When rational men fall sick: An inquiry into some assumptions made by medical anthropologists
- Allan Young
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Medical anthropologists spend most of their time eliciting and interpreting people's statements about sickness and health. For this task, they make certain assumptions about the importance of language and reason. In this paper I argue that their assumptions are tailored to fit an hypothetical Rational Man rather than real people. The concept of ‘explanatory models of sickness’ is used to illustrate this point.
My critique begins by drawing attention to two non-cognitive determinants of people's statements: their degree of emotional arousal and their capacities for discoursing on medical subjects. These determinants are briefly discussed and then set aside, to make room for the paper's argument proper. This starts with the observation that medical anthropologists tend to overlook the fact that they have established a cognitive no man's land stretching between their informants' statements and the cognitive structures which are supposed to generate these statements.
I survey this void, using a five-fold model of medical knowledge. People use one kind of knowledge to organize their medical experiences and perceptions. In Rational Man writing, this form of knowledge is considered equivalent to cognitive structures (e.g., causal models, classificatory schemes), but I argue that it also includes knowledge of prototypical sickness events and knowledge that is embedded in actions, social relations, and material equipment. The theoretical implications of the five-fold model are outlined.
This is followed by an analysis of the reasoning processes in which people use medical knowledge to produce the statements whose meaning we wish to learn. I demonstrate the importance of being able to distinguish operational and monothetic forms of reasoning from pre-operational and polythetic ones. Rational Man writers are described as ignoring the latter pair. The concept of ‘prototypes’ is reintroduced to illustrate these points.
- Beck, Aaron T., A John Rush, Brian F. Shaw, and Gary Emery 1979 Cognitive Therapy of Depression. New York: Guilford Press.
- Goody, Jack 1977 The Domestication of the Savage Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.
- Hallpike, C. R. 1979 The Foundations of Primitive Thought. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
- Kleinman, Arthur 1980 Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture: An Exploration of the Borderland Between Anthropology, Medicine, and Psychiatry. Univ. of California Press.
- Latour, Bruno and Steven Woolgar 1979 Laboratory Life: The Social Construction of Scientific Facts, Bererly Hills, California: Sage.
- Lazarus, Richard S., Susan Folkman, and Allen Kanner 1979 Congition, Motivation, and Emotion: Putting Humpty Dumpty Together Again. Manuscript.
- Lazarus, Richard S., Susan Folkman, and Allen Kanner 1980 Emotions: A Cognitive Phenomenological Analysis. In Theories of Emotions. R. Plutchnik and H. Kellerman (ed.), New York: Wiley. Pp. 66–85.
- Leventhal, Howard 1980 Toward a Comprehensive Theory of Emotion. In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Volume 13. L. Berkowitz, (ed.), New York: Academic Press.
- Needham, Rodney 1972 Belief, Language, and Experience, Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
- Olver, R. and J. Hornsby 1966 On Equivalence. In Studies in Cognitive Growth. J. S. Bruner, R. Olver, and N. Greenfield et al. (eds.), New York: Wiley. Pp. 66–85.
- Vygotsky, L.S. 1962 (orig. 1934) Thought and Language. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
- Willis, Roy 1981 Review of The Foundations of Primitive Thought, by C. R. Hallpike. Royal Anthropological Institute News number 43: 13–14.
- Young, Allan 1980 The Discourse on Stress and the Reproduction of Conventional Knowledge. Social Science and Medicine 14B: 133–146.
- When rational men fall sick: An inquiry into some assumptions made by medical anthropologists
Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry
Volume 5, Issue 4 , pp 317-335
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Additional Links
- Allan Young (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, Ohio, USA