Association of glucose metabolism with diastolic function along the diabetic continuum
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Stahrenberg, R., Edelmann, F., Mende, M. et al. Diabetologia (2010) 53: 1331. doi:10.1007/s00125-010-1718-8
- 681 Downloads
Hyperglycaemia and insulin resistance have been linked to diastolic dysfunction experimentally. We investigated the association between glucose metabolism and diastolic function along the whole spectrum of glucose metabolism states.
In the observational Diagnostic Trial on Prevalence and Clinical Course of Diastolic Dysfunction and Diastolic Heart Failure (DIAST-CHF) study, patients with risk factors for heart failure were included. We analysed data including comprehensive echocardiography from a subgroup of patients classified by OGTT and history as normal (n = 343), prediabetic (n = 229) and non-insulin treated (n = 335) or insulin-treated (n = 178) type 2 diabetic.
While ejection fraction did not differ, markers of diastolic function significantly worsened across groups. Prediabetes represented an intermediate between normal glucose metabolism and diabetes with regard to echocardiography changes. Prevalence and severity of diastolic dysfunction increased significantly (p < 0.001) along the diabetic continuum. Glucose metabolism status was significantly associated with prevalence of diastolic dysfunction on multivariate logistic regression analysis. In the whole cohort, HbA1c correlated with early diastolic mitral inflow velocity (E):early diastolic tissue Doppler velocity at mitral annulus (e′) ratio (E:e′) (r = 0.20, p < 0.001). HbA1c was significantly associated with E:e′ on multivariate analysis. Similarly, glucose metabolism status was significantly associated with E:e′ on multivariate analysis. The distance walked in 6 min decreased along the diabetic spectrum and was significantly correlated with E:e′ and grade of diastolic dysfunction.
Glucose metabolism is associated with diastolic dysfunction across the whole spectrum. Our data extend previous observations into the prediabetic and normal range, and may be relevant to preventive approaches, as no effective treatment has been identified for diastolic heart failure once established.
KeywordsCross-sectional studies Diabetes mellitus Diastolic heart failure Echocardiography Exercise tolerance Insulin resistance Prediabetic state
Late diastolic mitral inflow velocity
Late diastolic tissue Doppler velocity (at mitral annulus)
Chronic heart failure
Diagnostic Trial on Prevalence and Clinical Course of Diastolic Dysfunction and Diastolic Heart Failure
Early diastolic mitral inflow velocity
Early diastolic tissue Doppler velocity (at mitral annulus)
Fasting plasma glucose
Fasting plasma insulin
Heart failure with normal ejection fraction
- 1 h-PG
1 h plasma glucose
- 2 h-PG
2 h plasma glucose
- 2 h-PI
2 h plasma insulin
Insulin sensitivity index according to Gutt
Left ventricular mass index
Systolic pulmonary vein flow velocity
Diastolic pulmonary vein flow velocity
Quantitative insulin sensitivity check index
Ratio of PVS to PVD
Chronic heart failure (CHF) is an ongoing epidemic of growing dimensions in western societies . It has been recognised  and recently confirmed  that a large percentage of patients presenting with the clinical syndrome of heart failure have a normal left ventricular ejection fraction. These cases are therefore termed ‘heart failure with normal ejection fraction’ (HFnEF) and left ventricular diastolic dysfunction is believed to be common in these patients . Once hospitalised for heart failure, their prognosis is similarly grim to that of patients with ‘classic’ systolic heart failure [2, 3]. Randomised trials looking for specific therapeutic interventions have been few and notoriously unsuccessful [5, 6]. Prevention therefore is of the essence if HFnEF is to be dealt with at a population level.
Diabetes mellitus has also reached epidemic proportions worldwide, with a further 50% increase in worldwide prevalence projected to occur by 2025 . While well known as a strong risk factor for atherosclerotic disease, the relationship between diabetes and incident heart failure has as yet attracted less attention. Preclinical studies have linked diabetes to abnormalities in left ventricular relaxation and compliance . Clinically, a large proportion of diabetic patients has been shown to have diastolic dysfunction  and diabetes is prevalent in patients with HFnEF . Insulin resistance, a state that is generally present before the onset of type 2 diabetes, also seems to play a major role .
Given the proposed association of insulin resistance with diastolic dysfunction and the importance of preventive approaches for HFnEF, we sought to better define the link between glucose metabolism and diastolic dysfunction across a wide spectrum of metabolic statuses ranging from normal glucose metabolism through to prediabetes and type 2 diabetes mellitus treated either less intensively, i.e. without insulin (oral glucose-lowering therapy only), or more intensively with a regimen including insulin. Insulin treatment was used as a surrogate for more advanced disease requiring more intensive treatment.
The ongoing non-interventional DIAST-CHF (Diagnostic Trial on prevalence and clinical course of diastolic dysfunction and diastolic heart failure) study, which is part of the nationwide German Competence Network Heart Failure project, included patients aged 50 to 85 years with risk factors for diastolic heart failure (defined as history of hypertension, diabetes mellitus, sleep apnoea syndrome or atherosclerotic disease) or manifest CHF, defined as a history of CHF or presence of at least one major and two minor criteria according to the Framingham diagnostic criteria at presentation . Candidates were referred by primary care physicians. As a population-based study, the only exclusion criterion was inability to participate or consent due, for example, to language problems, concomitant diseases or geographic reasons. Participants underwent a comprehensive non-invasive diagnostic workup at baseline, including history and physical examination, laboratory analyses, echocardiography, ECG, 6 min walk test and completion of several psychosocial and quality of life questionnaires, with additional tests performed in subsets of patients.
At the two study sites with the vast majority of participants (Goettingen and Berlin, 1,728 participants included out of 1,935 in the overall study), all patients without a history of diabetes mellitus were offered an OGTT. For the analyses presented here, all participants who underwent OGTT at baseline were included, as well as those who had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes mellitus before inclusion and/or were being treated with glucose-lowering medication. Patients who were diagnosed with diabetes before the age of 40 and who became insulin-dependent within less than 1 year were considered to have a high probability of suffering from type 1 diabetes and were excluded from analyses.
The study complied with the Declaration of Helsinki, the protocol was approved by the responsible Ethics Committee and all patients gave written informed consent.
Oral glucose tolerance test
A simplified protocol was used for the OGTT. Fasting plasma glucose (FPG) was determined immediately before ingestion of 75 g of solubilised glucose, followed 1 and 2 h later by determination of 1 h plasma glucose (1 h-PG) and 2 h plasma glucose (2 h-PG). Insulin levels were determined as fasting plasma insulin (FPI) and 2 h after glucose load as 2 h plasma insulin (2 h-PI). Patients were considered to have: (1) normal glucose metabolism at fasting glucose <5.6 mmol/l and 2 h glucose <7.8 mmol/l; (2) prediabetes when fasting glucose was 5.6 to 7.0 mmol/l or 2 h glucose 7.8 to 11.1 mmol/l; and (3) diabetes mellitus at fasting glucose >7.0 mmol/l or 2 h glucose >11.1 mmol/l, as currently recommended by the American Diabetes Association . No OGTT was performed on insulin-treated type 2 diabetic participants and very few participants with stable type 2 diabetes treated by oral glucose-lowering medication underwent testing.
Insulin was measured with a commercially available immunoassay on an automated analyser (ADVIA Centaur; formerly Bayer Diagnostics, now part of Siemens Health Care Diagnostics, Eschborn, Germany). HbA1c was measured in EDTA blood on an automated analyser (Integra 800; Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany) with a reference range of 2.9% to 4.2% according to recommendations of the International Federation of Clinical Chemistry.
Echocardiography was performed on a Sonos 5500 (Hewlett-Packard, Andover, MA, USA) according to the guidelines of the American Society of Echocardiography, including comprehensive evaluation of diastolic function with Doppler and tissue Doppler techniques. All examinations were performed by physicians experienced in the technique. As DIAST-CHF is part of the nationwide German Competence Network for Heart Failure project, randomly chosen echo examinations were reviewed by the echo core lab at the University of Essen for quality assurance.
Dimensions were recorded by standard techniques. Interventricular septum, left ventricular posterior wall thickness, left ventricular end-diastolic diameter, and end-systolic and left atrial diameter were measured by M-mode or anatomically, as appropriate. Left ventricular end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes, and ejection fraction were determined by the modified uniplanar Simpson’s rule in the majority of patients. Transmitral peaks of early diastolic mitral inflow velocity (E), and late diastolic mitral inflow velocity (A) and E wave deceleration time were recorded at the tips of the mitral valve leaflets. Isovolumetric relaxation time was obtained in the apical five chamber view. Doppler signals of systolic pulmonary vein flow velocity (PVS), diastolic pulmonary vein flow velocity (PVD) and atrial reverse pulmonary vein flow velocity were recorded in the right upper pulmonary vein. Peak tissue velocities were derived by tissue Doppler analysis at the lateral margin of the mitral annulus for early diastolic tissue Doppler velocity (e′) and late diastolic tissue Doppler velocity (a′) inflow.
Calculations and statistical analyses
As an estimate of global glucose tolerance, the AUC for glucose over the 2 h interval of the OGTT was calculated using a trapezoidal approach for integration (AUCGlu0–120). To correct for FPG, we normalised AUC by indexing to the integral of fasting glucose over 2 h (AUCGlu0–120/[FPG × 2]), reflecting the relative increase in plasma glucose over the 2 h interval. As surrogates for insulin sensitivity, HOMA and quantitative insulin sensitivity check index (QUICKI) were calculated, as well as the insulin sensitivity index according to Gutt (ISI0,120), all as described and recommended previously .
Left ventricular mass index (LVMI) was calculated by the Devereux formula indexed to body surface area . For evaluation of diastolic function, we calculated the ratios of E to A (E:A), of PVS to PVD (S:D), of E to e′ (E:e′) and of e′ to a′ (e′:a′). Diastolic dysfunction was classified as follows: (1) normal diastolic function with 1 ≤E:A, E:e′ < 10, S:D ≥1, E:A with Valsalva manoeuvre ≥1; (2) mild diastolic dysfunction with E:A < 1; (3) moderate diastolic dysfunction with 1 ≤E:A < 2, and one of E:e′ ≥10, S:D < 1 and E:A Valsalva < 1; and (4) severe diastolic dysfunction with E:A ≥2, and one of E:e′ ≥10 and S:D < 1.
Descriptive statistics were performed stratified by glucose metabolism status. Several variables were not normally distributed. Therefore, data are expressed as median (interquartile range) for continuous variables or absolute number (per cent) for categorical. Log-transformed values were used for some analyses as appropriate. Non-parametric tests for group differences between categories of glucose tolerance were performed. The Jonckheere–Terpstra test is most sensitive for detection of effects across ordered categories. For comparison of proportions, Armitage’s test for trend was applied. To investigate relations between variables, bivariate correlations were calculated. We used multivariate analysis of covariances and logistic regression to unravel multivariate relationships.
Statistical analyses were performed with SPSS Statistics 15.0 software (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA).
Of 1,935 patients included in DIAST-CHF, 1,085 patients were analysed, of whom 637 had an OGTT. A minority of these (13 patients) had a previous diagnosis of type 2 diabetes mellitus and were being treated with glucose-lowering medication. Overall, 465 patients had a history of diabetes mellitus at inclusion, of whom four with probable type 1 diabetes were excluded from analyses. Of the remaining 461 patients with known type 2 diabetes mellitus, 178 were treated with insulin and 283 with diet and/or oral glucose-lowering drugs.
Clinical characteristics of patients with normal, prediabetic or diabetic glucose metabolism
Female sex, n (%)
Systolic BP (mmHg)
Diastolic BP (mmHg)
Heart rate (beats per min)
6 min walk distance (m)
Cardiovascular risk factors
Hypertension, n (%)
Hyperlipidaemia, n (%)
Smoker, n (%)
CHD, n (%)
Peripheral artery disease, n (%)
Cerebrovascular disease, n (%)
CHF, n (%)
Sleep apnoea, n (%)
Atrial fibrillation, n (%)
ACE-inhibitor, n (%)
AT1 receptor antagonist, n (%)
Beta-blocker, n (%)
Thiazide diuretic, n (%)
Loop diuretic, n (%)
Other diuretic, n (%)
Aldosterone antagonist, n (%)
Calcium antagonist, n (%)
Statin, n (%)
Acetylic salicylic acid, n (%)
Vitamin K antagonist, n (%)
Oral glucose-lowering, n (%)
Metabolic characteristics of patients with normal, prediabetic or diabetic glucose metabolism
2 h-PI (pmol/l)
1 h-PGe (mmol/l)
2 h-PG (mmol/l)
Glucose AUC (mmol l−1 × h)
Glucose AUC normalised
Diabetes duration (years)
Insulin-dependent for (years)
Daily total dose insulin (IE)
Total cholesterol (mmol/l)
Uric acid (mmol/l)
eGFR (ml min−1 1.73 m−2)
Consistent with the process of group allocation, prediabetic participants had significantly higher FPI and FPG than non-diabetic participants, as well as higher 1 h-PG and 2 h-PG, reflected also in AUCGlu0–120 and normalised AUCGlu0–120. Insulin resistance as approximated by HOMA was higher, and insulin sensitivity as approximated by QUICKI and Gutt index lower in prediabetic participants. Prediabetes also displayed an intermediate state in between normal and type 2 diabetic patients on oral glucose-lowering medication. LDL-cholesterol was paradoxically lower in this group and in insulin-treated type 2 diabetic patients, while HDL-cholesterol decreased with severity of glucose metabolism disturbance. This phenomenon is probably due to the fact that LDL-cholesterol is effectively lowered by statin therapy, which was more prevalent in diabetic patients, while low HDL-cholesterol is less amenable to pharmacological treatment.
Prevalence of diastolic dysfunction
Echocardiographic characteristics of patients with normal, prediabetic or diabetic glucose metabolism
Deceleration time (ms)
Status of glucose metabolism remained significantly associated with prevalence of diastolic dysfunction in logistic regression analysis adjusted for the significantly associated variables heart rate, systolic blood pressure, and presence or history of heart failure. Furthermore, an odds ratio of 1.77 (95% CI 1.10–2.86) for having diastolic dysfunction was estimated for the prediabetes group compared with the normal glucose metabolism group.
Impairment in glucose metabolism and severity of diastolic dysfunction
As a functional variable indicative of left ventricular end-diastolic pressure, E:e′ was similar in prediabetes compared with normal glucose metabolism, but was significantly higher (p = 0.002) in diabetes than in the other groups. In the whole cohort, E:e′ correlated significantly with HbA1c (r = 0.20, p < 0.001), as well as with several other markers of glucose metabolism, namely 2 h-PI, normalised AUCGlu0–120 and ISI0,120. Importantly, the association between E:e′ and HbA1c remained significant when including only patients with HbA1c in the normal range, i.e. ≤4.2% (r = 0.16, p < 0.05).
In multivariate linear analysis including sex, CHD, CHF, history of myocardial infarction, age, log(BMI), heart rate, systolic and diastolic blood pressure, cardiovascular medications and HbA1c as predictors, HbA1c remained significantly (p < 0.001) associated with log(E:e′). When modelling status of glucose metabolism in place of HbA1c in a general linear model with log (E:e′) as dependent variable, status of glucose metabolism was a significant predictor, together with sex, age, log (BMI), heart rate, systolic and diastolic blood pressure, and both beta blocker and aldosterone antagonist intake. These associations remained significant with Bonferroni–Holm adjustment for multiple testing.
LVMI and left atrial diameter as structural markers of diastolic function correlated significantly with HbA1c and also with AUCGlu0–120, normalised AUCGlu0–120, 1 h- and 2 h-PG, HOMA, QUICKI and ISI0,120. In contrast to E:e′, these structural variables also correlated with FPG and FPI. However, in multivariate analysis associations of LVMI and left atrial diameter with HbA1c lost significance. Interestingly, there was also a highly significant negative correlation of HDL-cholesterol with left atrial diameter and LVMI. No significant correlation of structural variables with HbA1c was observed in patients with HbA1c ≤ 4.2%. Nevertheless, when including only patients with normal glucose metabolism or prediabetes, the above-mentioned correlations remained statistically significant except those between left atrial diameter and HbA1c, and LVMI and 2 h-PG or HbA1c, respectively. While the two type 2 diabetes treatment groups (oral glucose-lowering medication, insulin) had a similar prevalence of diastolic dysfunction and similar distribution across grades of diastolic dysfunction, E:e′ was significantly higher in the insulin-treated than in the other group (10.7 vs 9.5, p < 0.05).
E:e′, left atrial diameter or LVMI did not correlate with duration of diabetes or daily insulin dose.
Diabetes, diastolic dysfunction and physical impairment
The distance walked in 6 min as a simple indicator of exercise capacity decreased along the diabetic continuum (Table 1). Both grade of diastolic dysfunction (r = −0.29, p < 0.001) and E:e′ (r = −0.17, p < 0.001) correlated significantly with the distance walked in 6 min. Ejection fraction did not differ significantly between groups and there was only a very weak correlation between ejection fraction and distance walked in 6 min (r = 0.09, p < 0.01).
Our data confirm and extend these observations, as prevalence of diastolic dysfunction was increased not only in type 2 diabetic, but also in prediabetes participants. Moreover, prevalence and severity of diastolic dysfunction were associated with degree of impairment of glucose metabolism along the whole spectrum of metabolic states. It is noteworthy that we found a very high absolute prevalence of diastolic dysfunction even in participants with normal glucose metabolism compared with older series [9, 17]. This, however, is not so surprising, considering the design of DIAST-CHF, which includes only patients with a risk factor for diastolic heart failure or (a minority) with manifest CHF. The high prevalence may also be due to the higher sensitivity of current echocardiographic techniques, as well as to our classification, which applies rather sensitive criteria for low-grade diastolic dysfunction. Even so, we were able to show an association between glucose metabolism and diastolic dysfunction.
With comprehensive echocardiographic characterisation of a large group of participants with prediabetes, we were able to show that prediabetes represents a morphological intermediate between normal and diabetic states. Also, we found significant trends for several indicators of diastolic dysfunction along the type 2 diabetic continuum, pointing to a graded effect of impaired glucose metabolism on diastolic function, although such an interpretation is limited by the cross-sectional nature of our analysis. Several mechanisms for a conditional relationship between glucose metabolism and diastolic function have been proposed. Hyperinsulinaemia can lead to increased myocardial mass through its growth-stimulating function and probably differential organ-specific levels of insulin resistance . Furthermore, hyperinsulinaemia leads to chronic sympathetic nervous system activation with detrimental consequences on the heart . These observations suggest a theoretical basis for our observation of subtle changes in myocardial, specifically diastolic, function in prediabetes. Recently, it was shown that insulin resistance was a predictor for incident heart failure independently of diabetes . Impaired insulin sensitivity and hyperinsulinaemia are often present before full manifestation of type 2 diabetes mellitus. Also, insulin sensitivity and levels are continuous (rather than discrete) traits, making a continuous and graded effect intuitively more plausible than a threshold constellation. Similarly, hyperglycaemia has been linked to alterations in myocardial calcium handling and extracellular matrix modifications, leading to increased ventricular stiffness and impaired relaxation . Indeed, across the whole cohort, HbA1c was independently associated with E:e′, a variable that strongly correlates with left ventricular end diastolic pressure  and with the presence of diastolic dysfunction. We even found some evidence for such an association in the subgroup with normal glucose metabolism. HbA1c as a continuous variable incorporates glucose levels over a longer period of time and can therefore be considered a more stable indicator of plasma glucose status, which is less vulnerable to acute perturbations around the time of testing. In fact, for these very reasons HbA1c has recently been suggested for use as a primary variable on which to base the diagnosis of diabetes . The correlation of E:e´ with HbA1c complements data showing that in diabetic patients a 1% increase in HbA1c is associated with an increase in the risk of heart failure of between 8 and 32% [22, 23, 24]. Similarly, FPG has recently been shown to be prognostic of incident heart failure in a very large randomised trial of patients at high cardiovascular risk . Our data strengthen the experimentally based assumption that a considerable part of the increased risk of heart failure in diabetes is due to impaired diastolic function linked to hyperinsulinaemia and hyperglycaemia.
The observed elevation in E:e′ can be assumed to be of prognostic relevance, as an E:e′ >15 resulted in an 11% relative increase in all-cause mortality rates in a recent retrospective analysis of diabetic patients from Olmsted county . Similarly, degree of diastolic dysfunction was an independent predictor of all-cause mortality in a large epidemiological study .
Statistically speaking, the biological signal we found is not very strong against the ‘noise’ in our heterogeneous population-based cohort; the model fitting also leaves something to be desired. However, the observed association may still be of considerable importance at a population level, considering the epidemic proportions of diabetes and the persistent lack of effective treatments for diastolic dysfunction and diastolic heart failure.
Exercise capacity, as measured by 6 min walk test, decreased along the diabetic continuum. Although this may in part reflect more activity-limiting comorbidities, we also observed a highly significant negative correlation between E:e´ and distance walked in 6 min in our sample, indicating that impaired exercise capacity may be partly due to diastolic dysfunction. It has previously been demonstrated in a small sample that decreased exercise tolerance is associated with diastolic dysfunction in patients with diabetes, even when well controlled and without CHD, hypertension or heart failure [27, 28]. Our results extend these data to a broader population and a much larger sample. In contrast to diastolic dysfunction, left ventricular ejection fraction did not differ across groups of glucose metabolism and was only very weakly associated with distance walked in 6 min.
Our data show that diastolic dysfunction is partly determined by glucose metabolism even in participants with normal glucose and those with prediabetes, thus supporting early preventive measures to improve glucose metabolism on a population scale as one possible approach to combat diastolic dysfunction and diastolic heart failure. Although we cannot directly draw such conclusions from our cross-sectional and non-interventional study, improvements in diastolic function with intensified glucose control have been demonstrated in diabetic patients , providing the theoretical basis for such a demand. The relevance of glucose metabolism for diastolic dysfunction in a longitudinal setting will be the subject of future analyses from DIAST-CHF.
With regard to technicalities, clear strengths of our study include its well characterised sample of patients with all stages of impairment of glucose metabolism. As all non-diabetic participants underwent OGTT, allocation to the respective group was exact. In addition, the measurement of HbA1c in the majority of patients adds further detail to the metabolic characterisation of our patients. Diastolic dysfunction was analysed with tissue Doppler techniques that were considered state-of-the-art at the time of data collection and indeed more advanced than those used by most published studies on the subject.
Several aspects of our report, however, merit critical review. As this analysis was cross-sectional, no conclusions on causality can be drawn. We did not limit our analysis to participants without overt cardiovascular disease like coronary artery disease or CHF, as is often done in studies investigating diabetic cardiomyopathy. This approach was chosen to assess the overall relationship of glucose metabolism with diastolic function, be it independent or be it mediated through end-organ disease. The fact that the associations remained significant when including coronary artery disease and CHF as covariates in the respective models indicates that glucose metabolism plays a role independently of coronary artery disease and CHF as mediating factors. Grading of diastolic dysfunction is the subject of an ongoing debate and newer guidelines have been published , whose clinical value has yet to be prospectively validated. It would have been interesting to measure fasting triacylglycerol, considering the recently proposed role of myocardial triacylglycerol accumulation in diabetic cardiomyopathy . We did, however, observe a significant correlation between markers of diastolic dysfunction and low HDL-cholesterol levels. As the latter are part of the typical pattern of dyslipidaemia with low HDL-cholesterol and elevated triacylglycerol most frequently observed in insulin resistance, this might provide some indirect evidence. Similarly, it would also have been interesting to include a larger group of patients with confirmed type 1 diabetes or to determine diabetes-associated antibodies for diagnosis of latent autoimmune diabetes in adults, as this might have allowed us to speculate on whether divergent underlying pathophysiologies could have had a differential impact on diastolic function. Given our observations, we were rather surprised that duration of type 2 diabetes did not correlate with E:e′ or other markers of diastolic function. We speculate that duration of type 2 diabetes does not necessarily reflect severity of disease. The latter might be more appropriately indicated by HbA1c, which reflects glycaemia over a period of time, and by the use of insulin, which reflects the necessity for intensified treatment in most cases.
In summary, our data show an association between diastolic dysfunction and glucose metabolism along the diabetic continuum, which extends into the normal range. Diastolic dysfunction negatively correlates with exercise tolerance. Our analysis supports a relevant role for diastolic dysfunction in diabetic heart failure and also the initiation of early preventive measures to address diastolic heart failure in the community.
This work was supported by grants from the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (German Heart Failure Network, TP 7 [FKZ 01GI0205], clinical trial programme ALDO-DHF [FKZ 01KG0506]) and the German Diabetes Foundation.
Duality of interest
The authors declare that there is no duality of interest associated with this manuscript.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.