–10320
Thurman EM, Ferrer I, Blotevogel J, Borch T (2014) Analysis of Hydraulic Fracturing Flowback and Produced Waters Using Accurate Mass: Identification of Ethoxylated Surfactants. Anal Chem 86(19):9653–9661
Chiaia-Hernandez AC, Schymanski EL, Kumar P, Singer HP, Hollender J (2014) Suspect and nontarget screening approaches to identify organic contaminant records in lake sediments. Anal Bioanal Chem 406(28):7323–7335
Howard PH, Muir DCG (2010) Identifying New Persistent and Bioaccumulative Organics Among Chemicals in Commerce. Environ Sci Technol 44(7):2277–2285
Howard PH, Muir DCG (2011) Identifying New Persistent and Bioaccumulative Organics Among Chemicals in Commerce II: Pharmaceuticals. Environ Sci Technol 45(16):6938–6946
Howard PH, Muir DCG (2013) Identifying New Persistent and Bioaccumulative Organics Among Chemicals in Commerce. III: Byproducts, Impurities, and Transformation Products. Environ Sci Technol 47(10):5259–5266
Ulrich N, Schuurmann G, Brack W (2011) Linear Solvation Energy Relationships as classifiers in non-target analysis-A capillary liquid chromatography approach. J Chromatogr A 1218(45):8192–8196
Wolf S, Schmidt S, Muller-Hannemann M, Neumann S (2010) In silico fragmentation for computer assisted identification of metabolite mass spectra. BMC Bioinf 11:148
HighChem (2014) Mass Frontier, 7th edn. HighChem Ltd./Thermo Scientific, Bratislava
Little JL, Cleven CD, Brown SD (2011) Identification of "Known Unknowns" Utilizing Accurate Mass Data and Chemical Abstracts Service Databases. J Am Soc Mass Spectrom 22(2):348–359
Little JL, Williams AJ, Pshenichnov A, Tkachenko V (2012) Identification of "Known Unknowns" Utilizing Accurate Mass Data and ChemSpider. J Am Soc Mass Spectrom 23(1):179–185
RSC (2014) ChemSpider www.chemspider.com. Royal Society of Chemistry. Accessed 17 Dec 2014
ICPDR (2015) Joint Danube Survey 3 www.danubesurvey.org. ICPDR - International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River. Accessed 23 Jan 2015
Liska I, Wagner F, Deutsch K, Sengl M, Slobodnik J (2015) Joint Danube Survey 3 Final Scientific Report (in print). Vienna, Austria
Schulze T, Krauss M, Bahlmann A, Hug C, Walz K-H, Brack W (2014) Onsite large volume solid phase extraction – how to get 1000 litres of water into the laboratory? Society for Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) Europe 24th Annual Meeting, Basel, Switzerland, 11–15 May, 2014
ChemAxon (2015) MarvinSketch Calculator Plugins 15.1.12.0 http://www.chemaxon.com. Accessed 30 Jan 2015
Greco G, Grosse S, Letzel T (2013) Serial coupling of reversed-phase and zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction LC/MS for the analysis of polar and nonpolar phenols in wine. J Sep Sci 36(8):1379–1388
LW/HSWT (2014) DAIOS Substance Database http://www.daios-online.de/daios/. Zweckverband Landeswasserversorgung, Langenau, Germany. Accessed 18 Dec 2014 (login only)
Muller A, Schulz W, Ruck WKL, Weber WH (2011) A new approach to data evaluation in the non-target screening of organic trace substances in water analysis. Chemosphere 85(8):1211–1219
NCBI (2014) PubChem (https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/). National Center for Biotechnology Information. Accessed 17/12/2014
LfU/LW/HSWT/TUM (2014) STOFF-IDENT Substance Database http://bb-x-stoffident.hswt.de/stoffidentjpa/app Environmental Agency of Bayern, Germany (Bayerisches Landesamt für Umwelt). Accessed 1 Apr 2015 (login only)
MassBank (2014) MassBank www.massbank.jp. Accessed 17 Dec 2014
MassBank (2014) NORMAN MassBank www.massbank.eu. Accessed 17 Dec 2014
Horai H, Arita M, Kanaya S, Nihei Y, Ikeda T, Suwa K, Ojima Y, Tanaka K, Tanaka S, Aoshima K, Oda Y, Kakazu Y, Kusano M, Tohge T, Matsuda F, Sawada Y, Hirai MY, Nakanishi H, Ikeda K, Akimoto N, Maoka T, Takahashi H, Ara T, Sakurai N, Suzuki H, Shibata D, Neumann S, Iida T, Funatsu K, Matsuura F, Soga T, Taguchi R, Saito K, Nishioka T (2010) MassBank: a public repository for sharing mass spectral data for life sciences. J Mass Spectrom 45(7):703–714
HighChem (2014) mzCloud https://www.mzcloud.org/. HighChem Ltd., Bratislava, Slovakia. Accessed 17 Dec 2014
SIS (2014) The NIST 14 Mass Spectral Library http://www.sisweb.com/software/ms/nist.htm. Scientific Instrument Services. Accessed 17 Dec 2014
Wiley (2013) Wiley Registry of Mass Spectral Data, 10th Edn. Wiley, ISBN: 978-0-470-52037-6
Broecker S, Herre S, Wust B, Zweigenbaum J, Pragst F (2011) Development and practical application of a library of CID accurate mass spectra of more than 2,500 toxic compounds for systematic toxicological analysis by LC-QTOF-MS with data-dependent acquisition. Anal Bioanal Chem 400(1):101–117
Agilent (2015) Broecker, Herre, and Pragst Accurate Mass Personal Compound Database and Library (PCDL) for Forensics and Toxicology. Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara
Agilent (2015) Accurate Mass Personal Compound Database and Library (PCDL) for Pesticides. Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara
Scripps (2015) METLIN: Metabolite and Tandem MS Database http://metlin.scripps.edu/. Scripps Center for Metabolomics. Accessed 23/3/2015
Smith CA, O'Maille G, Want EJ, Qin C, Trauger SA, Brandon TR, Custodio DE, Abagyan R, Siuzdak G (2005) METLIN: a metabolite mass spectral database. Ther Drug Monit 27(6):747–751
Bruker (2014) Bruker ToxScreenerTM - A Comprehensive Screening Solution for Forensic Toxicology. Bruker Daltronics, Inc., Bremen, Germany
Sciex (2015) iMethod Application - LC/MS/MS Meta Library Version 1.0 for Cliquid Software http://sciex.myshopify.com/products/imethod-application-lcmsms-meta-library-version-10-for-cliquid-software. AB Sciex. Accessed 23/3/2015
Gerlich M, Neumann S (2013) MetFusion: integration of compound identication strategies. J Mass Spectrom 48:291–298
Waters (2014) MassFragment (version 1.3) http://www.waters.com/webassets/cms/library/docs/720004823en.pdf?locale=en_US. Accessed 27 Jan 2015
Tellstroem V, Dunsbach R (2014) Technical Note TN-26: SmartFormula 3D – the new Dimension in Substance Identification – From Mass Spectrum to Chemical Formula. Bruker Daltronics, Inc., Bremen, Germany
Hill AW, Mortishire-Smith RJ (2005) Automated assignment of high-resolution collisionally activated dissociation mass spectra using a systematic bond disconnection approach. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 19:3111–3118
Agilent (2011) Agilent MassHunter Molecular Structure Correlator (MSC) Software, Revision A. Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara
NIST (2005) Automated Mass Spectral Deconvolution and Identification System (AMDIS), 26th edn. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), US Department of Defense, USA
Daylight (2012) SMILES- A Simplified Chemical Language http://www.daylight.com/dayhtml/doc/theory/theory.smiles.html. Daylight Chemical Information Systems Inc. Accessed 30 Jan 2015
IUPAC (2012) The IUPAC International Chemical Identifier http://www.iupac.org/inchi/. International Union of Pure and Applied Chemitstry. Accessed 30 Jan 2015
O'Boyle NM, Banck M, James CA, Morley C, Vandermeersch T, Hutchison GR (2011) Open Babel: An open chemical toolbox. J Cheminform 3:33
Liska I, Wagner F, Slobodnik J (2008) Joint Danube Survey 2: Final Scientific Report. Editors: Liska I, Wagner F, Slobodnik J ICPDR – International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River, Vienna, Austria
Kind T, Fiehn O (2007) Seven Golden Rules for heuristic filtering of molecular formulas obtained by accurate mass spectrometry. BMC Bioinf 8:105
Weiss S, Jakobs J, Reemtsma T (2006) Discharge of three benzotriazole corrosion inhibitors with municipal wastewater and improvements by membrane bioreactor treatment and ozonation. Environ Sci Technol 40(23):7193–7199
Rasche F, Svatos A, Maddula RK, Bottcher C, Bocker S (2011) Computing Fragmentation Trees from Tandem Mass Spectrometry Data. Anal Chem 83(4):1243–1251
Meringer M, Reinker S, Zhang JA, Muller A (2011) MS/MS Data Improves Automated Determination of Molecular Formulas by Mass Spectrometry. Match-Commun Math Co 65(2):259–290
Pluskal T, Uehara T, Yanagida M (2012) Highly Accurate Chemical Formula Prediction Tool Utilizing High-Resolution Mass Spectra, MS/MS Fragmentation, Heuristic Rules, and Isotope Pattern Matching. Anal Chem 84(10):4396–4403
Schymanski EL, Gallampois CMJ, Krauss M, Meringer M, Neumann S, Schulze T, Wolf S, Brack W (2012) Consensus Structure Elucidation Combining GC/EI-MS, Structure Generation, and Calculated Properties. Anal Chem 84(7):3287–3295
Eckel WP, Kind T (2003) Use of boiling point-Lee retention index correlation for rapid review of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry data. Anal Chim Acta 494(1–2):235–243
Schymanski EL, Gerlich M, Ruttkies C, Neumann S (2014) Solving CASMI 2013 with MetFrag, MetFusion and MOLGEN-MS/MS. Mass Spectrometry 3 (Special Issue 2):S0036
Reemtsma T (2009) Determination of molecular formulas of natural organic matter molecules by (ultra-) high-resolution mass spectrometry Status and needs. J Chromatogr A 1216(18):3687–3701
Reemtsma T (2010) The carbon versus mass diagram to visualize and exploit FTICR-MS data of natural organic matter. J Mass Spectrom 45(4):382–390
NORMAN Association (2015) Non-target screening techniques for environmental monitoring http://www.norman-network.net/?q=node/190. NORMAN Association. Accessed 27 Jan 2015
NORMAN Association (2015) Workshop on Non-Target Screening: http://www.norman-network.net/?q=node/162. NORMAN Association. Accessed 27 Jan 2015
NORMAN Association (2015) NORMAN MassBank Workshop http://www.norman-network.net/?q=node/163. NORMAN Association. Accessed 27 Jan 2015
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions of many others who helped during the analysis, reporting and discussion of the results presented here: Philipp Longree, Martin Loos, Matthias Ruff and Jennifer Schollee (Eawag), Margit Petre, Anett Kloß and Werner Brack (UFZ), Reza Aalizadeh, Nikiforos Alygizakis and Pablo Gago Ferrero (University of Athens), Sylvain Merel (University of Tübingen), Alexander van Nuijs, Alin Ionas and Adrian Covaci (University of Antwerp), Martijn Pijnappels (Rijkswaterstaat), Christelle Margoum (Irstea), Claudio Bortolini (University of Padua), Marie-Hélène Devier and Hélène Budzinski (University of Bordeaux, France), Christophe Tondelier and Mathilde Chachignon (VERI), Tobias Bader and Thomas Lucke (Zweckverband Landeswasserversorgung), Michael Schlüsener (BfG), Mar Esperanza (Suez Environnement), Siniša Repec (Croatian Waters), Peter Tarabek (Slovak National Water Reference Laboratory), Christoph Ruttkies (IPB, Halle, Germany), the ChemSpider support team, and Thierry Faye from Agilent. The water sample of the Danube was kindly provided by the International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River (IPCDR) as part of the Joint Danube Survey 3. Author contributions: ELS, HPS, JS, IMI, PO, MK, TS, PH, TL, SG, NST, CZ, and JH were involved in the core team preparing the trial, evaluation, workshop, and publication; MI, TP, RdB, MR, MO, UK, WS, AG, NN, GL, PB, SB, DS, and PR participated in the trial and publication efforts.
This trial was initiated by the NORMAN Association with in-kind contributions from participants; no fee was charged for participation. This work was supported in part by the SOLUTIONS project, which received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme for research, technological development and demonstration under Grant Agreement No. 603437.
Compliance with ethical standards
ᅟ
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Human and Animal Rights and Informed Consent
No violation of human or animal rights occurred during this investigation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Additional information
Published in the topical collection High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry in Food and Environmental Analysis with guest editor Aldo Laganà.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schymanski, E.L., Singer, H.P., Slobodnik, J. et al. Non-target screening with high-resolution mass spectrometry: critical review using a collaborative trial on water analysis. Anal Bioanal Chem 407, 6237–6255 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-015-8681-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-015-8681-7