August 1999, Volume 26, Issue 3, pp 262-275
Fiscal outcomes of the closing of Central State Hospital: An analysis of the costs to state government
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
This study reports estimates of the preclosure and postclosure costs of mental health services for patients directly affected by the closing of Central State Hospital. The data come from state budget documents and from the billing records of the community mental health centers serving the discharged clients. On average, it cost Indiana approximately $68,347 (in 1995 dollars) to provide 12 months of state hospital care for this client cohort in fiscal year 1993. In contrast, during the first year following the closure, the average per patient cost to the state was $55,417. When clients were served exclusively in community care settings, the average annual per patient cost was $40,618. The analyses suggest that the closing reduced the costs of caring for this cohort of patients by approximately 18.9%. A significant portion of the cost savings to the state mental health budget was achieved by shifting some of the direct patient care costs to Medicaid/Medicare.
The analyses and conclusions reported here are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position or opinions of the funding institutions, the individuals named in the acknowledgments section, the agencies that participated in this study, or Indiana University.
He is also with the Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research in Bloominton.
Mechanic D:Mental Health and Social Policy. Third ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1989.
Okin RL: Testing the limits of deinstitutionalization.Psychiatric Services 1995; 46:569–574.
Association of Federal, State, County, and Municipal Employees:Resisting the Tragedy: The Human and Financial Costs of Indiana's Plan to Close Central State Hospital. Indianapolis, IN: Association of Federal, State, County, and Municipal Employees, 1992.
Caleca LG: Central State ordered to close in '94.Indianapolis Star, June 24, 1992, p. A1.
Gillis L, Fahy J: Central State closing drawing criticism, acclaim.Indianapolis Star June 24, 1992, p. A1.
McGrew JH, Wright ER, Pescosolido BA: Closing of a state hospital: An overview and framework for a case study.Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research 1999; 26:236–245.
Pescosolido BA, Wright ER, Kikuzawa S: “Stakeholder” attitudes over time toward the closing of a state hospital.Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research 1999; 26:318–328.
Weisbrod B, Test MA, Stein L: Alternative to mental hospital treatment: II. Economic-benefit cost.Archives of General Psychiatry 1980; 37(April):400–405.
Knapp M, Beecham J, Anderson J, et al: The TAPS project. 3: Predicting the community costs of closing psychiatric hospitals.British Journal of Psychiatry 1990; 157:661–670.
Knapp M: From psychiatric hospital to community care: Reflections on the English experience. In: Moscarelli M, Rupp A, Sartorius N (Eds.):The Economics of Schizophrenia. New York: John Wiley, 1996, pp. 385–395.
Rothbard AB, Schinnar AP, Hadley TP, et al.: Cost comparison of state hospital and community-based care for seriously mentally ill adults.American Journal of Psychiatry 1998; 155:523–529.
Dickey B, Cannon N, McGuire T, et al.: The quarterway house: A two-year cost study of an experimental residential program.Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1986; 37:1136–1143.
Galster GC, Champney TF, Williams Y: Costs of caring for persons with long-term mental illness in alternative residential settings.Evaluation and Program Planning 1994; 17:239–248.
Fenton F, Tessier L, Contandriopoulos A, et al.: A comparative trial of home and hospital psychiatric treatment: Financial costs.Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 1982; 27:177–187.
Newton P: An evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of day hospitalization for black male schizophrenics.Journal of the National Medical Association 1983; 75:273–285.
Gudeman J, Dickey B, Evans A, et al.: Four-year assessment of a day hospital program as an alternative to inpatient hospitalization.American Journal of Psychiatry 1985; 142:1330–1333.
Bond GR: An economic analysis of psychosocial rehabilitation.Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1984; 35:356–370.
Bond GR, Miller LD, Drumwied RD, et al.: Assertive case management in three CMHCs: A controlled study.Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1988; 39:411–418.
Kent S, Fogarty MY: A review of studies of heavy users of psychiatric services.Psychiatric Services 1995; 46:1247–1253.
Hollingsworth EJ, Sweeney J: Mental health expenditures for services for people with severe mental illnesses.Psychiatric Services 1997; 48:485–490.
Indiana Division of Mental Health:A Comprehensive Community Based Service System Plan for Persons Disabled by Serious Mental Illness. Indianapolis: Indiana Family and Social Services Administration, 1993.
Indiana Legislative Council:Indiana Code, 1993 Edition, Volume 4: Titles 11 to 13: Corrections, Human Services, Environment. Indianapolis: West Publishing, 1993.
Indiana Division of Mental Health:The Hoosier Assurance Plan. Indianapolis: Indiana Family and Social Services Administration, 1994.
Wright ER, Holmes A, Deb P, et al.:Treatment Costs of the Former Central State Hospital Patients: A Comparison of Institutionalized and Community-Based Care (technical report). Bloomington: Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research, 1997.
Bureau of Labor Statistics: Consumer Price Indexes Home Page: Price Changes for Medical Care Services for Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana, 1987–1997. http://stats.bls.gov/cgi-bin/dsrv (April 20, 1997), 1997.
Cuffel BJ, Jeste DV, Halpain M, et al.: Treatment costs and use of community mental health services for schizophrenia by age cohorts.American Journal of Psychiatry 1996; 153:870–876.
Wolff N, Helminiak TW: The anatomy of cost estimates—The “other” outcome.Advances in Health Economics and Health Services Research 1993; 14:159–180.
Bachrach LL: The state of the state mental hospital in 1996.Psychiatric Services 1996; 47:1071–1078.
Frank RG, McGuire TG: Introduction to the economics of mental health payment systems. In: Levin B, Petrila J (Eds.):Mental Health Services: A Public Health Perspective. New York: Oxford University Press, 1996, pp. 23–37.
Deb P, Holmes AM: Factors influencing informal care-giving.Journal of Mental Health Economics and Policy 1998; 1:77–87.
Wright ER, Miller JB, Pescosolido BA, et al.:Central State Hospital Discharge Study Tracking Report—January 1994. Bloomington: Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research, 1994.
Mirola W, Wright ER, McGrew JH, et al.:Central State Hospital Discharge Study Tracking Report—March 1995. Bloomington: Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research, 1995.
Koorman H, Wright ER, McGrew, JM, et al.:Central State Hospital Discharge Study Tracking Report—December 1996. Bloomington: Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research, 1996.
Koorman H, Wright ER, McGrew JH, et al.:Central State Hospital Discharge Study Tracking Report—December 1997. Bloomington: Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research, 1997.
Luskin ML, Wright ER: The Criminal Contacts of Former Mental Patients. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society for Criminology, San Diego, CA, Nov. 20, 1997.
McGrew JH, Wright ER, Pescosolido BA, et al.: The closing of Central State Hospital: Long-term outcomes for persons with severe mental illness.Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research 1999; 26:246–261.
Pescosolido BA, Wright ER, Lutfey K: The changing hopes, worries, and community supports of individuals moving from a closing long-term care facility.Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research 1999; 26:276–288.
Pescosolido BA, Wright ER, McGrew JH, et al.: The human and organizational markers of health system change: Framing studies of hospital downsizing and closure.Research in the Sociology of Health Care 1997; 14:69–45.
Lutterman TC: The state mental health agency profile system. In: Manderscheid R, Sonnenschein M (Eds.):Mental Health United States 1994. DHHS Publication No. (SMA)94-3000. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1994, pp. 165–187.
- Fiscal outcomes of the closing of Central State Hospital: An analysis of the costs to state government
The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research
Volume 26, Issue 3 , pp 262-275
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links