Balancing pairs and the cross product conjecture G. R. Brightwell S. Felsner W. T. Trotter Article

Received: 20 June 1995 Accepted: 31 August 1995 DOI :
10.1007/BF01110378

Cite this article as: Brightwell, G.R., Felsner, S. & Trotter, W.T. Order (1995) 12: 327. doi:10.1007/BF01110378
Abstract In a finite partially ordered set, Prob (x >y ) denotes the proportion of linear extensions in which elementx appears above elementy . In 1969, S. S. Kislitsyn conjectured that in every finite poset which is not a chain, there exists a pair (x,y ) for which 1/3⩽Prob(x >y )⩽2/3. In 1984, J. Kahn and M. Saks showed that there exists a pair (x,y ) with 3/11<Prob(x >y )<8/11, but the full 1/3–2/3 conjecture remains open and has been listed among ORDER's featured unsolved problems for more than 10 years.

In this paper, we show that there exists a pair (x,y ) for which (5−√5)/10⩽Prob(x >y )⩽(5+√5)/10. The proof depends on an application of the Ahlswede-Daykin inequality to prove a special case of a conjecture which we call the Cross Product Conjecture. Our proof also requires the full force of the Kahn-Saks approach — in particular, it requires the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequalities for mixed volumes.

We extend our result on balancing pairs to a class of countably infinite partially ordered sets where the 1/3–2/3 conjecture isfalse , and our bound is best possible. Finally, we obtain improved bounds for the time required to sort using comparisons in the presence of partial information.

Mathematics Subject Classifications (1991) 06A07 06A10

Key words Partially ordered set linear extension balancing pairs cross-product conjecture Ahlswede-Daykin inequality sorting An extended abstract of an earlier version of this paper appears as [6]. The results here are much stronger than in [6], and this paper has been written so as to overlap as little as possible with that version.

References 1.

Ahlswede, R. and Daykin, D. E. (1978) An inequality for the weights of two families of sets, their unions and intersections,

Z. Wahrscheinlichkeitstheorie und Verw. Gebiete
43 , 183–185.

Google Scholar 2.

Brightwell, G. (1988) Linear extensions of infinite posets,

Discrete Mathematics
70 , 113–136.

Google Scholar 3.

Brightwell, G. (1989) Semiorders and the 1/3–2/3 conjecture,

Order
5 , 369–380.

Google Scholar 4.

Brightwell, G. (1990) Events correlated with respect to every subposet of a fixed poset,

Graphs and Combinatorics
6 , 111–131.

Google Scholar 5.

Brightwell, G. and Wright, C. D. (1992) The 1/3–2/3 conjecture for 5-thin posets,

SIAM J. Discrete Math.
5 , 467–474.

Google Scholar 6.

Felsner, S. and Trotter, W. T. (1993) Balancing pairs in partially ordered sets, inCombinatorics , Vol. 1, Paul Erdos is Eighty, pp. 145–157.

7.

Fishburn, P. C. (1984) A correlational inequality for linear extensions of a poset,

Order
1 , 127–137.

Google Scholar 8.

Fishburn, P., Gehrlein, W. G., and Trotter, W. T. (1992) Balance theorems for height-2 posets,

Order
9 , 43–53.

Google Scholar 9.

Fredman, M. (1976) How good is the information theoretic bound in sorting?

Theoretical Computer Science
1 , 355–361.

Google Scholar 10.

Friedman, J. (1993) A Note on Poset Geometries,

SIAM J. Computing
22 , 72–78.

Google Scholar 11.

Kahn, J. and Kim, J. Entropy and sorting,JACM , to appear.

12.

Kahn, J. and Linial, N. (1991) Balancing extensions via Brunn-Minkowski,

Combinatorica
11 , 363–368.

Google Scholar 13.

Kahn, J. and Saks, M. (1984) Balancing poset extensions,

Order
1 , 113–126.

Google Scholar 14.

Khachiyan, L. (1989) Optimal algorithms in convex programming decomposition and sorting, in J. Jaravlev (ed.),

Computers and Decision Problems , Nauka, Moscow, pp. 161–205 (in Russian).

Google Scholar 15.

Kislitsyn, S.S. (1968) Finite partially ordered sets and their associated sets of permutations,

Matematicheskiye Zametki
4 , 511–518.

Google Scholar 16.

Komlós, J. (1990) A strange pigeon-hole principle,

Order
7 , 107–113.

Google Scholar 17.

Linial, N. (1984) The information theoretic bound is good for merging,

SIAM J. Computing
13 , 795–801.

Google Scholar 18.

Saks, M. (1985) Balancing linear extensions of ordered sets,

Order
2 , 327–330.

Google Scholar 19.

Shepp, L. A. (1980) The FKG inequality and some monotonicity properties of partial orders,

SIAM J. Alg. Disc. Meths.
1 , 295–299.

Google Scholar 20.

Trotter, W. T. (1995) Partially ordered sets, in R. L. Graham, M. Grötschel, and L. Lovász (eds),Handbook of Combinatorics , to appear.

21.

Trotter, W. T. (1991)

Combinatorics and Partially Ordered Sets: Dimension Theory , The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.

Google Scholar © Kluwer Academic Publishers 1995

Authors and Affiliations G. R. Brightwell S. Felsner W. T. Trotter 1. Department of Mathematics London School of Economics London U.K. 2. Fachbereich Mathematik, Institut für Informatik Freie Universität Berlin Berlin Germany 3. Department of Mathematics Arizona State University Tempe U.S.A.