Prasad, P. Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. (Math. Sci.) (1990) 100: 87. doi:10.1007/BF02881118
This is in continuation of our paper On the propagation of a multi-dimensional shock of arbitrary strength’ published earlier in this journal (Srinivasan and Prasad ). We had shown in our paper that Whitham’s shock dynamics, based on intuitive arguments, cannot be relied on for flows other than those involving weak shocks and that too with uniform flow behind the shock. Whitham  refers to this as misinterpretation of his approximation and claims that his theory is not only correct but also provides a natural closure of the open system of the equations of Maslov . The main aim of this note is to refute Whitham’s claim with the help of an example and a numerical integration of a problem in gasdynamics.